SJCrew said:No that is not more reliable. Nothing you listed in that post included examples of what makes her more reliable than Nidoking. You went through and handwaved all of my examples of common Pokemon she is unable to check due to her low speed with weak reasoning like "I can use teammates for that." The entire point of an offensive Pokemon is to clean house and work for its team, which Nidoking has been doing since the beginning of Black and White while Nidoqueen set up rocks and died. Now she's suddenly better because "bulk"?
Ahem.
Nidoqueen is just as effective at killing things, doesn't die to a light breeze and is a far better check to Heracross, Mienshao, Zapdos, Raikou... (things that can't OHKO it in general). Which is what I meant by being "more reliable". She didn't get suddenly better, good players have been using Queen over King for a decent while now. Handwaving? Maybe you're not just not paying attention, because half of the Pokemon you mentioned don't usually
run speed. There are some obvious exceptions (Suicune) but the vast majority of the time you're looking at min speed Suicune. Nidoking can outspeed Chandelure, Kingdra(it ties with some of them) and tie with opposing Nidoking. That's great, and it totally didn't stop being a thing or anything, thats like its best advantages it has over Nidoqueen. My main point is that you're seriously overstating how good said advantages are, because let's be real here, they're inconsequential in the grand scheme of things. Base 85 speed on an offensive Pokemon is not good in any sense of the word... like, Nidoking isn't winning any awards for being in that speed tier, because in comparison to everything else in UU it's goddamn slow.
Nidoqueen isn't even that bulky. Most Fighting-types and other sweepers with a boosting item can just run right through her as she switches in (Heracross and Mienshao, for example) or straight up OHKO her at +2 with SR damage. The Electric-types you mentioned still 2HKO her with HP Ice as she switches in while Raikou just OHKOs her with +1 LO HP Ice after SR. Specs Rotom-H OHKOs with Overheat. Both Nidos are 3HKOed by Jolly Hera's CC after SR.
Nidoqueen fairly bulky for an
offensive Pokemon. For some reason, you're still under the impression that Nidoqueen users just throw it at Fighting-types/Electric-types willy nilly and except to counter them, which doesn't happen in practice. Your hand picked calcs are convenient, but my point was to show you that Nidoqueen can actually be used to somewhat check Electric-types while Nidoking is damn near worthless at checking them.
+1 Raikou vs Nidoking: Hidden Power Ice: 266-314 (87.5 - 103.28%) -- 56.25% chance to OHKO after Stealth Rock
+1 Raikou vs Nidoqueen: Hidden Power Ice: 240-284 (69.36 - 82.08%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
LO Zapdos vs Nidoking: Hidden Power Ice: 246-290 (80.92 - 95.39%) -- 12.5% chance to OHKO after Stealth Rock
LO Zapdos vs Nidoqueen: Hidden Power Ice: 222-262 (64.16 - 75.72%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Stealth Rock
As for Heracross vs the Nidos. Both of them are 3HKOed by CC... but Nidoking only avoids the 2HKO if it's at max health.
Heracross vs Nidoking: Close Combat: 118-140 (38.81 - 46.05%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Stealth Rock
Heracross vs Nidoqueen: Close Combat: 107-126 (30.92 - 36.41%) -- 99.9% chance to 3HKO after Stealth Rock
-If Nidoking has taken 20~ damage, it's 2HKOed by CC.
-If Spikes & SR are up, it's 2HKOed CC.
There's also Earthquake from Heracross (that didn't stop being a thing either)
Heracross vs Nidoking: Earthquake: 264-312 (86.84 - 102.63%) -- 56.25% chance to OHKO after Stealth Rock
Heracross vs Nidoqueen: Earthquake: 238-282 (68.78 - 81.5%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Stealth Rock
Nidoqueen has the luxury of staying in and tanking EQ, which is relevant in situations where Scarf Heracross is matched up vs Nidoqueen & Ground immune / resist, and there's always the chance the Heracross could predict and attacking using a coverage move.
(which actually just happened to me so...)
Really, I think yuou're marginalizing how useful of an offensive check Nidoqueen is to Heracross. Heracross is basically "a" King. If you're effective against the king, you're really good, it's that simple. Nidoqueen is more effective against Heracross than Nidoking and has the bulk to check (and avoid kos) multiple threats. Do you have any idea how many options that gives you? Nidoking is ONLY an attacker, Nidoqueen can play offense AND defense.
At the end of the day, Nidoqueen is beating less Pokemon than Nidoking, period. Players that prefer her for checking Scarf Hera is one thing, but saying she outclasses Nidoking? lol, bullshit. I'd honestly rather her not be in A-tier at all, but putting Nidoking in B-tier is a joke and ruins the credibility of this list.
That is not in dispute here. Nidoqeeun is unmistakably better than Nidoking in UU, like its almost an objective fact. Never did I mention that she outclassed Nidoking (as outclassed would imply that Nidoking doesn't really have a niche over Nidoqueen). And it's not like i'm pulling this out of my ass either, RT's team (one of the best UU teams mind you) makes better use out of Nidoqueen despite the fact that his team is massively weak Chandelure.
What does that tell you? I've also happened to watched a decent chunk of UU open matches (not spoiling teams / players) and I noticed a hell of lot more players using Nidoqueen over Nidoking.
You can argue that Nidoking is A tier but don't try and make your case by simultaneously putting Nidoqueen down, because it won't work. Nidoking is just an example of someone who doesn't really translate that well in battle at all, in the sense of being like his "on paper" sense. On paper, he's one of your best damage dealers throughout the course of the game, and a obscene wallbreaker. In battle, he's not
quite as good. He's got awesome power, but disappointing speed and even unimpressive bulk.
---
For the purpose of settling this, i'm going to quote some great UU players
FlareBlitz said:The best players in the tier, including myself, prefer offensive Nidoqueen over Nidoking because it can actually check Heracross and Mienshao and Zapdos and Raikou and Flygon and [insert Pokemon above Nidoking's mediocre speed tier with powerful attacks]. Offensive Nidoqueen is not only not OO material, it should be the first set in the analysis, no questions asked. You really should have written that before the defensive set, because I can't even remember the last time I saw a defensive nidoqueen.
RT. said:Nidoqueen is one of those Pokémon that got a whole lot better with the transition to BW2. On this team, it functions as an offensive SR setter and a solid Heracross/Mienshao check. Even now, some people still don’t expect Nidoqueen to be running an offensive set, which usually lets it net a few surprise KO’s. The advantages of using it over Nidoking aren’t limited to its surprise factor, however. The extra bulk is very helpful in taking hits from the various Fighting-types in the tier, and also lets it check Zapdos and Raikou more effectively. In my experience, the drop in speed is hardly noticeable. The 168 Speed EVs gives it a stat of 230, which is enough to outrun Modest Gothitelle and all relevant walls that can tank a hit from Nidoqueen. Stealth Rock and Earth Power are self-explanatory; Fire Blast is useful for crippling Bronzong and ensuring I can OHKO Heracross in a pinch, while Ice Beam nails Flying-types and easily dispatches Flygon if it tries to switch in.
Well there ya go, 2 really good UU players praising Queen over King.