1. New to the forums? Check out our Mentorship Program!
    Our mentors will answer your questions and help you become a part of the community!
  2. Welcome to Smogon Forums! Please take a minute to read the rules.

CAP 18 CAP 18 - Part 9 - Movepool Limits

Discussion in 'CAP Process Archive' started by jas61292, May 7, 2014.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. jas61292

    jas61292 used substitute
    is a Forum Moderatoris a Community Contributoris a CAP Contributoris a Tiering Contributoris a Battle Server Moderator
    Moderator

    Joined:
    Sep 30, 2010
    Messages:
    2,959
    This is the stage where we set limits to CAP 18's movepool ahead of the actual movepool submissions. Volkraken's stats generate a Base Stat Rating of 323 (Very Good). According to the recent Policy Review thread, a Very Good BSR corresponds to a Very Good movepool limit of 65 total moves and 33 "Restricted Moves". However, we may end up going higher or lower depending on the Pokémon. That is where this thread comes in. The actual list of Restricted Moves can be found in this article.

    Also, please note that there is no vote at this stage! Our Movepool Leader (ginganinja) will be gathering the community consensus at the end of this thread and making an executive decision.

    ---------

    CAP18 so far:

    Leadership Team:

    DetroitLolcat
    - Topic Leader
    jas61292 - Typing Leader
    PttP - Ability Leader
    srk1214 - Stats Leader
    ginganinja - Movepool Leader
    Typing: Fire / Water
    Abilities: Analytic / Infiltrator / ???
    Stats: 100 HP / 45 Atk / 80 Def / 135 SpA / 100 SpD / 95 Spe
    Last edited: May 7, 2014
  2. ginganinja

    ginganinja Dating Haunter
    is a Forum Moderatoris a CAP Contributoris a Contributor to Smogonis a Community Contributor Alumnusis a Battle Server Moderator Alumnus
    Moderator

    Joined:
    Apr 13, 2009
    Messages:
    3,750
    O.k, so with the movepool discussion threads now over, its time to move onto the Movepool Limits. This is an important part of the process, both in a competitive sense, and in a flavour one.

    In terms of finding an initial RMs baseline, I am currently looking at 25 RMs, mostly because I see this CAP as having a limited movepool. It could run an aggressive set with Double STABs + Power Gem and U-Turn for a Pivot role, or it could run a more defensive set, perhaps dropping a STAB, or maybe Power Gem / U-Turn for some more defensive moves. As far as I see it, I don’t think this CAP needs a huge number of moves, especially due to its already high stats.

    In terms of total movepool, initially I am currently thinking 60 as being a good starting point, again as I see CAP 18 having a smaller movepool, as opposed to a wider one.

    That said, these numbers are only provisional at the moment, and its highly likely that some of you might feel that I have been too restrictive, or perhaps not restrictive enough. I encourage anyone to post, giving their own opinions as to what sort of limits we should be looking at, with an explanation included. At the conclusion of the thread, I will make judgement call, so the better written your post is, the more helpful it is to me to get an idea as to the community opinion on this matter.
    Dragonblaze052 likes this.
  3. Kappaten

    Kappaten

    Joined:
    Mar 14, 2011
    Messages:
    273
    I agree with the initial baseline, though we could possibly even drop the total movepool lower. Volkraken really only needs its STABs and a couple support moves, since we disallowed virtually all coverage, so I don't think it's a stretch to say that the final movepool may resemble something like Talonflame (25 RMs, 50 Total). That said, I don't think the movepool necessarily should be narrowed, but it definitely has a bit of room to be reduced if necessary.
    LightningLuxray likes this.
  4. Elite Lord Sigma

    Elite Lord Sigma

    Joined:
    Oct 23, 2013
    Messages:
    122
    I also think the initial baseline is acceptable. Considering Volkraken's sparse coverage and limited support options, I would say that it would be fine if the final movepool were even lower, but I agree that it isn't mandatory for the movepool to be slimmed down. Nonetheless, we do have room to do so if it's deemed desirable.
  5. Pata Hikari

    Pata Hikari

    Joined:
    Oct 2, 2013
    Messages:
    151
    I think the baseline of 33/65 is fine.

