• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Rejected Impact of Tera Blast ban in OU on lower tiers

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don’t know my specifics and mechanics but as someone who plays all the lower tiers I liked the freezes

Yes ambipom had an uptick in interest but it’s definitionally a PU mon that’s important to the Meta, esp since NU will prob not use it as much with stuff like guno banned and will drop

The same can be said about woch which sees fluctuating usage in NU and ru as well

Ninetales would be UU purely because of light clay in a gimmicky role. Meanwhile in PU it has legitimate usages in specs or NP sets om offense. Plus, As soon as UU nerfs screens directly or indirectly it will drop back to PU.

The only exception is probably gardevoir who has become a stable in UU and wouldn’t drop most likely, though I’m sure RU is happy about keeping it since it’s a good anti cheese mon

I understand the argument for unfreezing - but I think continuing freezing is better. As for BL, it would make sense to me that they can rise to the tier, and then drop back to BL if they drop in usage. Having a mon in BL that has become meta stable is not accurate imo
 
Tuthur said:
this is the sign higher-ups have given up on tiering actively SV
Tuthur said:
Inactive council and tier leaders are what we should tackle right now, instead of comforting the false narrative that it is too late in the generation to have actual tiering
Agree with this sentiment entirely and want to bring up the below in further support of this
Mareep said:
I personally don't hate the idea of having councils more involved in approving/vetoing potential tier shifts but council members are also pretty bad sometimes which is why you get stuff like RE: Council Member Expectations & Accountability and general disdain from communities at how their respective councils just aren't in tune with the player base. Probably best to circle back to that at some point and see if both of these can be addressed in tandem
The Council Member Expectations & Accountability thread that was brought up in December of 2024 accomplished nothing with respect to making active improvements to an obviously flawed system. I think freezing tiering is fundamentally opposed to what low tiers are about - shifting metagames that inherently have some chaos to them, even at the risk of being flawed because of stuff like individual usage skewing actual statistics used to generate rises and drops. We all know how NU ladder hero Uberfiend spammed a bunch of low viability stuff and "ruined" PU for a while, along with bots in OU affecting usage as well by spamming triple weather teams and the likes, but the solution should not have been to simply freeze rises all together.

I do not think a system that solely relies on council members determining tiering actions is good, nor do I think one that only uses ladder usage stats is effective, either. Some sort of tiering council that can review ladder activity, look for obvious statistical anomalies, and use viability rankings and community input to make decisions would be difficult to implement and maintain but likely lead to more realistic outcomes and promote lower tier stability, at least to the extent that lower tiers should be "stable".

Freezing rises during current gen feels like a shortsighted decision in response to some public disdain for things that were entirely preventable. Maybe there is some behind the scenes effort to have a more rigid system for the upcoming gen, but the current system clearly fails on a lot of levels and attempts to address the councils that could maybe do something about these issues fell flat much earlier in the gen when people cared more, so who's to say what happens moving forward.
 
Tuthur said:
While last gen, the decision to freeze tiers was taken to avoid having to tier SS during SV. The current decision is to avoid having to tier SV during SV
You still were tiering SS during SV, even after two frozen shifts. Perrserker’s suspect test lasted until after the Generation ended. Heat Rock’s suspect was in late 2025 and had a nearly 50-50 split that ended up with a controversial DNB result, and this case wasn’t helped by being decided after the Generation’s conclusion. SS PU ran suspects in its tours this year because people are still discussing whether or not the tier is in a good state, and the hard end for the Generation has clearly made that process more difficult. These are evidential examples that last Generation’s freeze didn’t even happen early enough for the tiers that should have most benefitted from it if the goal is to making it so tiering doesn’t need to spill into future Generations.
 
missangelic said:
You still were tiering SS during SV, even after two frozen shifts. Perrserker’s suspect test lasted until after the Generation ended. Heat Rock’s suspect was in late 2025 and had a nearly 50-50 split that ended up with a controversial DNB result, and this case wasn’t helped by being decided after the Generation’s conclusion. SS PU ran suspects in its tours this year because people are still discussing whether or not the tier is in a good state, and the hard end for the Generation has clearly made that process more difficult. These are evidential examples that last Generation’s freeze didn’t even happen early enough for the tiers that should have most benefitted from it if the goal is to making it so tiering doesn’t need to spill into future Generations.
I appreciate you wanting to keep rises frozen as an opinion though I disagree, but you are making tremendous unsupported leaps with some of these arguments. Saying that the freeze did not happen soon enough, and then trying to tie suspect tests to this specific causal factor, is not an honest argument. Heat Rock was obviously not rising. And people do suspect tours for tiers as low as ADV or ORAS - it has nothing to do with not freezing tiers earlier, and there’s no data that supports an earlier freeze would have prevented these suspect tests.

This further ties in to what Mareep was saying in that if you don’t actually fix the root issue, no amount of tier freeze gymnastics is going to fix it.
 
I will speak as my approach as a council member for RU:

I was one of the people in the RU cord who was strongly for freezing the rises. If you follow RU you know that the tier suffered greatly from rises. We lose our best scarfer and a lot of top tier defensive pieces as they rose to OU like Gweezing and Moltres or UU like Cobalium, Hippo and Talonflame.
These losses which happened every shift made the tier very unstable as it made the tier prone to extreme playstyles like HO in general being ultra dominant.
We these rises we also lost most of our hazard control making the tier extremely focused on boots spam or just accepting stack hazard is ultra dominant.

With rises being frozen. We could let the meta settle and make the decisions that we belived would bring the tier to a better shape. People in the RU discord have expressed in general that the tier is in a good state besides some people saying sun is too dominante.

If we defreeze rises, we will lose Gardevoir which is one of the core pieces against sun with scarf Trace. We haven't gotten any significant defensive or anti offense pieces in months.

Of course I understand the arguments that we need to show mons in the builder that actually represent the tier. However, we also have the opposite problem where for example Forretress has 9% usage in general and is very used yet is considered a trash mon considered between C/ D tier in viability. I feel like usage based tiering doesn't reflect what's actually viable in a tier. I do agree with the sentiment that something should be done but I don't think this is the way.

