Eriorguez said:While I don’t agree with how you feel about cross-gen evos overall (but I do agree Dusknoir, Electivire and Magmortar are a mess, stat-wise), I do agree 460~ BST mons should not be given a Mega as a first resort, unless they already reach a third stage like Beedrill.A Mawile evolution wouldn't have Huge Power, and the issue with Mawile and Sableye is that their Megas have the same stat total as stuff like RHYDON.
Mawile and Sableye should had gone the way Lickitung and Porygon went, as those have similar stat totals. Hell, Munchlax has that stat total as well (as it is Snorlax with 25 less on each base stat).
I'd place the cutoff point for mega vs evo at around 460 BST. Absol getting Megas rather than evos strikes me as right, but Banette or Chimecho should be evolving (and, please, don't do messes like Dusknoir, even if Mega Banette is also sucky). Beedrill or other early game bugs get a pass, and I really don't vibe with the concept of Obstagoon if you ask me.
But yeah, Rhyperior, Electivire, Magmortar, Porygon-Z, Ursaluna, Kingambit and specially Archaludon throughly strike me as things that shouldn't be. Other than FULLY EVOLVED STARTER RANGE Duraludon, the rest of those were always in the Alakazam/Gengar/Poliwrath/Nidoking range of stats (or a bit beyond for Pory2), and a Mega could had worked wonderfully.
Compare Raichu X with Electivire knowing Raichu and Electabuzz are incredibly similar 'mons:
View attachment 859393
And hell, Mega Houndoom is a bit lackluster, but I'd say it is more solid than Magmortar.
You do need to remember the reason why cross-gen evolutions is usually more beneficial than a Mega in the long run; that you can’t carry more than one Mega per team, and the Mega Stone has to be carried as the to-be-Mega Pokémon’s held item, limiting their potential. And the three you converted into Megas might hurt more than it help because they have to compete with the best Mega Evolution around without causing even more power creep.
Ursaluna primarily aims to make Ursaring more memorable by bringing back the moon theming, and give a more bulky and power oriented statline wheras Ursaring’s statline is too rounded other than Attack to be worthwhile even back then (access to Guts did helped back in Gen 3, granted).
Meanwhile, Bisharp and Duraludon has only a bit above average bulk when compared to other fully evolved Pokémon at the time, which can make them awkward to use in-game. While I do think Duraludon is more likely recipient to a Mega Evolution than a cross-gen evolution given the 535 BST, the evolutions do focus on increased bulk significantly so that they become more viable to use in-game with new toys (Supreme Overlord and Electro Shot respectively), even replacing both of Duraludon’s Abilities from Light Metal and Heavy Metal by Stamina and Sturdy. With their increased bulk (and in Archaludon’s case, it’s role in Rain), they also finally have a place in VGC without the worry of competing Mega Charizard Y, Mega Staraptor and Mega Raichu Y + X.
I understand your hate towards evolutions to high BST Pokémon, but it is important that Mega Evolution can be a lot more limited than you may think, so converting them into Mega Evolution might make the situation worse than you may think.