    As is Volkraken is going to have 4MSS since it's going to need both it's stabs and at least one support move already. Letting it have more then a handful of options for the fourth slot isn't going to hurt it and allow it to do its job much better.
  6. Korski

    Korski Distilled, 80 proof
    is a Forum Moderatoris a CAP Contributor
    Moderator

    Joined:
    Mar 29, 2009
    Messages:
    2,142
    I think ginganinja's proposed limits are perfect. This Poke should be launching Fire Blasts and Hydro Pumps 90% of the time, and adding a bunch of riffraff for gimmick sets sounds like the making of an unfocused playtest. I've been tooling around with a preliminary movepool for a while and I can't even get to 25 RMs without counting the RMs I consider flavor additions that would otherwise be useless to this Poke. I personally have never cared for the maximum move limit in general, but 60 seems fair enough if people want to load up on flavor moves. That there are no Tutor moves in Gen. VI should make a 60 move maximum easy to deal with for submitters. We should go with these limits and let the community decide which low-impact moves Volkraken should have in its final movepool.
    Fencerman and Dragonblaze052 like this.
  7. Deck Knight

    Deck Knight October Surprise
    is a Forum Moderatoris a CAP Contributoris a Smogon Media Contributor
    Moderator

    Joined:
    May 27, 2005
    Messages:
    7,574
    Deck Knight used Post Resurrect:

    Malacondapost (open)

    "Deck Knight, post: 4658842, member: 653"]So here I am again going to ruin everyone's fun by pointing out brute obvious facts of movepool aesthetics.

    The fact is, STABs and "every mon" VGMs always take up a substantial portion of the movepool. Lets start with the basics:

    Toxic
    Hidden Power
    Protect
    Frustration
    Return*
    Facade
    Rest
    Sleep Talk

    That's 8 VGMs there, so now we've got 22 left w/ 60/30.

    Lets add in STABs, including all the moves we've discussed and Tutors/TMs:

    Crunch
    Dark Pulse
    Foul Play
    Payback
    Punishment
    Pursuit
    Sucker Punch

    Power Whip/Wood Hammer/Leaf Blade
    Energy Ball
    Giga Drain
    Grass Knot
    Seed Bomb

    That's 12 more, so we're now up to 20, just with aesthetic STABs and discussed STABs, leaving 10 moves left. This is further diminished if you want to offer people options like Power Whip and Leaf Blade etc.

    And I'm not even to support moves yet, which would in most pools include Taunt, Rapid Spin, Glare and Knock Off. There's another 4 down, leaving 6 left.

    Add U-turn, Dragon Tail, Roar, Aromatherapy, Synthesis, and Spikes and that completes the 30.

    30 is simply too low if we do not want a series of cookie-cutter movepool submissions, where the only difference lies in say whether someone likes Ice Fang but not Spikes and so excises their movepool that way - or deliberate cuts out superfluous STABs to make room for more competitive moves.

    Aersthetics is not a flavor argument. I take my movepool aesthetics very seriously because I want the product we produce to be comparable to existing Pokemon and not just be a jumbled mass of competitive moves placed in whatever slots they can (cape knows I detest Tomohawk's movepool aesthetics). It's about being complete and presenting an image of a realistic Pokemon.

    Therefore my suggest is a modest increase to 70/35 to account for the fact that at least a few movepool submitters take seriously the idea of replicating in-game learnsets including their flavor rules - which include moves that others don't think of adding to their movepools because they never come up competitively.


    I'll do a similar exercise here.

    The Auto- 7 Restricted Moves (since one is a duplicate) is still the same. Now for STABs that seem likely on this CAP:

    Fire Blast
    Flamethrower
    Flare Blitz
    Heat Wave
    Lava Plume
    Overheat

    Aqua Jet
    Aqua Tail
    Hydro Pump
    Muddy Water
    Scald
    Surf
    Waterfall

    Most people I imagine will boil this down to about 4 each for aesthetic purposes, so there's another 8 moves. We're now up to 15 RMs, and we haven't even gotten to coverage and support yet.

