Had them as a like bottom 5 read heading in toward the end of the day, and then voted them after the claim
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Lumiose Legends Mafia - GAME OVER (Mafia Win)
- Thread starter StupidFlandrs48
- Start date
1. Gut and Vibes. The reason for not tying the vote was weird when the EoD flurry was already there. A far more likely reason to not vote NE would be to not bus a teammate.
2. If I'm reading your translation right, then: Yes.
re: early NE on pulsar
continued sl on pulsar
sus on Lechen (which NE claims to later misremember as a DBD post)
literally asking for a pulsar vote
votes DBD, at this point only Des is on the wagon, but between this and the next update about the wagon, Des left, meaning NE is alone on the DBD wagon
Says something that sorta(?) supports the claim for the Lechen/DBD mixup
Moves from solo voting DBD to solo voting pulsar
Realization for the mixup later on
- I think the progression makes sense
- Agreed, but so is a good chunk of the pl
- Agreed, but wouldn't that be equally for Mekkah, Lechen, and AG who all actually ended up on the DBD wagon?
- Meta read
- Due to the role claim
I really do not think NE is our best vote here
Dead by Daylight why did you attempt to vote charlie?
pulsar512b Hello, can you talk about the game/interact with thread? What are your thoughts on the AligningStar wagon? Thoughts on CK's vote on me?
skippergamez What's your read on CK? Your recent posting makes me believe you are suspicious of them, and I am noticing a lack of vote
bluedoom What's your read on AG?
pulsar512b Hello, can you talk about the game/interact with thread? What are your thoughts on the AligningStar wagon? Thoughts on CK's vote on me?
skippergamez What's your read on CK? Your recent posting makes me believe you are suspicious of them, and I am noticing a lack of vote
bluedoom What's your read on AG?
Aura Guardian give me your case for NightEmerald that doesn’t involve the charlie not wanting to tie the vote?
Aura Guardian you're basically saying "imma role thief mekkah n3" right? go for it, not like i can stop you
Oh yeah, speaking as a former Smogon role madness town roleblocker, I agree, I see DBD’s getting roleblocked as null
https://www.smogon.com/forums/threa...fia-game-thread.3757566/page-44#post-10394910
here we are. i see people mostly using post #s as shorthand instead of links but there's no super quick way to refer back to those right?
here we are. i see people mostly using post #s as shorthand instead of links but there's no super quick way to refer back to those right?
I recommend a second tab if you’re not on mobile
4 pages is 100, 10 pages is 250, if you remember those associations you can pretty quickly find the post
I will also say I think it’s unlikely the specific s/s theater you mention re: charlie/CK because charlie mentioned it basically as soon as the day began, so it wasn’t in response to CK being in danger
Still could be theater to give CK a chance to fakeclaim but eh
would not vote right now (not necessarily because I think they're all town)
Aura Guardian - has an active role claim. i don't think it makes him a whole lot cleaner but i wouldn't hate it if he got his action off n3. that said if he does something scummy i'd move him out of here.
HyHy - his posts strike me as towny. I'd like to find an opportunity to go back and forth with him but I think our timezones match up poorly.
a fairy - even if AG is a mafia his claim strikes me more as TMIing a town than a scum/scum setup. glad to see af posting more on-topic on d2
CrreamyKitty - I think that vig role use and claim is wild but I can't wrap my head around this being a scum gambit. although the claimed kill being on cooldown is convenient if CK is scum. that said i'm against voting people who claimed on principle. i am contemplating on whether it makes sense for CrreamyKitty to give more info - like if there's any prospect of mega evolving to get rid of the cooldown - but i think that might give scum too much info. i'd rather they be the ones to think over whether it's worth killing a vig. I think if I was scum I would evaluate this on a night by night basis. if CK scumreads a bunch of town you'd rather leave him alive.
des121 - I do not find her posts very helpful and if someone else posted like that I would not put them in this category. I agree with the earlier assessment someone (Tommy?) made that she plays for self preservation. which I think is gonna work, I don't think scum is killing her any time soon regardless of her alignment.
Of those I'd rank their towniness for me rn as a fairy > HyHy > CK > des.
That leaves a fair amount of people but let me cross reference that with my EOD1 evaluation.
Aura Guardian - has an active role claim. i don't think it makes him a whole lot cleaner but i wouldn't hate it if he got his action off n3. that said if he does something scummy i'd move him out of here.
HyHy - his posts strike me as towny. I'd like to find an opportunity to go back and forth with him but I think our timezones match up poorly.
a fairy - even if AG is a mafia his claim strikes me more as TMIing a town than a scum/scum setup. glad to see af posting more on-topic on d2
CrreamyKitty - I think that vig role use and claim is wild but I can't wrap my head around this being a scum gambit. although the claimed kill being on cooldown is convenient if CK is scum. that said i'm against voting people who claimed on principle. i am contemplating on whether it makes sense for CrreamyKitty to give more info - like if there's any prospect of mega evolving to get rid of the cooldown - but i think that might give scum too much info. i'd rather they be the ones to think over whether it's worth killing a vig. I think if I was scum I would evaluate this on a night by night basis. if CK scumreads a bunch of town you'd rather leave him alive.
des121 - I do not find her posts very helpful and if someone else posted like that I would not put them in this category. I agree with the earlier assessment someone (Tommy?) made that she plays for self preservation. which I think is gonna work, I don't think scum is killing her any time soon regardless of her alignment.
Of those I'd rank their towniness for me rn as a fairy > HyHy > CK > des.
That leaves a fair amount of people but let me cross reference that with my EOD1 evaluation.
Yeah I think if you do that as an act, you set it up n1 because you expect CK to be in danger due to how EoD went.
I think the AligningStar vote doesn't have all the scum in it. Which from my POV makes me want to look closely at skipper, Lechen, sunny, bluedoom and Lechen. But I would feel safe as mafia parking like 1 vote there, which right now I would have to guess is NightEmerald.
When I got more time I wanna look at those posters in isolation which I'm guessing is what ISOing means?
When I got more time I wanna look at those posters in isolation which I'm guessing is what ISOing means?
I had 8 tabs open and I still got lost
Who is the second Lechen?
I just realized Lechen shows up twice in host votecounts lol. Does he really have two different votes? That's such an odd ability. I was just looking at the votecount in in 1289 when writing that list and I don't think there's anyone else that I meant.
The only people I haven't mentioned there who are a) off-wagon b) not flipped yet and c) not in my "would not vote off" list is DBD. I already said I think he is suspicious (that's why I kept my vote on him d1) though I really don't think d1 activity is a great scumtell nor does it give the most info to flip that person so I can see myself voting someone else.
Well I guess there's pulsar but I need to see what her d2 looks like first.
The only people I haven't mentioned there who are a) off-wagon b) not flipped yet and c) not in my "would not vote off" list is DBD. I already said I think he is suspicious (that's why I kept my vote on him d1) though I really don't think d1 activity is a great scumtell nor does it give the most info to flip that person so I can see myself voting someone else.
Well I guess there's pulsar but I need to see what her d2 looks like first.