• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Unpopular opinions

Eriorguez said:
A Mawile evolution wouldn't have Huge Power, and the issue with Mawile and Sableye is that their Megas have the same stat total as stuff like RHYDON.

Mawile and Sableye should had gone the way Lickitung and Porygon went, as those have similar stat totals. Hell, Munchlax has that stat total as well (as it is Snorlax with 25 less on each base stat).

I'd place the cutoff point for mega vs evo at around 460 BST. Absol getting Megas rather than evos strikes me as right, but Banette or Chimecho should be evolving (and, please, don't do messes like Dusknoir, even if Mega Banette is also sucky). Beedrill or other early game bugs get a pass, and I really don't vibe with the concept of Obstagoon if you ask me.

But yeah, Rhyperior, Electivire, Magmortar, Porygon-Z, Ursaluna, Kingambit and specially Archaludon throughly strike me as things that shouldn't be. Other than FULLY EVOLVED STARTER RANGE Duraludon, the rest of those were always in the Alakazam/Gengar/Poliwrath/Nidoking range of stats (or a bit beyond for Pory2), and a Mega could had worked wonderfully.

Compare Raichu X with Electivire knowing Raichu and Electabuzz are incredibly similar 'mons:

View attachment 859393

And hell, Mega Houndoom is a bit lackluster, but I'd say it is more solid than Magmortar.
While I don’t agree with how you feel about cross-gen evos overall (but I do agree Dusknoir, Electivire and Magmortar are a mess, stat-wise), I do agree 460~ BST mons should not be given a Mega as a first resort, unless they already reach a third stage like Beedrill.

You do need to remember the reason why cross-gen evolutions is usually more beneficial than a Mega in the long run; that you can’t carry more than one Mega per team, and the Mega Stone has to be carried as the to-be-Mega Pokémon’s held item, limiting their potential. And the three you converted into Megas might hurt more than it help because they have to compete with the best Mega Evolution around without causing even more power creep.

Ursaluna primarily aims to make Ursaring more memorable by bringing back the moon theming, and give a more bulky and power oriented statline wheras Ursaring’s statline is too rounded other than Attack to be worthwhile even back then (access to Guts did helped back in Gen 3, granted).

Meanwhile, Bisharp and Duraludon has only a bit above average bulk when compared to other fully evolved Pokémon at the time, which can make them awkward to use in-game. While I do think Duraludon is more likely recipient to a Mega Evolution than a cross-gen evolution given the 535 BST, the evolutions do focus on increased bulk significantly so that they become more viable to use in-game with new toys (Supreme Overlord and Electro Shot respectively), even replacing both of Duraludon’s Abilities from Light Metal and Heavy Metal by Stamina and Sturdy. With their increased bulk (and in Archaludon’s case, it’s role in Rain), they also finally have a place in VGC without the worry of competing Mega Charizard Y, Mega Staraptor and Mega Raichu Y + X.

I understand your hate towards evolutions to high BST Pokémon, but it is important that Mega Evolution can be a lot more limited than you may think, so converting them into Mega Evolution might make the situation worse than you may think.
 
Samtendo09 said:
I understand your hate towards evolutions to high BST Pokémon, but it is important that Mega Evolution can be a lot more limited than you may think, so converting them into Mega Evolution might make the situation worse than you may think.
As a bonus, Mega Evolutions will always have the issue that they can ONLY show up in games that do feature Mega Evolutions, whereas regular evolutions will always show up in a game where the base pokemon will be.
 
Worldie said:
As a bonus, Mega Evolutions will always have the issue that they can ONLY show up in games that do feature Mega Evolutions, whereas regular evolutions will always show up in a game where the base pokemon will be.
Assuming they don't do nonsense like the Hisuian Evos in SV where you CAN'T evolve the ones that can transfer in because someone can't be bothered to add an item.

Here's something I'd like to raise: a mon getting a Mega, an Evo, or nothing is entirely arbitrary by TPC's decision. Popularity can impact it but Glup Shittos getting acknowledged is something that can only happen so often, and intrinsically there's a difference in giving either form of update.

Yes, cross-gen Evos are on-paper better in battle for the Pokemon as a gameplay unit; on the other hand, evolving the mon fundamentally shifts the identity of the creature rather than a Mega adding to it. Bisharp was moderately popular, but as soon as Kingambit came out, it stole the majority of the line's attention because it made Bisharp just a stage passed on the way to the top form. No big talk comes about modern Ursaring or Duraludon because they're not the final forms of importance anymore. The flip side of this is I have known naysayers as far back as 2009 who dislike evolutions like Rhyperior, Tangrowth, Magmortar, or Mamoswine because those as the final form essentially leave their originals behind if they liked those

TPC clearly views Pokemon, even within the same Evo family, as distinct entities for marketing that can compete with each other, hence the infamous downplaying of Raichu in favor of its pre-evolved mascot form (and the Megas were STILL criticized for building on Pikachu's design instead of Raichu's). An evolution being added may be to capitalize on an existing mon's popularity, but it's in the interest of pushing a replacement rather than revitalizing an existing one.

