good day
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Low Power Mafia -- Mafia Win
- Thread starter Celever
- Start date
I don’t think it is fair to say I blanketed my entire wagon town because I had said I was fine with pulsar going, but I do get what you mean in the sense that I didn’t push her super hard. Interesting read from you because I think that’s actually part of what I was being scumread for, but I can believe the process
- Jalmont
Has seemed fine to me. Seems pretty pure Jal right now in my mind, which is to say that I don't think he's acting oddly or anything. I could absolutely see him as being scum down the line, but for the moment my gut instinct is that he's VT and is playing as he can in the situation.
-Eli
God it's great to play with him again. He's one of my stronger townreads, I really don't think he comes out and tries to powerwolf that way the way he has been, especially in a game with so many strong players that I know he'd respect. Though, if he stays alive until late game, I'll start to get worried. But right now I trust him a lot.
-Tommy
Not a fan currently, other than literally the last 12 hours or so, Tommy hasn't really felt like Tommy. I don't know what that means, and I don't think it necessarily indicates scumminess, but I'm much lower on this slot than I wish I was. I could see this improving, but I'm not currently reading his posts with the level of comfort that I would like to be. Most of his posting has been empty "skilled player tutoring" too rather than guiding gamestate forward (vs, say, Eli) which makes me wonder if that's a desired goal. Of course, this is super hypocritical of me to say, seeing as this is my second ever readslist, and I have been the person going back and forth with CK on gameplay tips and stuff for a fair bit of D1.
-your current vote or my current vote (if you are not voting realiti)
I'm currently on realiti. I like that vote, not of my own reads necessarily but due to the logic provided by the NE dossier and the overall net-positive opinions I have on most of the people on that wagon. (Currently an AG fan, as an example)
apricity
Has seemed fine to me. Seems pretty pure Jal right now in my mind, which is to say that I don't think he's acting oddly or anything. I could absolutely see him as being scum down the line, but for the moment my gut instinct is that he's VT and is playing as he can in the situation.
-Eli
God it's great to play with him again. He's one of my stronger townreads, I really don't think he comes out and tries to powerwolf that way the way he has been, especially in a game with so many strong players that I know he'd respect. Though, if he stays alive until late game, I'll start to get worried. But right now I trust him a lot.
-Tommy
Not a fan currently, other than literally the last 12 hours or so, Tommy hasn't really felt like Tommy. I don't know what that means, and I don't think it necessarily indicates scumminess, but I'm much lower on this slot than I wish I was. I could see this improving, but I'm not currently reading his posts with the level of comfort that I would like to be. Most of his posting has been empty "skilled player tutoring" too rather than guiding gamestate forward (vs, say, Eli) which makes me wonder if that's a desired goal. Of course, this is super hypocritical of me to say, seeing as this is my second ever readslist, and I have been the person going back and forth with CK on gameplay tips and stuff for a fair bit of D1.
-your current vote or my current vote (if you are not voting realiti)
I'm currently on realiti. I like that vote, not of my own reads necessarily but due to the logic provided by the NE dossier and the overall net-positive opinions I have on most of the people on that wagon. (Currently an AG fan, as an example)
apricity
SOD1 neon wagon didn’t really exist, so my thought is that early on scum would be more likely to jump on me than support the cw I was vanitying and potentially look paired or TMIING me town
GZ FAIRY
i have told you my reads
There was DBD iirc
oh yeah i guess there was
awesome.
Can you (and you can use the search function if you want) tell me one interesting read that jalmont has?
1473 - one of the few game reads on chickening
1295 - a realiti "sus read" before the ne dossier
1219 - a dbd read that i dont really buy into but i'd call interesting
1215 - one of the few people i saw wondering why AP got shot
i didnt look at his iso too closely admittedly
how would you describe normal tommy gameplay?
I do actually like to gambit as scum on occasion but that’s not the type of gambit I’d pull, my scum game is definitely more aggressive / controlling than my town game and I’d be inclined to push a wagon rather than townhunt
this is a good question i dont know that i can answer tbh. i dunno most of your posting has either been non-existent or non-game-relevant posting w/ CK talking about mafia gameplay theory. again super hypocritical on that last part seeing as it's me talking but. idk maybe you start working towards the solve more often and don't vanish for entire cycles and then my thoughts improve but right now most of your presence has felt filler and that doesnt feel like tommy to me
This is super interesting. I'd like to engage with you on this very deeply
calling 1473 a game read is a stretch
1295 is a realiti TOWN read -- he says that realiti's scum game is predicated on pushing easy votes and not engaging on the game, which is why he is not voting realiti
This is 1219 -- it's calling out an interesting post
and 1215 is, like you said, just wondering why the guy who got shot got shot
i think he has expressed nearly zero opinions that I can hold his game to and that for me is very, very strange
What's your take?
I think the theoretical talk is fine here because it does tie in to the justification for his reads
hey I’m tour hosting expect activity to drop
here you are