So Gaijin Goombah released a video on the 26th giving his theory on what Sun & Moon is going to be about and I feel it might be worth some discussion. Here's the video (it's only 7 minutes long)
So to summarize his main points:
1. Since past mascot Legendaries all have basis in mythology, he believes the same for S&M.
(Reasonable enough, I'd say almost obvious)
2. He believes the mascot Legendaries would be the Shinto deities
Amaterasu the sun goddess and
Tsukuyomi the moon god. (
A plausible theory, sun and moon gods would be the obvious direction to go for Legendary mascots. Of course others (if not most) polytheistic cultures also have a sun and moon god. Not only that, with Pokemon having moved out of Japan it would be odd for them to go back, or would it?)
3. With Unova based on New York and Kalos based on France, Pokemon hasn't had a new region based on Japan for a few years now (minus the remake of Hoenn and re-release of Gen I). However since then a new challenger has arisen in the mon genre: Yo-Kai Watch!. Anyone who knows about Yo-Kai Watch! knows it has taken over Japan and does serve as the closest competitor to Pokemon. It could be possible that GF may want to go back to their roots to show their homeland fans they haven't forgotten about them and try to set a foothold back in the Asian markets (
which could also be why they have translated the games into Chinese).
So, what do you think? Everything Gaijin Goombah says makes sense, and he is experienced in Japanese culture.
Personally, I would think this would be a step back for GameFreak. First off I don't think Yo-Kai Watch's popularity has anything to do with the Pokemon franchise basing regions on non-Japanese places, especially since Yo-Kai Watch is going to do the same thing with their third game. I can understand it's disappointing to know your franchise isn't as popular in its homeland as it once was, but if they focus on trying to restore Pokemon's popularity in Japan they could risk losing some of the international community. Not because it'll be another region based on Japan, I'm fine with that as long as they make it interesting, but if they want to really attract back the Japanese audience from Yo-Kai Watch! they'd have to do more to make it appealing to Japanese audiences. And remember, Yo-Kai Watch! may be popular in Japan but it's not doing so hot anywhere else because its so rooted into Japanese culture that anyone not part of it has a lot of the meaning and symbolism lost on them. Now Pokemon's popularity will carry it on through if they do that, though it will give off a message to the international community that, no matter how big of a fanbase they have outside of Japan, the Japanese fanbase comes first and they'll do anything to get that audience back over the international audience.
I say GF should just keep pushing on with basing regions off location outside of Japan (at least unless they want to go back to Japan because they feel they could do something unique there, not just because there's a new mon series). It would give the message they're focusing on a global scale, no favoritism.