Okay, I'm going to post some thoughts on the game right now, since we really need to start lynching scum if we want a chance to win this thing.
The only thing we can know for certain this round is that the mafia wanter UncleSam dead. He was definitely the most vocal member of the village and the mafia thought that he needed to die more than any other member of the group, even more so than a claimed vigilante. That's right, we know that UncleSam was deemed more of a threat to the mafia than a vigilante, and Sam didn't have a power role, or at least didn't confirm one, meaning the mafia didn't know he had one if he did.
Since UncleSam wouldn't shut up, the mafia had to shut him up. This means he was a serious threat to the mafia, and that Sam was probably on the right track when he posted suspicions. However, we must see that Sam also voted for a townie both times. Why would the mafia want to kill a non-power role that has mislynched both times? Because his other suspicions were correct. Sam just wanted the day to end on Day 2, and everyone wanted to off Galladiator Day 1.Let's look at the people Sam voted for and why he changed:
Day 1:
He voted Fangren for bandwagoning No Lynch
He changed to Galladiator for bandwagoning No Lynch
He changed to polelover for bandwagoning No Lynch despite being an experienced player
He changed back to Galladiator for panicking and bringing up wolves, despite being an inexperienced player.
He changed to Spiffy for not being godkilled. He thought it was suspicious that he only got a warning and Groshi was killed.
He changed to Galladiator again because he saw it as the smallest risk for the village. Galla claimed no night role so Sam thought that even if he was town, nbd if lynched.
Then came the uber-tl;dr post that Sam wrote on page 9. Basically an invective against Galladiator. The rest of D1 goes on and Galladiator gets lynched.
Day 2:
He votes polelover again, this time to kickstart the day with a suspicion.
He switches to Isaac 2.0 for bandwagoning and being more suspicious than masterful. He supports a masterful lynch, though.
He unvotes, Isaac claiming bodyguard.
He goes to J-Man, claiming inactivity.
he also claims here that if J-Man is mafia, so is polelover
He goes to rickheg, claiming bandwagoning.
Acklow then posts about CAP ASB, spurring my interest in it and forcing me to play ASB.
He then goes to Da Letter El for being closely related to Brammi and wants to pressure him
He lastly votes for masterful, wanting to end the day. Little did he know that those would be the last words he ever utters...
From his votes, he clearly suspected polelover, Da Latter El, and slightly rickheg
Our only other major lead is HSA's claiming of cop. I'm not so sure about this claim, but it's the only cop claim there is and it's for polelover. I voted for polelover once before, so I'm mildly suspicious of him.
Vote: polelover
I think there's more than enough information to call him scum.