SJCrew said:
Actually, I would argue things like that alone make Night Slash worth its salts on teams that don't really need a trapper (because let's be honest; most things that Scizor can trap are either now unviable or can see it coming miles away and get around it). Besides, if you wanted to make sure you get rid of Jellicent, you would have to run both CB Scizor and another Pursuit trapper, which is doing too much.
Fair enough. Jellicent has to switch in you for you to beat it, which is a realistic scenario. However, you need to roll the absolute maximum damage both times to 2HKO max/max Jelli (which no one runs; and accounting for a presumed burn). On the standard 248/216 Jelli, you still need to roll high, though it's much more realistic to beat it. However, you'll still prolly end up with a Burned Scizor. Of course, the typical Jelli prolly won't be carrying WoW, but it's a risk you take by trying to Night Slash it. If you're running Specially Defensive Scizor with your CB, then you utterly fail against Jelli, Night Slash or not.
Chandelure can avoid being OHKOed by running 248/8, although I don't think anyone would run that. It doesn't need to tank another hit, as Scizor dies. Scizor can switch out, but that doesn't solve the original issue: technically, you didn't kill it.
There are no "things like that". Dark hits Psychic and Ghost super-effectively. Psychics are hit harder by U-Turn, and the only other OU Ghost is Gengar, who wouldn't switch into Scizor at all. Jelli and Chandy are literally the only targets of Night Slash in OU.
I'll concede your point that obvious Pursuit is obvious, and I'll admit that Quick Attack, while useful, is no stronger than any other 'mon using STAB priority. However, I would say that both of them have more utility than "Jelli + Chandy".
SJCrew said:
This is stupid. Why do we have to be afraid to even talk about Pokemon? Why the fuck would I even come here if I can't discuss what's going on in the metagame? Did we do something that was so bad as to make everyone paranoid about topicality all of the sudden?
You can come here to talk about what's going on in the metagame. But Night Slash Scizor is, as far as I know, not going on in the metagame.
It's fine and dandy to theorymon, and prove me wrong if you will, but tbh this recent conversation scared me when I checked the thread. I cannot, in my apparently un-enlightened state, comprehend why Night Slash would be worth even talking about on Scizor (again, let me know if I'm showing absurd amounts of ignorance).