    That leaves us, given a 25 limit, 10 moves out of the following:

    Allowed List from AM, minus STABS:
    Aura Sphere
    Clear Smog *
    Flash Cannon *
    Power Gem *
    Sludge Wave *
    U-Turn *
    Physical flavor moves that would technically be RMs like Gunk Shot, Poison Jab, Rock Blast, etc. *

    Allowed List from NAM, minus any moves that aren't actually RMs:
    Aromatherapy / Heal Bell / Refresh*
    Baton Pass *
    Destiny Bond
    Haze
    Healing Wish
    Memento *
    Pain Split *
    Rain Dance *
    Reflect *
    Stealth Rock *
    Will-O-Wisp *

    I've marked with an asterisk moves that will be in high aesthetic or competitive demand, the total of which is 14 (and technically more for physical aesthetic RMs).

    It's thus my recommendation that if the RM limit is to be lowered from 33, the amount should be between 28 and 30 (inclusive) and not 25. 25 is too prohibitive aesthetically because we judge RMs based on their inherent competitiveness and not their specific competitiveness.
    Last edited: May 8, 2014
  8. DetroitLolcat

    DetroitLolcat Maize And Blue Badge Set :)
    is a Forum Moderatoris a CAP Contributoris a Tiering Contributor
    Moderator

    Joined:
    Apr 11, 2010
    Messages:
    2,322
    Looking at Deck's list, I'm inclined to agree with him about the RM limit. 25's a good place to start, but seeing all the moves listed out like that shows that we're going to need to give movepool submitters a little more leeway when picking some of the fringe-competitive and flavor RMs. Right now, there are 31 total competitive RMs: 11 Non-Attacking Moves, 6 Attacking Moves, 7 STAB moves, and 7 Required moves. A limit of 25 RMs would force people to cull 6 moves from that list before giving Volkraken any Physical STAB (with every flavor move forcing another competitive RM to be cut). While movepools with 25 RMs can definitely accomplish all of the goals we would like Volkraken to accomplish, there is very little room for diversity of competitive and flavor options. 25 RMs is where some of the smaller movepools should fit, not a limit.

    I believe a limit of 29-30 would do a better job of allowing diversity of competitive and flavor moves. Users won't be forced to raise their movepools from the current 25, and I hope to see some movepools with only 25 RMs in Movepool Submissions. But if the limit is 25, then just about every submission will be forced to ride that limit in order to fit in the necessary competitive and a few flavor options. 29-30 lets users have 25 competitive RMs while giving Volkraken a few nifty Physical options, or even stay under the limit without having to ride it.
    dwarfstar and elementalpenguin like this.
  9. ginganinja

    ginganinja Dating Haunter
    is a Forum Moderatoris a CAP Contributoris a Contributor to Smogonis a Community Contributor Alumnusis a Battle Server Moderator Alumnus
    Moderator

    Joined:
    Apr 13, 2009
    Messages:
    3,750
    O.k, so I have looked at the community opinions on this matter, and agree that both DLC and Deck Knight have a point. While it is certainly possible to get a RM movepool of 25, doing so unduly impacts on the variety this CAP can get within its movepool. Therefore I have decided to increase the RM limit to 29 since I think this is a suitable balance between constraining the number of RM's allowed, without handicapping variety. Seeing as (in my humble opinion), the Upper movepool limit is mostly flavor anyway (and no-one really discussed it), I will be keeping the total movepool limit to 60.

    Thank you to all the people that gave me your various thoughts and opinions, both here and on irc. I will be seeing you all in the movepool submission thread!
  10. DetroitLolcat

    DetroitLolcat Maize And Blue Badge Set :)
    is a Forum Moderatoris a CAP Contributoris a Tiering Contributor
    Moderator

    Joined:
    Apr 11, 2010
    Messages:
    2,322
    No surprise here, the limit stays as is. My most recent post right before ginga's explains why 29 is a good limit for Restricted Moves, and 60 total moves will give everyone plenty of room to customize their movepools as they see fit.

    See you all in the movepool submission thread! We're almost done with CAP 18!
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Users Viewing Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 0)