And the funniest thing in my head is Archaludon EXISTING already feels like a hole in the idea that Megas cap a line, because GMax already demonstrated that NFE mons can be given the big explosive gimmick both at the time and retroactively. Wanna give Chimecho an evolution? Sure, the Evo just won't Mega, and retains a use case for all the reasons mentioned prior in favor of Evo > Mega Evo regardless of if it's an inferior 1 or the other build
 
pika pal said:
Assuming they don't do nonsense like the Hisuian Evos in SV where you CAN'T evolve the ones that can transfer in because someone can't be bothered to add an item.

Here's something I'd like to raise: a mon getting a Mega, an Evo, or nothing is entirely arbitrary by TPC's decision. Popularity can impact it but Glup Shittos getting acknowledged is something that can only happen so often, and intrinsically there's a difference in giving either form of update.

Yes, cross-gen Evos are on-paper better in battle for the Pokemon as a gameplay unit; on the other hand, evolving the mon fundamentally shifts the identity of the creature rather than a Mega adding to it. Bisharp was moderately popular, but as soon as Kingambit came out, it stole the majority of the line's attention because it made Bisharp just a stage passed on the way to the top form. No big talk comes about modern Ursaring or Duraludon because they're not the final forms of importance anymore. The flip side of this is I have known naysayers as far back as 2009 who dislike evolutions like Rhyperior, Tangrowth, Magmortar, or Mamoswine because those as the final form essentially leave their originals behind if they liked those

TPC clearly views Pokemon, even within the same Evo family, as distinct entities for marketing that can compete with each other, hence the infamous downplaying of Raichu in favor of its pre-evolved mascot form (and the Megas were STILL criticized for building on Pikachu's design instead of Raichu's). An evolution being added may be to capitalize on an existing mon's popularity, but it's in the interest of pushing a replacement rather than revitalizing an existing one.

And the funniest thing in my head is Archaludon EXISTING already feels like a hole in the idea that Megas cap a line, because GMax already demonstrated that NFE mons can be given the big explosive gimmick both at the time and retroactively. Wanna give Chimecho an evolution? Sure, the Evo just won't Mega, and retains a use case for all the reasons mentioned prior in favor of Evo > Mega Evo regardless of if it's an inferior 1 or the other build
GMax was already shown to be applicable to NFEs, Megas have been explictly stated in canon and in marketing to be only for Pokemon that cannot evolve further. They are entirely unrelated.
 
pika pal said:
Yes, cross-gen Evos are on-paper better in battle for the Pokemon as a gameplay unit; on the other hand, evolving the mon fundamentally shifts the identity of the creature rather than a Mega adding to it. Bisharp was moderately popular, but as soon as Kingambit came out, it stole the majority of the line's attention because it made Bisharp just a stage passed on the way to the top form. No big talk comes about modern Ursaring or Duraludon because they're not the final forms of importance anymore. The flip side of this is I have known naysayers as far back as 2009 who dislike evolutions like Rhyperior, Tangrowth, Magmortar, or Mamoswine because those as the final form essentially leave their originals behind if they liked those
At least those mons build on the pre-existing line. I'm out here like Scyther, whose evo went in a totally different direction, and Zigzagoon, who got utterly replaced by a visually-distinct regional form that added a totally different final evo.
 
ant4456 said:
personally ive been playing the shit out of pokemon rejuvenation to get my yearly fix of pokemon, and it might be my favorite game ever now, but im not gonna talk about that on a forum for general pokemon stuff since chances are not a single other person active in these threads has played it to completion
Just hopping in real quick to get behind this hype as well; the game's recently received a major update with its latest chapters being the longest and most expansive in a long while, and the game's reached quite the considerable length by this point (being not only longer than any pokemon game, official or not, but also several other video games period!). Yet despite that, the game's level of quality and attention to detail, especially with its many expressive events and gameplay additions remains as impressive as ever, even with the ever-increasing length and multiple choices, options, and now even routes!

What's most amazing though is how the game just builds upon things despite using mainline pokemon game mechanics for its core gameplay still; in fact the game just got updated with pokemon champions mechanics not too long ago! (and consequently, PLZA mega evolutions and forms, in addition to the vast majority of the currently existing pokemon throughout gens 1-9, are now available!) It's a truly unique experience and one that's definitely worth trying out -for free, no less!- even if things start really ramping up by the end, both story-wise and difficulty-wise; the average player may definitely be in for a surprise, even if you get more than enough OP things to handle basically any challenge along the way.

