actually sorry I've changed my mind I find your role to be extremely bizarre.
who are the last remaining 3 mafia do you think and who do you feel we should vote today
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN
- Thread starter HydrogenHydreigon
- Start date
who are the last remaining 3 mafia do you think and who do you feel we should vote today
NE/Evie are two prime suspects, unclear about the third mafia, i'd probably vote NE if deadline was in an hour or so
If you're using this as your decision on who to vote, I'd strongly recommend you follow your own thoughts instead, "who do you feel we should vote today" gives me the impression that you're just gonna vote for whoever I tell you to. And about my role being bizarre, I could easily confirm it by checking you and telling if you're an info role or not (assuming you're alright with that being revealed)
"You're going to vote for whoever I tell you to" is a hilarious misreading of the room.
Hypothetically: gun to head, you're gonna get dayvigged right now if you say nothing, who is the third mafia besides NE and Evie?
Hypothetically: gun to head, you're gonna get dayvigged right now if you say nothing, who is the third mafia besides NE and Evie?
Im gonna guess Chemdahs bonus action: its a kill
How correct was I?
Right, gun to head, I'm picking des, because apparently (looking at #2308) des is usually way more active than what I've been seeing. Would appreciate some links to other mafia games to see what that looks like
nah, I wouldn't have mentioned that I had a bonus action if it was that
Des's progression makes no sense. People should stop applying low expectations to Des. Her town game is better than this. In this game she went from 0 reads to Im maf with skipper and evie which makes no sense. I don't see any town progression
I find it interesting that Flandrs me and Des are the only people not interested in NE, seemingly. Not sure what it means yet
Dammit why did you expose us, now everyone knows we're the rest of the scumteam /s
I think we need the people with weird roles to clarify with the host how they work. In particular, NE should ask what "failed action" constitutes. Does getting blocked count? What about redirected?
I think your role is bizarre because it's useful, in fact, it's worse the useless it seems extremely negative to me. I don't really see why we would want to know if someone is an info role, people are probably not going to be lying about that plus info roles are more likely to be town than not so what's the point? when I look at you from that standpoint then unfortunately I can't just clear you even given the other towny stuff you have
incidentally, can you ask the host if a role that had to guess how many actions failed at night and gained a demonstrable benefit if correct would count as an info role ie give you a positive result?
I'm interested in your thoughts because I think it will help me and the rest of the town deduce your alignment, not necessarily because I want you to convince me to vote one way or the other. (ofc you are more than welcome to try, actually I would love that). The more you are able to post (coherently, not like neon), the better.
I think your role is bizarre because it's useful, in fact, it's worse the useless it seems extremely negative to me. I don't really see why we would want to know if someone is an info role, people are probably not going to be lying about that plus info roles are more likely to be town than not so what's the point? when I look at you from that standpoint then unfortunately I can't just clear you even given the other towny stuff you have
incidentally, can you ask the host if a role that had to guess how many actions failed at night and gained a demonstrable benefit if correct would count as an info role ie give you a positive result?
Why did you pick out des? They have more posts than pulsar, me/DBD, realiti/CK, even joey.
Because as explained, people have said that des is usually far more active than she's being right now (refer to AP at post #2483 for example). If that also applies to any of the people you've mentioned, then I'd love to see anything that can show that.
I'll go ahead and ask hydro abt this
update: NE's role wouldn't count as an info role, as even though it has the possibility of gaining info by knowing the number of failed action, by technicality the pay-off for the role comes as voting power, which does not give info, hence NE's role would be classified as not being an info role
lol amazing ok if you're town everybody please read back the end of day 1 from celever' claim to EOD and just tell me who of the people who voted celever are NOT scummy, like CK literally goes from yeah let me reeval I thought he was town to nope yeah he's scum and "I don't care for his claim" huh???? guys am I going crazy here fixating on this? this is all I basically talked about yesterday is no one else concerned about this?
why did pigeon put a random vote eod on evie that had no effect? also lol des was afk all day 1.
lol I lowkey could see mafia teammates Hal and pigeon arguing for dramatic effect day 2.
maybe it's just me but feels like NE and wist only ever talk about each other and with each other lol. I'll be honest reading day 2 I don't really get the sense Hal was getting a lot of help from his teammates like how easy would it have been to be like "yeah agreed let's vote angry pigeon" or even easier just pick like pulsar/des/neon etc and draw attention that way. it seems like a big error to not be placing votes trying to get some movement voting wise and most importantly off Hal,
one of NE and Evie is probably town.
for being such an active presence wist not voting at all day 2 is a red flag to me.
honestly I wonder if we can guess who M2h might have rogued. evie? this is probably not worthwhile but I did want to just throw this in here
##vote realiti
why did pigeon put a random vote eod on evie that had no effect? also lol des was afk all day 1.
lol I lowkey could see mafia teammates Hal and pigeon arguing for dramatic effect day 2.
maybe it's just me but feels like NE and wist only ever talk about each other and with each other lol. I'll be honest reading day 2 I don't really get the sense Hal was getting a lot of help from his teammates like how easy would it have been to be like "yeah agreed let's vote angry pigeon" or even easier just pick like pulsar/des/neon etc and draw attention that way. it seems like a big error to not be placing votes trying to get some movement voting wise and most importantly off Hal,
one of NE and Evie is probably town.
for being such an active presence wist not voting at all day 2 is a red flag to me.
honestly I wonder if we can guess who M2h might have rogued. evie? this is probably not worthwhile but I did want to just throw this in here
##vote realiti
oh ok
this is not indicative of town!NE in my eyes so like, figures
i guess i can see a role where the info cop is a scum-aligned role but idk how much stock i want to put in this
(not indicative as in, it doesn't townclear him)
why do i not remember this
ill go reread in a sec
tbh i can definitely see this as a possibility considering that M2H had been expressing a sr on evie for quite a bit
jalmont pings towny
EBWOP brain hazy from long nap
ah this post
Okay what's keeping me from saying myself as a bit so that I don't have to commit to anything