• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Other 1v1 Tournament Policy Discussion Thread

just wanted to drop in to tierbash ss express my support for uu and to a lesser degree nd. uu has a very low barrier to entry coming from sv, and two of the biggest issues have been improved with custap ban and tour based usage (the lower survery score than nd can. ignoring the quality of the tiers themselves as I enjoy them about equally, I think the lower barrier to entry will result in higher effort building and promote growth with newer players more than nd, which will have inevitably have much more building done by already established players. anecdotally comparing the activity and involvement of players in my cl cord, uu clears and its not even close (s/o gp). I would certainly prefer either tier (or mg or dpp or adv tbh) over ss2, but I think uu would generally be a better decision in the end.

multigen is cool too, as a player I love the format but it unfortunately seems unwise to include due to the prep required and also it can be painfully long to watch sometimes
 
gmurm 1v1
1. uu>nd>mg>dpp>ss2>sv4
as much as i love sv idt 4x sv slots is a great idea we can have more variety over just going back to the wcup format
post cl we have had changes in uu and are workin on the issues which we had in cl namely the custap ban deg wont agree custap changed anything but w/e and also switching to a more tour based usage just like anon mentioned above
mg is going to be painful to prep for considering pl is a longer tour than cl and cl had its struggles with mg
i like the idea of dpp and ss and like leave both nd and uu for cl i m not super against nd but like we had people reusing for the most part of it with barely 2-3 people putting in prep on a regular basis
lowkey we should do past gen bo3 in rby gsc and adv
 
Tiers - I strongly believe in NatDex as a replacement slot for SS2 with being guaranteed better resources and the tier being both more universal and appealing to players outside this community. I also like think the tier has a lot more competitive exploration that can work well in the coming tour, especially as a slot with successful players like Blanched being able to just express a lot of ideas in teams over the short size of CL.
appropriate image
pwAwEe_xf8Nc_DxQiE7qpQ.png
At this exact point in time given the lack of an idea of how UU is going to go with about a month before player signups I will maintain a weak opinion on UU as a valuable format. The concept is there but there is just no execution wrt resources / changes / tiering as of my post, other than the Custap ban and assurance that the tier will be based on tournament usage. In a trophy tour like PL unless there is like pretty rapid motion I do not want to support this option without like noticeable changes given how it was viewed in CL.

Multigen I think is just too much work for one slot over like 7+ weeks to be reasonable. Despite the high quality a lot of fatigue showed with players just reusing teams from other people building them and often when picking from 7 tiers the quality of tiers played was more one-sided. Can work in PL but there's little reason to add it, it kind of improves collaboration but likely just increases player burnout in the tour especially when people care more about winning.

SS2 and SV4 I view similarly, in that there is just no reason to field an additional slot when you have good alternatives. In an auction based tour you can actually pick your players to serve distinct slots better so there's less need to field an extra current gen / second newest gen slot to even out drafts (especially when WC exists).

Bo7 vs Bo5 - Tiebreak Bo7 forced rule should continue applying.

For all the rest I would like the managers to just vote on this something like this a week before the auction and finalize tiers that way based on how the player sign ups are. Alternately poll people and weight people who are likely to play for the tier they select higher than people who won't. Don't force people to play Bo5 when they want to Bo7 and vice versa; most things should just be community opinion.

Pricing - Personally I found the CL pricing idea kind of strong for what it was doing outside the one count of price fixing. Just requires some degree of integrity and prices will be fine. Don't think we should revert to previous pricing systems. If someone has a better idea they can feel free to chip in though on that front.

Let's have a good PL X!!
 
Personally I'm in favor of
Sv4-dpp-uu-nd-ss2

Reason for not liking ss2 is because, in the last 2 pls it's been hated by ss mains and by non ss mains, it really hasn't been fun to watch either. So i don't see any reason for it being in this tour.

I don't like nd since it you look at cl it was sadly not that great. Sure it was fun to watch, but the games were not competitive at all and i dont think mg has the upsides that a Sv4 or uu would have.

I think uu kinda falls in the same boat as nd competetive wise, but the big difference for me is the low barrier of entry for potential new players trying to get into 1v1 + i liked to watch uu more then nd in cl because i felt like the games were of higher quality and there was some sort of meta that developed during the tour, which i think will only see more in a long tour like pl where i think we will see the opposite of nd getting stale.

Dpp being here is purely only because I'm biased, but i also genuinenly think it could be a great option if the council actually did something post cl. Sadly quite literally nothing happened. Reason why i think dpp could be good is that it's easy to pickup for new players + it also has some old heads that still play it.

Sv4 for me i think this is the best option based off the fact that it's cg. Competetive wise this tier is prolly the worst out of all the options but none of these options are really that competitive, but i think sv4 has the biggest upside out of all the other options. Them being the player pool will be big and its the easiest format to pick up as a new player, which i think should be the end goal of teamtours getting more players permanently into 1v1.

For bo5 vs bo7 I'm not really in favor of 1 or the other although i believe that if there are gonna be 4 sv slots there should only be 1 sv7 slot. And tb should be bo7 obviously.