But yeah with how much content the game's got by this point, it's an amazing way to fill this supposedly increasing gap of silence in the franchise's quiet period. There's also a few other cool-looking romhacks and fangames being released lately, but that'll be a topic for another day probably.
 
pika pal said:
Assuming they don't do nonsense like the Hisuian Evos in SV where you CAN'T evolve the ones that can transfer in because someone can't be bothered to add an item.

Here's something I'd like to raise: a mon getting a Mega, an Evo, or nothing is entirely arbitrary by TPC's decision. Popularity can impact it but Glup Shittos getting acknowledged is something that can only happen so often, and intrinsically there's a difference in giving either form of update.

Yes, cross-gen Evos are on-paper better in battle for the Pokemon as a gameplay unit; on the other hand, evolving the mon fundamentally shifts the identity of the creature rather than a Mega adding to it. Bisharp was moderately popular, but as soon as Kingambit came out, it stole the majority of the line's attention because it made Bisharp just a stage passed on the way to the top form. No big talk comes about modern Ursaring or Duraludon because they're not the final forms of importance anymore. The flip side of this is I have known naysayers as far back as 2009 who dislike evolutions like Rhyperior, Tangrowth, Magmortar, or Mamoswine because those as the final form essentially leave their originals behind if they liked those

TPC clearly views Pokemon, even within the same Evo family, as distinct entities for marketing that can compete with each other, hence the infamous downplaying of Raichu in favor of its pre-evolved mascot form (and the Megas were STILL criticized for building on Pikachu's design instead of Raichu's). An evolution being added may be to capitalize on an existing mon's popularity, but it's in the interest of pushing a replacement rather than revitalizing an existing one.

And the funniest thing in my head is Archaludon EXISTING already feels like a hole in the idea that Megas cap a line, because GMax already demonstrated that NFE mons can be given the big explosive gimmick both at the time and retroactively. Wanna give Chimecho an evolution? Sure, the Evo just won't Mega, and retains a use case for all the reasons mentioned prior in favor of Evo > Mega Evo regardless of if it's an inferior 1 or the other build
Hugin said:
At least those mons build on the pre-existing line. I'm out here like Scyther, whose evo went in a totally different direction, and Zigzagoon, who got utterly replaced by a visually-distinct regional form that added a totally different final evo.
I do agree with Hugin overall, but I do understand where pika pal is coming from. At the same time, popularity and marketing should not get a fan’s way to like their favorite Pokémon for the reason they are. As an example, people eventually fell back to Electabuzz and Rhydon once the backlash reaches on Electivire and Rhyperior, respectively, so the shift in popularity is not permanent. And one good thing about the additions is that it does still give some nice attention to the likes of Girafarig, Tangela and so on as otherwise they’ll linger in obscurity for you know how longer without outside media highlighting them.

Another thing is that, if GF and TPC stopped with giving new toys to old Pokémon (Gen 5 included thanks to Hidden Abilities) and after the initial fiasco of BW regarding the new Pokémon, people would rather not more of the same old all the time either, so the new toys are made, alongside marketing aims, to give a bit more diversity and spotlight to more Pokémon, even if it feels like a “stepping stone” on the surface.
 
I've said it several times before, but Game Freak prioritizes worldbuilding and flavor when it comes to giving Pokemon anything, whether it be a cross-gen traditional evolution, a Mega Evolution, or something else like a regional form, G-Max, and whatnot. They want to sell Pokemon as fully realized creatures in a living, breathing world first and foremost.

Their thought process when giving anything of that sort to an existing Pokemon isn't "Oh this Pokemon needs a buff". Their thought process is more something among the lines of "Is there a way we can create a new design that integrates into this Pokemon and its evolutionary line or its design in a way we think that is creative and works?".

Even as late as Annihilape and Kingambit you can see this thought process. Annihilape is the evolved form of Primeape, whose lore is that it's perpetually angry and raging, and Annihilape is basically a case of "Primeape's anger reached a critical point where the blood vessels in its brain burst, and turned into a power that exceeds the physical limits of its body, causing Annihilape to emerge. Kingambit is a twist on Bisharp and Pawniard's usual lore. In most cases, Bisharp lead packs of multiple Pawniard and compete with each other, and Bisharp that lose are driven from the group while the winning Bisharp are accepted as the new leader. Kingambit is a case of situations where instead of loser Bisharp being driven out, they and their Pawniard packs are integrated into the winning Bisharp's pack and both the loser Bisharp and their Pawniard become the winner's servants. This eventually results in a Bisharp who stands above all other Bisharp, and that Bisharp will become Kingambit as an expression of its status as the supreme leader of a group of Bisharp and an even bigger pack of Pawniard.

