Slate 5 Official Distribution, with my reasonings as usual!
These lists are still subject to change upon suggestion, so if you disagree with me giving something a certain move, or think I missed out on giving something a move, then please let me know!
Shadow Mist -
:Zubat::Ledyba::Murkrow::Spheal::Dratini::Lapras::Mantine::Tentacool::Natu::Omanyte::Chinchou::Chansey::Octillery::Porygon::Roselia::Wailmer::Slugma:
Reasoning
I had to be a little careful with this one due to the autocrit effect in Shadow Sky, while also avoiding mons that already get the also powerful-in-Shadow-Sky Shadow Storm. I kept a few of the originally suggested mons, leaning towards the more Special Attacking ones that don't already have Shadow Storm (which was just Hoothoot, I think), and swapping out the Bagon line for the Dragonite line. With the Haze effect and mons that use Haze in later gens of VGC being here already like Crobat, Murkrow, and Dragonite, I figured that adding other mons that got Haze like Lapras and Xatu also made sense. The latter is also one of the better attackers to use the move with in Shadow Sky, though Crobat and Dragonite are probably the absolute best there, for the former's super high Speed and the latter's bulk and decently high SpA. The rest were mainly support-leaning mons or slow Special Attackers that didn't have any/many Shadow moves yet.
Shadow Down -
:Volbeat::Illumise::Aipom::Qwilfish::Sentret::Skitty::Sneasel::Spinarak::Mankey::Corsola::Taillow::Sableye::Rattata::Torchic::Tyrogue:
Reasoning
Since I never finished my suggested distribution for Shadow Down, I kinda had an open book here. I mainly gave this to frail support Pokemon since priority Leer is a pretty strong tool to put next to the many strong physical attackers of the tier and it's probably not the best idea to give it to something that can use it like 3 or 4 times before going down, with the bulkiest thing I gave this to being Hitmontop (who doesn't get Fake Out this gen), and then a massive drop down to, of all things, Blaziken and Corsola. Highlights include Fake Out users in Sneasel and Delcatty getting extra utility, Furret as a Follow Me user that can give its STAB a bit more oomph, and Sableye as a Fake Out-immune option.
Shadow Hold -
:Azurill::Duskull::Gligar::Qwilfish::Growlithe::Grimer::Mawile::Gastly::Rattata::Slowpoke::Shellder::Mr. Mime::Dunsparce::Miltank::Baltoy:
Reasoning
Mainly gave this to bulkier mons, who should be able to keep a target trapped for a decent number of turns, with a bit more of an even split between physical and special attackers than the suggested more specially-oriented distribution. Probably the most notable addition here in Growlithe, as Arcanine is one of the better mons in the tier and the best Intimidate mon, with the idea being that it can lower something's attack and then trap them in their weakened state (or trap the switch-in). Could end up controversial but I think it should be fine. Gengar is another really good mon with this move, but is definitely a worse user of it, leaning more into the support role that being a Shadow gives it with it having Shadow Wave already. Mr. Mime is another somewhat notable user, since you can trap something that can't do much to it, then spam Follow Me to keep its teammate safe, or use stuff like Encore and Baton Pass for other shenanigans.
Now, let's get to a very special Slate 6!
----
Slate 6 - Shadow Half, Shadow Shed, Custom Move
This next slate includes the last two non-signature Shadow moves from XD, being Shadow Half and Shadow Shed! But since I don't want a slate with just 2 moves, we will also add an entirely new Shadow move in this slate as well!
I've put some notes below to help you make submissions for Shadow moves:
- Remember that every Shadow Pokemon must run all of the Shadow moves they can learn and that every Pokemon will learn at least 2 Shadow moves. Thus, try to avoid making redundant Shadow moves, in case they are both given to the same mon, and think about whether it would be worth giving a Pokemon that already learns 2 Shadow moves an additional one.
