NOC Working Title Mafia (Game Thread) [Mafia Wins]

i'm going to sleep in the next bit, i'll post readlists with reasoning tmrw when I can analyze the thread
 
ElectricityCat said:
1) for what I said in my post #690 I can't determine any stance from him. I saw all his messages in the thread and I don't see him giving an opinion on anything that isn't very obvious.

2) Simply from reading how he's playing THIS game, he's not giving much explanation for his actions to see the reaction of others, but then he argues concisely and coherently.

I was also his teammate in the previous Mafia game of the temples and saw/heard that his style is different from the conventional one for the reasons mentioned above.

That's what I observe, at least.

3) Honestly, I’ve never made one of these reads lists, but it would be something like this:

Town: Lechen, Hydreigon
Probably town: Jalmont, Alice, Joey, M2H
Neutral: DBD, Genisu, probably everyone else
Slightly scum: Saber, Redless
No read: Des, Catfries, Flanders (I don’t really understand his aggressive playstyle)
Click to expand...
Why am I slight scum?
 
genisu said:
#1 you have no friends in this game everyone is an enemy, for example me and alice are good friends outside but here i try my best to have no positive bias vs her, which has helped me a lot.
#2 Jalmont, Alice, Joey, M2H I also like how they post, the ideas that really point towards something concrete. I feel they are trying to contribute to the town. didnt you just say jalmont was thinking incoherently, and can you explain your thoughts as to what is concrete in the following 3 peoples posts?
Click to expand...

1) this very hard for me :psycry: but I got your point, it completely makes sense.

2) No, maybe I didn't explain myself well because English is not my native language. But what I meant to say is that Jalmont, at first glance, makes posts that catch attention, like #649, but I really think he has reasoning behind them. They aren't random comments even if they seem so at first. I get that feeling from what I read in his other messages before #649 where he talks a bit about the game.

Now I’m going to sleep, good night.
 
Reads:
Towncore:
me ofc
Genisu (his postings are consistent as always despite his arrogance and despite how much I dislike his angle shooting and his condescending attitude)
Townread:
HyHy (love his postings, is on point but I see powerwolf hyhy as well even tho it's hella unlikely)
Strong Townlean:
M2H (good posting, good points, don't like obsession over the first saber post but that's it)
Flandrs (gutread, I feel like he would try to pocket me if he was scum but instead he started by being the Flandrs I think is town)
Townlean:
Jalmont (fun fact autocorrect changed this to "harmony" is it trying to say something? Anyways jalmont feels like the tos jalmont and doesn't read scum)
joey (good posting esp with his defense)
Mixed:
Ecat (good posting, mention of friendship is weird)
Alice (is town if M2H is scum, these two don't feel paired. mixed posting but entry was good)
Light scumlean:
Catfries (no posts lmao)
dbd (middling posts but I feel like Des is scum and DBD is not paired with Des basically 100%)
Scumlean:
saber (doesn't feel like tos saber but posting is weird.might be light scumlean)
Pulsar (weird post, bad posting, not reading the thread. They haven't been that active in Diplo so maybe she's just busy idk)
Scumread:
Des (terrible posting, doesn't feel like noob town this slot is very scummy)
Redless
(Weird focus on wolf reading werewolf on their slot)
 
Lechen said:
Reads:
Towncore:
me ofc
Genisu (his postings are consistent as always despite his arrogance and despite how much I dislike his angle shooting and his condescending attitude)
Townread:
HyHy (love his postings, is on point but I see powerwolf hyhy as well even tho it's hella unlikely)
Strong Townlean:
M2H (good posting, good points, don't like obsession over the first saber post but that's it)
Flandrs (gutread, I feel like he would try to pocket me if he was scum but instead he started by being the Flandrs I think is town)
Townlean:
Jalmont (fun fact autocorrect changed this to "harmony" is it trying to say something? Anyways jalmont feels like the tos jalmont and doesn't read scum)
joey (good posting esp with his defense)
Mixed:
Ecat (good posting, mention of friendship is weird)
Alice (is town if M2H is scum, these two don't feel paired. mixed posting but entry was good)
Light scumlean:
Catfries (no posts lmao)
dbd (middling posts but I feel like Des is scum and DBD is not paired with Des basically 100%)
Scumlean:
saber (doesn't feel like tos saber but posting is weird.might be light scumlean)
Pulsar (weird post, bad posting, not reading the thread. They haven't been that active in Diplo so maybe she's just busy idk)
Scumread:
Des (terrible posting, doesn't feel like noob town this slot is very scummy)
Redless
(Weird focus on wolf reading werewolf on their slot)
Click to expand...
i disagree with your alice points, m2h switched very fast could be a light bus and i feel like des seems like saber his first game as 3p, gives wolf vibes idk
 
Votecount 1.5 - Hopefully this is, for once, an accurate edition
joey (3): M2H, Alice, Redless
Redless (2): Flandrs, ElectricityCat
Flandrs (2): Jalmont, des
Dead by Daylight (1): genisu
Jalmont (1): Dead by Daylight
des (1): Lechen
Not Voting: pulsar, Catfries, saber, joey, des121, Hydro
 
I'm not really feeling this game honestly - I'll be in class at deadline so won't be around. I don't really like any of the mainstream options. I suppose I'm okay with saber/dbd/flanders (depending on how flanders is from now until I can't check the thread). Didn't really like saber or dbd's responses to my pushes.

I'll try and come back to this in a few minutes
 
JALMONT said:
I'm not really feeling this game honestly - I'll be in class at deadline so won't be around. I don't really like any of the mainstream options. I suppose I'm okay with saber/dbd/flanders (depending on how flanders is from now until I can't check the thread). Didn't really like saber or dbd's responses to my pushes.

I'll try and come back to this in a few minutes
Click to expand...
do you have any options you do like?
 
not sure if you consider the three you mentioned there mainstream so i'll specify
assuming you consider the three votes you said you were ok with as mainstream and thus "don't really like" them, what are the non-mainstream options you like
 
just the three guys i listed but i don't really feel super strongly about them in all fairness. honestly i still believe day 1 vote might as well be randed so we should just spin the wheel but that's not really fun
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top