Pricing is a bit of a annoying topic cause like radu said realistically none of the options will be good, although i quite liked how the pricing worked in cl. It requires some integrity from the managers but I'm sure that shouldn't be a problem
 
TIERS

so after reading a lot of the posts I see that the main contenders to replace ss is either UU or ND (with some people wanting dpp too ig). Me personally, I support the idea of UU being added into pl over nd and this is probably biased by the fact that I played and built for uu in cl for 2 weeks

ADVANTAGES OF UU

1) easier for newer players to get into, this point has been repeated in many posts and i'm repeating it again since its one of the most important ones. Might be wrong on this but i believe most newer 1v1 players get into 1v1 through playing cg, which is sv. UU not being too different from sv is a great format for newer players to try.
2) the tier is really fun with the recent changes post cl with banning of custap and banning/unbanning some mons

points are probably already said by others in previous posts but still no issue repeating

RANDOM CRAZY SUGGESTION THAT WILL PROBABLY NOT BE ACCEPTED : what if, due to a lot of people wanting uu and another lot of people wanting nd, we go from 8 slots to 10 slots and add both nd and uu and keep ss2 (or replace that with dpp/sv4 idk ). This is a random thing I thought of because both are great tiers that should be tried out (with me personally edging towards uu). this is probably not good for a million reasons but just a say since we had 10 slots in CL too


BO5 VS BO7

we have 3 sv slots rn but if one more sv slot gets added with the suggestion i gave / it is placed over ss2, id suggest keeping two sv bo7s and two sv bo5s. maybe one sv bo7 and 3 sv bo5s. basically i dont want more sv bo7s than sv bo5s.

idk about pricing bye bye
 
Last edited:
Not going to make an effort post but

anti support to mg, it’s a good tier but very exhausting and more fit for shorter tours

UU has been getting big changes that address a lot of the community concerns namely: custap ban; tour based usage; heavy work towards a set comp, No Johns tour to give players a place to test before its inclusion in PL, etc. It also still has a low barrier for entry

ND I have not been convinced by, the CL performance was not great and I can’t expect that it’ll be any better in PL (I suspect it will be worse). Additionally, some of the “benefits” to me do not make sense. A lot of the team dumps are from outdated metas + one of the critics of the tier was the excessive reusing of teams and the counter is that there’s resources of teams you can reuse?

SS2 I’m slightly down on but it’s fine as a tier. There have been new players that consistently play SS and are relatively successful. It’s not super flashy but it will be consistent and consider the devil you know is better than the devil you don’t I wouldn’t immediately write it off.

DPP no real opinion on, used to be advocating for it but now I’m just meh. Not really a fan of any tier before ORAS (or maybe SM) because of crit mechanics but if people want to play it that tier at least has relatively good resources and some new interest in it so knock yourself out.

Pricing: Agree with radu that the platonic ideal is no self buys at all but we still think it’s not feasible so I don’t want to argue.

TLDR: UU ≈ SS2 > DPP ≈ ND >>> MG

Edit: SV4 such a bad option I forgot it was being considered, that shit worse than MG VETO! UU is just SV4 but better in almost every way
 
Last edited:
I support UU in PL X. Here are three arguments why:

1. Two big issues with the tier that people had in CL was Custap Berry and Ladder usage. Both are now changed as per community feedback.

2. The tier's resources will be even more developed than in CL, with the experience of that tour. We'll have a setcomp by the start of PL, and the notable gaps in the VR (Iron Treads, Maushold) will be added. We have 3 new active council members who performed in CL. There has also been a no johns tournament request, which will help make sure we don't miss anything.

3. With regards to Natdex vs UU. Natdex had a grand total of 7 players in the entire CL, and comparing the survey results of UU/Natdex in Other Tiers thread, UU outperforms Natdex in both enjoyment (8 vs 7.58 /10) and competitiveness (7 vs 6.75 /10). And this doesn't factor in that the low responses for UU in these fields all emphasised their dislike of the now-assassinated Custap Berry. I'm not against Natdex in the tour, it's not a tier I feel strongly about, but if it's Natdex or UU then we should choose UU.

I think every tier should be Bo7
 
I support UU to get the last PL slot.

Numbers usually tell a convincing story, one thing they didn't grasp though was how smoothly one can start engaging with UU compared to the alternatives. UU has the distinct advantage to be different enough to standard SV to be considered as a standalone slot and at the same time share enough attributes with it, that lower the barrier to play. We are heading into a tour that will contain 3 standard SV slots. With the majority of the teams being forced to heavily focus on SV due to the current gen nature of PL, UU makes it so new(er) players have the best experience adapting and teams will have less of a headache to draft sack slots, pass repeated teams and hope for the best. This is something that has happened with ND in CL and SS2 in PLIX.

