Ironmage said:I'm surprised this rant doesn't bring up that Quark Drive and Protosynthesis will boost speed 50% but other stats only 30%. Even within a single Ability, Speed is still favoured for whatever reason.
My post 1 AM brain must've somehow forgotten to include them, although these abilities are also unusual in that they're malleable and don't always provide the same stat boost...and originally, the post was mainly just going to be about rain dish/ice body anyway.
AztecCroc said:Shore Up
I...can't believe I let this slide by. Then again it's a signature move of a singular evolution like that often goes overlooked by many....
Samtendo09 said:It also speaks volume on how biased the games in general are to Speed despite how impactful that stat is in a vast majority of the games, between Flinching, the higher risk of slower Pokémon suffering a secondary effect, and so on. Giving 50% boost in case of Quark Drive and Protosynthesis, I understand to avoid making the potential Speed Tiers even more convoluted, but you’d think at that point Game Freak would make Speed less impactful instead of more at this rate.
This is mostly my own consensus too, and many of these points are neatly lead me to my own next following set of annoyances; without further ado, let's get into it:
Flinching. Just, the existence of this mechanic in general. Speed is already advantageous as-is, and now you have the ability to just...deny the opponent's turn completely, just by using a select few moves? Even disregarding how utterly absurd and unfair this is in and of itself (especially considering many of these moves are choices that their users would run anyway due to often being their best choice of STAB/coverage move for their respective types), the fact it takes out so much agency from either side when the flinch dice roll comes around makes for really stressful and heart-wrenching gameplay moments whenever such a move is clicked and it has the potential to flinch. The games already have so much out-of-control variance on a turn-by-turn basis, but this just goes on another level when you consider how important every turn can be on this turn-based game; going first by having more speed is already advantageous enough, but now even being
rewarded for it is just...ugh.
Important: I'm obviously not including fake out on this list; the move has its own, specific purpose that makes it a unique, powerful strategic tool if used correctly. If any move were to deserve retaining the flinch mechanic, it would be fake out; everything else can get other side effects instead.
Damage rolls. This part arguably deserves to be in the unpopular opinions thread, but since it's relevant enough here and such threads are arguably interchangeable at times, might as well include it here. So you managed to get everything right in order, and are getting to play the game normally, landing attacks that inflict damage; this attack has a strong chance to finish off the opponent...but didn't, because RNGods said it ought to low-roll this turn and you didn't get your deserved k.o. because of an outcome completely out of your hands.
Indeed, it's frankly pretty

that your regular attacks have such a wide variance of damage scores; apparently up to 16 different outcomes?? That's pretty absurd; even if it's a 1-15% difference, such a seemingly minute range can often make all the difference in a turn-based game with a fixed set of combatants and rules
"power of friendship" B.S. notwithstanding. And unlike factors like crit rate, stat stages, status conditions etc....there's literally nothing you can do about damage rolls variance, other than ensuring your attack can do enough damage that even the lowest possible roll doesn't end up ruining intended outcomes (while at the same time, being prepared that even the highest damage roll from the opponent doesn't ruin everything unexpectedly)
....But the real factor that makes the placement of this message controversial, is that when I bring up to the others that damage rolls are no good for the game and it would be better off without them (or at least with much less variance), I'm frankly...impressed by the amount of people that believe damage rolls are actually fine? Like yeah, some amount of unpredictability is arguably fine (like the 4% crit rate "punishing" overly passive play for example even if I'd also rather not have that in the game either, and only attain crit rate capability through the various modifiers) but THIS much variance? Especially over something you have very little control over, and is always looming around even the most "normal" battling conditions possible? It just...surprises me how many people think this is ok, probably because most pokemon games are too easy and not tight-knit enough for the variance of damage rolls to present too much urgency? I can't wrap my head around this, man.
Accuracy. This is arguably getting too far into controversy territory, but since I'm getting on a roll here, may as well go all-in at this point. Yes, I said it: accuracy deciding if you just waste an entire turn, is a pretty damning mechanic in -again- a turn-based game with a fixed set of combatants like pokemon, where every turn is so relevant and wasting one of them because the RNG didn't feel like it that moment, can be really heart-wrenching. Now, I get it: various moves (the special attacks with 110+ bp, the guaranteed-status high bp moves, sleep-inducing moves, etc) would arguably be too much if they could just be spammed with no drawback; the really insulting part is where other, weaker moves like take down, slam (???), play rough as well as the majority of rock-type attacks are caught in the crossfire.
