NOC Lumiose Legends Mafia - GAME OVER (Mafia Win)

I am gonna wait for hyhys post and give my reaction to that and then prob wait till tmrw and will post a readslist after all players have had a chance to post. Had some vax today and am not feeling 100% too so will sleep. If want my thoughts on other stuff pls ask
 
guys the cognitive dissonance is insane for me rn just based off of 1298-1302 posts.

- charlie's 1298 seems extremely tmi and coordinated with ck's 1301 vig claim. 1302 is also weird bc i think charlie was around when ck was going hard on tommy so why was it a surprise? like maybe its just me but ck vigging tommy was not surprising at all (bad, maybe, but not surprising) given his read on tommy d1
however, what are the implications of this?
- if ck/charlie are s/s and tommy was the mafia kill then what of blazade's death? 3p or an actual town vig, surely they have the foresight to like see. hey. two deaths maybe there is a town vig and we could get cc'd. but then again what town vig shoots blazade. god idk bc up until this point i was leaning town on charlie and was prepared to be a ck defender, and i kind of stil am bc i think if you read his past posts the progression on tommy makes sense!! charlie has townie progression making sense posts too! i dont know at this point i think they're becoming scummier for md
- ck mentioned scum!charlie possibly having a track result on him resulting in tmi which is an option i hadnt thought of before
- option three is im reading too much into this and ck is fully just town vig and mafia shot blazade which is not unreasaonble ig but doesnt address the tmi concerns i had

god that was a lot of stream-of-thought and word vomit. tldr im fully conflicted over my ck/charlie reads rn
 
Like if this was closer to an endgame scenario I think I would almost certainly vote CK here because it just makes too much sense from a wagon deflection standpoint. The vig claim with no CC makes us not want to vote out KP and explains a kill but it also gives an excuse to live another day or two b/c it takes 2 cycles to charge up again (so the slot, if true, is not a threat whatsoever). That extra couple of days would be critical in end-game but not here??
 
But the fact that this ISN'T close to endgame yet makes CK's claim a bit more believable. But I do think the timing is strange, especially after there were only 2 kills (unlike the 3? I would expect with a SK role) IK that doesn't do too much to develop the pairing idea but that's just my current train of thought.
 
Gonna go to bed soon but if anyone has last minute interaction they want to do before I sleep I will check thread one last time after I get ready for bed.

Last thought for now is that I agree with this statement
charlieum said:
Withholding thoughts on AG and AF but I really want them to engage with the actual thread instead of each other because both have been kind of flies on the wall threadwise.
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top