I know I said I wasn't going to change the front sprites, but the feedback from Cartoons and X-Presumptuous made a lot of sense. So, I revised the front sprites yet again (version 9, ugh...):
After hearing the feedback, I went back to Cartoons original design and looked at the hands. I realized that in my quest to make good detailed hands, I made the new hand too human-proportional. In Cartoons design, the hands are very articulated (much more so than most pokemon with hands), but they are still somewhat fat and squishy, like many cartoon character hands. The lower front hands in my sprite have "cartoony" dimensions, but with the recent update to the top front left hand, it lost its "cartoony-ness". On top of that, I was in the middle of revising the top front right hand to look more like the top front left!
Even if I liked the realism of the new hands, they were not consistent with the other hands in the drawing. So, I decided to make the top front hands a little fatter, and I softened up the edges in some of the finger joints. I think the result is very good. Overall, all the hands in the drawing are more consistent internally and are more true to Cartoons' original design.
For those of you that have been following my travails with this sprite, you know that I have focused a lot on the hands. I think that feature is the thing that really sets the design of this pokemon apart from the rest. Hands are the most useful part of the body, therefore lots of hands makes perfect sense for a "pure utility pokemon". So I have invested most of my time trying to make the hands really stand out on this sprite. Here's the progression of the top front hands of this sprite through the many versions I have made:
Some of you may be getting sick of all my progress posts on this sprite. If so, I apologize. I'm posting lots of detail and explanation, since I see a lot of posts in this thread from people that appear to be learning how to sprite. While my sprite may not be the best, it might be helpful for others to see how this sprite develops over time. Besides, this thread is going to be open for quite a while longer -- so what else do we have to talk about, other than sprites in progress?