It is obvious to whoever has been involved that PL has shifted a little more towards being an inclusive tour than in previous iterations which I find to be a good transition and that is something we can serve much better with UU. If competition was the only priority that I have seen some talk about, the tournament would already have 6 slots. In either case, the competition metric between the new CL entrants is similar (7 for UU, 6.75 for ND).

Despite my belief that SS is a model 1v1 gen, teams have historically dealt with it as a chore and that doesn't push player inclusion or retention. I think it's only worked due to better alternatives not being put forward at the time of those tours and I would only consider it if no consensus regarding the new entrants can be reached.

Manager prices to be decided by vote (still watch out for excessive outliers), flat pricing treats manager pairs unfairly behind the facade of equality.

At the time of writing this I think MG, SV4, DPP are non-issues.
 
Last edited:
personally Ss2 > ND = UU >> SV4/DPP

PL is a format that works and there's really no need to change it. SS has predictably lost a dedicated playerbase over the year but SS2 has still been a very competitive slot. If we were to change it, it should be to Natdex or UU as both are growing tiers. I like Natdex more, but UU is in a good spot where it won't feel wrong in PL.

SV7/SS7 should be the only bo7 tiers imo except for tiebreaks where every tier should be bo7. CL was nice and let other tiers show off bo7 but I think everyone can agree it was exhausting. PL is a longer tour and another bout of half the tour being bo7 is going to kill some people. If we were to add a bo7 slot it should be limited to just 1 more bo7 slot (maybe SM7 but meh)

Pricing should be flat pricing. 15/35. No stress. No headache. :)
 
UU > SV4 > NatDex > SS2

No matter which of these 4 options gets picked, it'll most likely fall to one of the team's cheapest players; no effective manager will be allocating much of their budget for a slot that a solid player who does not main 1v1 could reasonably pick up with a bit of outside support. With this in mind, it will also be one of the slots where the reuse of teams from past samples and during the same series is all but guaranteed, as I assume there are less players who specialize in building for these slots compared to the standard gens 9-5, where building teams for the core gens ARE their 9-5 XD. Hence, I evaluated UU to be the most optimal from both a player, manager, and spectator's perspective due to the greater community demand for it compared to ss2 or sv4, while also not having as much of a barrier for entry for less experienced players comparing to natdex. While natdex does have better resources for player imo, it requires much more in-depth knowledge that spans multiple gens, which often leads novice players to get overwhelmed and end up copy pasting teams from the CL team dump instead of building with a specific oppponent in mind. To preface, there's nothing wrong with the copy pasting part, but to do this every series, which was observed by some in CL, can lead to boring games with uninspired teams. Ultimately, especially with the newly revamped UU where custap is banned and the list of available mons have been revised, i'm hoping to see this tier shine where it was previously a hint lackluster in CL.

You may have noticed i didnt mention MG, and that's because i was considering having it replace monopoke as the for fun slot. My idea is that this slot shouldnt be just something to keep the subs active, but also to prepare them for potential future games. An issue with mg in cl was burnout and the players often looking for their teammates to build teams for gens that they didnt specialize in, but this no-stress slot is perfect for just reusing old teams. This is prevalent for when a sub is doing a last minute switch in for a player, and has no time to build. This allows them to not delve into the competition empty-handed, and have some exp using teams built by their teammates.
 
Re: SS2
SS2 for the last few teamtours has been mostly fed clicker vs fed clicker. I don't think it's led to terrible games but not sure why it would need to stay. I don't know much about ND or UU but I support replacing SS2 for a more actively evolving tier.

Re: pricing
I only see four real options: flat pricing, fixing by hosts, some weird formula, and some weird manager vote.

Flat pricing: Sucks. If you look at all the team tours over the past few years, there is always one manager pair that is worth at least 2-3x one of the other ones. I really do not believe it is possible to assign a fair price to managers to allow those cheaper, less experienced managers to be able to play while preventing a team from getting delemon + bellchimes for 25k.

Fixing by hosts: OK. I think this would be fine in a tournament with more active 1v1 tournament players as hosts, but I'm unsure if (mostly) dedicated hosts like arai and heika (who I am deeply thankful of for hosting) can speak accurately towards pricings, besides essentially acting like a formula.

Formula: Not a fan. I think past formulas have over-weighted performance in the previous tournament. Maybe with adjustments it would be fine, but if hosts adjust the formulas until prices "look right", they might as well just pick the prices themselves.

