I don't disagree that much, and some of the responses are just that.. responses, not counter arguments.
TheValkyries said:If he doesn't slide at the end of his runs or doesn't run out of bounds and continues to take hits from Linebackers, yes, his running is certainly a detriment rather than an asset. But in these past two years he has not been running with as much risk, and has said that he is consciously making effort to keep his body safe.
Is that so? If he scrambles once in a while like Rodgers, then i'd be fine with it. But like i said his speed gives a very good reason to put himself in needless harm. But if you say that his focus has changed on not getting brought down, then he might be able to last all 16 games. But i'm not totally convinced he has it down to a science.
TheValkyries said:How does Eli Manning avoid the sack? It's certainly not his intelligence or his ability to read defenses, because if that were actually any good he wouldn't have unxpected pressure in his face, and he would have thrown it off to his hot read already (Which is what Peyton and Brady do, and it's how they make poor lineman look rather good). Eli on the other hand throws the ball away just before he gets hit, and is good at extending plays by avoiding the first contact or sliding it off him. That doesn't prevent the various incoming hits from happening just as much as Vick's style doesn't. The hit still happens, and now we'd just argue about semantics in to which brand of hit is harder. A linebacker hitting you as you're running/sliding, or a DEnd hitting you while you're standing upright after a pass. Point is it's a myth that Running QB's get hit more often than not. However, the running QB exposes himself to injuries to the knees and so forth that will affect their ability to play for a whole season (i.e. to their knees and ankles and so forth), which is certainly a disadvantage, but it's not because they take more hits, it's rather the style of hits.
Didn't you just prove my point then? If Vick does get a blown knee or a tear, it would affect him much more than it would a generic pocket quaterback. Since he relies on his legs more and his body will never return to what it used to be. So yes, Running QBs are more vulnerable to injury based solely on the fact that they rely on their body much more. And while they may take the same amount of hits in the end, their is always the posibility of worse hits on a quaterback who willingly walks into an area filled with defenders. Though this is of little concern if, like you say, Vick is avoiding contact at this point.
TheValkyries said:Barring some career ending injury, the Athletic players will last longer than most because they keep their body in shape. You think it's magic that keeps Randy Moss at the level at which he plays for so long? Do you think it was pure willpower that kept Jerry Rice in the league for 20 years? No. These guys keep their bodies at peak physical condition, and that makes it easier for them to keep coming back and playing at a high level. Eli doesn't have that kind of body. In reality the thing that keeps Running QBs out of the league is that they can't rely on their legs as much, and it exposes them as poor pocket passers. However, Vick is out there showing that he can stay in the pocket and pass well, as did Elway in his time, or Steve Young or many of those other types of players.
I'll let you compare Elway to Vick, but remember the three most consistent/"healthiest" quaterbacks in NFL history are all almost identical: Brett Favre, Peyton Manning and Eli. Eli being the third quaterback with most consecutive starts and the only one in the top 5 whos streak is alive. Like you said, career ending injury aside, Eli is the only quaterback playing right now that can ever hope to beat Favre(though to be honest in all likelihood Eli will retire after winning a SB..). So in terms of potential longevity, Eli has no current equal and doesn't need to be incredibably athletic. And your point only works if you assume Vick is as talented as Rice/Moss... Which i don't exactly believe right now.
TheValkyries said:Both are evasive in the same way. Eli ducks and slides away from pressure, and his escape is very subtle and minimalistic, whereas Vick just outruns everyone. Both use their feet, and both will be unable to rely on such a tactic as they get older. Neither read Defenses exceptionally well (You think Eli does, but he does not) and both are calm under pressure (and they should be when almost 40% of their dropbacks last season came under pressure).
Are you not contradicting yourself here? You call Elis movements "minimalistic" and "subtle" yet you also go on to say that he won't be able to do this in say 5 years? If you think about it, Elis playing style fits what an older quaterback could do without overextending themselves. Unless you think it takes that much effort? To be clear, not many people could do it, just that i don't think age will deprive him of the sufficient amount of energy to move around in a way you called "minimalistic". And by older, i'm assuming Eli will not play beyond 38.
TheValkyries said:At this stage, Eli and Vick are outstandingly similar. Eli definitely has the edge in performance under pressure (His drop off in accuracy is much less than Vick's), whereas Vick has the edge in athletic ability, and accuracy (Part of why Vick's under pressure drop off is steep is because his accuracy when not under pressure is ridiculously high to begin with). It's also funny to point out, that both rely heavily on the long Ball to play well (Eli's short game "development" this year is thanks to one man with the initials V.C.), and Vick does the deep game far better than Eli.
Remember one word: McCoy. Eli had the misfortune of a nearly non existant running game. So his passing stats suffered because of that(which is insane if you think about it).Give Eli a dangerous running game and i don't think this comparison will happen again. Though i won't predict anything(*cough*mvp*cough*) and going with this year only i guess i'll accept the comparison.. for now.
Wikey said:I think Tebow actually does work hard but just lacks talent. I think Sanchez doesn't work hard because he realized he would have to work his ass off just to be Brad Johnson and girls would sleep with him even if he sucked.
Tebow untalented??? He may not be the most accurate passer in the world but is far from lacking talent. Though his exercises confuse me. I saw him pushing a car... In what situation would a quaterback ever need the ability to push something?