I'm not particularly good (read really bad) at articulating my thoughts well so
:bewear: with me...
1. Number of Teams and Franchising:
This year between RBEL, WCoR and Circuit, we had some good showing from new names. However I don't think we have enough new quality players to form 2 whole new teams. Specially considering there might always be some drops from previous season and some might just not signup due to reasons. And if we try to squeeze in every potential players, RBEL becomes kinda obsolete, which, I think most would agree that already dropped quite a bit in quality last season. With teh quality of the tournament in mind, I think we should
keep 8 teams for the time being.
Franchising however is not a good idea imo. I think we have a good structure for deciding teams and it also makes for more creative and fresh teams and CAs scene (where else would u find team Arcanine at the same place as team "insert broken ahh legendary here"), which is a big charm of RBTT; being one of the only 5 tours on the site that awards CA as a recognition for getting in. Therefore
I'm heavily against franchising.
Just
drop the manager signups early and give a break week for the artist to finish up the work.
2. Draft vs. Auction:
Altho snake draft has been always part of RBTT,
Auction makes for a much more engaging draft planning for the managers, and it's also more enjoyable for the spectators. It might be first time for many managers but everything starts somewhere. So hopefully it's not a debate anymore but would absolutely love to see how auction goes.
3. Number of managers, act and substitute rules:
With teh community cord (which was a really nice idea from last year) and self sub, I think 2 managers are enough. However, I don't hate the idea of 3 managers. Arguement for 3 is: other top tours have the same/ shifting to 3 (whenever I'm referring to top tours it's usually SPL and SCL), specially with auction being the format (if that's the case) an extra brain is always appreciated. It can also help with tz differences to keep things extra smooth. Arguement for 2 is: the workload is generally lower than other tours, with practically no prepwork involved after the auction...
I get the concern of some bias (which tbh exist everywhere and is kinda uncontrollable without extreme measures) and diluting the player pool but I'm
ever so slightly biased towards 3 managers. Specially with upto 2 playing per team.
If I'm not mistaken, SCL
allows players self subbing without any managers intervention (or alleast this year did, I recall noname winning a game while self subbing... Correct me if I'm wrong)
and I think it just makes sense considering circumstances might occur when no manager is available and a sub is needed. It's definitely better than handing an act win when a sub was available (basically get as many as possible, if not all games done).
As for
acts we should just follow the official rules with a bit more leniency in case by case example since it's Rands.
4. Formats:
Either works but I prefer
16 with some rework:
With SV going into 4th year, we don't need a 3rd SV slot.
BSSF has an extremely niche playerbase, but so does some other formats.
The reasoning to keep or boot HC is the same, it's the embodiment of randomness. That very quirk can make it extremely fishy and unfun; specially when u have to bank on it in do or die situation in the biggest Rands tour.
There's a significantly active randubs community our there and we should let them decide on what to do with the dubs slots, however from a spectators pov, the dubs2 slot did intact feel somewhat lackluster compared to dubs1. Personally I think we should
make it 1 dubs and move the 2nd dubs slot to RBEL, where the power level should be much more similar.
Roulette is overall a good format for showcasing skill, considering we have players that are good into multiple tiers. But the execution is kinda poor imo. The built-in roulette format potentially being able to load 3x gen2 is just absurd. Instead I suggest a
multi gen format, where the host rolls 5 formats for each series without any repeat within the series. Or a pick and ban style format with the 1st format being rolled by the host.
Now for some formats worth exploring:
1.
B12P6 SP: This format it extremely liked within and outside of the active rands community and most top players I know enjoy it asw.
2.
VGC Rands: If we decide to keep 2 dubs slot, I think we replace dubs2 with VGC rands, considering the mainstream success of champions and easy access to VGC in general recently.
3.
Battle Factory: Been saying this for a while, but battle factory bridging Rands to general play is always fascinating, and this can get more players than some other tiers since a lot of good tier clickers might join which is also positive for overall quality of the tournament
4.
Broken Cup: HC but better, with more control
5.
Baby Rands: I just want a format represented where I can roll

6.
Hybrid Bo3/5: if we want to represent as many formats as possible, we could merge some niche formats into a single bo3/bo5 such as Mono Rands, Draft factory, BDSP/LGPE rands etc.
We can also do the same for the tiers that are in contention for booting to still keep them.
However I'm not sure how this format will affect overall playerbase and quality of the tour.
With all that being said, I propose smth like this:
Formats
• 9 Bo5
• 9 Bo3
• 8 Bo3
• 7 Bo3
• 6 Bo3
• 5 Bo3
• 4 Bo3
• 3 Bo3
• 2 Bo3
• 1 Bo5
• Dubs Bo3
• Roulette* Bo5 (multi gen/pick and ban)
• Battle Factory
• B12P6 SP Bo3 / VGC Bo3 / HC or Broken Cup Bo3 / BSSF Bo5/7 / Hybrid Bo3/5 (Mono, Baby, Draft; add BDSP / LGPE if Bo5) / Champs Bo3 - For the last 3 slots
5. Team Structure:
3 managers, upto 2 playing.
16 starter + 4-6 subs (20-22 players in total, maximum 25 people if 3 non playing managers)
Edit: 4-6 subs as in minimum 4 and maximum 6, instead of a hard cap so that managers have a bit more flexibility drafting
6. Budgeting, Self Buys, and Retains:
200k for an average of 10k per player in case of minimum players (like most other tours)
Manager is
self buys are 15k for 1 and 15k+20k, total
35k for 2
I also like retains and for that I suggest:
- Every manager must include a primary and 2 secondary choice teams they want to retain from. From there, the following in order:
- If a manager pair is rerunning with, they get their previous team to retain from.
- If a manager pair splits into multiple, one of them gets the previous team, and the others are considered as new managers; upon hosts discretion
- If a different manager pair wants to take a team with same mascot as the previous year and nobody else wants to retain that team or it doesn't clash with the prior criterias, they get to retain from that team.
- If completely new managers and mascots, including the remaining managers from criteria 2: they get assigned teams by choices given and/or randomisation; upon hosts discretion
Finally... That was a whole lot of rambling and it took me a while.
Tried to touch as many topics as possible, but still feels like I missed smth

(ig I'll just make new posts if I remember smth)
Anw a lot of these are my personal opinion/preferences, and I don't know how much weight they carry. There will probs always be some disagreement since no single thing can satisfy the mass, but at the end of the day I just hope we all can come to some conclusions that contribute to RBTT X being the biggest and best version of the tour we have seen so far. As I've said many times, this is my favourite community on the site so looking forward to enjoying the biggest tournament of it and it's success with everyone.