I probably missed something since I'm typing this at 1am in the morning but I prob ain't writing it without being sleep deprived lol.
I think freezing rises was possibly the single best thing for lower tiers in like, forever, and honestly agree with miss that they if anything, were not early enough. People talk about "4+ shifts left" but frankly put, every time a shift occured, a lower tier would be ripped of a very important staple that usually would lead to a lot of tiering needed. Usually this was RU and PU getting fucked, but there is nothing to say UU/NU would either. This also would not always be the mons that were actually representative of the tiers. NU still hoards braviary because a few ladder players spam it (one of which is infamous for using it), NU took arcanine for reasons? (even if I am an arcanine believer it is not an NU mon in the slightest) UU took talon while it was currently UR (yes, I know it rose to B rank but that was very much after the rise and ATP it rose it was not seen to be generally great). We have seen this throughout the gen (gallade and a bunch of mons rose to UU cause somebody spammed a team so much, zorua hisui rose to NU in early SV etc). Frankly put, rises have not been because a mon 'deserves' to be in a tier, its sometimes has been, but a good chunk of the time, it was just up to the whimsy of ladder to pull a glue mon from a lower because it looked cool or something. Lets dispel the notion that rises are actually making tiers representative of the mons that are good in them, they are not and there is copious amounts of evidence.
You could rise the BL mons to the actual tiers, but a good amount of the time BL's are discussed to be dropped to said tier below (RU has discussed this a lot recently while PU also has), so rising them to said tier just takes away agency from lower tiers. Maybe once SV is done you can do that moreso, but rn i think thats a big no go, taking away any tiers agency just feels wrong when tiers usually already are at the peril of higher ones.
Django said:So, looking at the above, we see a large number of mons which are ranking highly on the tiers they should be rising to VRs, as well as getting usage way above the 4.52% cutoff. Some of course are much closer to the cutoff, but there is a real variety here. I also think it's worth pointing out that these types of rises are not metagame defining in the way previous rises were (e.g. Talonflame and Hippowdown rising from RU to UU). What we're seeing here is mons shifting with metagames as we get closer to tiers which are more stable. The tops of the tiers are staying relatively the same, and middling usage mons are shifting around as niches are discovered and solidified.
This last part about "not metagame defining rises" is just, so untrue. Garde is a MASSIVE part of the RU metagame, helping keep a lot of cheese in check like weather and such and just generally being an excellent pokemon. Ambipom is another great anti cheese pokemon for PU since fake out prevents a lot of cheesier playstyles from being great, its why partly in general HO has been on the tamer side in PU i would say. Wo-chien is a great Pokemon in PU, one of which is a great softcheck to a lot of things like Bruxish, Hoopa, Rhydon etc. ZU literally loses both of its S tiers, you cannot get more impactful then that LOL, while also losing a very good offensive pokemon in Whimsicott. This leaves Alolan Ninetales (between mediocre and meh in the tiers its in), Grimmsnarl (B+ in PU so again, not shabby) and Brute Bonnet (who is A- in ZU so not exactly a slouch either). We can also see that some of these are just, not really great in these tiers? Grimm is B- in NU and while it has been used at top tour level, calling it "representative of the meta" would just feel wrong. Whimsicott is C+, which is reaching shitmon territory.
But to answer the questions asked:
Django said:
- Do the results we see above make sense to you? Should we be blocking these rises?
- Are we optimising for the right metric at the right point in the generation e.g. stability over all else with 4+ tier shifts left
- If the answer to either of the above is "no" - what is the solution?
- If the answer to 1 or 2 is "yes" - why? Do we need to change anything outside of the tiering system to handle the change in accuracy and consistency?
1. We should be blocking these rises yes. Firstly, we have already had a frozen shift, so going back on it I feel would just be a weird thing to do. Secondly, is there truly a bad thing to blocking rises that comes from it? People talk about it being confusing to newcomers, but we have allowed pokemon who are not good pokemon in said tiers to stay there (azu in UU, forre in RU, braviary/avalugg in NU, coalossal in PU), which is just as confusing. If we allow pokemon to stay in tiers that they do not actually belong in, then saying about it being confusing for newcomers to get into lower tiers IDG.
2. Yes, stability is a very important thing to do. As I stated above, 4+ shifts seems like a lot, but it is not enough time to deal with considering that every rises forces a tier to majorly change and thus impacts a lower tier. Garde rising to UU for instance, would force RU to take other scarfers/anti cheese mons from NU (lets say for example, flamigo rises from this), making a series of events that by the time all the shifts are done, the lower tiers are not stable going into gen 10. People state that "well this is the fault of lower tier councils not being active" and while I do agree with that, lets be real for a moment? IDT much is going to change in that department. As listed in this thread, there was a thread to do that and nothing came out of it.
4. The reason why as explained is simple, promoting stability in tiers. But what we need to change is quite a few things. IDT any of these can be implemented current gen, since they would be too large of changes.
Firstly, make sure pokemon that are not good in a tier can be forced dropped. This could be something like: If x mon is C tier and below for 3 consecutive VR shifts OR 6 months of being in the tier (whichever comes first I think? Could do whichever comes last maybe but idk, first seems better), then it is forced dropped. This ensures that said pokemon is flat out bad, if something is hovering between C+ and C or B- and then falls to C for a bit before it rises up again, then it might be just a phase of it being considered bad. Ofc this does require VR councils to be vetted more to make sure people won't try to force drop something, but honestly making sure VR councils are better is a side benefit.
Secondly, if X pokemon is C/UR when it would rise, it is veto'd to rise. This would make sure braviary and shit doesnt rise because people want to spam it. God knows that we all remember the SS hitmontop incident right?
Also adding the aformentioned "councils should be more active", because honestly its something that should be done but IDT its going to actually happen.
Overall, I do not see a reason to unfreeze rises. They are very beneficial to tiers and a lot of the arguements against them feel not worth it. Yes, I like having the mon being represented in the tier it actually is, but if it is at the cost of metagame health? Shit, i will take Mesprit having Z in its tier placement over P any day of the week.