Oh tbf you're my top town read and I don't want to tinfoil you as godfather here because that's a lot more ridiculous.
The bolded is where I'm like "why would mafia even shoot tommy instead of neon or the doc???"
-
Check out the relaunch of our general collection, with classic designs and new ones by our very own Pissog!
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Mafia - Explorers - Game Thread (Game Over!)
- Thread starter charlieum
- Start date
Oh tbf you're my top town read and I don't want to tinfoil you as godfather here because that's a lot more ridiculous.
The bolded is where I'm like "why would mafia even shoot tommy instead of neon or the doc???"
I did consider the holster too tbf, I checked and mafia can apparently holster infinitely (which I guess is why we can only no vote once)
The kill depends on who it is, like if hydro is mafia he kind of probably has to shoot me you or maybe a fairy last night to get though?
I doubt anyone but celever would’ve holstered last night tbf since he’s the only person who gets any sort of gain out of it (town cred wise)
but I’m also hoping he’s just town all 3 of mafia roles have had protection / disruptive messing up roles so far, and the unliked does too based on strongman + day kill so the mafia have a had insane amounts of counter play
The kill depends on who it is, like if hydro is mafia he kind of probably has to shoot me you or maybe a fairy last night to get though?
I doubt anyone but celever would’ve holstered last night tbf since he’s the only person who gets any sort of gain out of it (town cred wise)
but I’m also hoping he’s just town all 3 of mafia roles have had protection / disruptive messing up roles so far, and the unliked does too based on strongman + day kill so the mafia have a had insane amounts of counter play
Yeah agreed about the doc
The flip side of this is that all the mafia so far have actually had their fake claims as part of their role
so even if celever is mafia then doc is part of his role right?
yeah probably, doc is just such an easy fake to make though lmao.
That does make me wonder why mafia had protection roles like jailkeeper. Jalmont couldn't hit during the night so...red herring?
Duskfall98 do you think flanders-joey was a crossbus? Because I didn't read it like that at all
What do you folks make of Hydro's behavior so far, his only real defense was to invoke the AF doctrine at 7518
af doctrine?
Saying "ok but im town lol" and pretending not to care
yeah its hard to really see that behaviour being townie. I don't really have a reason to townread HH given that he hasn't done anything this game, has been offwagon on every mafia lynch. What keeps me doubting it is ofc how the flipped mafia shaded his slot unanimously and were fine with offing him. I mean its that plus mafia killing tommy instead of celever makes sense if its coming from people not really comprehending the thread, like hh/neon. Otherwise I just find that claim hard to believe?
only if you know there’s no other doc in the game though
jk with doc is also a weird combo, jk is good on mafia though anyways since it’s a roleblocker it’s as good on both alignments imo, even if town has no night kp
I’ll have to go read back I guess
my ultimate answer is I think the likeliest mafia is hydro and everyone else has very good reasons to be town so if hydro is town it’s a tough call, but some people are more obviously town than others imo
He’s complete lhf this game behaviour wise, regardless of his alignment
yeah people shading hydro is a fair point that is the only thing that makes me doubt a bit
Tommy let me ask you a question about last night. What mafia, in their right mind, is going to try and kill you when you're the most obvious doc target ever? I don't buy that it's not obvious once Shane goes down.
You would have to ask the mafia, I also believe it was a bad shot