LoseToRU? said:Na I'm the schizo who would rather repost than edit, sorry about that.
Nothing like hoping on a mid ladder alt and striking fear into players lol
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen9ou-2613266113
No one gets more use out of big iron jug
:iron jugulis: on the planet than I do
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen9ou-2610419618
https://replay.pokemonshowdown.com/gen9ou-2613255782
My brother in Smogon, we gotta meet the meta where it's at. Just like you gotta meet ppl where they're at.
It's a concept that will help you tremendously in personal and professional life. Adjust your standards a bit.
Def something you should try to master as an adult- along with learning how to say no, and how to take a no.
Anyway man, no one is glazing this shit ass tier. You live on here, so I know you've seen my literal essays and diatribes about why Tera was never meant for a serious 6v6 singles meta- that it was 1000% made for 9yo kids to meme with in-game. It's whatever in VGC with team sheets on display but still quite goofy. It was a mistake to keep it, and I will never compromise on that.
We can agree to disagree on moth- personally I think anyone who favors a Volc meta is shortsighted on the long-term brokenness of the mon.
But where we will just straight up argue on is how there are no currently broken mons in SV OU. Not sure if you played Gen 7, but a power creep meta is what it is. You're not losing because there are broken, OP pokemon in OU, you just aren't. Post any replay you wish and I will respectfully analyze what you could have done better, either in play or the builder.
Banning/dropping whatever mon you personally are attached to isn't going to move the needle on SV being ass. You know this deep down. Tera as a mechanic hard caps any tier it's allowed in at a solid C+. It will never rise above that because it's an insidious, pernicious, incredibly stupid af gimmick that throws away decades of 6v6 framework. It's so refreshing to play older gens and actually get to map out a consistent end game, with consistent win conditions.
We were given trash. Cringe gimmick with DeviantArt level fan-made pokemon that are comically min/maxed.
I'm looking at the positive side of things, that's all. It took a lot of time and effort to ban the right mons.
We're not banning any more mons, just accept that. We banned TB before we had a Dragonite suspect. Gambit, Gold, Zame, Oger-W- they would all pass a suspect easily. The people have spoken. Try to accept their viewpoints and reasoning, even if they don't make total sense to you. If I can do that with Tera, which to this day I do not understand how the shit is accepted whatsoever, then I promise you can do it with Volcarona.
There's a reason I've been taking multiple 3-7 month breaks this gen. There have been many times where the meta is actual dogshit, straight up. My entire point is we are finally at a place where it can't get any worse, if that makes sense. You say there is a long way to go, but there isn't. We're done. It's over. We might get a meme Light Clay suspect or something, but what will that really do? You can either be content that the meta is finally stable, albeit pretty bad, or rage against things you simply cannot change.
One last thing though; I will still always be sad about the meta that could have been. I try to be respectful, especially after giving Finch a stupidly hard time all gen, including many bad faith, literal meme ragebait posts for my own amusement lol... but yeah I will say I am disappointed there wasn't more support around a no-tera SV OU meta. It's like they were scared to even entertain the idea of no-tera room tours, or including it in the "other meta" category. I vastly exceeded all official requirements for my own official chat room on PS! to host no-tera tours in, but it was just straight up denied. They were worried it would siphon players away or something, which kinda says all you need to know. I went to war over this dumbass gimmick, and lost. So I've just accepted what we have, and try to be positive about it. But yeah, no one seems to have the vision of how good SV could have been.
As another person that was super anti-Tera to the point that I actually stopped playing competitive Pokemon entirely for a year, and might be becoming a cringe VGC player, I kinda agree.
This meta is dogshit, Gen 5 OU 2 (but probably worse). Rather than a few Pokemon I'd consider in Gen 5 to be stupid to be allowed, that could basically describe half of the top-tiers in this generation, but that basically describes it all: This is a bad OU metagame. And that's fine.
It is what it is. The moment Tera was sealed, the metagame had a cemented cap to how good it could be, and it's somewhere close to that cap. While you could easily make the case that most of the top tier Pokemon dynamics are broke check broke, it's enough checks to things that you can have a coherent metagame. It's the bare minimum for competitiveness. It works.
I won't reserve my critiques for the future: The way the tiering policy on this generation was handled (again: tiering policy, NOT tiering) is actually so bad that it convinces me the reason TPCi doesn't see a threat in Smogon is actually because it's incompetent enough that we'll be irrelevant in a decade. There were so many blunders and what feel like PR moves or holding onto a broken system that needs to be changed before the "next generation" (that itself is in my opinion a blunder, I haven't been shy in other threads on this site that I view Champions as the 'new competitive *forever* gen').