Voting: Not perfect but I think this is still best. My proposal for a voting system:

1. Each host internally votes on an approximate fair price for each manager with a total budget limit of $X (depending on manager quality, but for example, X could be 15k * 16 = 240k), and a minimum price of $10k.
2. Take the median of the hosts' vote on each manager. That is the "host price" of that manager. The "host prices" are hidden from the managers.
2. If a team's managers have a combined "host price" of $Y, then they receive a budget of $(X-Y) to vote on the other managers, with a minimum price of $10k per manager.
3. Any team that votes less than 50% (adjustable number) of the "host prices" on any manager have ALL of their votes thrown out. This is mostly to prevent teams from voting 10k on radu (knowing that the price will be dropped out) to jack up the prices on other managers. Teams are disincentivized to vote really high on one manager, so that is not a concern
4. For each manager, between the 3 hosts' votes and 7 managerial pairs' votes, drop the highest 2 and the lowest 2 prices, then take the mean of the remaining 6, and round to the nearest .5k

I believe this to help with both egregious/malicious voting while also allowing hosts to set a rough total budget to prevent teams from overpricing other managers. Let me know if there's still any way to exploit the system and I would be glad to rework it
 
Last edited:
ND > SS2 > UU > DPP > SV4 > MG

To the surprise of nobody I am advocating for natdex above all else to be included in pl. The tier is in an excellent state with updated resources post-cl (announcement soon tm) and is undergoing active tiering with the custap suspect. I think criticisms of game quality are more an indictment of the manager pool than anything since it is a manager's responsibility to draft players that will make the correct plays and win games, and there is nothing inherent to natdex that makes it more difficult than any other tier (because it IS every other tier smashed together). You can cherrypick misplays and bad sets from any tier where a majority of the players went for 3k and are using teams from public dumps. I think the fact that the two most experienced players (myself and crucify through LogIce proxy) topped the pool speaks to the fact that it is a tier where experience and motivation are positively correlated with success, which is about as desirable as a competitive tier can get. Further, that LogIce heroically turned his season around from 0-3 to 4-3 with 2 wins in playoffs is proof to me that the tier is not as opaque and difficult to pick up and play as some have suggested.

SS2 next because SS is well developed and a known factor. I like UU and would much prefer it over SV4 because SV fatigue is pretty real. DPP is not desirable, SV4 is very undesirable, and MG is just too much work over the length of a tour like pl.

Flat pricing is bad unless you raise the floor to 20k minimum, and I would go higher. A very common denominator in tournament winning teams is a highly skilled manager self-buying for far less than they're worth. Formula is bad for similar reasons. Manager/host votes have no objective criteria and can be trolled but they produce the prices that most accurately reflect a manager's skill.
 
Last edited:
UU>>>>>>>SS2>>>>DPP

UU
+Easy to get into cz its just reg sv but w/ other mons
+High interest during CL
+A way to add another SV Slot without it actually being SV
+New update makes it more UU-like & brings in popular changes
+Managers don't have to bend their whole plan and budget to accommodate the rare player pool since its easier to migrate/get someone to UU
-Less resources than other metas

Natdex
-High entry barrier. Actually have to learn multiple interactions from multiple gens as a start
-Low interest in CL. Contrary to the posts that vouched for ND, everyone ran away from that slot and people that vouched for it didn't play it, just migrated to another slot
-V Limited pool and polarizing. You'll get 1-2 mainers and a ton of filler options, so not only u have to draft a filler willing to play but a builder also
-Budget chokehold just like DPP (Same playerbase issue)
-Ton of reuses in CL, really tough meta to build / get into as a builder
+Lot of resources

We actually tried Natdex in CL, numbers & facts speak from themselves. It was a complete snoozefest. Repeating the points, lot of reuses, lot of fillers cause supporters played something else all tour, bad gameplay that came from complex interactions. Not very competitive. Only way this would work is by force tier locking all the supporters in this thread to natdex cause nobody act gonna play it in the tour lmao

SS2 status quo is OK. SS is a snooze gen but its balanced, but ye nobody plays in 2026 so it also makes it a filler slot / budget constraints ss1

DPP is fine just has no playerbase but better than sv4 & mg


Keep everything bo5. Bo7 in PL is too tiring and it barely mattered in CL. Make TB Bo7

Just use the good trialed and test manager pricing (put a budget, use the voting system, remove outliers, average others). Idk why we're circling around other options while this one clearly worked everytime it happened
 
idc about the tiers cuz i'm still playing sv it's not like i'm magically switching to ss2 like pl9 that was mainly cuz there was a lack of ss players in pults, but i will talk about the manager pricing.

very skilled manager pairs we've seen before like bellchimes/delemon or crucify/potatochan comparing themselves to other manager pairs means that flat pricing, regardless of how you sugarcoat it, is gonna be unfair.

fixing by hosts might be mixed but i'd be fine with it, since even though heika and arai aren't as experienced with the scene, there will probably be a third host that knows more about it and i think it would be at least the second-best option.

the previous pl's formula went like this: price last pl/2+wins last pl*2k, with 10k as the minimum bar.
i'm fine with this formula, but it does lead to slightly funny scenarios like people that've never played pl costing 10k, maybe there could be an argument of raising this to 12k? but i think 10k is a bit low.

as a manager, i disliked voting this cl, people can still troll, and yeah hosts can remove until you're left with a result that's favorable to most but at that point just pick a price that you think looks good and stop fumbling with formulas and other stuff, which, as i said before, is the second-best option imo.

overall it's becoming a lot more difficult to come up with formulas/decisions that can satisfy everyone, mainly because flat pricing is so fucking awful, idt we're being nit-picky though, trying to come up with stuff that is helpful for all of us is the end result that will matter, something something the friends we made along the way.
ok byeeeeeee
 
DEG said:
Natdex
-High entry barrier. Actually have to learn multiple interactions from multiple gens as a start
-Low interest in CL. Contrary to the posts that vouched for ND, everyone ran away from that slot and people that vouched for it didn't play it, just migrated to another slot
-V Limited pool and polarizing. You'll get 1-2 mainers and a ton of filler options, so not only u have to draft a filler willing to play but a builder also
-Budget chokehold just like DPP (Same playerbase issue)
Genuinely baffled by this, uu and natdex pools were about the same quality and natdex actually had a few people on council play it for the entire tour (zo and blanched). Outside of the fact that you played UU, I don’t know what difference you could possibly be seeing.

