I feel like Chansey with Leftovers would be absolutely manageable since it would only have 2/3 its usual bulk, but that's asking for a complex ban I know Koko won't do.
You're right, I haven't used Chansey at all. (on my OU teams)
![]()
Chansey is the most pressured pokemon in all of UU? I don't believe you.
There are very few special attackers that can pressure here, and even most physical attackers can't do more than 60% unless they're banded. I've found myself just healing on a physical attacker to see what it would lock itself into, often times predicting my switch, I'd gain HP rather than lose it. That's just silly playing on my part and maybe its unsafe but honestly taking 10% to scout on Chansey is no big deal, so long as the opponent does not run knock off, but knock off users are all noted and kind of pressure Chansey. I say that knowing full well that, Torn-T can't deal with an itemless Chansey unless it carries superpower and even if it does, it needs to be fully invested in physical attack to be able to still do over 50% to Chansey on the second superpower.
They key things that pressure chance are very limited, the list of things that threaten Chansey is even less. And since to make a balanced team one must have defensive pokemon these days, this always leaves openings for Chansey. Yes chansey does take a lot of attacks and does not have leftovers to patch up passively but she barely needs it, heck you could run leftovers instead and still have a wish cleric with superior bulk to florges AND Umbreon on both sides. Not to mention the ability makes her a goddess of the class, able to soak up status her self on a pivot.
And she can wish pass to every single one of their counters. Are you telling me you've manage to make a team where all 6 members can either fast taunt and not get killed by seismic tosses, or 2HKO chansey outright?
I mean knock off exists but that does not really solve the problem, Chansey is still a decent special wall without it. And still more bulky than any other wish cleric in the tier without eviolite.
Part of my problem is that she is specially unbreakable. We don't have Lucario's +2 STAB Aura Sphere in UU. There is no Pokemon that can reliably 2HKO her specially. Keldeo does not count because Secret Sword is essentially a physical attack. I hesitate to mention Psyshock users because most users require upwards of 2 boosts to 2HKO with what is, again, essentially a physical attack, and one that is still pretty limited in distribution.
No other special wall can claim this. Giratina, Lugia, and Ho-oh, the next specially bulkiest Pokemon in the game after the blobs, all go down after enough punishment. But Chansey is simply too bulky for UU power level; she's worth 15 Raditz when the rest of the tier is putting out at best 5.
You lose credibility when you post something factually inaccurate Shiny Minun.
Chansey without eviolite does not have superior bulk to Umbreon on both sides. These sets are the "usage" sets according to PS. I am aware most people, or at least most strong players run some defense in Florges but that won't significantly change my damage calculations. In any case Floreges is less bulky on both sides than Chansey given most reasonable EV invesments. I have Keldeo using Hydro Pump for all of them even though Secret Sword would obviously be the better option for Chansey and Umbreon so we can simply compare special bulk. For the same reason Darmanitan is not using Superpower.
252 Atk Sheer Force Darmanitan Flare Blitz vs. 252 HP / 0 Def Umbreon: 249-294 (63.1 - 74.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
252 Atk Sheer Force Darmanitan Flare Blitz vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Chansey: 534-628 (75.8 - 89.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
252 Atk Sheer Force Darmanitan Flare Blitz vs. 252 HP / 0 Def Florges: 369-435 (102.5 - 120.8%) -- guaranteed OHKO
252 SpA Keldeo Hydro Pump vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Umbreon: 108-127 (27.4 - 32.2%) -- 57.5% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
252 SpA Keldeo Hydro Pump vs. 252 HP / 4 SpD Chansey: 171-202 (24.2 - 28.6%) -- possible 5HKO after Leftovers recovery
252 SpA Keldeo Hydro Pump vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Florges: 94-112 (26.1 - 31.1%) -- 12.3% chance to 4HKO after Leftovers recovery
Umbreon is bulkier physically using a standard set compared to Chansey without eviolite. You were correct when you said Chansey would still be bulkier specially though.
Here you do not specify Chansey is even holding Leftovers. In this case you are even more incorrect in regards to Chansey's bulk compared to Umbreon and Florges. The majority of the time both Umbreon and Florges will take less overall damage than Chansey after factoring in Leftovers for special moves and occasionally for physical moves for Florges, especially if she runs a small amount of EVs (less than 80) in defense. Then you should factor in you can occasionally, I would say at least 30% of the time on average, be able to use Protect to scout safely and recover even more Leftover's health. In the event that this is possible (keeping in mind this is less likely to happen than not to happen) in these scenarios Chansey is certain to take more damage overall than either Florges or Umbreon both physically and specially.
