You ever wonder if Pokémon Showdown is going to be DMCAD someday?
On one hand, it's pretty farfetched to think about, considering it's been up since BW2, and there's thousands of videos of it on YouTube. It isn't obscure. Yet nintendo nor tpc has taken any action.
But on the other, the nintendo ninjas strike like thieves in the night so I'm not that sure.
What I'm saying is that in terms of Nintendo axing Showdown isn't likely, but I wouldn't put it past them. And I shudder what the competitive fandom would have to do to raise their competitive teams using the hellspawn that is cartridge gameplay.
Do you guys agree?
In order for nintendo to actually DMCA showdown, they would need solid evidence that the PS team is doing at least 1 of the following:
1. Making a profit off of their software. This is what led to brick bronze getting shut down, because the game had microtransactions (albeit very few).
2. Using copyrighted materials. Although things like logos are easy to get copyrights on, it's far harder to get designs, and if they decide to crack down on their old sprites that have gotten released to the public over the years, PS just needs to replace them all with art, which would take time (enjoy the april fool's sprites for a while) but can definitely be worked around
3: PS is a software that actively helps pirate the original pokemon media. I'm mostly throwing this in for semantics (PS is obviously not handing out download links to roms) but this was the reason Yuzu/Citra got shut down. Yuzu, for regularly putting out updates meant specifically to improve performance for TOTK, as well as making money, and Citra, because they were able to cobble together an argument in court that if Yuzu was making money off of this, then Citra would be too.
Fortunately for us, PS has yet to do any of these things. There's no evidence PS is taking funds off the top of their donations, they don't plaster the copyrighted logo everywhere, and they aren't pirating anything. Until copyright laws change, PS will be fine.