Unfortunately I don't have a solution for the tiering problem.

Hope this can resonate with other people as well and I'm open to a debate.

Have a good day folks.
 
For what it's worth, I'm on team unfreeze rises for all the reasons Django stated - banning Tera Blast was a sizeable meta shakeup, and there's enough time in the generation for things to settle after allowing rises. I would favor mons being accurately represented by the tiers they actually get usage in over some hand-wavey concept of 'stability' (that drops can just as easily disrupt). Lower tiers have and always will adapt to mons rising out of them, it's not the end of the world.

If it's still on the table, the idea of decoupled rise and drop thresholds would also be an interesting solution that would curb the yo-yo effect of mons that exist on the border of the usage cutoff.
 
As another member of RU council, I have to admit I'm also on team unfreeze rises. This decision was made with Champions in mind originally, and then champions turned out to be a wet fart of a video game with a ladder that hits numbers I wouldn't dare consider decent. Suffice to say, much of the attention remains on SV, contrary to expectations. This alone facilitates enough reason to relook into this decision.

Personally, much like Django mentioned in his sidenote, I too have become quite soured with usage based tiering. I thin k its good for tiers with enough activity, but having our system and tiers enjoyment factor being beaten down by the interest and it must be said, competence, of the players in question laddering all the time is truly asinine. Forretress at 10% usage or so or HIGHER while hugging D tier and C tier the entirety of DLC2 is stupid, and deprives NU of potential quality removal. This applies elsewhere as well. While people complain about rises screwing the balance of tiers, truthfully like tuthur said alot of it can be attributed to extremely slow action on problematic elements. RU for awhile aquired quite the backlog of problems for a bit, which came to a head when we slated Gyara Volcanion and Mamoswine after a shift. Still stand by this decision by the way, but this was also a skill issue that should've been dealt with earlier.

I will say for RU specifically, tera blast ban did a genuine miracle for the tiers stability. By far the lower tier impacted the most, and its ban relieved pressure from PZ, Entei, Torterra and more while letting Comfey and Yanmega back, with Yanmega quickly becoming a top-end wallbreaker with set variety. Beyond that, I'll admit the changes are somewhat muted. UU freed nothing and not a whole lot used tera blast religiously. NU was affected a little, Raikou went from aight to dogshit within a day. PU freed Frosmoth after a suspect concluded of its own. Aaand then immediately dropped to ZU. (Frankly it shouldn't have, if Comfey was forbidden from dropping, Frosmoth should've been aswell.)

I'm rambling so let me paraphrase a bit with a TLDR. Free rises for BL Pokemon toute suite. There is zero justifiable reason not to, in my opinion. As for full rises, free them too. Also allow councils to forcechoke their trash down the wrung if we don't unfreeze. I think it was a good decision for a spell, but it was also quite hasty and with the presumption champions wouldn't be outright dogshit. That did not come to pass. Also yeah as I said, let council send specific trash down. If I have to stare at RU Forretress mucking up my teambuilder for the whole gen imma be seen on national news.
 
I probably missed something since I'm typing this at 1am in the morning but I prob ain't writing it without being sleep deprived lol.

I think freezing rises was possibly the single best thing for lower tiers in like, forever, and honestly agree with miss that they if anything, were not early enough. People talk about "4+ shifts left" but frankly put, every time a shift occured, a lower tier would be ripped of a very important staple that usually would lead to a lot of tiering needed. Usually this was RU and PU getting fucked, but there is nothing to say UU/NU would either. This also would not always be the mons that were actually representative of the tiers. NU still hoards braviary because a few ladder players spam it (one of which is infamous for using it), NU took arcanine for reasons? (even if I am an arcanine believer it is not an NU mon in the slightest) UU took talon while it was currently UR (yes, I know it rose to B rank but that was very much after the rise and ATP it rose it was not seen to be generally great). We have seen this throughout the gen (gallade and a bunch of mons rose to UU cause somebody spammed a team so much, zorua hisui rose to NU in early SV etc). Frankly put, rises have not been because a mon 'deserves' to be in a tier, its sometimes has been, but a good chunk of the time, it was just up to the whimsy of ladder to pull a glue mon from a lower because it looked cool or something. Lets dispel the notion that rises are actually making tiers representative of the mons that are good in them, they are not and there is copious amounts of evidence.
You could rise the BL mons to the actual tiers, but a good amount of the time BL's are discussed to be dropped to said tier below (RU has discussed this a lot recently while PU also has), so rising them to said tier just takes away agency from lower tiers. Maybe once SV is done you can do that moreso, but rn i think thats a big no go, taking away any tiers agency just feels wrong when tiers usually already are at the peril of higher ones.
Django said:
So, looking at the above, we see a large number of mons which are ranking highly on the tiers they should be rising to VRs, as well as getting usage way above the 4.52% cutoff. Some of course are much closer to the cutoff, but there is a real variety here. I also think it's worth pointing out that these types of rises are not metagame defining in the way previous rises were (e.g. Talonflame and Hippowdown rising from RU to UU). What we're seeing here is mons shifting with metagames as we get closer to tiers which are more stable. The tops of the tiers are staying relatively the same, and middling usage mons are shifting around as niches are discovered and solidified.
This last part about "not metagame defining rises" is just, so untrue. Garde is a MASSIVE part of the RU metagame, helping keep a lot of cheese in check like weather and such and just generally being an excellent pokemon. Ambipom is another great anti cheese pokemon for PU since fake out prevents a lot of cheesier playstyles from being great, its why partly in general HO has been on the tamer side in PU i would say. Wo-chien is a great Pokemon in PU, one of which is a great softcheck to a lot of things like Bruxish, Hoopa, Rhydon etc. ZU literally loses both of its S tiers, you cannot get more impactful then that LOL, while also losing a very good offensive pokemon in Whimsicott. This leaves Alolan Ninetales (between mediocre and meh in the tiers its in), Grimmsnarl (B+ in PU so again, not shabby) and Brute Bonnet (who is A- in ZU so not exactly a slouch either). We can also see that some of these are just, not really great in these tiers? Grimm is B- in NU and while it has been used at top tour level, calling it "representative of the meta" would just feel wrong. Whimsicott is C+, which is reaching shitmon territory.