- In Pokemon XD: Gale of Darkness, all non-signature physical Shadow moves are single-target attacks and all non-signature special Shadow moves are spread moves. Keeping this distinction is not a requirement, but is something to consider.
- Shadow moves are super effective against all non-Shadow Pokemon, but don't give the user a STAB boost. Keep this in mind when deciding how strong they should be.
- The Shadow Pokemon mechanic will be a powerful offensive tool, so keep that in mind when giving moves you make strong to already good Pokemon.
-
Click here to see Orre Colosseum's Viability Rankings to see what's already strong.
- If you need a reminder of Gen 3 or Orre Colosseum's mechanics,
click here to go to this thread's OP.
- If you need a reminder of what the mechanics of Shadow Pokemon are, you can see them below or in the
spreadsheet.
Ema Skye said:Going for something very out there but still faithful to the games (cause they're my favourite Pokemon games)
Shadow Pokemon Effects
- Moves: All Shadow Pokemon learn at least TWO Shadow moves (and can learn a max of FOUR, all of which are default/Lv1 moves). All Shadow moves the Pokemon has available to it must be included in the moveset (so some mons have one legal moveset).
- Type Chart: Attacking moves are always 2x super effective on non-Shadow Pokemon, and 0.5x effective on Shadow Pokemon, but Shadow is not a Pokemon's type and so there is never STAB. Moves can be physical or special, decided on a per-move basis.
- Availability: Any mon that has a Shadow move in its moves is a Shadow Pokemon (keeping in mind how moves work). On its first switch in, there is a message identifying it as a Shadow Pokemon (akin to Terapagos' ability). There isn't a limit on the number of Shadow Pokemon on a team.
The moveset limitation seems interesting to build around and can let us create some very interesting move distribution. A Shadow mon is obviously powerful offensively, giving it near-perfect coverage in one move (which can offset it not getting STAB). Defensively, resisting Shadow is a huge benefit (since there's no STAB, the BP does all the heavy lifting). How moves adapt to this could be interesting as well - the more Shadow moves a Pokemon gets, the less slots for other moves it can run, which could make some unable to run Protect, Fake Out and other meta relevant moves, and so the moves it would get to run would need to be designed around that.
Soo Yoshi left a comment:
For attackers, making it a Shadow (instead of a regular mon) opens up perfect coverage in a single move slot (2x effectiveness vs everything will hit harder than a STAB attack). Depending on its ability to run boosting moves (if it has less than 4 Shadow moves), it could end up snowballing quick. Something like CB Tauros would also be a very scary Shadow mon since it's locked to one move anyways, and this move would have 2x effectiveness on everything.
On defense, the key value is resisting Shadow attacks from the above attackers. It's probably a requirement to have at least one just to be able to switch into Shadow attacks (since being a Shadow effectively quarters damage from Shadow attacks compared to regular mons). Something like Metagross or Arcanine, which have a lot of defensive value already, could benefit from this, especially if their Shadow movepool lets them still run options like Protect. While Shadow attackers don't really get to use their offensive typing, defenders do, and so defensive answers with good typings can get a lot of value from also resisting Shadow attacks.
I have also included the original versions of each of the slated Shadow moves, in case you need inspiration:
Shadow Half in XD
Name: Shadow Half
Power: --
Accuracy: 100%
PP: N/A (Shadow moves didn't have PP in the original games, but they will here)
Category:
Type: Shadow
Effect: Damages every Pokemon on the field for 50% of their current HP. User must recharge next turn. This damage cannot cause fainting and is counted as an attack for the purposes of Bide, Mirror Coat, and Focus Punch.
Priority: 0
Flags (ex: Contact, Sound): Protect, Recharge
Distribution:
:arbok::hitmonlee::electabuzz::swellow:
Shadow Shed in XD
Name: Shadow Shed
Power: --
Accuracy: 100%
PP: N/A (Shadow moves didn't have PP in the original games, but they will here)
Category:
Type: Shadow
Effect: Removes the foe's Reflect/Light Screen/Safeguard.