Archaludon and G-Max Duraludon are different spins on Duraludon's actually underlying concept, and Duraludon was designed to be somewhat plain looking from the get-go despite its high BST so its design could "transform" further. The idea is that Duraludon is a raw, unshaped hunk of metal monster, and it gets "sculpted" into some form of architecture. The G-Max form causes Duraludon to become a skyscraper, while Archaludon is Duraludon turning into a bridge.

I went on and on but you get the point. Megas are usually more rooted in expanding on or playing with a Pokemon's design: taking certain features of a Pokemon and exaggerating them in many cases. Cases like Mawile and Sableye are cases where Game Freak would never have given them a normal evolution to begin with, because they felt those designs were otherwise "complete" as they are even if in-game they are statistically weak battlers. Sableye takes the chest gem it has and turns it into a giant shield, Mawile amplifies the jaw horns it has. And so on and so forth. Cross-gen evos on the other hand take designs that are somewhat plain and expand on them in a slightly more grounded way. Ursaring is a pretty standard bear but Ursaluna is a bigger, more imposing beast that came about as a result of being around peat and a full moon, which plays into the moon motif Teddiursa and Ursaring have. Rhyperior came about as a result of Rhydon fusing with some sort of armor (the Protector) that Rhydon liked. Tangrowth, Mamoswine, and Yanmega are implied to come about as a result of Tangela, Piloswine, and Yanma tapping into some ancient, dormant power that their ancestors once had.

That's the gist of it but yeah, when it comes to designs and what things certain Pokemon get, the lore potential, worldbuilding, flavor, and design ethos they feel fits most are what matter, not gameplay stats and battle capabilities, even though those are bonuses.
 
ScraftyIsTheBest said:
I've said it several times before, but Game Freak prioritizes worldbuilding and flavor when it comes to giving Pokemon anything, whether it be a cross-gen traditional evolution, a Mega Evolution, or something else like a regional form, G-Max, and whatnot. They want to sell Pokemon as fully realized creatures in a living, breathing world first and foremost.

Their thought process when giving anything of that sort to an existing Pokemon isn't "Oh this Pokemon needs a buff". Their thought process is more something among the lines of "Is there a way we can create a new design that integrates into this Pokemon and its evolutionary line or its design in a way we think that is creative and works?".

Even as late as Annihilape and Kingambit you can see this thought process. Annihilape is the evolved form of Primeape, whose lore is that it's perpetually angry and raging, and Annihilape is basically a case of "Primeape's anger reached a critical point where the blood vessels in its brain burst, and turned into a power that exceeds the physical limits of its body, causing Annihilape to emerge. Kingambit is a twist on Bisharp and Pawniard's usual lore. In most cases, Bisharp lead packs of multiple Pawniard and compete with each other, and Bisharp that lose are driven from the group while the winning Bisharp are accepted as the new leader. Kingambit is a case of situations where instead of loser Bisharp being driven out, they and their Pawniard packs are integrated into the winning Bisharp's pack and both the loser Bisharp and their Pawniard become the winner's servants. This eventually results in a Bisharp who stands above all other Bisharp, and that Bisharp will become Kingambit as an expression of its status as the supreme leader of a group of Bisharp and an even bigger pack of Pawniard.

Archaludon and G-Max Duraludon are different spins on Duraludon's actually underlying concept, and Duraludon was designed to be somewhat plain looking from the get-go despite its high BST so its design could "transform" further. The idea is that Duraludon is a raw, unshaped hunk of metal monster, and it gets "sculpted" into some form of architecture. The G-Max form causes Duraludon to become a skyscraper, while Archaludon is Duraludon turning into a bridge.

I went on and on but you get the point. Megas are usually more rooted in expanding on or playing with a Pokemon's design: taking certain features of a Pokemon and exaggerating them in many cases. Cases like Mawile and Sableye are cases where Game Freak would never have given them a normal evolution to begin with, because they felt those designs were otherwise "complete" as they are even if in-game they are statistically weak battlers. Sableye takes the chest gem it has and turns it into a giant shield, Mawile amplifies the jaw horns it has. And so on and so forth. Cross-gen evos on the other hand take designs that are somewhat plain and expand on them in a slightly more grounded way. Ursaring is a pretty standard bear but Ursaluna is a bigger, more imposing beast that came about as a result of being around peat and a full moon, which plays into the moon motif Teddiursa and Ursaring have. Rhyperior came about as a result of Rhydon fusing with some sort of armor (the Protector) that Rhydon liked. Tangrowth, Mamoswine, and Yanmega are implied to come about as a result of Tangela, Piloswine, and Yanma tapping into some ancient, dormant power that their ancestors once had.