But to answer the questions asked:
Django said:
  1. Do the results we see above make sense to you? Should we be blocking these rises?
  2. Are we optimising for the right metric at the right point in the generation e.g. stability over all else with 4+ tier shifts left
  3. If the answer to either of the above is "no" - what is the solution?
  4. If the answer to 1 or 2 is "yes" - why? Do we need to change anything outside of the tiering system to handle the change in accuracy and consistency?
1. We should be blocking these rises yes. Firstly, we have already had a frozen shift, so going back on it I feel would just be a weird thing to do. Secondly, is there truly a bad thing to blocking rises that comes from it? People talk about it being confusing to newcomers, but we have allowed pokemon who are not good pokemon in said tiers to stay there (azu in UU, forre in RU, braviary/avalugg in NU, coalossal in PU), which is just as confusing. If we allow pokemon to stay in tiers that they do not actually belong in, then saying about it being confusing for newcomers to get into lower tiers IDG.
2. Yes, stability is a very important thing to do. As I stated above, 4+ shifts seems like a lot, but it is not enough time to deal with considering that every rises forces a tier to majorly change and thus impacts a lower tier. Garde rising to UU for instance, would force RU to take other scarfers/anti cheese mons from NU (lets say for example, flamigo rises from this), making a series of events that by the time all the shifts are done, the lower tiers are not stable going into gen 10. People state that "well this is the fault of lower tier councils not being active" and while I do agree with that, lets be real for a moment? IDT much is going to change in that department. As listed in this thread, there was a thread to do that and nothing came out of it.
4. The reason why as explained is simple, promoting stability in tiers. But what we need to change is quite a few things. IDT any of these can be implemented current gen, since they would be too large of changes.
Firstly, make sure pokemon that are not good in a tier can be forced dropped. This could be something like: If x mon is C tier and below for 3 consecutive VR shifts OR 6 months of being in the tier (whichever comes first I think? Could do whichever comes last maybe but idk, first seems better), then it is forced dropped. This ensures that said pokemon is flat out bad, if something is hovering between C+ and C or B- and then falls to C for a bit before it rises up again, then it might be just a phase of it being considered bad. Ofc this does require VR councils to be vetted more to make sure people won't try to force drop something, but honestly making sure VR councils are better is a side benefit.
Secondly, if X pokemon is C/UR when it would rise, it is veto'd to rise. This would make sure braviary and shit doesnt rise because people want to spam it. God knows that we all remember the SS hitmontop incident right?
Also adding the aformentioned "councils should be more active", because honestly its something that should be done but IDT its going to actually happen.

Overall, I do not see a reason to unfreeze rises. They are very beneficial to tiers and a lot of the arguements against them feel not worth it. Yes, I like having the mon being represented in the tier it actually is, but if it is at the cost of metagame health? Shit, i will take Mesprit having Z in its tier placement over P any day of the week.
 
missangelic said:
You still were tiering SS during SV, even after two frozen shifts. Perrserker’s suspect test lasted until after the Generation ended. Heat Rock’s suspect was in late 2025 and had a nearly 50-50 split that ended up with a controversial DNB result, and this case wasn’t helped by being decided after the Generation’s conclusion. SS PU ran suspects in its tours this year because people are still discussing whether or not the tier is in a good state, and the hard end for the Generation has clearly made that process more difficult. These are evidential examples that last Generation’s freeze didn’t even happen early enough for the tiers that should have most benefitted from it if the goal is to making it so tiering doesn’t need to spill into future Generations.
Heatranator said:
I think freezing rises was possibly the single best thing for lower tiers in like, forever, and honestly agree with miss that they if anything, were not early enough. People talk about "4+ shifts left" but frankly put, every time a shift occured, a lower tier would be ripped of a very important staple that usually would lead to a lot of tiering needed. Usually this was RU and PU getting fucked, but there is nothing to say UU/NU would either.

...

Frankly put, rises have not been because a mon 'deserves' to be in a tier, its sometimes has been, but a good chunk of the time, it was just up to the whimsy of ladder to pull a glue mon from a lower because it looked cool or something. Lets dispel the notion that rises are actually making tiers representative of the mons that are good in them, they are not and there is copious amounts of evidence.
You could rise the BL mons to the actual tiers, but a good amount of the time BL's are discussed to be dropped to said tier below (RU has discussed this a lot recently while PU also has), so rising them to said tier just takes away agency from lower tiers. Maybe once SV is done you can do that moreso, but rn i think thats a big no go, taking away any tiers agency just feels wrong when tiers usually already are at the peril of higher ones.


But to answer the questions asked:
2. Yes, stability is a very important thing to do. As I stated above, 4+ shifts seems like a lot, but it is not enough time to deal with considering that every rises forces a tier to majorly change and thus impacts a lower tier. Garde rising to UU for instance, would force RU to take other scarfers/anti cheese mons from NU (lets say for example, flamigo rises from this), making a series of events that by the time all the shifts are done, the lower tiers are not stable going into gen 10.

I think these points (and others throughout the thread) point to a general opinion that rises (and thus usage based tiering) are flat out bad. The debate can basically be summed up as one side wanting to prioritise stability without concern for the negative outcomes associated with it (do VR based tiering), and the other wanting to prioritise correctness without concern for the negative impact on lower tiers (do usage based tiering). There's a fundamental philosophical difference here which I don't think is getting resolved, but I will say that I find it baffling to choose to play and engage as a lower tier community and not embrace the constant change associated with it. That is quite literally the most appealing part of playing these tiers - stability can be found in many other metagames, usage based lower tiers are not the place to play if that's what you want.

