Lord Death Man
i cant read
This reminds me a little of the NP posting reqs in the doubles Skymin suspect; it forced readers to articulate a new opinion and also to read the thread. However, I think this system was really flawed and felt arbitrary; note user tehy 's posts re: Skymin and his obvious frustration that people (not really TDs to my knowledge) essentially said that his reasoning "wasn't good enough". If a TD was to mysteriously not add someone w/a "bad" opinion to the voting section and justified it with a "your post sucked", then they can essentially pick and choose the vote and should just quickban or not do a suspect, in my opinion. I'm very much of the opinion that subjectivity should be removed as much as possible from the suspect decision, so I would never advocate for those kinds of reqs, but I see the appeal.I obviously lack the statistics, but I think it seems likely that most lurkers who qualify for suspect tests check the forums and would probably use it's resources for teambuilding. I feel as though the role of the np: thread is dualfold - it's a general common area for metagame discussion and during suspect season the center for suspect discussion in particular. I wouldn't be surprised if most voters read through the suspect thread and the arguments before voting. But when your suspect thread is only two pages long, there really isn't much for somebody not initiated into the community to look at. I suppose that was what irked me looking back at this suspect - people expressed some well formulated arguments in the thread, but compared to the voting base it was very little. Also, a collection of individual arguments isn't the same as a discussion in which users interact with other users and argue over strong/weak points in the argument. Maybe this points to the fact that there was widespread agreement that Durant was broken this time, but if we acknowledge that the situation was even remotely gray than surely there should be discussion?
I think its notable that one of the most controversial suspects, Tyrantrum, only got about 4 pages of discussion. I think a big part of this is that RU is just not very active as a subforum. Because of that, I stopped freely giving people teams near RU suspects (there's other reasons) because I often feel that people are confused that a team engineered around handling a suspect as easily as possible steamrolls said suspect, which I believe is somewhat related to Tyrantrum staying (solely because it was just such a close vote).
Personally, during suspects I use the VR to make choices more than the NP anymore; many times viability threads mention suspects nonstop once they're announced, which gives me a clearer idea of its meta impact.