That's the gist of it but yeah, when it comes to designs and what things certain Pokemon get, the lore potential, worldbuilding, flavor, and design ethos they feel fits most are what matter, not gameplay stats and battle capabilities, even though those are bonuses.
I would agree.... but then what's the lore / worldbuilding behind Dudunsparce? I feel that mon was made purely because fans wanted it to turn into something legendary and Gamefreak wanted to subvert their expectations with a joke that also served a more practical purpose of buffing it.
 
Magcargo said:
I would agree.... but then what's the lore / worldbuilding behind Dudunsparce? I feel that mon was made purely because fans wanted it to turn into something legendary and Gamefreak wanted to subvert their expectations with a joke that also served a more practical purpose of buffing it.

While I mostly agree with Scrafty’s post, I think there probably is still an element of “this could use a buff” to their decisionmaking (certainly I think this was pronounced with Gen 4’s cross-gen evo selection), it just isn’t the end-all be-all. Oftentimes they’ll do something just because they have a cool idea for it.

That said, with Dudunsparce I feel like the joke works particularly well in the context of the encryption constant mechanic that it and Maushold use. Dunsparce was historically very rare at a 1% appearance rate but utterly unremarkable and plain; its evolution is doubles down on that bland normalcy, and then its evolution has a super-rare 1% alternate form that… triples down on it. Funny little full-circle moment for Dark Cave’s silly worm-snake. I’d be curious to know whether Maushold or Dudunsparce was conceptualized first.
 
Samtendo09 said:
Ursaluna primarily aims to make Ursaring more memorable by bringing back the moon theming, and give a more bulky and power oriented statline wheras Ursaring’s statline is too rounded other than Attack to be worthwhile even back then (access to Guts did helped back in Gen 3, granted).

1788172460050.png


Ursaring has always been Normal Machamp tho. This should already be understood as a solid enough mon, even if not optimized.

Can always pivot to the power creep talk tho, even if BW are now closer to the beggining of the franchise than to the present, because sheesh.
 
Ursaring has also failed to be readily available for playthroughs outside of XD because it's often shoved into the end of the games it appears it, and sometimes as a rare encounter to boot. Very good chance you never even saw one in GSC if you played Gen 2 as a kid. Machamp is somehow more available despite being a trade evo just because Machop is encountered quite early and easily in a lot of games.
 
Karxrida said:
Ursaring has also failed to be readily available for playthroughs outside of XD because it's often shoved into the end of the games it appears it, and sometimes as a rare encounter to boot. Very good chance you never even saw one in GSC if you played Gen 2 as a kid. Machamp is somehow more available despite being a trade evo just because Machop is encountered quite early and easily in a lot of games.
I think Teddiursa has a window early game in Crystal at least, albeit still very specific time and only in one place. It does at least up it from "end game where do I use this" to "early game novelty that's pretty useable if you bother."

Here's something I have in hindsight: Everyone talks about "this Evo would be better as a Mega" and vice versa, but now that Paradoxes exist as variants on clear-inspiration from existing mons as distinct species, I feel several Cross-Gen Evos, especially for 4, would work better as such in hindsight, especially to play with their stats. Stand out examples therein would include Tangrowth, Electivire/Magmortar, maybe Lickilicky, and Porygon-Z.

None of this is to say I think they would be "objectively" better in one form or the other, but I do have this sense of seeing them under this lens now that it has an established precedent.
 
Eriorguez said:
View attachment 859914

Ursaring has always been Normal Machamp tho. This should already be understood as a solid enough mon, even if not optimized.

Can always pivot to the power creep talk tho, even if BW are now closer to the beggining of the franchise than to the present, because sheesh.
This is probably the default opinion anyway but I think it's actually a bit odd how tame the pokemon incarnation of Bears have been, specifically with Ursaring, Pangoro, and Beartic. They certainly aren't weak by any stretch, 130 Attack was the soft ceiling at the time Ursaring was created and given STAB Thrash access it is in practice the second strongest Attacker in terms of raw neutral damage in the entire game behind Rhydon at that point. Instead, it's the bulk that is most surprisingly low. The number of unassuming Normal types that have greater or equal bulk to Ursaring is kind of absurd - Kangaskhan, Miltank, Lickitung, Porygon2, Drampa, Dubwool, and Audino are just some, and most absurdly Dunsparce (with 100 HP / 70 Def / 60 SpDef) is just barely frailer overall. I think the comparison which most obviously illuminates this is Bewear. 90 HP / 75 Def / 75 SpDef might not look especially poor, but in comparison Bewear's 120 HP / 80 Def / 60 SpDef is much more like what would I expect, and that's in a case where Bewear's bulk is purposely stunted to account for Fluffy as an ability. I think a pretty big part of why Ursaring is kind of a deflated Pokemon to me is exactly because it has never felt like a menacing opponent in the way a Big Bear would be. Even in cases where Guts is active and Ursaring is incredibly scary, it ends up playing like a glass cannon which feels way off.