One last question because I don't think the debate is going anywhere useful: Over the last few years, NU has lost (just to cherry pick a few): Slowbro, Registeel, Talonflame, Umbreon, Krookodile, Magnezone, Noivern, Thundurus. All hugely metgame defining. Using all the same logic we should have frozen rises before all of these happened, in order to preserve NUs stability. Why do it now and not before all of these changes happened? What's the difference? The change we've made is arbitrary and too early, and will cause issues further down the line as SV continues to evolve.

Also, quite frankly, impact on ZU and below should not really be considered in this discussion. They are not governed by the tiering framework (even if they choose to follow it). The framework and system wasn't designed to support 5+ usage based tiers and this is probably where a huge amount of complaints about the vacuum affect comes from. I sympathise with the issues, but changing policy that adversly affects RU / NU etc (officially supported tiers) based on impact on ZU and below doesn't make sense.
 
Django said:
That is quite literally the most appealing part of playing these tiers - stability can be found in many other metagames, usage based lower tiers are not the place to play if that's what you want.
I think it's more appealing if it was early in the generation where there is a lot of uncertainty about what is going to happen to the OU metagame (and thus reverberating changes are to be expected and that is what makes early gen lower tiers fun), but I don't think OU has much uncertainty about its tiering much now so lower tiers should not have to be as accepting of constant and largely uncontrollable metagame upheaval for lack of better phrasing as OU's tiering slows down. So when offered the opportunity late in the gen to insure metagame stability or at least grant further control on how shifts impact a tier, I think I would always accept such an offer since that would allow the playerbase to develop the tiers for longer without upheaval so they can enjoy the fruits of their labor when it becomes a post-gen. This is kinda why I appreciated the "middle ground" concept of raising and lowering the bar for rises & drops respectively and creating a buffer zone of sorts but that idea was shot down near immediately in the past thread so :(.

click for pipe dream tiering take
So most people should know that after every lower tier gets their tier shifts in post dlc releases, the system switches from 1 month to 3 month shifts. What if we continued this process to do something like from 3 month to 6 month, and then possibly to 6 month to 12 month if we're feeling really committed? Hypothetically could this mitigate the issue missangelic has brought up of lower tiers getting gutted harder by shifts the lower down the rung we go while offering longer periods of stability for suffering metas like RU? For a future gen ofc not current gen SV.

But in summary I think that the reward for investing in a tier for 3 months is not substantial and I think having a better returns on time investment is better for all parties involved regardless of potential identity issues of a poke being Whateverused BL instead of WhogafUsed proper. 1 month tier shifts makes this claim of "constant change is the point" stick better which is why I do in fact like early gen low tiers, 3 month shifts just get more annoying (and more impactful especially in terms of rises) as time progresses though.

As for Tera Blast ban in low tiers, it's not really something that impacts the humble untier player such as myself, but I think if the state of ladders are hypothetically going to keep deteriorating and get less active then it's probably worth it to commit to freezing rises (or just tier shifts in general). Say we unpause it now, there would be 2 shifts by 2027, and if the November release date is to be believed 3 more shifts in 2027. And assuming you pause rises again for the last two shifts, you would only have done 3 shifts in total. Is that worth the hassle of unpausing rises? Up to interpretation, not mine though I'm just throwing the question out there.
 
Runo said:
Say we unpause it now, there would be 2 shifts by 2027, and if the November release date is to be believed 3 more shifts in 2027. And assuming you pause rises again for the last two shifts, you would only have done 3 shifts in total. Is that worth the hassle of unpausing rises? Up to interpretation, not mine though I'm just throwing the question out there.

I believe that, generally, people are not saying to completely unfreeze rises for the rest of the generation or even up to the last two tier shifts. Just unfreeze them for now given Gen 10 is over a year away. Me personally, I think having just one more shift on January 1st to allow rises will help keep the tiers more accurate and then can resume the freeze after.

As for the rest of this post, I generally agree with a lot of the principles in it. I always thought that you could have rises be earned by consecutive shifts at above the threshold instead of just one 3 month period above it. Doesn't require any different thresholds and doesn't require any freezing, it just truly makes the rises more earned and, given it has to be consecutive shifts, it makes them less frequent since it requires at least 6 months for them to rise. That probably fixes many of the issues with the tier shifts system while still preserving the identity of the system as a whole.
 
Runo said:
I don't think OU has much uncertainty about its tiering much now
Tera blast was banned in the middle of the most recent shift, and we're seeing huge mons like Tyranitar and Heatran drop out of OU. We're also seeing mons like Cresselia rise up to A on the OU viability ranks. Even while actual tiering action looks minimal, we've just had maybe the biggest piece of tiering action of the generation, and the meta is changing significantly outside of tiering action.

Runo said:
click for pipe dream tiering take
So most people should know that after every lower tier gets their tier shifts in post dlc releases, the system switches from 1 month to 3 month shifts. What if we continued this process to do something like from 3 month to 6 month, and then possibly to 6 month to 12 month if we're feeling really committed? Hypothetically could this mitigate the issue missangelic has brought up of lower tiers getting gutted harder by shifts the lower down the rung we go while offering longer periods of stability for suffering metas like RU? For a future gen ofc not current gen SV.
I think this would be an interesting option, but to a degree it delays the inevitable. If our goal is to reach a stable state by the end of the generation, then waiting longer to rise a mon leaves less time for the other tiers to respond. If anything, following something like the Tera Blast ban with a few 1 month shifts in a row to see how things shake out might lead to more stable tiers more quickly. Short term there would be a lot of upheaval but it would leave more time on the other side to take any tiering action on "accurate" tiers.
 