For one, locking Tera for
every Official Tier (to be clear again, I'm not talking about 'OU didn't ban Tera', I'm talking the uniform decision on this for all Official Tiers) was the worst (and I mean worst) decision all generation. The fact that tiers like Little Cup and Ubers which had arguably way more support to ban Tera than the regular tiering rung meant that those players were fucked over, and in some ways are still fucked over to this day, see the LC metagame thread where some (not saying it's a majority, as I'm not in the community) are quite literally saying "is it worth to keep being an official tier if we have to deal with Tera". You can say the tiering leaders agreed, but frankly, it's not up to the tier leaders to decide that when a giant portion of their playerbase wants Tera gone. I'm a believer in a more hardline council deciding that they have a vision for the tier, and I think it's fair to say we have a vision with Tera, that's the way it's gonna work. But in the modern era it feels like uniformity between tiers is just kinda the wrong decision, sorry. The monoculture around OU has never been this weak, and the difference in how tiers play has not been greater. More than that, as shown with oldgens, I think most playerbases are quite tired of Tiering Policy telling their playerbase what they can't do, even when fairly reasonable, and that is what this feels like, especially given it was supposed to be a long-term declaration. My belief that tiering councils picking a vision can be good also includes changes in leadership allowing for different visions, or changing alongside more knowledge. This didn't feel like a game design decision, this felt like a Public Relations thing.
Shoutouts to UUBers for making a play to become an official tier by also following the announcement's rule and getting shafted also, by the way. I see you and get you, maybe you'll get it next time.
Terapagos is a Pokemon that I feel would absolutely have made this metagame better. It's a Bulky Offense style Pokemon that has had great success in NatDex without being overbearing, and it's a Rapid Spinner that can kind of go toe-to-toe with Gholdengo, but also isn't a domineering matchup to it. I've been the biggest Gholdengo hater of all-time, but respecting the fact that clearly a lot of the playerbase is fine with it, this wouldn't be like a "kill Gholdengo spikestack" change, it'd just be a slight nerf and put more pressure on Gholdengo to find ways around another common spinner. More than that, it's a Dragonite-style Pokemon in a tier that is always looking for more one-time checks to massive offensive threats, and unlike Dragonite wouldn't have had the sweeping potential without Tera Blast that makes that Pokemon its own demonic threat.
But then in the policy thread where basically every normal person looking at it normally was like "This is basically a Mega Evolution that uses Tera just ban the Mega Evolution" and tiering policy was like "NO!!!! That's a complex ban it requires a code blablabla clause" oh my god shut the fuck UUUUP lmaooooo. Be normal. That thread is something that should be framed on the wall of "Smogon takes its rules more seriously than real world governments", fuck, lawyers take EULAs less seriously than Smogon Tiering Policy enforcement does the very specific bits of language in this document we adapt from 4channers 20 years ago.
Next generation we could stand to do more common sense rulings on Tiering Policy and not treat it like a fucking Bible. Terapagos wouldn't make the meta good, but it in my opinion absolutely would've made it better.
Lastly, the original suspect test on Tera was not a mistake, but not doing a second one was one, and this is where I have my greatest regret in regards to this tier: I was a Pro-Tera Soldier in late 2022 early 2023, because I didn't understand the mechanic very well. I was looking at Tera as what I wanted it to be: a CYOA Teambuilder Custom Mega Custom Regional Form thing, when other better players knew, but given how many likes I farmed in those threads, not everybody knew, that it's actually not like that at all and is mostly a variance generator. The point is that few (besides goats like Srn) actually understood the mechanic, which is to be fair one of its strengths—the skill floor and skill ceiling for the generational mechanic was much higher than Dynamax (lol), Z, and Megas basically didn't have any outside of maybe "how 2 get it online sooner", the rare Pokemon that didn't want to Mega instantly, or Gen 6 speed tier shenanigans.
But that suspect test, which was already extremely close to some kind of action, barely didn't make that and we never tested it again. And I do not want to hear "the surveys!" we literally just saw that surveys don't actually mean everything, and I've hammered for millenia about how a sizable portion of the playerbase in just about every time it was asked, including tour players, already voted yes for action on said surveys. And just doing it and then getting closure would've been better than just randomly declaring one day that nothing was going to happen.
There were many positives in how this generation was handled and I think it would be bad of me to write a bunch of paragraphs critiquing these actions, especially of volunteers, and not give props for the great things accomplished.