With all this in mind, Ursaluna's stat spread is much closer to an idea in my head of what a Pokemon Bear would end up looking like statistically compared to Ursaring, and I have a less difficult time accepting it even if it is pretty blatantly a form of Power Creep. I think the thing I'm most disappointed in with Ursaluna is the step to cut it's Special Attack from 75 to 45 to sheerly optimize it's stats; there was always a kernel of untapped potential in Ursaring's weirdly passable Special Attack given it didn't really get the old-gen Normal type suite of random coverage moves, and for whatever reason it never got Moonblast or Moonlight when those were introduced despite being a dead ringer with the abundance of Moon theming. Ursaluna Bloodmoon kind of rectifies this with access to both moves and a dedicated focus on Special Attacks, but then in that case I wouldn't be shocked if most folks didn't even know it learned Moonblast with how absurdly laser focused its' sets are on Blood Moon, Earth Power, and Hyper Voice / Calm Mind.

Beartic Extra
Beartic being given the treatment it had is probably the most absurd thing. It has a very slight Bulk bump compared to Ursaring (95 HP / 80 Def / 80 SpDef) but when it was released in Generation 5 it also had only 110 Attack. That's a pretty substantial cut, and is even less understandable given Beartic's strongest attack (Icicle Crash) is only 85 BP compared to the now 120 BP Thrash Ursaring gets. Unless there was some playtesting hurdle with Brycen's difficulty or a frankly irrational fear of what a Swift Swim Ice Type was capable of in competitive play, I have no idea why this was the case, and the raw 20 point bump to Beartic's Attack remains one of the most impactful direct Base Stat boosts ever given.

Also Beartic is a Polar Bear. For those unaware, Polar Bears are massive. Ursaring was made 5'10" / 1.8m, which is definitely short for a Brown Bear but is a reasonable if not a bit large for the many smaller Asian Black Bears it was inspired by. Beartic is 8'06" / 2.6 m tall, and that's on the shorter end for real adult Polar Bears. Why is it only a salt pinch bulkier than Ursaring???
 
Last edited:
Genuine_Angus_B33F said:
This is probably the default opinion anyway but I think it's actually a bit odd how tame the pokemon incarnation of Bears have been, specifically with Ursaring, Pangoro, and Beartic. They certainly aren't weak by any stretch, 130 Attack was the soft ceiling at the time Ursaring was created and given STAB Thrash access it is in practice the second strongest Attacker in terms of raw neutral damage in the entire game behind Rhydon at that point. Instead, it's the bulk that is most surprisingly low. The number of unassuming Normal types that have greater or equal bulk to Ursaring is kind of absurd - Kangaskhan, Miltank, Lickitung, Porygon2, Drampa, Dubwool, and Audino are just some, and most absurdly Dunsparce (with 100 HP / 70 Def / 60 SpDef) is just barely frailer overall. I think the comparison which most obviously illuminates this is Bewear. 90 HP / 75 Def / 75 SpDef might not look especially poor, but in comparison Bewear's 120 HP / 80 Def / 60 SpDef is much more like what would I expect, and that's in a case where Bewear's bulk is purposely stunted to account for Fluffy as an ability. I think a pretty big part of why Ursaring is kind of a deflated Pokemon to me is exactly because it has never felt like a menacing opponent in the way a Big Bear would be. Even in cases where Guts is active and Ursaring is incredibly scary, it ends up playing like a glass cannon which feels way off.

With all this in mind, Ursaluna's stat spread is much closer to an idea in my head of what a Pokemon Bear would end up looking like statistically compared to Ursaring, and I have a less difficult time accepting it even if it is pretty blatantly a form of Power Creep. I think the thing I'm most disappointed in with Ursaluna is the step to cut it's Special Attack from 75 to 45 to sheerly optimize it's stats; there was always a kernel of untapped potential in Ursaring's weirdly passable Special Attack given it didn't really get the old-gen Normal type suite of random coverage moves, and for whatever reason it never got Moonblast or Moonlight when those were introduced despite being a dead ringer with the abundance of Moon theming. Ursaluna Bloodmoon kind of rectifies this with access to both moves and a dedicated focus on Special Attacks, but then in that case I wouldn't be shocked if most folks didn't even know it learned Moonblast with how absurdly laser focused its' sets are on Blood Moon, Earth Power, and Hyper Voice / Calm Mind.
I’ll give Ursaluna this, it really did feel as dangerous as a bear should be. Ursaring had a strong attack stat, but that’s really all it had going for it and it just kept falling behind more and more as the generations passed.
Except for Paul’s Ursaring, that thing was dang cool.