Priority: 0
Flags (ex: Contact, Sound): N/A
Distribution:
:paras::dugtrio::dodrio::shellder::exeggutor::mr. mime::magmar::pinsir::tauros::lapras::snorlax::articuno::zapdos::moltres::dragonite::ledyba::togepi::natu::mareep::pineco::magcargo::houndour::lugia::makuhita::roselia::numel::zangoose::lunatone::snorunt:
And with this slate featuring a slot for a new Shadow move, here are a couple rules/notes for that:
- The new Shadow move must be Shadow-type
- The new Shadow move's name must be two words, with the first word being "Shadow"
- All the tips for making Shadow moves listed above still apply here
- Below I've listed every Pokemon that currently doesn't have a Shadow move, if you need inspiration on what direction to take a completely new Shadow move:
Fully Evolved Pokemon without Shadow moves so far
:clefable::parasect::Dewgong::Seaking::Ditto::Kabutops::Mew::Quagsire::Forretress::Heracross::Skarmory::Stantler::Smeargle::Linoone::Whiscash::Glalie::Regirock::Registeel::Rayquaza:
:Lugia: (for a reason)
And lastly, below is the template for making Shadow move submissions, as well as the rules for making subs:
Template & Example Moves Submission
Blank Template
Name:
Power:
Accuracy:
PP:
Category:
Type:
Effect:
Priority:
Flags (ex: Contact, Sound):
Potential Pokémon With This Move:
Justification:
Template With Explanations
Name:
[Name of the move]
Power:
[Base Power of the Move]
Accuracy:
[Accuracy of the Move. Has to be a multiple of 5]
PP:
[Power Points of the Move. Has to be a multiple of 5]
Category:
[Physical, Special, or Status - Note that offensive Shadow moves are allowed to be either Physical or Special]
Type:
[Type of the Move]
Effect:
[What the move does. Can be a secondary effect or an inherent effect like Throat Chop's. Also include whether or not the move is a spread move]
Priority:
[The priority bracket of the move. The standard priority of a move is 0]
Flags (ex: Contact, Sound):
[Specify which flags the move has. A full list can be found here.]
Potential Pokémon With This Move:
[List a few Pokémon that could learn this move. The council ultimately decides what Pokémon get what moves, but we'll generally use the same list]
Justification:
[Explain what purpose this move would serve]
Example Move Submission
Name: Shadow Sky
Power: --
Accuracy: --
PP: 5
Category:
Type: Shadow
Effect: Summons Shadow Sky for 5 turns, a weather that damages all non-Shadow Pokemon for 1/8 of their max HP at the end of every turn. Weather Ball becomes 100 BP and Shadow-type.
Priority: 0
Flags (ex: Contact, Sound): N/A
Potential Pokémon With This Move:
:ho-oh::articuno::zapdos::moltres::voltorb::taillow::nincada::trapinch::diglett::treecko::meowth::tauros::pichu::volbeat::illumise::deoxys::elekid::poliwag::vulpix::larvitar::castform::ponyta::kyogre::groudon:
Yoshiblaze said:After Slate 1 - Adding Shadow Moves (5 Days per slate)
After we decide how our Shadow Pokemon mechanic works, we'll then adjust every Shadow move from XD: Gale of Darkness to fit a PvP setting and make them fit better into whatever our Shadow mechanics are. 3 Shadow moves will be slated each slate for you to sub changes to, for a total of 6 slates for all 18 original Shadow moves, plus any additional slates if deemed necessary. Submissions should follow the template in the spoiler tag below and be balanced for the Orre Colosseum metagame (taking our Shadow Pokemon mechanics into account), as the council reserves the right to veto any submissions deemed broken, uncompetitive, or uncodeable. Shadow moves should generally follow the same idea of their original versions, but they don't need to. You can only make 1 submission per move slated.
This slate will be open until Saturday, January 17th.
See you soon!