To try and be completely fair when addressing your post I will also give you this though, in the event that Umbreon or Florges has lost their Leftovers they will be always less specially bulky than Chansey who has lost her Eviolite if all three are running reasonable EV sets.
With regards to putting on pressure on Chansey and again another factual inaccuracy
Could you, to be blunt Shiny Minun, stop pulling your facts out of thin air? Tornadus with Superpower can easily easily easily deal with an itemless Chansey assuming you are a competent player. If Chansey switches in with SR up on a U-turn or an Air Slash it will die the majority of the time to the very next Superpower. Itemless Chansey is not as good as you think it is Minun.
So instead of having to waste a turn and valuable PP (8/8) you can just switch in and out on status, I don't see why umbreon is better, I guess you can punish status a bit more, but you still have to stay in to heal bell, and I've even been in scenarios where the opponent will continue to status you, knowing you only have 8 PP to spare. (no pressure tho.)You say her ability Natural Cure makes Chansey very potent at status absorbing. I say you are not taking into account all three Wish Passers are also clerics and Umbreon is arguably even better at status absorbing because he can reflect the status and then heal it off for his entire team.
My concept of pressure is "Can this harm me? Can't this leave a lasting hindrance" If not, then its not pressuring. Why would I switch out on Darm if hes only gonna do max 55% and kill himself why he does it?i guess your concept of pressure is different of mine. your assume your concept is that pressure is the fear of being OHKOed, while my concept is that pressure is the acumulation of damage. how does your chansey deal with the situations i mentioned in my other post?
and also, who cares if florges/umbreon are less bulky than it? by that logic, we could ban florges since it's bulkier than aromatisse, then ban aromatisse since it's bulkier than slurpuff, then...
you guys keep thinking that chansey must be banned because it's impossible to OHKO it, but if you start to use tatically adequate offense, you'll see that chansey is less of a big killer boss and more of a big setup fodder
who in the world would leave darmanitan in chansey? the things that switch in chansey more (at least in the universe of not terrible players) are taunters, calm mind users, powerful physic attackers, hazards users, or even a cleric/wisher of their own. also, chansey cannot use 2 moves on the same turn; if it uses toxic as i switch crawdaunt in, your team has a high chace of being punished for using chansey: you can send something like chesnaught as i use swords dance and aerial ace, send something like hydreigon while i superpower, or leave chansey in while i use knock off.
Changing the topic (if only for a little bit) to talk a little bit about Mega Ampharos. I know a few people talked about it a page or two ago, but it is really underrated right now imo. It has a really cool defensive and offensive typing in Electric / Dragon, and a solid movepool to allow a lot of flexibility for. The two sets I've really liked thus far are a Bulky Attacker set and a physically defensive set. The bulky attacker set focuses more on Mega Ampharos's offensive typing while still not neglecting its defensive typing. Its STABs have such good coverage that allows it to run Heal Bell in the last slot to provide support for its team. I've really loved using it with Tornadus-T and Mienshao since its slow Volt Switch gives the two that many more chances to pressure teams. Vaporeon and Florges, two of the better Wish passers for balanced teams, also have really good defensive synergy with Mega Ampharos. The same set can be used on Trick Room teams (with Focus Blast over Heal Bell) thanks to its synergy with Slowbro, Slowking, and Escavalier.
The physically defensive set is an amazing switch-in to some really awkward threats. Crawdaunt, Tornadus-T, Mega Manectric, and Victini can all be countered or hard checked by the set. Base 165 Special Attack stings a fair bit, even without investment, and the ability to, at worst, hard check some of the top offensive threats in the metagame is amazing. While it does have to rely on RestTalk for recovery, it does pair well with Florges, Umbreon, and Chansey (irony!) (thank you jamashawalker for introducing me to the set) Here are the sets for anyone that's interested:
Ampharos @ Ampharosite
Ability: Static --> Mold Breaker
EVs: 248 HP / 252 SAtk / 8 SDef
IVs: 0 Spe (only if used on Trick Room teams)
Nature: Modest / Quiet
- Volt Switch
- Thunderbolt
- Dragon Pulse
- Heal Bell / Focus Blast
and
Ampharos @ Ampharosite
Ability: Static --> Mold Breaker
EVs: 248 HP / 252 Def / 8 SDef
Nature: Bold
- Volt Switch
- Dragon Pulse
- Rest / Heal Bell
- Sleep Talk / Toxic / Thunder Wave
now do a calc on secret sword with both spreads and see what happens
Chesnaught Wait, why is Chansey holding Leftovers in your Hydro Pump calc? Besides, it trades slightly smaller physical bulk for an equally small amount of better special bulk, but you'd lose out on Wishes.