Two of the “filler” players you mention have also made posts engaging with the meta in the other tiers thread, which is not the case for the clickers who got thrown into UU.

Also, while I have not built either meta to such an extent I can compare accessibility. Natdex games are a lot more readable as a spectator just from having a baseline understanding of sm/sv(/ss too).

I think natdex is the clear best choice for a replacement.

Speaking more generally:
  • I’m okay to see ss2 leave, its consistently been the least interesting and lowest quality slot.
  • If we are comparing metas that haven’t been good or held major interest but might potentially be good with a Bit More Tiering, I’d sooner give a slot to dpp than uu.
  • Any slot that doesn’t have 8 mainers playing with 100% certainty should never be Bo7. Would only keep sv7 and ss7.
  • Tiebreak being always Bo7 is good.
  • I think voting is still the best price system despite that cl pair (POTENTIALLY) acting in bad faith. Would prefer flat pricing next.
  • pqs tourban should be extended to cover this pl.
 
crow crumbs said:
Genuinely baffled by this, uu and natdex pools were about the same quality and natdex actually had a few people on council play it for the entire tour (zo and blanched). Outside of the fact that you played UU, I don’t know what difference you could possibly be seeing.

This is correct. UU pool is/wasn't better. Learning ceiling is just lower by FAR and easier to get into. people can easily pivot to UU only cause they play SV/mons in general, unlike Natdex which is a made up multi generational/mechanical/interaction which requires more in-depth understanding. Plus UU never said they had the vast playerbase but Natdex keep saying there's interest and players when in reality there's barely

I'm fine with DPP over both tiers too if people would want to play DPP
 
A burden I've seen lacking generally is "Why is the status quo bad". When you propose a new slot you have to prove why the current situation has certain exclusive harms in the first place.

The only real harm i've seen expressed so far "SS2 is a filler feeding slot" and I dont see how this exclusive.
  1. SV4 has the exact same issue
  2. DPP has a few "mainers" but even fewer builders
  3. UU and Natdex were feeder slots in CL and will continue to be so in PL
So at this point there's only one tier here that stands on any exclusive benefit on the comparative w/ ss2, and thats UU. Given that both are feeder slots, UU is better because:
  1. Lower Entry barrier for established CG mainers who will have to build
  2. Lower entry barriers for newer CG players
  3. Is proximate enough to SV4 that the same type of player can slot in while preventing burnout by being differentiated enough
  4. Weighs over natdex due to the accessibility proven above
But the problem with it is very obvious: a lack of resources. Aside from the fact that proper resources for an ever-changing meta is probably an impossible task, something 1v1 mainers seem to desire a lot is pre-established resources such as samples setcomp etc. that allows you to insert yourself into the builder with ease.
UU vs Natdex is just about whether you care about broad accessibility or resources more.
But I think this is mitigated with the nature of UU itself. I think its fine to have one slot that revolves around a consistently changing meta from tour to tour rather than a pre-established backlog.

I don't particularly support any tier, I think ss2 is is fine, would love to see natdex but I think the best midground option is probably UU.

I trust the TDs to weigh out all the arguments here effectively.


idk much about manager pricing but the current system looks like ur punished for doing well in tours.
 
Just a reminder that Natdex has multiple teamdumps from dozens of players, setcomp and sample teams, multiple forum and discord tours, while UU still doesn’t have any of this. I’d even rather have CAP 1v1 be in (somehow this has more resources than uu?) because having UU in would just be a slap in the face to the many people who actually care about 1v1 and developed resources for fun and competitive tiers.

Natdex is harder because it is a developed tier with many resources, UU is an easier tier with little resources. How does this make sense? UU is just not competitive; we still have Spinarak and Alolan Persian being brought and winning games from 1v1CL, and the argument of “it’s easy to learn because its cg” should be irrelevant due to the difference of mons being used in SV OU and SV UU. The skill ceiling is lower in UU because its more underdeveloped, not because it has easy-to-access resources or a bigger, more active playerbase.
 
Slots
The nuclear option is to remove SS2 for ND and remove SV3 for UU.

At the outset of this post, Indi made an astute point that whatever happens with this 8th slot, it’s just gonna be mostly cheap players with a few “mainers” sprinkled in.

