NOC Amnesiac Mafia Game 1 - N2

[Ditto]

Twas I! jumpluff chose to target me, but failed.

 

[Blazade]

quick q who was pluff's target
also is it possible that maf just hit blazade fsr or no

Me then ditto.

I'm considering Sam's post atm

 

[Ampharos]

fuck it unvote, lynch jumpluff

vig is our least useful role so even if this is a mislynch (which honestly i don't think it is) we don't lose a ton

just have to hope that A. this isn't a mislynch B. mayor doesn't get fucked over tonight

 

[UncleSam]

Pluff claimed hooked but 'targeted Ditto', that is a huge part of the reason that they can basically only be Don.

I don't think it's really possible Blazade was the kill target, I mean it's always 'possible' in the sense that maybe someone went off the deep end, but I very much doubt anyone would've killed Blazade last night.

 

[rssp1]

alright fair enough
vote jumpluff
since we're outing all roles would it be a good idea for mayor to claim?

 

[jumpluff]

It's about parity oh my god hi scum team

SAM ALL I WAS TOLD WAS THAT MY ROLE FAILED I EXPLAINED WHY I CLAIMED HOOKED

If any of you three are town you deserve to lose

Peace

 

[UncleSam]

Mayor doesn't know who they are, that's part of the problem with going to the later 50/50s

 

[jumpluff]

fuck it unvote, lynch jumpluff

vig is our least useful role so even if this is a mislynch (which honestly i don't think it is) we don't lose a ton

just have to hope that A. this isn't a mislynch B. mayor doesn't get fucked over tonight

you specifically are the scum, for posterity

 

[rssp1]

pluff you can only be vig or scum though since you have an action
if you can explain why it isnt worth following through with the lynch ill unlynch but with how far ahead we are rn i dont see the reasoning for not lynching you

 

[UncleSam]

The reasoning is that jumpluff's scumteam loses when they get lynched because we can guess wrong on one of their teammates and still win rofl

The rest is just OMGUS

 

[jumpluff]

pluff you can only be vig or scum though since you have an action
if you can explain why it isnt worth following through with the lynch ill unlynch but with how far ahead we are rn i dont see the reasoning for not lynching you

Parity

Killing me solves literally nothing since you can simultaneously consider the scenarios where I am town and where I am scum

What you need to know is who else is lying

 

[jumpluff]

The reasoning is that jumpluff's scumteam loses when they get lynched because we can guess wrong on one of their teammates and still win rofl

The rest is just OMGUS

Sub me out this guy is insufferable and I'm trying to enjoy Wheel of Fortune internet vonFiedler

 

[Ampharos]

pluff just scumslipped, her flipping town would clean me so picking me to throw shade on is uhhhhh

 

[UncleSam]

More like pluff just resigned many times over lol

 

[Ampharos]

*they not her my b

 

[jumpluff]

Don't know

pluff just scumslipped, her flipping town would clean me so picking me to throw shade on is uhhhhh

if you noticed but I'm not keeping track which I mentioned earlier

All my posts have been commentary

I also enjoy Jeopardy so bye

 

[jumpluff]

More like pluff just resigned many times over lol

Is making town die your win con?

If yes k

If no you are not playing a good game, try debating.org instead

 

[Ampharos]

picking trebek over us smh

 

[Blazade]

The reasoning is that jumpluff's scumteam loses when they get lynched because we can guess wrong on one of their teammates and still win rofl

The rest is just OMGUS

I see the upside, but this is also one of the only pathways scum have to winning if this is a mislynch.

Like I also get your point about not that much more info but there's only so many times a scum can lie to keep themselves undercover with respect to every single result, only so many 50-50s they can propagate

Is this a scumslip? Not sure how to read pluff's reaction besides justified frustration lol. I don't see it significantly change my view on no lynching since I just don't get why taking the risk makes sense

 

[UncleSam]

I see the upside, but this is also one of the only pathways scum have to winning if this is a mislynch.

Like I also get your point about not that much more info but there's only so many times a scum can lie to keep themselves undercover with respect to every single result, only so many 50-50s they can propagate

Is this a scumslip? Not sure how to read pluff's reaction besides justified frustration lol. I don't see it significantly change my view on no lynching since I just don't get why taking the risk makes sense

Because by no lynching we can't reliably figure out which of you/Walrein/aska is bad later on

We take no risks later by taking no risks lynching jumpluff now

Like it's so easy

Not to mention that if you're good then pluff is 100% scum

 

[Ampharos]

A pluff townflip cleans me and rssp while confirming Blazade for scum

A pluff scum flip is good for obvious reasons, plus is imo much more likely than a townflip

The more I think about this lynch the more I like it

 

[vonFiedler]

To everyone's surprise, the town couldn't come to a decision and no one was lynched!

It is now Night 2. Deadline is in 48 hours.

 

[Ampharos]

Ignore the first paragraph all it does is confirm I'm the psych, went full dumb for q sec

 

[vonFiedler]

For the record, you guys can post all the spreadsheets you want to the thread. But you can't share one outside of it.

 

[vonFiedler]

BTW zorbees has subbed in for jumpluff