NOC Lumiose Legends Mafia - GAME OVER (Mafia Win)

Mekkah said:
Oh I wasn't even factoring in NE's mixup here, my motivation to vote him was just gut feeling + inactivity. Which I'm aware isn't the strongest reason but I thought it'd be a good place to park my vote.

I just became aware Isolate Posts is a button you can use btw, I've been using search this whole time to look through NE, sunny, bluedoom and skipper...my impression of NE has not improved. I still agree with most of what sunny says, maybe because we're both OC players we think the same way?

From what I can see with skippergamez it looks like he scumleaned Vizh, charlie and Lechen in 1009 and now swapped Lechen for bluedoom.

More thoughts on that later I need to get to work again
Click to expand...
search is better imo because its exclusively posts from this thread
 
I didn't even notice the difference imo

Maybe I'm missing something but claiming blocked seems very NAI until we have a lot more info about what roles are in the game. Either the town randed onto you (could be either), or the mafia randed onto you (you're town) or you're just a mafia liar. There's like a possibility that mafia!DBD knows the mafia roleblock failed and so he can claim it was on him? I don't think it's worth assigning any worth to.
 
Mekkah said:
I didn't even notice the difference imo

Maybe I'm missing something but claiming blocked seems very NAI until we have a lot more info about what roles are in the game. Either the town randed onto you (could be either), or the mafia randed onto you (you're town) or you're just a mafia liar. There's like a possibility that mafia!DBD knows the mafia roleblock failed and so he can claim it was on him? I don't think it's worth assigning any worth to.
Click to expand...
Yeah agreed, if he’s scum then either they know a rb failed, they used it on tommy who I shot, or the rb doesn’t even exist and he claimed it because it looks towny.

If he’s town, scum rbd him (idk why him of all people) which they obviously don’t flaim, or town rb was on him (more likely) which isn’t worth outing yourself to claim the rb on dbd
 
HydrogenHydreigon said:
thoughts on dbd:
i came into today with a rather negative opinion on his slot and nothing has made me change that. hes honestly rly giving disengaged mafia. 1331 would have been good if he followed it up with good posting but nope, its just all super surface level and doesnt seem to be genuinely solvy. what i esp dont like is his "vote analysis" post 1422 where he calls out ne/vizh and then uses that as an excuse to make no content for the rest of the day. his only substantive post after that being 1801 "vote NE i need answers man" fully indicates to me he seems to be using that post as an indirect (direct? idk how to describe) excuse to not be a productive member of town.
also again the not genuinely solvy point. dbd doesn't explain anything. why did he randomly vote charlie? why does he want to start with voting vizh and ne on the aligning wagon?? when he says "give me a reason why I should vote the other over you" what is he looking for?? what makes people more towny and lessy towny to him?? it just seems so fake solvy

dbd is fully a vote consideration for me today
Click to expand...
charlie vote was a moment of madness

I wanted to vote the D1 wagon that lead to a townie’s death as well as analyze who solidified the counter push from me to ASS.

I’m looking for a small towncase on yourself/scum case on the other when I ask why they should stay over the other person. Forcing them to give this response also clues me in about their solving.

Being towny to me means trying to advance the gamestate as well as having votes that are, at worst, slightly scum-sided to NAI
 
Dead by Daylight said:
charlie vote was a moment of madness

I wanted to vote the D1 wagon that lead to a townie’s death as well as analyze who solidified the counter push from me to ASS.

I’m looking for a small towncase on yourself/scum case on the other when I ask why they should stay over the other person. Forcing them to give this response also clues me in about their solving.

Being towny to me means trying to advance the gamestate as well as having votes that are, at worst, slightly scum-sided to NAI
Click to expand...
Yeah this is like, pretty commonplace thinking and not a bad way to think esp if you’re scared of misclearing scum more than anything, but I think the issue with this is that villagers who are struggling to keep up become incredibly hard to find, and when you can’t find those villagers you often lose games because of it.

I think it’s not worth taking scumsided/townsided voting and “solviness” at face value, because wolves have enough information and wolfteam coaching on their hands (even without daychat) to fake both better than the villagers left at the bottom of the POE, what I’m generally looking for to find villagers is either posts/votes that are -EV for wolf regardless of team composition, and for genuine thought processes that make sense for you to go through as villager, uninfluenced by TMI, and much harder for you to fake as wolf, regardless of how wolfsidey the post looks at face value.

Thanks for listening to my yap sessiob
 
Lechen said:
your sus content on me is literally me saying something generally applicable to all mafia games that is my opinion LOL so idk where you are getting this from. your slot looks worse and worse with each passing post
Click to expand...
No my sus content on you is you saying I don’t have to try on day 1 bc it’s a rand. That is not and should not be applicable to all mafia games.
 
skippergamez said:
No my sus content on you is you saying I don’t have to try on day 1 bc it’s a rand. That is not and should not be applicable to all mafia games.
Click to expand...
?? that IS applicable to basically every noc game lol, day 1 is like basically always a rand imo, and I genuinely think that. If you scumread me solely for having an opinion on the game that is not specific to this game idk what to say lmao
 
Mekkah said:
I just became aware Isolate Posts is a button you can use btw, I've been using search this whole time to look through NE, sunny, bluedoom and skipper...my impression of NE has not improved. I still agree with most of what sunny says, maybe because we're both OC players we think the same way?
Click to expand...
iso (isolate posts) is better for people who dont do anything on this site other than a mafia game (which tbf is most of us, most of the time) because it is basically a "search for posts on this site by this user" but the search function is better for folks who are active elsewhere (sorry) because it searches in this specific thread.
 
i am not particularly convinced by the bd case. but im not necessarily against it either. i think id rather vote pulsar or dbd i guess? i feel like im kind of lost for as to where to put my vote unfortunately, which means im likely to be relying on wagon rosters as to where to place my vote which im not thrilled abt at the end of a d2
 
Votecount 2.5: Where is Everyone?
pulsar512b (2): Vizh, des121
bluedoom (2): sunny004, Aura Guardian, skippergamez
skippergamez (2): bluedoom, Lechen
Dead by Daylight (2): Lechen, HydrogrenHydreigon
NightEmerald (2): Dead by Daylight, Mekkah
Aura Guardian (1): charlieum

Not Voting (6): , a fairy, pulsar512b, NightEmerald

Hammer will be called at 8 votes.

Deadline is in ? hours. Please notify me of any errors I may have made in this VC.
 
Vizh said:
Votecount 2.5: Where is Everyone?
pulsar512b (2): Vizh, des121
bluedoom (2): sunny004, Aura Guardian, skippergamez
skippergamez (2): bluedoom, Lechen
Dead by Daylight (2): Lechen, HydrogrenHydreigon
NightEmerald (2): Dead by Daylight, Mekkah
Aura Guardian (1): charlieum

Not Voting (6): , a fairy, pulsar512b, NightEmerald

Hammer will be called at 8 votes.

Deadline is in ? hours. Please notify me of any errors I may have made in this VC.
Click to expand...
skipper is on BD’s wagon it should be at 3
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top