Can you stop using 252 HP / 252 Def+ / 4 SpD! I already said this, but it was after a long post, so. 4 HP / 252+ / 252 is the proper spread, it gives it much more bulk, for instance:
252 SpA Keldeo Hydro Pump vs. 252 HP / 4 SpD Chansey: 171-202 (24.2 - 28.6%) -- possible 5HKO after Leftovers recovery goes to (21.1 - 25.2%) with 4 / 252
I think it somewhat depends on what the team needs Chansey to wall. Overall, I think the 252 HP / 252+ Def / 4 SDef spread is the best overall for Chansey (though I only run 248 HP since it doesn't effect Wish and rounds down hazard damage) but teams that absolutely need Chansey's ability to wall stuff like NP M-Houndoom, Specs Magnezone, and the like could get mileage out of the other spread. Still though, you've got shit like Latias, Reuniclus, NP Mew, and many other Psyshock users that Chansey needs to, at the very least, hard check for its team, and the max HP/Defense spread works better for that.
Also, you are basically saying "noobish players can't beat it! Ban it!" This is illogical. To prove something's broken post replays, calcs, anything besides repeating the same MEANINGLESS WORDS over and over again. It's like when some body saysThat was my bad, I forgot to factor in stab against chansey when I doing calcs myself, but still very comparable at their job, which I'll get into a bit later.
You found my point, anyone is hindered by knock off and its very present in the metagame, its much easier to avoid it than it is to avoid using this demi-god because shes so resilient in the metagame and does so much work.(oh so Knock Off isn't broken?)
The only reason to use umbreon or florges over chansey is typing and "If I make a mistake and get my eviolite knocked off, I'm gonna have a bad time."
And I'm not going to play macho and say I've never been knocked, but when I let it happen its so late in the game it barely matters.
I think it is a little unfair to have the Chansey switching into a superpower and already having her item off, and have stealth rock up. That would take some time to set up.
I did my calc assuming that she switches into an unfortunate knock off (and I'm giving that to you because Cansey can be an answer for Torn-T, but its not really a good one) And from there can soft-boiled stall till it's attack stat is laughable. Yes if you're a competent player setting that up is not too hard, however, if you're also against one, that kind of set up can be reversed, and the chansey user wouldn't be switching into something that is so obviously a knock off user (peaking in regard to having experience with chansey first hand.)
My concept of pressure is "Can this harm me? Can't this leave a lasting hindrance" If not, then its not pressuring. Why would I switch out on Darm if hes only gonna do max 55% and kill himself why he does it?
I'm not saying just ban it because it outclasses things, I'm saying its effect on teams is too powerful to be in a balanced environment. Specifically her 300+ HP Wishes which heal a vast majority of the metagame for full HP
Yes, Chansey is giant setup fodder to things with over 300 HP that are immune to toxic and don't mind thunder wave either. Additionally anything with over 400HP and a faster substitute.
What, just Zygarde then?
I want to take the chance to apologize for my inaccuracies, I made a mistake when calcing and I'm not gonna pretend that didn't happen, but don't throw my argument out the window because of it. Chansey completely outclasses everyone in her job and her wishes make teams as a group borderline unkillable. Even with added tools to dispose of her, she is almost as bad as she was last generation.
I remember this argument happen last gen regarding the best spread for Blissey, and 4 HP / 252 Def / 252 SpDef maximizes its overalll bulk. The only time I would see 252 HP necessary is when you need 350+ Wishes, which in of itself is overkill.
Still though, you've got shit like Latias, Reuniclus, NP Mew, and many other Psyshock users that Chansey needs to, at the very least, hard check for its team, and the max HP/Defense spread works better for that.
Ding dong, the bitch is dead! That does my heart good. Gotta contend with some dangerous new Pokemon now, but it's all gonna be okay.Chansey