NOC E.G.O Wielders Mafia - A 17P Role Madness (Game Thread) - MAFIA WIN

JALMONT said:
no clue. CK town read NE pretty strongly and scum read Evie. read of that what you will. I guess it's kind of ironic that realiti is now leading the wagon on NE but you know I cba to really look into how that read changed so I'll let someone smarter than me connect the dots

I mean if NE is town it's a bummer but really I'm not sure how many regrets we can have, he's been objectively scummy with their voting patterns and weird claim. The constant interaction with wist is strange too but I don't know how much I can read into that as a scum thing.
Click to expand...
get that, tbh my head was at NE/realiti unpaired off of NE's posts re: realiti earlier in the phase (#2282 #2302 #2322)
 
JALMONT said:
So you don't think it's weird that CK was town reading NE and a sub comes in and now NE is the top scum read?
Click to expand...
i mean. literally taking myself as an example i was pretty convinced NE was town d1 and now i think he has partner equity with hal off the re-eval. i guess you could argue that different people can have different takes on the same slot too /shrug

i dunno i like realiti's posting now and i towned CK when he was still in the game. you're right that CK going "i don't care for the tracker claim" pings weird in isolation though

do you think unpairing these two slots is unsound
i guess i can see the world where this is a bus on realiti's end
 
JALMONT said:
So you don't think it's weird that CK was town reading NE and a sub comes in and now NE is the top scum read?
Click to expand...
Wouldn't this mean the scenario is either:

a) CK/realiti and NE were both scum and CK decided to TR NE while realiti decided to bus him

b) CK/realiti are town and came to different independent conclusions on NE

either way it looks bad for NE
 
joey said:
Wouldn't this mean the scenario is either:

a) CK/realiti and NE were both scum and CK decided to TR NE while realiti decided to bus him

b) CK/realiti are town and came to different independent conclusions on NE

either way it looks bad for NE
Click to expand...
Or it’s a convenient excuse for a scum slot to get on the town wagon. I don’t get why you precluded that

Again I’m not trying to say no no no to any NE vote. I just think it’s important to play devils advocate because I do feel there is a town here in evie and NE
 
wisteriapurple said:
i mean. literally taking myself as an example i was pretty convinced NE was town d1 and now i think he has partner equity with hal off the re-eval. i guess you could argue that different people can have different takes on the same slot too /shrug

i dunno i like realiti's posting now and i towned CK when he was still in the game. you're right that CK going "i don't care for the tracker claim" pings weird in isolation though

do you think unpairing these two slots is unsound
i guess i can see the world where this is a bus on realiti's end
Click to expand...
Well I guess I would expect you to say that because there are a non insiginificant number of worlds where you and CK are both just mafia lol.

I would normally ask you why you didn’t vote yesterday when you were online but I think I already asked and you answered and I have to go to bed so
 
Evie said:
do you think theres also a scum in me and ne two or could it be t/t
Click to expand...
You tell me. If you and NE are town who are the mafia? Why did two town see a tracker claim and go “yolo let’s vote that off”. I can give you somewhat of a pass for voting neon as self pres but really you’re voting record is basically equally as poor as NE
 
JALMONT said:
You tell me. If you and NE are town who are the mafia? Why did two town see a tracker claim and go “yolo let’s vote that off”. I can give you somewhat of a pass for voting neon as self pres but really you’re voting record is basically equally as poor as NE
Click to expand...
6 people voted for celever so a minimum of two town mustve seen a tracker claim and voted them off, im not sure why me or ne are specifically worse for it.

also like you didnt really answer my question, do you think me/ne could be t/t
 
Evie said:
6 people voted for celever so a minimum of two town mustve seen a tracker claim and voted them off, im not sure why me or ne are specifically worse for it.

also like you didnt really answer my question, do you think me/ne could be t/t
Click to expand...
7 even, including hal and M2H, so a minimum of two unrevealed town voted for a tracker claim
 
:wo: noo my question
AngryPidgeon said:
Sometimes its better to just vote. I think weve reached the logical end of todays discussion. Des's NE vote is odd though.

##vote: Chemdah
Click to expand...
i guess? i'm just not really a believer in hammering and ending the day prematurely especially when there's still 9 hours to go in the phase
des121 said:
How is my vote odd
Click to expand...
it's odd because you spent the day phase townreading him only to swap because you think your reads are wrong
 
For what it's worth I would also be voting NE today if it wasn't close to hammer

Which maybe is a red flag that so many people are willing to
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top