2nd Chessking post in the Almost Any Ability thread you know this is going to be a banger.
:SV/Lugia:
Lets talk about Lugia, more formally. I've been rambling about this mon for a while on discord but with Ghold suspect going DNB, next most demanded mon being Deo-S that completely clowned itself in PL winrate and probably lost its chance to be suspected, and meta not in a volatile state, I think there is a better argument for a Lugia unban suspect with nothing its interrupting, so I'm making a formal forum post.
First timing wise AAAPL starts Manager Signups this Thursday, then week 1 starts Aug 3, while OMPL semis is next week (July 6) and finals is either July 13/20 depending on tb or not. Considering playoffs are tierlocked? and not all teams in playoffs this is a respectable window to run a suspect. Theres a similar window after AAAPL and before OMCL around end of September, but I think its less good with AAA Seasonal ongoing.
As background information, Lugia was released with DLC 2 and quickbanned in
this slate in a 4-3 vote, the closest one of the legends. This is actually an arguable vote since the vote passes the 50% threshold but doesn't hit the 60% one. Obviously since then it has never been legal in AAA, and this does mean that arguments all have to be based on theoreticals, but that's also why unban suspects make them ladder legal. From here I'm going to try to suggest that Lugia has several issues that prevent it from posing as big of an issue its 680 BST might suggest.
1. Awful typing defensively
Psychic / Flying turns out to be really not good in current AAA. Flying grants a rocks weakness, which means Lugia is either running Magic Guard, or is basically locked into running Boots, and this makes Knock Off extra threatening. This typing also has a lot of weaknesses and not that many useful resistances in the tier. Notably, going down OMPL usage so far its typing matches up unfavourably defensively into the typings of (above 5% usage): Gholdengo, Roaring Moon, Ting-Lu, Zapdos, Kingambit, Meowscarada
And additional weaknesses to coverage options of: Zamazenta (Crunch, Stone Edge, Wild Charge), Deoxys-S (Thunderbolt, Ice Beam, Shadow Ball, Knock Off if you think thats real still), Iron Moth (Discharge), Great Tusk/Manaphy/Iron Treads (Knock Off), Landorus-T (Stone Edge).
And some misc VR Pokemon: Chien-Pao, Ogerpon-C, Electrode-H, Iron Boulder, Mamoswine, Sandy Shocks, Samurott-H, Thundurus(-T).
Meanwhile its typing is good defensively into... Zamazenta STAB, Deoxys-S STAB, various EQs.
This means despite its phenomenal bulk, it more or less needs a defensive ability + substantial defensive investment in the right spectrum to not fold to coverage options, and that STAB users can muscle past unless its very specific counter abilities. This also means more offensive sets are just vulnerable to being checked due to its weaknesses and lack of bulk investment.
2. Lacks a lot of defensive tools?
For anyone new to SV, Lugia lost Toxic and half its Recover PP. It also doesn't have like many useful utility moves at all, no status spreading move like Thunder Wave, no pivoting option, no utility moves like Knock, no play in the hazards game, it just gets some moves with secondary effects and phazing. So for the most part its not going to be annoying to handle or a momentum grabbing machine, and not able to role compress nearly as well as some defensive staples currently like Corv, Pech, STail, Ting.
3. Poor typing offensively + limited coverage
Turns out Psychic / Flying is also not great offensively despite Lugia having the excellent STAB Aeroblast. Steels resist it and many of the more popular Pokemon resist one and isn't weak to another (e.g. Moon, Ting, Zap) while threatening back with SE STAB.
Its coverage options are also not impressive. You have some options to help, but no universally good one and they are also not very strong, with Ground for non-Levi Ghold and Gambit, Ice for Moon Ting Zap, and Electric for non-VA Corv. This also means for Calm Mind sets, having only two moves leaves it very hard to hit everything.
3.5. It doesn't have Stored Power
This is a pretty major point, as if it did have Stored Power I think I wouldn't be making this post. Unlike existing Stored Power users (STail, Cress, Latias)? it does not have the explosive power they have after several CM boosts + anything else like Kee and Stamina. This should theoretically make those mons better at performing this role despite lower offenses/bulk/speed.
It also doesn't have coverage like Fairy move to hit the Psychic resists/immunes hard.
4. It's offensive stats are not very impressive
Base 90 is pretty middling especially without explosive setup moves like Nasty Plot+. Deo-S has higher offenses with a way more colourful movepool, runs max investment + Nature + ability + item and it still needs to get like every turn right to do anything. Lugia will need like investment + multiple CM boosts before it is meaningfully threatening and in that time opposing checks should have time to deal with it between counter setting up, phazing, status, grinding it down with strong hits. Its speed, while great especially for its bulk, is still only decent, speed tying with Latios and Moth, with stuff like Moon above, plus in order to make the most out of the speed it needs to invest into it.