The timing of the freeze on rises feels appropriate. Assuming Generation 10 releases in Fall 2027 and after October 1st, 2027, that leaves five more major tier shifts for the following to happen:
:dragonite::volcarona:
OU's ladder metagame gets 3 months from July 2026 to the end of September 2026 to settle following the ban of Tera Blast and test of Volcarona. The imprint of that settled ladder metagame then affects UU in October 2026 without taking anything, then moves to RU in January 2027, NU in April 2027, and PU in July 2027, and out of PU by October 2027, which gets it out of the way just before Wind and Waves release.
:porygon-z::garchomp::serperior:
On the Tera Blast ban as justification for halting/delaying/reduxing/whatevering the freeze on rises: It's very easy to identify correlations between the Tera Blast ban and declines in usage for its biggest users, such as Porygon-Z in RU: I've already done a post on that. The problem is that it's very difficult to prove how, let alone explain how much, the Tera Blast ban plays into any Pokemon's rise in usage. For the most part, these seem more to be related to the direct metagame trends they were already part of. For example, the only averted rise to OU this cycle was Garchomp, which was actually a significant Tera Blast user in April 2026 that didn't actually didn't break 4.52% usage until May, which was after Tera Blast was banned. Garchomp wasn't the only significant Tera Blast user, let alone averted rise, with this paradoxical relationship to Tera Blast either. Serperior, currently RUBL and a major Tera Blast user in April, only started picking up in usage in UU after Tera Blast got banned, and it didn't even break 4.52% usage in May. These are Pokemon that ran Tera Blast too, so they're easier to track, so how do you track how Tera Blast's ban influenced trending Pokemon that weren't even running it to a significant extent, especially when some Pokemon that ran it actually went up in usage? Knowing that there's no easy way to link the Tera Blast ban to rising trends and that the averted rises that used Tera Blast still trended regardless of the ban, the argument that the freeze on rises should be lifted or changed following the Tera Blast ban in order to recognize rising trends caused by its removal is very hard to back with evidence.
:guzzlord:
I see a lot of people wanting exceptions to the freeze on rises for BL Pokemon, which I get: there's the notion that BLs moving up wouldn't affect lower tiers, and it's easy to pity the BLs when they're stuck, especially when there's as charismatic as favemon Garchomp. However, taking from a BL still does have an impact on lower tiers. One example of why it would be a mistake to exempt BLs from the freeze on rises is the ongoing retest of Guzzlord from PUBL. Guzzlord would have moved from PUBL to NU in the last shift of SS, denying PU the opportunity to retest it and make it a potentially positive re-addition to its metagame. Aside from what I've already described how lower tiers should not decide the tierlist of higher tiers through their tiering actions, this would also make it so that any council that wants to temporarily ban anything during the frozen rises period would actually be unable to retest it. Effectively, this would just take away opportunities for councils and communities to change their minds about bans just because they said banned Pokemon trended in a higher tier for whatever reason. With this Generation being one where we have the opportunity to allow for drops to trickle back down and alleviate the strain the tier vacuum exerted, I think rising BLs would also be a poor exception to make, especially when there's been Tera Blast-related bans this Generation.

I recognize there are those who aren't totally pleased with the policy freezing rises, and it wasn't entirely satisfying to me either. In the OP I wrote in the PR thread that led to the freeze on rises, I explicitly said that I didn't think the freeze was enough of a change. In that same post, I went on to suggest decoupling the threshold for rises and drops (which was shut down), a suggestion that Django echoes in this thread, which I wanted as a compromise for people (like myself) who do want there to be some way for the usage-based system to reflect staple-levels of usage without the constant yo-yoing of staples. My reformist points in that discussion weren't taken up by those in charge of usage-based tiering when they turned that thread from a discussion into an implemented policy and closed it, so I'm seeking the next best thing and aiming to suggest reforms for next Generation. I've considered Runo's suggestion of longer shifts before and like what's outlined, and I would be interested in seeing something like it for the next Generation, especially now that we've seen the lifespan for Generation 9 was a lot longer than Generation 8 and how declines in activity leads to more skew over time. Ultimately, I still think the freeze on rises for Generation 9 is better than an alternative of having no guardrail, especially after having considered the impact Tera Blast's ban on OU and lower tiers.
 
Tuthur said:
While last gen, the decision to freeze tiers was taken to avoid having to tier SS during SV. The current decision is to avoid having to tier SV during SV; this is the sign higher-ups have given up on tiering actively SV. Lower tier communities shouldn't be rotting, while waiting for WW release.

BigFatMantis said:
As for the rest of this post, I generally agree with a lot of the principles in it. I always thought that you could have rises be earned by consecutive shifts at above the threshold instead of just one 3 month period above it. Doesn't require any different thresholds and doesn't require any freezing, it just truly makes the rises more earned and, given it has to be consecutive shifts, it makes them less frequent since it requires at least 6 months for them to rise. That probably fixes many of the issues with the tier shifts system while still preserving the identity of the system as a whole.

I agree with Tuthur in that freezing rises this early is doing lower tiers a disservice, and it should be on lower-tier Councils to manage tiering issues in a timely fashion instead of requiring 2 quickbans midway through the generation as was the case for Gyarados and Volcanion in RU. If lower-tier Councils can't proactively handle tiering issues as the leaders of their respective tiers, it's just not a good idea to do VR-based tiering as it'd be very subjective and and based on the input of an extremely small number of people with the number decreasing as you go further and further down, which increases barriers to the accessibility of Smogon's tiers.

I believe BigFatMantis has made the best proposal I've seen so far about reducing the volatility of rises. If one believes the function of usage-based tiering is to ensure, for the most part, that the Pokemon that deserve to be in the tier end up there, but one also cares about the volatility and stability of lower tiers, making it so that individual Pokemon need to have OU-level usage in OU for two consecutive tiering cycles (6 months rather than 3) is intuitive even if it slightly increases the complexity of the system given the playerbase would ideally want the mons with consistent usage in OU to be officially OU (UU, RU, NU, PU, etc.).

I have always been against the idea of completely decoupling rises and drops with separate thresholds for rises and drops, but as BigFatMantis said, requiring two consecutive tiering cycles with the required level of usage for a respective tier makes rises less common and more earned while preserving Smogon's usage-based tiering system without resorting to a smaller and smaller group of people (VR-based tiering) deciding which Pokemon should be in which tier, increasing the subjectivity of tiering the further removed from OU you are due to there being less activity from lower-tier playerbases.

