Large Thanks to everyone that posted in the thread, we've read and considered every post. I'm going to be sharing some updates now.
1. The hosting team will be RADU + Arai + bellchime.
:cacnea: :ralts: :jirachi:
2. We have come to a preference for what we want the tiers for 1v1PLX to be:
SV Bo7
SV
SV
SV UU
SS Bo7
SM
ORAS
BW
SS2 was already frowned upon for being a so-called "filler feeder slot", but what that mostly impacts is the SS "mainers". Most teams end up bleeding out for a dedicated SS player that will be able to both be self sufficient and also handhold a second slot both in teambuilding and occasionally in teaching them the intricacies of SS. This leads to lower quality teams, games, and a lot of burnout. Now that there are good alternatives, it's a good time to retire the SS playerbase from their babysitting side-hustle.
Let me be honest, UU and NatDex sit pretty much on the same level when it comes to interest, resources, development and playerbase. Both had a good CL representation and would be great replacements for SS2. Honestly, I considered the idea of running with the nuclear option and adding both, but it's just not feasible to remove an SV slot, sorry.
My initial edge was to prefer NatDex strictly because I liked the idea of having National Dex players potentially interested in 1v1PL and it's good to be able to expand to other communities, but on the other hand, UU appeals to players from the existing 1v1 playerbase that have been around but have not been able to play in teamtours as much. UU, as a tier, directly promotes
the players that are motivated and active, and minimizes the inherent "metagame knowledge" gap that makes starting new players so risky. This directly cultivates our existing internal community, which is something I think is really important in a moment of lowered 1v1 interest.
I can only speak for myself but this is why I prefer having UU over NatDex in PL, the metagames are otherwise pretty much equal in my eyes and it could've swung one way or the other. To reiterate, this is not a final decision, but our current preference. More discussion with compelling arguments could make us change our minds, and the format is not locked until managers are selected/draft happens basically.
3. SV1 will be Bo7, and SS will be Bo7. All other slots will be Bo5 during regular weeks and playoffs, but Bo7 during tiebreak.
This is just about the status quo we've been running with except for the CL experiment. While we would've liked to make SS Bo5 too, the Council was strongly in support of Bo7, and our reasons were not strong enough to deny them of that. As for the tiebreak, I'm under the impression that this is just the majority opinion and I haven't seen anybody oppose this, correct me if I'm wrong.
4. Manager Prices will be presented by the Hosts.
While we understand the concerns that come with this method, we believe this far and above eclipses all other methods when it comes to obtaining a list of fair prices for the managers, and we would like to at least give this a chance for once. We have a highly qualified team of well-intentioned hosts, and whether or not this system is sustainable for future editions, it is definitely feasible for the upcoming one, and that's good enough. We don't intend to systematically enforce whichever price we first come up with, either, of course. Just as I'm doing here and communicating our preferences way in advance and allowing the community to dissent, the list of prices will be shared with the list of managers as soon as possible, and a constructive discussion will ensue. I believe we are all reasonable people and we will be able to achieve an outcome that is 'accepted' by all managers.
5. We would like to celebrate PLX as a community achievement, and we have some things in mind we wanna do:
- 1v1PLX Post Draft Power Rankings - I'll make sure we are well prepared, mobilized, and are able to get it to the finish line. To that extent, YOU (yes, YOU!!) need to help us with it. I'll prepare some sort of interest form once we've reached out to TFP and set out some sort of deadline and guidelines.
- I wanna make a longer YouTube video related to 1v1 on the Smogon youtube channel. Highly depends if I've got the bandwith for it personally, and is mostly on my shoulders to make, but if you have ideas or ways you think you can be helpful I'm all ears. If anyone capable steps up I may recruit you for some YouTube Short.
- Manager Interviews: I would like to hold some sort of mini interviews to the manager pairs before and after the auction, because I think it would be really fun for them to be able to discuss their draft plan before the auction and then afterwards share the reaction to what their team ends up looking like. As long as all the managers are ok with it, we should be able to get this done easily.
- ^This is about all of what the hosting team can offer in terms of their time and effort. We invite you (yes, YOU) to participate and do whatever you think will be fun to make, other projects, personal prs, pre draft rankings, predicts, weekly video recaps, memes, cheering for your team, anything. I just hope we can bring some well deserved hype to this tour.
6. To that extent, we would like to add a Media Break Week after the Auction
This would give us one week to better prepare the PRs, the potential video, and any other project. The media break week happens in other official team tournaments and they're also a great moment for you to establish a team environment, get a head start on prep, and just let you get in the groove. Here is what the timeline should look like with that in mind:
Manager Signups: April 27th - May 3rd
Player Signups: May 4th - May 17th
Draft: May 16th - May 17th
Media Week: May 18th - May 24th
Week 1: May 25th - May 31st
Week 2: June 1st - June 7th
Week 3: June 8th - June 14th
Week 4: June 15th - June 21st
Week 5: June 22nd - June 28th
Week 6: June 29th - July 5th
Week 7: July 6th - July 12th
As I have slightly mentioned above, everything in this post is the current preference of the hosting team, and we are always open to conversation and changing things. We still have 10 days til manager signups, and there's a lot of things that we can change even after manager signups and selection.
Please (PLEASE) post in this thread (down here) any and all thoughts you may have, I don't want anyone to feel resentment towards the finalized decisions because they simply did not post here but got buried in #pl-discussion. Do feel free to converse about this stuff on discord as well though.