Bumping Lucario to challenge the Nasty Plot set (or better yer Lucario itself)
It's certainly safe to assume that Lucario commonly runs one of two sets in the current metagame: its standard Swords Dance or Nasty Plot sets. Any other set would make Lucario underwhelming in comparison to sets with +2 boosts.
General traits of each set
Swords Dance:
- Swords Dance Lucario is a dangerous sweeper, capable of screwing over various types of team when it gets the chance to boost its Attack. These opportunities are many due to Lucario's decent typing and resistance resistance to common entry hazards.
- The above is amplified by Extremespeed, which beats most Pokemon without an immunity or resistance to Normal-type attacks. Extremespeed's new mechanics also lets Lucario beat some priority users to the punch. Arguably, without Extremespeed, Lucario would suffer as an OU sweeper.
- In addition to Close Combat and Extremespeed, Lucario has room for one more coverage option: Crunch for Ghost-types (especially Jellicent), or Ice Punch for the ubiquitous Gliscor and Dragonite. Choosing one over the other leaves Lucario extremely vulnerable to the aforementioned threats; without Crunch, Ghost-types threaten to burn you, while without Ice Punch, Gliscor and Dragonite have an easier time setting up on it.
- Lucario has the ability to smash through certain walls on defensively-oriented teams, mainly Skarmory (who is crippled after taking a Close Combat) and bulky Water-types (most are hit for an OHKO), which is fairly nice.
Nasty Plot:
- An innovative, if not somewhat overhyped, use of Lucario this generation, more focused on raising Lucario's Special Attack and going all-out with Aura Sphere.
- With Special moves, Lucario has the ability to bypass more physical walls in addition to additional threats
- Doesn't have to set up to beat certain Pokemon, such as Gliscor and Skarmory.
- Also relies on priority in the form of Vacuum Wave, allowing Lucario to hit faster Steel- and Rock-type Pokemon. This comes at the cost, however, of giving Lucario redundant coverage and a weaker move.
- A move that could replace Vacuum Wave would be Hidden Power, giving Lucario additional coverage against Gastrodon (Grass) or 4x Ice-weak threats. The latter is preferable due to the popularity of Dragonite.
- Isn't crippled by burn.
So judging from the way both sets play, I'd like to ask this question:
Is there any actual point to using Nasty Plot Lucario competitively outside of Vacuum Wave (to hit Terrakion of all things) and special moves?
or:
Why should we use Nasty Plot Lucario?
From what I see, Swords Dance Lucario does the same thing Nasty Plot does, including breaking through defensive threats (with a more powerful move, too!) and just being a threat that just doesn't care about hazards. The popularity of threats such as Latios, Deoxys-S, and Landorus leaves Vacuum Wave's advantages to be desired, even though you now hit Terrakion (a common check to Swords Dance). I personally prefer ExtremeSpeed's neutral coverage (relative to Psychic- and Flying-types) and additional power over Vacuum Wave's more specific use (relative to faster Steel- and Rock-type Pokemon). Even if we take Vacuum Wave out of the question, you may as well be using another special sweeper if Lucario has to resort to subjective measures to beat some threats (read: Lucario's Hidden Power Ice vs Starmie's Ice Beam).
Finally, I don't use Nasty Plot Lucario simply because there's so many specially defensive threats in OU that lowers its practicality. Things like Blissey, Chansey, Jirachi, and Gastrodon can cripple Lucario in time, even though they might be 2HKOed by Aura Sphere (which is more than enough time). +2 Close Combat instantly slaughters them.
If anybody uses Nasty Plot Lucario (at all), kindly explain why others should use it rather than Swords Dance, which, as explained above, does better in the metagame where it's at. Hey, I'd really like to use it, but I hate having to stack sweepers just to get rid of the many faster Psychic- and/or Flying-type threats. Judging by the way others play, I'm also under the impression that it's played just
because.