Since the resource argument against UU has come up a lot, I ain't gonna reiterate it and honestly don't think it matters too much for a meta whose point is to consistently change. Instead I will point out the elephant wearing camouflage in the room: SV. I'm pretty sure ND has more resources available than SV does at this point. Obviously SV has a ladder (ignoring its quality), which helps with its lack of updated resources. But man, the SV comp got a sort-of revamp for 1v1 factory but then it was never actually updated after Custap Berry got banned so idk. SV really just hasn't earned anything as a tier honestly, at least this iteration of SV. For the amount of games SV gets played in individuals and UM tours, its level of metagame and resource development almost doesn't make sense to me. Maybe it's just solved and the custap ban changed nothing, what do I know, but I think the fact stands that SV has one of, if not the worst, pool of resources. But in the end, it's the current gen and has a Bo7 slot so we say it's the pinnacle.

I also think the tier bleed that’ll happen with UUs inclusion + 3 SV slots is actually substantial. UU “playerbase” is similar to SV3 with cameos from other playerbases filling in. You're not really diversifying the tour / its playerbase by adding UU > SS2. SV is where you would want the "filler" players to be but SV has the least resources! At least it has a ladder! We just have the Valin frogfacts Cabal passing everyone teams. I guess that's fine considering Indi's point. Whatever man. I will say I do like the idea of UU and think it's fun to play an underdeveloped meta. Like I want UU to be in the tour because it has that bonus over these stale ass metas and prefer it over SV3. but the current gen can't have the same amount of slots as an old gen (SS) and 3 SV + UU is a lot as aforementioned. So remove SS2 for another tier...

For ND, I'm obviously biased towards it because I like the tier, but I have to say ND had some of the most creative throws I've seen. Very high entertainment value, but I on't think it's a strong argument against ND. ND is the hardest tier in terms of sequencing with the SV mon pool and Z Moves and Megas and it takes some getting used to. On a related note, I think the argument being posed about # of unique players who played ND and UU in CL is just misconstrued. I would argue the majority of the playerbase sticking with the tier for the duration of the tier is healthy. Blanched (I don't think he will play another tier outside of ND again), THR, Logice, and shadow (maybe he played other tiers before idk) all actually posted in that other tiers thread which is pretty impressive engagement honestly. I think this core engaged playerbase (that I will add is relatively unique from other slots) and ND's resources are the main arguments for its inclusion, but the biggest ? is how the other slots will fill, of course (seraphz also notably played the duration of CL).

With all that being said, the safest bet is to keep SS2. IMO CL should be unique because of its tiers (older gens, other tiers, MG), WC should be unique because of its different format + current gen focus (retaining 4 regular SV slots), and PL should be the "polished" of the three team tours with a formulaic format that has persisted since 2020 (3 CG, 2 of most recent gen, 1 of each old gen) with the exception of 2022 MG Bo5. note, the nuclear option disrupts this framing in order to fully capitalize on the excitement the two other tiers currently hold.

Realistically, SS2 is not significantly worse than the other options; I find it incredibly uninspiring and it falls under Indi's point but those aren't solid arguments against it. Valin is correct that the burden of argument is on other tiers to justify their inclusion over SS, and not gonna lie man I don't think any did outside of personal excitement for a particular tier. But at the same time who is strongly excited about SS? Unclear. It's admittedly a lukewarm option but maybe that's best when otherwise we just have a popularity contest.

SV4, MG, and DPP shouldn't be entertained.

tl;dr is SS2 (for stability / tried and true) or the nuclear option (excitement) are best. these two > ND = UU over SS2 with SV3 intact.

Manager Pricing
Don't do flat pricing. Punish disingenuous votes more for any voting system. I like linux's method.

Bo5 vs Bo7
This should always just be playerbase preference.
 
I think SS2 is also the best slot to choose in PL, even though in CL, Natdex and UU were chosen
1. SS is a much more well-established, where a second slot wouldn't change anything
2. In a more serious tournament setting like PL, I don't feel as confident that Natdex and UU will have serious building. I think it will be CL 2.0
3. UU has how many players?
Let's keep SS2 for CL and have UU+Natdex for WC+CL (P.S SS2 should always have been Bo7)
 
i'll keep mine short
slot 8 post: uu>>>cap>dpp>nd>ss2>sv4

UU is a really fun tier, it's easy to pick up so lack of players isn't a problem. It's really fun to build, and the idea of just putting your "worse" players there because it's a new tier doesn't really make sense to me. This is going to happen at SOME point in whatever 8th slot we choose, or somewhere else because of this 8th slot. Unless you have a perfect draft, there WILL be a "filler" slot. It is a competitive format, there was success in CL, the two main issues of it (in my opinion, being custap and ladder usage) were changed, which I think will only make the format realer and more competitive than before. I built a bit in PL and it was honestly very fun, I think it would be a great 8th slot in PL.

