-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)
- Thread starter charlieum
- Start date
Honestly Alice flipping maf makes this solve a lot easier imo. Since Shane and Cel are still almost certainly not teammates I'd guess it's either
1. Alice/Shane/HyHy or Laurel or AF/Jalmont
2. Alice/Celever/Laurel or AF/Jalmont.
I don't see this dynamic changing much based on if Jalmont is 3P or not
And the HyHy townspew is probably wishful thinking, any observation about Alice's thread behavior has to come with the "new player" asterisk
1. Alice/Shane/HyHy or Laurel or AF/Jalmont
2. Alice/Celever/Laurel or AF/Jalmont.
I don't see this dynamic changing much based on if Jalmont is 3P or not
And the HyHy townspew is probably wishful thinking, any observation about Alice's thread behavior has to come with the "new player" asterisk
I'm also forgetting about Joey in every theory I craft but that's typical and I hope to remedy that a bit today
From my perspective it has to be. It makes no sense not to touch them and kill the roleblocker when those roles are more threatening to mafia.
It is probably Celever/Shane though.
That's what he said on D2 yeah
Well it does give an answer for why town is so PR stacked, I'm not surprised
the thing is, most of the town roles are useless against this combo
I keep asking myself "is laurel's role the mafia's answer to a dayvig" but it seems really weird for them to assume that there's a dayvig out there when they likely have day kill power and wouldn't think so.
and then I go "but why bother giving it to clouds" and the argument is p much towncred lol.
and then I go "but why bother giving it to clouds" and the argument is p much towncred lol.
Idk, I'm not sure if Charlie would design the game with that many useless roles, it casts more doubt on AF/Laurel in particular. I smell a safeclaimer in one of those, or maybe Celever too. Same logic would apply to Saber if he was still live and claimed
usually when you design the setup like that the philosophy is "I don't want town to use role speculation as a crutch for finding scum, I want town to read scum properly" but uh, we've been failing hard this game lol
Well in that case we're better off with M2H dead, sounds like a thread leader who only thinks in mech terms is a pretty bad fit for this
Laurel gave me nothing last night and Celever visited JALMONT
I'll catch up tomorrow morning, just got back from work and not doing this right now
I'll catch up tomorrow morning, just got back from work and not doing this right now
Good shot by the way, I'm bad
I'm assuming we have to vote out JALMONT regardless here no matter what he says his win con is but I'll get the full details tomorrow
the is little reason to keep a non town player alive
Can you run me through the scenario where I’m not town
what is my win condition?
doesn't Joey's role reveal you as not town?
I used my ability 'Empower' (resolves end of day) on you and your action succeeded. There isn't a physical item like a vest.
who do you think this is referring to if not mejoey's role said:
if you think i am 3p, please explain to me my win condition and how my play so far has forwarded that win condition
how would it provide false investigations if you are a dayvig though
clouds the TOWN COP said:
let's get it, i am marowak the dojo master
...and also the town cop. the reason i switched to a townread on Duskfall98 is because i checked him N1 and it returned innocent. i'm not a perfect town cop though, all i can do is learn if someone is able to kill due to their role or alignment, which i assume is because JALMONT is a vigilante. so if i was to inspect a town killing role, it'd still return guilty. duskfall can be 3P that can't kill, but he can't be be mafia, so i'm treating him as town
to everyone else: massclaim is fine at this point, because we had enough townie roles outed already that mafia were always gonna have kill targets. so might as well make up the difference and overwhelm them with kill possibilities. also, i think it's good for me to claim here anyways because people are suspicious of me and duskfall to some extent, so now you're gonna have to work with both of us being town. have fun!
##vote joey
ok whatever you can read that as it still being a truthful result in which case i guess there's a godfather in this game likely separate from their team
it's very tempting to give up i was going to do another analysis tonight but i'm a little burned out on mafia so gonna skip. i'll let the town geniuses in this game who have had a lot of success so far take over. carry me plz
it's very tempting to give up i was going to do another analysis tonight but i'm a little burned out on mafia so gonna skip. i'll let the town geniuses in this game who have had a lot of success so far take over. carry me plz