Will be unable to play w1 and w2.
Re: Manager selection
I am not much of a complainer but I have found the certain decisions related to this tour to be very disappointing, so here is my constructive input:
Leadership is predicated on trust from the playerbase. That trust is derived from convincing the playerbase (and the site as a whole) that decisions are made fairly and thoughtfully. However, these manager selections (and related rules) are highly questionable in these regards. I don't intend to put anyone down so apologies if it comes off as such, but I will be making comparisons between selected and non-selected manager pairs.
- Firstly, I guarantee you nobody (sane) has any problems with damflame/maybca as users. Moreover, damflame is clearly very competent at pretty much all of the tiers featured, and maybca can double up on AAA knowledge – I would say this pair would be above average in their metagame knowledge and ability to provide test games to their players. Therefore, player competence doesn't make sense as reasoning. While I am not super tapped into the greater OM community, the Leaves not being selected strikes me as quite surprising.
- Second, will try to be unbiased as possible – Icemaster and Fc's OM achievements are even more impressive and, especially given their managing experiences elsewhere, their rejection appears extremely confusing at best. There is no rationale related to playing or managing ability that realistically justifies this decision: Ice won BH open and made it to circuit semis last year as someone who only observes the core OM metagames in passing, while Fc obviously succeeded in GG without any prior metagame knowledge last OMPL while building his own teams. While gaming prowess isn't everything in a social, team tour environment, there also isn't anything to the weighing against them hard enough to make non-playoffs OMPL/CL teams an obvious choice should it have come to that. Occasional OMcord trolling is not a sufficient explanation, even if it's for sure a negative.
- Lastly (and perhaps most importantly), the purposeful vagueness in the manager signup process is very concerning. To my knowledge the OM community is unique on the site in OMPL's manager signup deadline is "whenever there are 8 suitable teams", which introduces significant ambiguity for no benefit. This does nothing to improve the quality of signups, because there is incentive for less qualified candidates in addition to the more qualified ones to sign up early, and pairs that want some time to think about managing are directly harmed. Why lock the latter group out? Moreover, the most plausible explanation for Icemaster/Fc's rejection is Ice being barred as a manager – however, Fc was clearly not informed before the deadline. Why?
- While pannu's admission that they may cancer is definitely sanctionable, immediately resorting to punishment without exploring the possibility of pannu having forgotten the rules also supports a narrative of minimal effort for transparency.
Of course, I give the benefit of the doubt to the OM leadership and will consider these cases as simply major fuckups. However, I would like to see outside signs of greater thoughtfulness in the implementation of rules, through indication of thoughtful discussions before pulling any triggers, greater transparency for relevant parties, and amending rules for which enforcement is especially ambiguous, even if any unfairness is unintentional.
Let's have a good tour everyone