CAP 1v1: I know this is personal bias and the tier hasn't been tried out too much. I'm aware. Although I love CAP 1v1, it probably needs an actual larger playerbase to be in a team tour (maybe next CL?). Although there will be people willing to play the tier, and it honestly being pretty simple to pick up on, the metagame is just not developed enough. It's really fun, an alternative to UU and SV4, and honestly the most fun out of these tiers, with a few really fun mons that can be used in addition to SV mons. There's a setcomp and stuff and half of a VR which is cool!

DPP: I like this tier but honestly I'm worried about building, I don't think there's enough people to build in this as all the uncs are gone (uncs sign up and dpp will be cool)

ND: Honestly, a very high skill floor and ceiling, I'm horrible at the tier but I won't deny that it's fun. Very hard to build, combining mechanics across multiple generations, and I don't really think it'd fit in an 8 team tournament.

SS2: I think one bo7 SS slot is enough, two is too many, I don't really see a reason for it to be included

sv4: we do not need 4 SVs if we want 4 SVs we play world cup or UU (or cap peak)

i did not keep it that short but it was relatively short

Despite my personal enjoyment of CAP 1v1 and the advocating for it, realistically, UU would be a WAY better slot.
 
Having heard that it's a viable option from TD's whatever authoritative role Radu is, I'd like to shift discussion to crucify's proposal of a double tier swap of UU > SV3 and ND > SS2, which I am strongly in favor of. I'm of the opinion that, assuming 2 metagames are devoid of obviously uncompetitive elements, the one that people are more interested in will be the one that they are trying harder in, and therefore will be the more competitive one. Reading this thread, it seems obvious to me that people are very interested in both UU and ND, while support for SS2 (or anything else) is lukewarm at best. Both tiers are undergoing active tiering with their respective custap suspects and UU's tournament usage restructure, and ND resources have been heavily updated following 1v1CL. I think the inclusion of both of these tiers in PL would be overall positive for competition and engagement in a tour that has a tendency to drag on.

As far as replacing SV3 goes, I know there is concern about breaking the unspoken 3 CG representation rule that PL has always followed. However, this will be the first time that 1v1PL will feature the same current gen for its 4th consecutive iteration. SV fatigue is real and has led to a pretty large increase in phoning it in (apparently all but 3 SV series in CL had teams passed from frogfacts or valin loaded?? nobody wants to build this tier anymore). The length that SV has dragged on is starting to have negative effects on the seriousness of competition as people just don't care as much. Replacing SV3 with UU breathes new life into the lowest interest slot while maintaining an entry point into the team tour scene for new players, as seen in CL with ollierob and gp.

TLDR: UU > SV3 and ND > SS2. Discuss.
 
Last edited:
Large Thanks to everyone that posted in the thread, we've read and considered every post. I'm going to be sharing some updates now.

1. The hosting team will be RADU + Arai + bellchime.

:cacnea: :ralts: :jirachi:

2. We have come to a preference for what we want the tiers for 1v1PLX to be:

SV Bo7​
SV​
SV​
SV UU​
SS Bo7​
SM​
ORAS​
BW​

SS2 was already frowned upon for being a so-called "filler feeder slot", but what that mostly impacts is the SS "mainers". Most teams end up bleeding out for a dedicated SS player that will be able to both be self sufficient and also handhold a second slot both in teambuilding and occasionally in teaching them the intricacies of SS. This leads to lower quality teams, games, and a lot of burnout. Now that there are good alternatives, it's a good time to retire the SS playerbase from their babysitting side-hustle.

Let me be honest, UU and NatDex sit pretty much on the same level when it comes to interest, resources, development and playerbase. Both had a good CL representation and would be great replacements for SS2. Honestly, I considered the idea of running with the nuclear option and adding both, but it's just not feasible to remove an SV slot, sorry.

My initial edge was to prefer NatDex strictly because I liked the idea of having National Dex players potentially interested in 1v1PL and it's good to be able to expand to other communities, but on the other hand, UU appeals to players from the existing 1v1 playerbase that have been around but have not been able to play in teamtours as much. UU, as a tier, directly promotes the players that are motivated and active, and minimizes the inherent "metagame knowledge" gap that makes starting new players so risky. This directly cultivates our existing internal community, which is something I think is really important in a moment of lowered 1v1 interest.
I can only speak for myself but this is why I prefer having UU over NatDex in PL, the metagames are otherwise pretty much equal in my eyes and it could've swung one way or the other. To reiterate, this is not a final decision, but our current preference. More discussion with compelling arguments could make us change our minds, and the format is not locked until managers are selected/draft happens basically.

3. SV1 will be Bo7, and SS will be Bo7. All other slots will be Bo5 during regular weeks and playoffs, but Bo7 during tiebreak.

This is just about the status quo we've been running with except for the CL experiment. While we would've liked to make SS Bo5 too, the Council was strongly in support of Bo7, and our reasons were not strong enough to deny them of that. As for the tiebreak, I'm under the impression that this is just the majority opinion and I haven't seen anybody oppose this, correct me if I'm wrong.