Plus it barely gets a chance to shine ingame, outside of Crystal specifically and before Legends Arceus & SV it only had any decent availability in XD.
So across the almost 30 years of the franchise there’s been only 1 chance for Ursaring specifically to shine in players eyes which is crazy to look back on.

As for the special Movepool, that might be why they made Bloodmoon, to make use of that Special attacking side. Heck, maybe someday there could be a regional variant based off of Spirit Bears.
Genuine_Angus_B33F said:
Beartic being given the treatment it had is probably the most absurd thing. It has a very slight Bulk bump compared to Ursaring (95 HP / 80 Def / 80 SpDef) but when it was released in Generation 5 it also had only 110 Attack. That's a pretty substantial cut, and is even less understandable given Beartic's strongest attack (Icicle Crash) is only 85 BP compared to the now 120 BP Thrash Ursaring gets. Unless there was some playtesting hurdle with Brycen's difficulty or a frankly irrational fear of what a Swift Swim Ice Type was capable of in competitive play, I have no idea why this was the case, and the raw 20 point bump to Beartic's Attack remains one of the most impactful direct Base Stat boosts ever given.

Also Beartic is a Polar Bear. For those unaware, Polar Bears are massive. Ursaring was made 5'10" / 1.8m, which is definitely short for a Brown Bear but is a reasonable if not a bit large for the many smaller Asian Black Bears it was inspired by. Beartic is 8'06" / 2.6 m tall, and that's on the shorter end for real adult Polar Bears. Why is it only a salt pinch bulkier than Ursaring???

Genuinely I hope for the day we get an Evolution to Beartic like Ursaluna was for Ursaring. Polar Bears are the most dangerous land animal around, only a Tiger comes close.
Like how many animals look at people and go ‘ah yes, a fine meal’, not a lot just Tigers, Lions and some Sharks, but Tigers and Lions at least are likely to back off and with Sharks it’s often them mistaking us as weird Seals.
But Polar Bears? They actively will track and hunt people down for hours, they're that dedicated to eating. Pokémon really should show off that with like an Ice/Fighting or an Ice/Water type or something similar, with Snow+Slush Rush it’s got potential as a mainstay in Snow, and with Rain it has potential as an Ice type option with Liquidation and even Tera
 
Last edited:
Ursaring (and version counterpart Donphan) were stuck with the baffling approach Gen II had where every single new species was awkward to find and not very good unless invested heavily, in the gen where TMs as a rule sucked and thus Gen I species had it better by virtue of being able to go to Gen I games to learn better attacks.

Teddiursa was just outside the final gym (and 20 levels below it) in Gold (and Japanese Silver), and also with a 5% encounter rate IN THE MORNING in the Dark Cave near Violet in Crystal. Because Crystal really doubled down on the weird encounter tables Yellow had, but made it even more awkward with a ton of morning exclusives. And wouldn't evolve until level 30.

Ursaring was easier to find, you'd keep running into it in Victory Road, but lol Victory Road wild Pokemon being useful, ever.

Oh, and at Mount Silver. Second best grind encounter after Rapidash I recall. At least could be captured earlier, unlike Sneasel, Misdreavus and Larvitar.

...

Johto games are incredibly overrated and have always doubled down on anti-QoL.
 
I went a long time without rewatching Pokemon Heroes, actually close to twenty years at this point. This was because the movie was insanely important in my childhood to the point where Latios was a comfort Pokemon I would always dream about, and I was scared that removing the nostalgia goggles would expose me to a movie that was ultimately far better in my head than in reality.

Man I am extremely happy I decided to finally watch the movie. Not only is Latios definitely worth it, but it turns out that me fantasizing heaven as riding above the sky on top of Latios as a child was my subconscious taking something from the movie that I didn't possibly remember. The permanent stakes are really good and the fact that it took such a risk and portrayed the connectivity of the soul at the end was something I did not expect but absolutely needed to see. Combine that with gorgeous cel-shaded animation, beautiful environments, and a really cohesive plot that gives both time for fun scenes and really excellent pacing and you get a genuinely fantastic kid's movie even if they've never seen a lick of Pokemon.

Which makes me more shocked when I found out that this is an unpopular opinion. Apparently, Pokemon Heroes is mostly disliked, mostly given really poor reviews and is the worst performing Pokemon film of all time financially.
 
