-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Town of Salem 2 Mafia: Revival - WON BY THE MAFIA AND THE WITCH
- Thread starter Ehmcee
- Start date
Fair enough lol
Yea action failed basically the target was already transported
Here is Alice readlist #2. This was really hard to make because most of the content by everyone is reactive.
Hydro
Assuming he is saying the truth and there is a second transporter he is likely town from a mechanic perspective. He has been inactive and questionable at times when he has come online in the thread so I'd like him to step up a bit.
Miyami
Good activity but toned it down a bit and became a bit confused with mechanics when every talk has been about it. Considering she is new, or so I think, she has been a really good chat pressence. I don't think she can be blamed for focusing mostly in what's in front of her, the mech talk, when far more experienced players have done the same.
Jalmont
Seems like he is back in his do nothing early era to not get voted out. At least his content is forgettable. Funnily enough this catches scumleans like joey's one. I don't know how to rate this slot because while he did that as town every time this is not helpful for town so wake up if you are town.
Joey
Definitely a solid presence in thread and the second person that notice that we have to think outside of the four players we have been talking about the entire day or we lose. Do not fully agree with his readlist, dbd towncore is extremely questionable and he called me out for my content being mechanical when I'm the one that has given thoughts about other players and pushed for other things. I only think he would be scum if he was paired with someone like dbd or ecat.
Electricitycat
His 143 post as I said earlier in my previous list is not the best. Says a bunch of things but leaves everything ambiguous, I remember his town posts in previous games having more confidence. I think if he is not town this behaviour comes from third party and not mafia as he has experience as mafia. It would have been my top candidate for vote but he feels far better today, he makes a solid point with his post 390 and his follow up.
Celever
Jumping a bit too much into the mechanic aspect when in other games he has expressed his dislike for mechanic based days and that it doesn't help town that much, he even called me out for "ruining a day" on team galactic mafia. This behaviour plus making crazy theories like in post 287 when I haven't opened a dm with anyone yet. He is still looks more solvey than your average player in this playerlist but doesn't look like it comes from a town point of view. Calling transporter to claim in 181 only adds fuel to the fire. I'm getting paranoid with this slot.
Evie
Like I said earlier she feels reserved, checked her posts and yeah could be both newbie town and newbie scum, her behaviour is reasonable from both sides. Hard to read right now. She is not worth focusing right now as she is too hard to read because of lack of meta.
Aura Guardian
This looks like his standard behaviour as town which to surprise of no one catches scumreads as I've been reading while elaborating this list. A bunch of couples of posts here and there reacting to the thread and then (hopefully) becoming more involved later on when he is usually on the POE. The thing is this is extremely easy to replicate as mafia so if anyone has his meta as mafia I'm interested in it. So far I've only seen him as town.
AirC
Similar to Evie but gives far better vibes somehow. I think it's because he started slower but has been ramping up in confidence which either means he is town or third party. I don't think a mafia new player has this ramping up behavior. So statistically above average town.
Dead by daylight
His content so far is basically him saying his result, not trying to get past it and thinking outside of that would get punished normally but because that's what most players here talk about it's normal and doesn't stand out. He is either lookout or recon. Well he could have a a mafia teammate as a recon but that doesn't make sense and would complicate things for them in case an investigator exists. He can't be third party.
Des121
240 and 244 are weird. The late claim from 332 after dbd said he got no notification in 310 is off as well but not unheard from des. Then contradicting herself in post 364 and 439 ?? Des if you are town please be more clear when expressing yourself, you do not look good with those posts. I know something similar has happened before with claims but it's still not optimal.
Lechen
This feels too reactive for his mafia meta. Too many one liners that seems like the previous game as town when he was busy. This, however, is like in aura guardian case a bit too easy to replicate as scum. I don't sense any agenda behind his behavior unlike in celever's case but has not been proactive enough to townlean.
A fairy
Again more reactive behaviour and similar vibes to celever jumping in at a similar time. However her post 352 makes her townier than him. I don't know I can never read her. I can't even make an analysis properly yet when I can do it in other slots with less activity.
Hydro
Assuming he is saying the truth and there is a second transporter he is likely town from a mechanic perspective. He has been inactive and questionable at times when he has come online in the thread so I'd like him to step up a bit.
Miyami
Good activity but toned it down a bit and became a bit confused with mechanics when every talk has been about it. Considering she is new, or so I think, she has been a really good chat pressence. I don't think she can be blamed for focusing mostly in what's in front of her, the mech talk, when far more experienced players have done the same.
Jalmont
Seems like he is back in his do nothing early era to not get voted out. At least his content is forgettable. Funnily enough this catches scumleans like joey's one. I don't know how to rate this slot because while he did that as town every time this is not helpful for town so wake up if you are town.
