LonelyNess said:Alright, expect a sort of a long post here... so if you're not into reading one, I suggest you leave now.
There are oh so many "creative" ideas that we could go with, but I feel that perhaps you could consider a less "creative" one, in lieu of one that would benefit the metagame at large.
It's no small secret that the metagame is largely centralized around physical attacking. They have the easiest time breaking through and making a sweep. And have, in general, better distribution of stat-upping moves such as Swords Dance. A quick look at OU Pokemon used will reveal that the majority of them are of the Physical variety.
Now if you were to look at the physical attackers of OU, it is pretty apparent that they are the more powerful Pokemon compared to their special attacking counterparts (whose usefulness generally stems from the lack of good Special Defense of the majority of OU, rather than raw power). Very rarely does anyone complain about special attackers (atleast those who are good at battling). And that is because of one thing, Blissey. Blissey is such a complete stop to what special attacking has to offer that if one has such a huge special weakness, the only thing you need to add is Blissey and you're good to go. The beauty of Blissey, however, comes in its exploitable weaknesses, and lack of ability to do MUCH of anything but sit there and stall (aside from the gimmicky Calm Mind set).
So I offer to you, my concept submission.
---------------------
Name: The Physical Blissey
Description: A Pokemon capable of coming in on the majority of Physical attackers and threatening them in some way.
----------------------
This one Pokemon could wildly shake up the Metagame as we know it. Much like Blissey, it should be able to do little offensively, and have fairly few support options, but what it does have ... it should be able to utilize incredibly effectively.
Not only do I believe that this Pokemon would be benificial to the Metagame at large, but I also think that it would be a nice change of pace for the CAP community. I am interested in seeing how the community will go about balancing, while not nerfing, this tentative Pokemon.
Consider the submission... you won't regret it!
Considering...and completely supporting. I really can't think of a better concept to help the metagame right now. I like the idea, however, one nitpick. Change "Wall" to "Tank". I don't like the idea of an outright wall, but something along the lines of say, Zapdos or Appliance Rotom would be good. Those examples can "Wall" threats, but still hit things hard on the offensive too. This would also help you fit it onto offensive and stall teams, much like Vaporeon or Zapdos can.
linton said:Well, this would be an alright concept but what about the predictable CAP6/Blissey walling combo. Though I guess the whole typing thing would need to be discussed first. But it's a good concept never the less.
If you're already comparing this to SkarmBliss, know that "walling combinations" generally won't get you far in D/P/Pt. You need a full stall team core if you want something to compare to SkarmBliss in ADV, because things like Mixape and Mixnite tear right through it.
rippersteveM5 said:I could see this working maybe if it shared common weaknesses / counters to Blissey so it there wouldn't be CAP6/Blissey in every team. Then again if they both had a common counter the metagame could overcentralise to that counter...just something to dwell on. I'm tired, so sleepy time for me now.
Again, not needed really, see Mixape/Mixnite example. All you need is something that can go mixed with good type coverage really. It wouldn't overcentralize, because there's always going to be more than one thing that can take care of both.
Lightning Storm said:I agree with what other people are saying, that if this pokemon becomes a physical bliss, everyone will use two slots for bliss/CAP 6. I think this will cause even MORE centralization. It cuts the amount of physical attackers down to those that can deal with CAP 6, or people will just play more special sweepers. But if everyone plays Bliss/Cap 6, That's only 4 slots for any team left, which will be taken up by either the few physical sweepers that can handle CAP 6, the few special sweepers that can handle Blissey, or a mixture of those pokemon. In my opinion, this would over-centralize the metagame. Not to totally plug my concept, but IMHO, a pokemon that has specific counters that don't work in other situations will create more variety, due to the occasional team carrying CAP6 (there's 1 more pokemon right there), and the occasional team carrying on of the few
not-so-useful-otherwise CAP 6 counters, adding more variety. My specific concept being a shapeshifter pokemon, which would demand counters that almost by definition have to not be used otherwise.
Just my 2 cents.
How do you know? What about people who don't like playing stall, obviously they won't pack two slots for either of them. You don't need to be able to deal with Blissey to be successful in the metagame. You can just pack other members that can, like Machamp or Revenankh. Walls can be played around usually, and if you can't, then you're not that good a player. A good player should be able to play around certain threats in order to achieve their goal, unless their backup plans are taken out. In that case, you were outplayed anyway. You don't need physical sweepers or special sweepers that can deal with physical/special walls, that's why there are 5 other members in your
team.
LonelyNess said:Also, both Stall and Offense gain something in this, it's not all to one side. Stall obviously gains a new toy for its team, but Offense gains something that can take a few hits and provide a pivot Pokemon (one that you switch to in transition to one of your other Pokemon).
I can't think of anything other than a Pokemon that deftly counters the entire metagame that would be more benificial to the current world of Pokemon.
This is where what I said earlier comes in, change it to "Tank". Wall implies Blissey, where it really can't do much besides sit there and take hits. Tank implies it can do something back, a la Zapdos or Skarmory. Tanks generally can fit into both offense and stall teams, while dedicated walls usually go with stall.