QuickBH said:
Which makes me more shocked when I found out that this is an unpopular opinion. Apparently, Pokemon Heroes is mostly disliked, mostly given really poor reviews and is the worst performing Pokemon film of all time financially.
Really? I was under the impression that it was one of the more well-liked movies. Reviews and financial success don't necessarily corollate to fan opinion. Especially since Heroes is one of the earlier movies*, which means it has a lot of nostalgia attached like you just demonstrated.

*The cutoff for people thinking "the movies started getting more bad than good" seems to be after Gen 4 fwiw
 
Karxrida said:
Really? I was under the impression that it was one of the more well-liked movies. Reviews and financial success don't necessarily corollate to fan opinion. Especially since Heroes is one of the earlier movies*, which means it has a lot of nostalgia attached like you just demonstrated.

*The cutoff for people thinking "the movies started getting more bad than good" seems to be after Gen 4 fwiw
Pokemon Heroes made a million less than it's predecessor and much less than it's older contemporaries. When I say it's the least sold it's by a pretty wide margin with the only one coming close being the Pokemon Rangers film. (Which so happened to be my second favorite movie growing up lmao)
 
Decided to look back at my past unpopular opinions and revise them since some of them have changed over time as I went back and actually played the older games, or I was just point blank missing the point of something.

LPBvgc said:
-After replaying Base BW, I think the story is overrated. Team Plasma COULD have been a great twist evil team, but the game quickly hammers it in that they are the bad guys by showing them beating a Munna up and stealing Pokémon from people. Also Ghetsis almost says the quiet part out loud when you confront him in Castelia City.

I honestly said this thinking Team Plasma and Ghetsis was a twist villain, but this actually wasn't the case. Team Plasma was a team that, rather than using force like past villains, used authority and influence to reach their goals, with the game hinting that Ghetsis has ulterior motives at Castelia. So, I take this back.

LPBvgc said:
-The QoL the newer games have made Gens 1-4 feel nearly unplayable. The only reason I would be playing something like Emerald or Platinum is for the Battle Frontier. Excluding that, I would take ORAS or BDSP over them any day of the week.

Replace 4 with 3 here, and replace "nearly unplayable" with "extremely hard to go back to". I've actually ended up liking and preferring Pokémon Platinum over BDSP, and do find that the Vs. Seeker actually is a good QoL addition. Although I still think the wild mon Level Scaling in the first three gens is still just too far.

LPBvgc said:
-There's no such thing as a "last good game/Gen", it's mostly just nostalgia combined with the inability to accept that a fan isn't a part of the target audience anymore.

Yeah, I was being pretty snobbish here, I still believe the main point that the concept of a last good gen isn't a thing, and it's typically really subjective and nostalgia driven, but I don't thing the inability to accept not being part of the target audience plays as much of a role in it as I thought it was.
 
In light of the likely final night of ambiguity in this regard, I want to make this post.

Golisopod is one of my favorite Pokemon. Emergency Exit is one of my favorite abilities, if not just my outright favorite.

If they give Mega Golisopod some run of the mill generically advantagous ability that discards Emergency Exit I will not be surprised by any means but I will be extremely disappointed. Maybe even actively depressed.

I care about this significantly more than I do if Mega Golisopod is actually good in any metagame sense.
 
Genuine_Angus_B33F said:
In light of the likely final night of ambiguity in this regard, I want to make this post.

Golisopod is one of my favorite Pokemon. Emergency Exit is one of my favorite abilities, if not just my outright favorite.

If they give Mega Golisopod some run of the mill generically advantagous ability that discards Emergency Exit I will not be surprised by any means but I will be extremely disappointed. Maybe even actively depressed.

I care about this significantly more than I do if Mega Golisopod is actually good in any metagame sense.
It’s likely it’ll get a renamed Emergency Exit, something like “Tactical Retreat” which work the same as before.

Or even if reaching 50% or less, it’ll “self-faint” instead of swtiching away to make it more extreme.
 
The thing I find stupid about Golisopod's Emergency Exit theme is that it's not even comically strong the way Slaking or other self-crippled mons tend to be without their ability knee-capping them. Generally there's a theme with these builds like Regigigas being groggy on wake up, Slaking being powerful but lazy, or Wishiwashi's school form scattering when it looks dangerous despite the strength in numbers.

Wimpod I get the theme perfectly fine because it has very low stats and lacks fighting ability to suit its cowardice, but then Golisopod is not extreme enough on either end to carry the joke through. It could be absurdly overpowered yet still afraid out of habit, or look imposing but still not have a very effective-at-fighting Stat spread like high Speed and Defenses to look imposing and tanky without the punch to match. If they're not going to commit heavily enough to Golisopod's theme (which the Mega KIND OF does with the stat allocation and more-defensive Steel subtype), I would prefer they stop giving it power ups that neither play into the idea hard enough nor make it playable (not even good, playable) in spite of it.
 
Back
Top