While I won't argue Smogon is shrinking (I don't know whether traffic across Smogon during the SV years is down compared to the SS years), one can make the case Smogon's community's seen some fragmentation given there are players who mostly play SV OU, players who mostly play NatDex tiers, players who mostly play lower tiers, those who only play old generations, those who mainly play other formats, and those who do a combination of these things, and I believe this is a reason to continue usage-based tiering with the fix BigFatMantis suggested being the best idea given it maintains what Smogon has while addressing one of its biggest issues.

The Tera Blast ban is clearly a big enough shift affecting the viability of many mons in each other to warrant the unfreezing of rises. And if you really want to freeze rises, I'd argue that doing so after the October 1, 2026 or the January 1, 2027 tier shift (as TheBigFatMantis mentioned) is a better idea given freezing rises so soon after Tera Blast's ban doesn't really make much intuitive sense given how that's a big shift to many metas, and Smogon should be doing its due diligence in making its tiers as accurate as they should be.
 
Last edited:
Since Tera Blast's ban has not been meaningfully linked to significant rises in Pokemon that would justify undoing the freeze, I'd like to talk about something that actually has a material impact on tier shifts and validity: ladder activity declines, and especially how Champions's release is already correlated with a decline in Smogon format ladder activity and accelerating the Generational fatigue.
SV Usage
SVOUUURUNUPUZU
November 20222531335N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
December 20223385255392966N/AN/AN/AN/A
January 20232188410245804222573N/AN/AN/A
February 2023146628413592265976146054N/AN/A
March 202315116561302074752241764112746N/A
April 2023119452914647241054322714203534823
May 2023128263115300240461297553409415242
June 20231999363791432602518292234689786
July 202313369742046963317026589276486678
August 202312502141309738198026368293577505
September 202319120751209224220533514291637031
October 202317091123145686780353886651968304
November 2023133948220081196806530737093012418
December 202318622501186004938047103387667887
January 202418809682332377057866430683298109
February 20241410738158837127332529715351913675
March 2024133008416871474054962145412914450
April 2024116382913227658840675107946816229
May 20245323785565726460288652468012228
June 202410333129531046265434664608716703
July 2024106487211338348449563844431716250
August 2024114100811418551901410014298316869
September 2024109346310894045932318644098615030
October 2024113791212248855518335373813413928
November 202499561210071847403264033574712930
December 20241005497851264300627067299879597
January 202510866369011048304319683663315323
February 202510063159550047152292823107111903
March 2025125320611538555224321293327512562
April 2025113705811272761386306373910113878
May 2025111716011448468728324423415516464
June 202510095938792053776234223303512631
July 202511039888600054139316982931215632
August 202511231268846145580252862530114627
September 202510927788444642165235762419013297
October 202510858818430743728271872635110513
November 2025933115670363396718110201266989
December 2025935985600093082415722174867578
January 202610509037330240352190382057710901
February 20261034254750853734218116187059236
March 202612891209016546115232692017810732
April 202611354868660844659234422326015149
May 2026942140595153295813781189049576
June 2026767456507532270914969157957694
SS Usage
SSOUUURUNUPUZU
November 20191291782N/AN/AN/AN/AN/A
December 20192647791371449N/AN/AN/AN/A
January 20201780471243818174112N/AN/AN/A
February 2020171664914204362011107885N/AN/A
March 20201622850188997617044742287542N/A
April 20201550124190969778895562564043N/A
May 2020144335916803086222456104888916408
June 2020193305313999463444634444018010662
July 202017916732549676724141264590457229
August 2020166162817921492073424764327111132
September 202012728861443576616345567404956969
October 202018284811193675257235377411425720
November 20202332407263186143499585325194913064
December 2020191341319584791162928227939312713
January 2021180416916265282373589497743422508
February 2021148510413597770582444996057921060
March 2021162808115931783701538506921420573
April 2021139822312808469677480596347817918
May 2021134573112507166778508895918318040
June 2021133673911630661860501195513413514
July 2021155843313429873809460405779816812
August 2021150686214354475321447456700422369
September 2021146736712679065955424246225214614
October 2021154131115468972397538926191515673
November 2021129020410794152627399415355613618
December 20211042648831383994926689405938000
January 20221024667753954173928684397059953
February 202210920718353041955358824040210061
March 2022141526811850956953432865292512114
April 2022138503013298959652529126133212685
May 2022143041312884863205492796004913068
June 2022146662411131056608441605650312585
July 2022154007612203654989450995498913541
August 2022169390212076354676450996513211869
September 2022161345512525461618436756360316223
October 2022157404412878161512377715862117108
November 2022949815717673219123264366409409
These numbers can speak for themselves, but I'll still interpret. Putting aside that SS overall saw greater usage than SV from their debut for 3 years, SV's numbers have dropped even further as its life cycle has worn on. Since we are only interested in the stable periods of both Generations for this discussion, I'm going to focus just on their stable periods of DLC2 tiering.

From April 2021, the first month after a 3-month tier shift of SS, to October 2022, the last full month of SS, the number of OU games played per month remained between ~1.0 million and ~1.7 million, with an average of ~1.4 million games played per month. There was a decline in games played between November 2021 and February 2022 (BDSP's impact, which would motivate the freeze in that Generation), but the number of games actually recovered in March 2022 and did not go below ~1.4 million for the rest of the Generation. These trends are unsurprisingly matched by lower tiers. Contrary to the catastrophizing about a rise freeze killing activity, SS actually kept its same average activity level of its DLC2 era through its frozen period. Even in their last 4 months of usage, OU and lower tiers generally saw the same (sometimes greater!) amount of usage they'd had during the stable period.

From July 2024, the first month after a 3-month tier shift of SV, to the most recent month of June 2026, the number of OU games played per month stayed between ~0.8 million games and ~1.3 million games, with an average of ~1.1 million games. Unlike SS, the decline is happening now, predictably falling off from 1.1 million games in April (which had the Tera Blast suspect test) to 942k games in May 2026 (which had the Volcarona suspect test) and further to its Generational lowest, if not lowest ever, 767k games in June 2026. As expected, lower tiers are seeing parallel declines to OU: UU has gone from 113k games played in July 2024 to 51k games played in June 2026, RU has dropped from 48k to 23k, NU from 56k to 15k, PU from 44k to 16k, and ZU from 16k to 8k. Nearly every lower tier ladder has overseen over a 50% decline just in the stable DLC2 period. The last three months have been the lowest point, but this pattern was already identifiable before the freeze on rises, let alone the Tera Blast suspect, was even announced.