4. Manager Prices will be presented by the Hosts.

While we understand the concerns that come with this method, we believe this far and above eclipses all other methods when it comes to obtaining a list of fair prices for the managers, and we would like to at least give this a chance for once. We have a highly qualified team of well-intentioned hosts, and whether or not this system is sustainable for future editions, it is definitely feasible for the upcoming one, and that's good enough. We don't intend to systematically enforce whichever price we first come up with, either, of course. Just as I'm doing here and communicating our preferences way in advance and allowing the community to dissent, the list of prices will be shared with the list of managers as soon as possible, and a constructive discussion will ensue. I believe we are all reasonable people and we will be able to achieve an outcome that is 'accepted' by all managers.

5. We would like to celebrate PLX as a community achievement, and we have some things in mind we wanna do:

  • 1v1PLX Post Draft Power Rankings - I'll make sure we are well prepared, mobilized, and are able to get it to the finish line. To that extent, YOU (yes, YOU!!) need to help us with it. I'll prepare some sort of interest form once we've reached out to TFP and set out some sort of deadline and guidelines.
  • I wanna make a longer YouTube video related to 1v1 on the Smogon youtube channel. Highly depends if I've got the bandwith for it personally, and is mostly on my shoulders to make, but if you have ideas or ways you think you can be helpful I'm all ears. If anyone capable steps up I may recruit you for some YouTube Short.
  • Manager Interviews: I would like to hold some sort of mini interviews to the manager pairs before and after the auction, because I think it would be really fun for them to be able to discuss their draft plan before the auction and then afterwards share the reaction to what their team ends up looking like. As long as all the managers are ok with it, we should be able to get this done easily.
  • ^This is about all of what the hosting team can offer in terms of their time and effort. We invite you (yes, YOU) to participate and do whatever you think will be fun to make, other projects, personal prs, pre draft rankings, predicts, weekly video recaps, memes, cheering for your team, anything. I just hope we can bring some well deserved hype to this tour.

6. To that extent, we would like to add a Media Break Week after the Auction

This would give us one week to better prepare the PRs, the potential video, and any other project. The media break week happens in other official team tournaments and they're also a great moment for you to establish a team environment, get a head start on prep, and just let you get in the groove. Here is what the timeline should look like with that in mind:

Manager Signups: April 27th - May 3rd​
Player Signups: May 4th - May 17th​
Draft: May 16th - May 17th​
Media Week: May 18th - May 24th​
Week 1: May 25th - May 31st​
Week 2: June 1st - June 7th​
Week 3: June 8th - June 14th​
Week 4: June 15th - June 21st​
Week 5: June 22nd - June 28th​
Week 6: June 29th - July 5th​
Week 7: July 6th - July 12th​



As I have slightly mentioned above, everything in this post is the current preference of the hosting team, and we are always open to conversation and changing things. We still have 10 days til manager signups, and there's a lot of things that we can change even after manager signups and selection.
Please (PLEASE) post in this thread (down here) any and all thoughts you may have, I don't want anyone to feel resentment towards the finalized decisions because they simply did not post here but got buried in #pl-discussion. Do feel free to converse about this stuff on discord as well though.
 
i'm not in a position to type a large or well crafted post right now but i really want to post my thoughts as soon as possible,
- one of the main points i see people use to argue in favor of uu is the low skill floor/metagame knowledge gap argument. is it really that hard to learn the intricacies of natdex? yeah it adds new interactions like those between encore and zmoves and it adds new mons but is it really crazy to suggest that people who don't play a tier will have to put in minimal effort to learn it? it's not that daunting and i think its insane that one of the most prevalent arguments against its inclusion is the fact that it's marginally harder to learn than its biggest competitor
- why not remove an sv slot? uu and natdex are both sv based tiers, and having 3 sv slots isnt written in stone. obviously just because theyre gen 9 doesn't make them the same as sv3 but it definitely doesn't hurt their case either. much more reasonable than saying something like add dpp over sv3. having two alternative tiers garner this much support to the point that both of them are seriously considered as a slot in pl is huge and i would think it could at least warrant a discussion abt removing an sv slot
- or just make it 10 slots. it's a custom avatar tour, there are definitely enough 1v1 players to go around, and 1v1 is a really accessible and easy to pick up tier for players of other formats. again the resounding support for both of these tiers can certainly attest to a scenario where both get picked
- if one or the other gets picked there will be a part of the playerbase that is dissatisfied with the decision. if both get added, especially as an additional 2 tiers, everyones happy(?) i don't know how many people are strongly against the removal of an sv slot though and i am unsure if there is any data to back having 10 slots except for my recollection that a lot of notable players didn'r get drafted last pl. although it is common practice in ca tours to have 10 slots nowadays.
- i am obviously acting out of bias however as i want the opportunity to play natdex in this pl and its inclusion raises the chance i get to play at all. at the end of the day there are 100 reasons to include 1 over the other so i say include em both and if we can't have that then lets fight to the bitter end natdexers Blanched crucify LogIce pqs Rec frogfacts Marshmelto and i guess our founding father RADU has snaked us with his flagrant uu advocacy
 
Back
Top