But the ones that REALLY boil me
are 95% accuracy moves. This is frankly the most insulting category that should straight up just not exist, PERIOD. The miss chance is -still there-yet it's so small that most people don't (and can't) pay much mind to; it's so nerve-racking when it does occur, especially for the 5-8 pp high bp legendary signature moves.
Apologies for potential theorymonning but, the game would be much better off if instead of doing no damage entirely, said "missing" moves instead did halved damage with no secondary effect. Some other workaround could be figured out for the status moves instead.
Now shifting gears away from mechanics, my next gripe is...the fact that :grimmsnarl: has prankster. This might sound like a strange choice, considering mons like :klefki: :meowstic: :whimsicott: all also have the ability and are considered fine. The main difference is that these fully-evolved pokemon are otherwise relatively understatted, which not only makes it cool that prankster lets them partically overcome such a flaw, it also makes them not terribly difficulty to deal with aside from their status moves shenanigans. And sure enough, :grimmsnarl: is largely no exception to this rule....except the mon also has an actual statline, and one that would normally befit a slow, tanky and powerful attacker. This is further reinforced by its unique typing, which is quite potent both offensively and defensively, and the mon gets no shortage of good attacking options to make use of it; be it sucker punch for priority, low kick for anti-steel coverage, and even TWO signature STAB moves!
...But of course, all of this gets overlooked in favor of it being able to setup screens with priority and -as of this gen- also use said priority to not only pivot out but also further reduce your own damage output in the process! And there's also options like taunt to prevent you from just turning it into setup fodder and even twave to further cripple your mons!! (thank god this was removed in champions at least...but not parting shot from it or :incineroar: ugh). And its attacking prowess? It's largely reduced to just using spirit break to not become complete taunt fodder while also further weakening your damage output! And also cover dark types that would otherwise shut down prankster taunt/parting shot. This part is further baffling by the move's poor distribution otherwise; even to this day it's still stuck to 2 mons while every other physically attacking fairy type is crying for a more accurate alternative to play rough (which in and of itself is a problem because it necessitates said fairies to learn play rough at much earlier levels than what -reasonable- lvup progression would otherwise indicate, just because they're otherwise completely lacking in viable STAB options for a long time. fairy in general suffers from a lack of mid-BP attacks from either side of the spectrum, with dgleam being the closest thing fitting the category). Back to grimm itself though, having priority parting shot at all (especially on top of screens) is frankly pretty dumb in general, even with dark types being immune to it at least. Good thing it at least doesn't have any methods of recovery, otherwise it'd frankly be pretty game-warping.
....While we're still on the topic of moves -and fairy type ones specifically- it's pretty insane how moonblast's been allowed to exist in its current state for as long as it has; here we have a move that not only has 95 bp (while every equivalent move got nerfed out of said bp in the same gen!), but also has a 30%??? chance to lower your sp.atk? This move is literally scald vs special attackers, exchanging a bit of the dmg output reduction for not only having no immunities, but already being the most reliable attacking move of choice for any mon that gets it, being the higher BP alternative to moves like dgleam and having no "stronger alternative" outside of specific cases (whereas scald competes with surf and even hydro pump for their higher BP). At the very least champions nerfed its spa drop rate to a much more reasonable amount, yet the move still has its superior base power...all the fairies that don't get the move REALLY feel the lack of it, most of them opting for the 50 BP draining kiss instead of even dgleam.
And finally, on the topic of surf and hydro....the starter trio type options feel reasonably spread throughout, with the fire/water basic moves matching their final, strongest counterparts (ember vs flamethrower/fire blast (down to the burn rate chance!) and water gun vs surf/hydro pump (with no additional effect). However....grass gets no such moments. What's even the basic grass-type attack? Absorb? Hp restoring is quite the powerful side effect, yet BP wise giga drain is still far behind flamethrower/surf. Vine whip? Ok fair enough, there's power whip (and arguably leaf blade?) as its lategame alternative, yet not every grass type gets it/has vines or tentacles in the first place. Leafage? This one is clearly intended to be it, yet the lategame alternatives don't quite measure up unless you count wood hammer (which has recoil, while leafage has no side effect).
This admittedly minute discrepancy just caught my eye earlier today, and I found it rather...stange and off. And it's a little enough thing that makes it a perfect wrap-up to an essay that I definitely didn't intend for; I could also talk about topics like paralysis, freeze and even confusion/infatuation, but this post's already gotten unreasonably long as-is. Until next time!