As I've mentioned in this post and posts before, BDSP's release bruised the activity of SS for about 3-4 months, but SS ladders actually ended up recovering and ending strong. However, Champions is an entirely different game from BDSP, one that is actually featured in VGC and saw more Regulation M-B ladder games last month than SV OU games. Champions already reached 10 million downloads by June 25th, and its release date on mobile was just June 17th. One of its producers has stated that they plan for Champions to be a long-term product, and it's not hard to see how that's going to be the case when it received what was basically a new content drop just 2 months after its release. Champions is not going to be like BDSP where the problem of it divesting from usage is going to naturally go away as the new toy syndrome wears off, it's going to reinforce itself through continuous new content and official support.

The unprecedented lifespan and decline of SV were factors that were cited as motivating the freeze this time around. Whether you look at the last 3-6 months or 3 years of usage, activity in SV has numerically and proportionally dropped to a point that the freeze on rises is fit to maintain.
 
Freezing rises for 18+ months of a generation would go down as an all-time tiering failure regardless of SV's obscene length. It's definitely beneficial to preserve a tier's identity and reduce tiering issues at the end of a gen's lifespan, but we aren't even close to that with Smogon committing to waiting for Gen 10 rather than doing anything official with Champions. Shifts are THE core part of lowers and what even makes them exist in the first place. Cutting off rises that early puts an asterisk next to the existence of these tiers, not unlike the ancient old gen lowers of the 2000s. If you disagree with that then I think you simply don't like usage based tiering as it is, which is valid. It'd be far more productive long term for those in favor of keeping rises frozen to focus on how you can improve the tiering system like some have already done in this thread (like Runo or BFM) rather than campaign for having this bandaid solution implemented longer than it should be.
 
I feel like there’s a far more systematic issue at play than rises being frozen or not. The whole reason these freezes happened is bc ladder quality has fallen off a cliff as the gen has gone on and only looks to get worse. Freezing rises is a bandaid solution that, while improving stability, doesn’t address that there are STILL mons that are in tiers they don’t belong in
- Azumarill in UU
- Forretress in RU
- Coalossal in PU
Etc etc

I can understand the sentiment that freezing when there’s so much time left is weird but are we seriously about to put the entire stability of all LTs in the hands of the ladders that already keep mons that don’t belong in tiers in said tiers? Imagine how rough it gets when they gain the ability to actually steal Mons. Does something like gard probably deserve to be UU? Yeah maybe, but that kinda throws a whole wrench in RU if it even happens bc again, ladders are a mess.

I havent rlly been keeping up w cg much at all recently due to a mix of business and just not enjoying it much anymore, but I STRONGLY recommend the LT players advocating for an unfreeze to think a little more about this and how there may be a better way to do this that isn’t just throwing it in the hands of ladders again
 
Tiers will still get drops, there will still be change, and drops are the more motivating changes compared to rises. We have yet to see, but if the last seven months of SS are a good model, activity will not wane because of a freeze on rises, as it clearly didn't kill activity in SS as seen in my post above. Meanwhile, we've been seeing declines in SV ladder activity before the freeze on rises took effect or was even announced.

There have been multiple reactions I've seen in this thread and in lower tiers Discords that have been in bad faith. You won't catch me telling people against the freeze on rises to just go play 35pokes/Champions/[insert tier that has changes] if they want to play something with constant change, so we don't need to hear "if you don't like rises, go play OU/[insert tier that has no change]". The bad faith argument of "you don't like usage-based tiering" can be twisted the other away to "you must not actually like usage-based tiers if you want to keep a system that warps them." The truth is that everyone in this thread who shows up is doing so because they care about the direction of usage-based lower tiers, so we don't need to waste time acting like people we disagree with dislike usage-based tiering or lower tiers.
 
There's an undercurrent of <i want these mons to shift in the way i want, i want these specific shifts to happen and these specific shifts to not happen> in this thread. For every problem the rises freeze is presented as a solution, better, cleaner ways to address them exist. The only reason a 18 month rises freeze is on the table is because this weird bandaid we stumbled our way into is the only way to cherrypick Ambipom to stay in PU, but Avalugg to fall to PU (or whatever equivalent applies to other tiers). Oh, and because this was done historically, but like, historically the reason tiering cutoff was raised is to make rises less frequent but drops more common, so i don't exactly believe that the precedents here are well though-out or whatever.

A longer period over which to do shifts - say six months - can be implemented to alleviate the issue of low ladder activity near the end of the gen. It's something that can be a considered as a rule for future ends-of-generations, or for low activity ladders in general, and this is an alright opportunity to test it out.

But to give councils the time to wrap up their tiers, to deal with remaining problems and finish up all potential tiering action, do suspect tests of the less clear-cut stuff or retest some mons from your BL: the solution to that is to freeze *all* shifts a set time before the end of the generation. I don't know what the ideal amount of time for that is - two, three shifts? six, nine months? but i'm confident that for end-of-gen stability this is the way to go. You don't get any stable end period with drops still going on, drops can throw a wrench into your tiering as much as rises do. The idea the you "just ban" anything bad that drops is beyond naive, so many mons are on the line of "problematic", "unhealthy" where it takes time to realize that tiering action can maybe be helpful, or necessary, and often the metagame just needs to develop a bit before issues arise. Or perhaps they turn out to be okay, and a hasty quickban neccessitated by the lack of time would be a mistake! Potential future drops also can create pressure against doing less urgent suspect tests, and new drops can open doors for resuspects at the very end of the gen after the last shift where there's no time left.

I believe fully freezing shifts 6-9 months before the generation ends deals with most issues outlined here by the freeze-rises crowd - even better than the 18 month rise freeze. It's clean, it's safe. The "i want these shifts but not others" changes i'd hope would be something to do for the next generation, if VR tiering or some hybrids is the way we want to go.
 