1. The most transparent generation ever. It was basically always telegraphed what was next in the tiering process, or when nothing was next, or when the council didn't really know what was going to happen. If a tournament would get in the way, that was said, when in previous generations sometimes that was just a "if you know you know we're not going to suspect shit until (blank) is over".
Sometimes Finchinator revealed things behind the scenes that got him clowned on (at least temporarily), even if it was something that wasn't his fault, and I think we should all salute him for taking the bullet and also for showing that side at all. He easily could've just said nothing, but he did, and I think that just shows how committed as a tier leader he is to the community.
2. The splitting of the Suspect Test threads. I don't remember my opinion on this at the time, but it was a great idea. While the overall singles playerbase is actually shrinking, it feels like the proportion of said playerbase that wants to be active on the forums was higher than ever especially in 2023/2024, and it lead to the most clusterfuck low quality threads I have seen. I also participated in some SWSH suspect test threads, and those were fairly chill, the most rowdy of those didn't meet the most chill suspect thread of SV before this change.
I have massive critiques for some of the elitist attitudes of how Smogon broadly operates in regards to betterer skill = better opinion (in just about any competitive game, you'll find that many of the GOATs have dogshit opinions on said game, or even dislike the game, because being good at a game doesn't make you a 'game designer' which is what balancing requires), but having 1300 andies dogpiling 1,000 hour 10,000 games tournament winning quality players just blindly reciting talking points from False Swipe Gaming or whatever is a total swing in the opposite direction. I don't think betterer skill = betterer opinion, but I think there is a bare minimum to understanding the game that a lot of posts weren't meeting and I do think betterer skill = informder opinion. Being informed doesn't make an opinion better (and I say better as in, there IS actually a "correct opinion", as in if we had a multiverse and were able to explore every single option, we would find a reality with the objectively best outcome or several with better outcomes), as you can be knowledgeable on something and still say whack ass shit, but there's still more of an actual dialogue to be had, and not just copypastas of Smogon Legalese or Metagame Theory. Most of the time the 1300 andies had a good point it was usually by accident and usually the way they said it made it clear they didn't understand what they were saying. And that was like, the best case scenario, most of the time it was just not making a good point and saying nothing that made sense, leading to a good portion of the threads being "hey this is not how this works" and explaining baseline theory. Splitting the threads seemed to dissuade a lot of this behavior and allowed a more casual thread and a thread for only informed opinions, as well.
That was a long ramble but all to say, it was a good change, and encouraged better discussions, I think. In fact it's so long, I'm going to straight up minimize its text size because it isn't super relevant. Please keep this in the next generation.
3. The handling of the DLCs was a much needed improvement from SWSH. While DLC1 was also fucking trash IIRC (it's been so long I've not fully remembered to be honest, and I kinda tuned out the last month of it as well) but it was better handled tiering wise whereas SWSH DLC1 felt like it was tiered conservatively and less so with the mindset that, when DLC2 dropped, it'd basically be reset anyways. Remember that Urshifu lasted all the way from the beginning of DLC1, to a few months into DLC2. It was not fun! I'm a rare breed that enjoyed HOME SWSH meta, but DLC1 seemed to be it but honestly just worse in my opinion, it felt like it led to a more matchup fishy metagame, and until Crown Tundra it was mostly just a waiting game sans Magearna suspect, which honestly feels like it would have been a quickban if the tier was handled like it has this gen (which, positive). The DLC drops this gen were handled with more grace in my opinion, it never felt like tiering policy really paused and the transition to DLC2 was handled about the same in mentality, just DLC1 we didn't have to suffer as much and had the same active council.
This is probably the last serious post I'll ever write in this thread not just because I don't have much attachment to CGOU anymore, but also because I just barely consider this "CGOU", anyways, no matter how much the official take from Smogon seems to be that Champions is a spinoff or something similar. Not that I'll really post much there either for now considering that as a live service title, it is currently the most barren it'll be and they didn't give many good tools for a singles metagame. But while I've had a lot of bad to say about this tier, and it made me feel like community-based balancing is actually in fact terrible, and feel that the Smogon system needs an entire rework, the metagame has gotten to a point where it's the best it's probably going to be, and that's thanks to the council despite critique, and to be fair, sometimes due to critique, which was handled gracefully which many councils haven't. Shit, have y'all read the public crashouts of early days Smogon council leadership? It's kinda funny.
SV OU is a OU tier of all-time, and I look forward to being able to read spicy Policy Review threads on the tier when I'm 65 years-old.
Finch if Gen 10 is an action rpg you will be leading this tier for the rest of your time in thus mortal realm. Your soul will be chained to the SV OU Aether via dark magic. Do not resist.