For reference here's what 90 offense is capable of uninvested
0 SpA Lugia Earth Power vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Gholdengo: 128-152 (33.8 - 40.2%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
0 SpA Lugia Ice Beam vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Zapdos: 130-154 (40.4 - 47.9%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
+1 0 SpA Lugia Aeroblast vs. 0 HP / 4 SpD Zamazenta: 260-308 (80 - 94.7%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
+4 0 SpA Lugia Aeroblast vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Gholdengo: 159-188 (42 - 49.7%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
+6 0 SpA Lugia Ice Beam vs. 248 HP / 68 SpD Assault Vest Roaring Moon: 292-344 (70.7 - 83.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
+6 0 SpA Lugia Aeroblast vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Assault Vest Manaphy: 189-223 (46.7 - 55.1%) -- 69.5% chance to 2HKO
+6 0 SpA Lugia Ice Beam vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Corviknight: 189-223 (47.2 - 55.7%) -- 21.5% chance to 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
+6 0 SpA Lugia Psyshock vs. 252 HP / 4 Def Corviknight: 150-177 (37.5 - 44.2%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
This is what happens if you let something like Cresselia or even Scream Tail get 6 Calm Minds
+6 0 SpA Cresselia Stored Power (260 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Corviknight: 351-414 (87.7 - 103.5%) -- 25% chance to OHKO
+6 0 SpA Scream Tail Stored Power (260 BP) vs. 252 HP / 252+ SpD Corviknight: 314-369 (78.5 - 92.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
5. Not BH, doesn't have unlimited EVs
Turns out you can't have full defensive investment in both spectrums, full offensive investment, and full speed all at once. Its going to be missing out somewhere, just like with its ability and moveset.
These combined make me think that Lugia seems balanced to be allowed into the metagame, as at least for me tiering wise I think if something isn't broken it shouldn't be banned. But I know theres many people out there who think something should have some benefits to be allowed back so:
Lugia is a nice defensive presence that can be reasonably tailored to the teams needs
While I mentioned before that Lugia's defensive capabilities are undermined by its typing, with team support, the right spread and ability it can fill roles that I can see valuable as additions.
It can't reliably check Band Zama due to the double threat of Crunch and Stone Edge, but non-Band it can soft check and its a great sponge against Close Combat, as well as IronPress sets. This especially helps alleviate teambuilding from fitting the same Zama checks.
It helps beat Deo-S even further down into the ground as a decent soft check, even though Deo-S has a lot of moves that can hit it between BoltBeam SBall and Knock.
It can check offensive Moth sets especially with anti Electric ability. Can also sponge other special attackers like Pixi STail, Latios, or the apparently 100% winrate Inteleon etc. This could help with RegenVest dependency and open up possibilities.
Prevents offensive Tusk from running away, particularly valuable with the intrinsic Ground immunity with recovery.
With the proper spectrum investment and maybe ability, can phaze various setup attackers like TG Mana, SD Chomp, CM wincons.
And in general it can typically live a hit from a lot of things to serve as a potential blanket emergency backup answer. Its also decently fast for defensive purposes, so it can outspeed some stuff to not take a second hit, similar to STail.
I will also list a counterargument that has been brought up before on discord and I think is reasonable
Lugia picks and chooses its counters making it a high variance matchup mon
This is a valid point. Just like how it can customize what it can check for the team, it is able to pick what it wants to have a better matchup into. If it runs like Purifying Salt it could maybe swing the matchup against Gholdengo, Fluffy for Dark-types, Volt Absorb/Delta Stream for Zapdos, or even sets like MGLO s/o DFM for special walls. Its similar to Gholdengo with its various abilities it can run. But in the same comparison, Gholdengo comfortably survived the recent suspect test and has much greater variety in offensive sets and more threatening (making it more punishing to read the ability wrong). And I think this is something that is hard to evaluate on paper, because it is also easy to argue on paper that teams can naturally have multiple forms of counterplay.
Lastly
I don't see significant harm in conducting a suspect test
An unban suspect allows the element to be allowed and tested on ladder for its duration. Even if you find my arguments above to be disingenuous or such, I think its fair to suggest that Lugia is definitely not clear cut banworthy, and so the best way to find out would be to actually see it in action. While not the same meta, we've seen previously feared elements end up proving completely balanced (MnM Dragapult, Rusted Sword, both with ~90% unban votes, or GG Gholdengo, and these all actually once were in the meta and got banned, unlike Lugia who never had a chance). Under the assumption that the AAA playerbase makes logical votes (which seems true), then if it ends up being overbearing people will vote ban (with precedent, AAA Annihilape) and vice versa. I think there is minimal harm in trying out the suspect test, and a test also helps boost ladder plays and interest, good stuff all around.