idts unless Shane is also scum tbh. if joey's last scum he has to kill carry, and his safeclaim provides no explanation for him being seeing in a watcher or tracker report. to me that's not safe enough to put in the game.
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)
- Thread starter charlieum
- Start date
That is just not true, AF made a point of being holier than thou against both parties
during the fight with Shane, a fairy said that Shane looked scummier but then she tunnelled me as the scum in the duo instead of Shane soon after. a tunnel she's still in!
i was considering going flanders into hydro into a
she definitely soft defended someone a bit more Celever which was it?
she definitely soft defended someone a bit more Celever which was it?
(she's also pushed the me/shane t/m narrative a lot which you know my feelings on lol)
whats your towncore rn
this game doesn't have a towncore. you're probably not the godfather. that's the towncore.
I doubt I would vote out bluedoom any time soon so he also gets up there. not full towncore because I will tinfoil that if we're both alive late in the game but he's not on a list to vote out rn.
JALMONT might be worming his way up to towncore territory too. I wouldn't vote him out soon but there are mech reasons why we might have to vote him out later so is that really towncore.
Flandrs is the bridge because I still townread him but I also don't outright disagree with what others have said about him. I just read him as reducing-in-quality town rather than reducing-in-quality scum.
i cant really vote Flanders here in good conscience, just don't really think he's a wolf, no time to do a towncase beyond my early musings and I'm not too sure my reads are good this game, I'm going to offer what I think is a revelatory alternative
##Vote HydrogenHydreigon
in the back of my mind i'm Always going to be willing to vote Celever but his posting has improved in the last few days from what I've been able to read and i don't really have the confidence in any of my reads necessary to go against the concensus of the thread
im gong to be busy at work till eod, I'll probably tryhard a catchup and refresh my reads if it gets to the point where my vote is very important since i owe it to the game to play this out, despite my own feelings and waning interest
gl today, hope we hit
##Vote HydrogenHydreigon
in the back of my mind i'm Always going to be willing to vote Celever but his posting has improved in the last few days from what I've been able to read and i don't really have the confidence in any of my reads necessary to go against the concensus of the thread
im gong to be busy at work till eod, I'll probably tryhard a catchup and refresh my reads if it gets to the point where my vote is very important since i owe it to the game to play this out, despite my own feelings and waning interest
gl today, hope we hit
you dont think shane is probably town atp?
oh
##Vote a fairy
i think if Celever is villa i have zero reasons to townread her, less than hh
##Vote a fairy
i think if Celever is villa i have zero reasons to townread her, less than hh
i read about that being "mechanically correct" yeah and certainly we will probably
was unrelated to what you said actually haha
0 reasons to townread her, or you ahve reasons to scumread her?
i mean i don't think this is a set conclusion, it would be perfectly fine to vote hh today if there's a case for him
no real confidence in anything like that at this point, i think I've been looking for the wrong things this game when it comes to scum reading, i feel very rusty
the best i can do is say that someone has never compellingly given me villa feelings and cast that way.
that vote probably will not change though, i have to go work
not really. I don't think a self-watcher and a watcher are implausible scumbuddies, especially with Shane's role being as restricted as it was / is. I certainly don't think mech implies him town.
You can argue that it's good that he didn't lie about me doccing. I think that forcing that 1v1 would be worse in the longterm for scum!shane because it means he dies today or tomorrow whereas if he just reports the watch accurately he could endgame.
'early'?
sorry buddy
from what i gather i probably have the mechanically strongest role yet still alive so i don't think needing reasons from me to evaluate my alignment will be too relevant, I'm probably a mechanically correct kill and the only reason to keep me alive would be the fact that my reads are poor (not terribly unlikely)