There's starting to be more talk about what should happen in the future and how to best handle these issues with some method other than freezing rises early before the end of the generation. I'm interested in the idea that we freeze everything or freeze partially at different times, it is true that as ladder game quantity declines we need to reconsider whether drops or rises are being counted serviceably, and I certainly am in favor of continuing to hold councils and tier leaders to activity expectations.

That being said, we've gone so far into these ideas that I want to briefly return to the decision that kicked this all off to say that PU leadership has been very happy with the impact of freezing rises and does not want to see that changed before the end of the generation. It's meant a lot for creating a good metagame and dodging the constant flip-flopping the tier had been seeing, and the data people have been analyzing from post-freeze months only confirms that the tier would've continued to struggle because of the particular quirks of the NU ladder rather than council activity or some other scapegoat. Even with the Tera Blast ban we see no reason to unfreeze rises now when it's the path we've committed to and it's been having this level of positive impact. I think any considerations made here are important, and we could certainly reconsider percent thresholds or shift timings for next generation, but they should be next generation considerations and we should keep this path for the remainder of SV.
 
Just want to share a few thoughts as the Ubers UU TL, a tier that has been kind of ravaged by shifts recently and is super appreciating the chance to settle down and sort out what is looking to be one of our healthier meta periods for quite a while. (If ZU and SU get to be referenced we do too!)

Django said:
If the data we have from ladder isn't good enough to allow for rises, it also isn't good enough to allow for drops. You can't use that argument one way and not the other - by that logic we should freeze tiers entirely
I don't see the point in this argument as rises and drops are fundamentally different in how they effect a given meta, since rises at their most impactful take important pieces away from a tier and at their least mean that a BL pokemon gets to be designated differently in the teambuilder. Drops on the other hand create oppourtunities for tools a meta has access to to grow, and isn't remotely as impactful on meta stability and health as if councils are active as so many people argue unfreezing rises will promote appropriate tiering action can still be taken on any unhealthy additions. The best case scenario for a drop is improving a meta while the worst case should ideally be a temporary issue. Equivocating the two makes absolutely no sense when people have made it clear that the main issue with ladder data being bad is leading to pokemon unecessarily rising from tiers, but rarely the other way around.

To quote Shiloh's post quoting previous freezes,
Also, the reason we're only targeting rises and not drops (aside from that being the scope of this thread) is that drops are much more within a tier leader's control. You can prevent a broken drop from terrorising a tier via banning it, but can't prevent the rise of a staple to another tier.

I think that there is some justification for unfreezing rises given the Tera Blast ban, and understand that this is not an issue ubers uu faces due to its nature as a tier so I really have no issue with that argument, but the idea that rises and drops are equivalent and "can't be argued one way and not the other" is kind of laughable when the differences between them and the stability and consistency freezing rises gives while still allowing for less disruptive movement is why a decision like this can even happen in the first place.

sugar ovens said:
I believe fully freezing shifts 6-9 months before the generation ends deals with most issues outlined here by the freeze-rises crowd - even better than the 18 month rise freeze. It's clean, it's safe. The "i want these shifts but not others" changes i'd hope would be something to do for the next generation, if VR tiering or some hybrids is the way we want to go.
Reducing the arguments in favour of rise freezes to "i want these shifts but not others" is a pretty reductive way of looking at what the benefits of freezing rises specifically are. I have already elaborated why the difference is notable here but I do think its worth saying that when faced with the issue of reduced activity and the chaos that rises can thrust upon the lower tiers, if we want to uphold as much of the usage based tiering framework as we can while reducing the negative impacts it can have on lower tiers (as activity and interest winds down), meeting in the middle does offer the "best of both worlds" solution. I'd be perfectly happy with a complete freeze, but with the combination of precedent for rise freezes and the amount of time we have left in the generation I will gladly take the oppourtunity for Ubers UU to settle down without the risk of giant meta upsets from rises. I have seen this sentiment reflected by other council members from lower tiers, showing that this isn't just appreciated in tiers that admittedly have not been impacted by the TB ban, and I hope to see the freeze stay.
 
Gonna revive this thread again. Looking at currently slated shifts.. yeah idk. 1 month usage stats should always be taken with a grain of salt, but I think just about everybody can admit that the ladders for lower tiers are just inert. Using it for tiering is not a viable means of tiering, at least not standalone. They simply do not get the numbers they used to during the COVID boom, and pretending otherwise is naïve. I'm gonna throw at least one nod in the air again and hope to get some actual responses from tiering heads. And maybe see if we can get a discussion thread made specifically for WiWa on the topic because I don't think a single person is truly satisfied with the current system in place.

Allow rises from BL tiers to the one above.
This one goes without saying. Pokemon like UUBL Garchomp, RUBL Thundurus-I, and NUBL Cresselia should be allowed to rise to their respective OU UU and RU. There's no real impact on the lower tiers in these, as I mentioned above awhile ago. There's genuinely zero real reason why it cannot be done to make the builder more accurately reflect the meta the tier has. Freezing rises already brutalizes that a decent bit, at least implement this. The only Pokemon in BL tiers that have been discussed to unban that could rise, is Thundy-I/Serperior and Porygon2. That's it. Comapred to the what? 40+ Pokemon in BLs, that's paltry. Please, if literally nothing else gets done, implement this. I have yet to see a single argument anywhere to the contrary that isn't the unban argument.
 
I know people feel bad for BLs, but please don’t single them out as deserving rises just because they aren’t usable in a lower tier. Taking away a lower tier’s ability to retest something like SS PU is doing with Guzzlord is not immaterial when that Pokemon would have otherwise been NU. This would get even more arbitrary when considering Pokemon can be in a BL of a lower tier, not used / barely used in the tier directly above, and then used much more in a tier more than one directly above (Brute Bonnet with more usage in NU than PU or ZU combined, Ninetales-Alola in UU versus PU, Cresselia in RU and OU).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top