*sigh* I've tried to explain politely. But you didn't understand. Are you seriously that dense?What exactly is wrong with the characteristics?
The characteristics are fine. But because they are on such a subjective topic, it is a given that they will not be ideal for everyone. Therefore, while they represent something we all want, they themselves are not "perfect" for some people. Therefore, they should not be something we are bound to. They can be an excellent reference, be an excellent suggestion or guideline, but to use them so strictly and never roam from getting exactly the metagame that they describe will not leave everyone happy.
So I'm am trying to tell you that they are fine to use but to branch out a little and have some compromises is perfectly fine, because we try to please as many people as possible. Majority rules, remember?