Joey
Definitely a solid presence in thread and the second person that notice that we have to think outside of the four players we have been talking about the entire day or we lose. Do not fully agree with his readlist, dbd towncore is extremely questionable and he called me out for my content being mechanical when I'm the one that has given thoughts about other players and pushed for other things. I only think he would be scum if he was paired with someone like dbd or ecat.
Electricitycat
His 143 post as I said earlier in my previous list is not the best. Says a bunch of things but leaves everything ambiguous, I remember his town posts in previous games having more confidence. I think if he is not town this behaviour comes from third party and not mafia as he has experience as mafia. It would have been my top candidate for vote but he feels far better today, he makes a solid point with his post 390 and his follow up.
Celever
Jumping a bit too much into the mechanic aspect when in other games he has expressed his dislike for mechanic based days and that it doesn't help town that much, he even called me out for "ruining a day" on team galactic mafia. This behaviour plus making crazy theories like in post 287 when I haven't opened a dm with anyone yet. He is still looks more solvey than your average player in this playerlist but doesn't look like it comes from a town point of view. Calling transporter to claim in 181 only adds fuel to the fire. I'm getting paranoid with this slot.
Evie
Like I said earlier she feels reserved, checked her posts and yeah could be both newbie town and newbie scum, her behaviour is reasonable from both sides. Hard to read right now. She is not worth focusing right now as she is too hard to read because of lack of meta.
Aura Guardian
This looks like his standard behaviour as town which to surprise of no one catches scumreads as I've been reading while elaborating this list. A bunch of couples of posts here and there reacting to the thread and then (hopefully) becoming more involved later on when he is usually on the POE. The thing is this is extremely easy to replicate as mafia so if anyone has his meta as mafia I'm interested in it. So far I've only seen him as town.
AirC
Similar to Evie but gives far better vibes somehow. I think it's because he started slower but has been ramping up in confidence which either means he is town or third party. I don't think a mafia new player has this ramping up behavior. So statistically above average town.
Dead by daylight
His content so far is basically him saying his result, not trying to get past it and thinking outside of that would get punished normally but because that's what most players here talk about it's normal and doesn't stand out. He is either lookout or recon. Well he could have a a mafia teammate as a recon but that doesn't make sense and would complicate things for them in case an investigator exists. He can't be third party.
Des121
240 and 244 are weird. The late claim from 332 after dbd said he got no notification in 310 is off as well but not unheard from des. Then contradicting herself in post 364 and 439 ?? Des if you are town please be more clear when expressing yourself, you do not look good with those posts. I know something similar has happened before with claims but it's still not optimal.
Lechen
This feels too reactive for his mafia meta. Too many one liners that seems like the previous game as town when he was busy. This, however, is like in aura guardian case a bit too easy to replicate as scum. I don't sense any agenda behind his behavior unlike in celever's case but has not been proactive enough to townlean.
A fairy
Again more reactive behaviour and similar vibes to celever jumping in at a similar time. However her post 352 makes her townier than him. I don't know I can never read her. I can't even make an analysis properly yet when I can do it in other slots with less activity.
You guys are whispering without me?
i just found out ehmcee accepted my friend request on discordYou guys are whispering without me?
I did try to unvote, is that not possible?
catching up now, seems like a lot happened while I was asleep
Just received a dm from a fairy saying she is town so she gets added to the towncore.
confirming his
You are able to unvote, will be reflected next vc
I'm not satisfied with this explanation!
And most smogon games have too much mech no matter if open or closed other than the one you hosted from what I remember.
Also Hydro did whisper with me like when the game immediately started (not since) and in it talked about whispering with you already which explains 287 (just looked up the post lol)I'm not satisfied with this explanation!
Most Smogon games have a lot of mech but closed setup mechsolving sucks due to the variables and assumptions most of the time. Town basically lost Lumiose because they assumed there wouldn’t be 2 town roleblockers and there were for example
Half the time I’m mech solving but my thread presence is dominated by “nono that mech solving rabbit hole doesn’t work” bc of this kinda thing, it’s just that when in closed setup that includes more “mech solving is altogether bad because by going down this rabbit hole it pressures claims / PoEs role possibilities for scum that they’re probably not doing themselves” and that’s actual town strategy to not do that
I think if you compared me this game with prior open / semi-open games you’d see similarity bc I’m a relatively consistent player in approach but I’m not your teacher I can’t give you homework
Do you have a discord perchance? Would much rather whisper there than on here
As for NVing day 1, I don’t like it especially when there are slots we can flip Toronto
for info* I love autocorrect
Yeah, I'm air.c on discord :)
I know that's Trump's policy but I don't think we can or should help him with that
#MAGA
