Texas Cloverleaf said:This is somewhat true in that Durant is capable of running 4 sets effectively, Scarf, Band, Hone Claws and 4 attacks; but fails to take into account how each perform. When running Scarf Durant you are always at a perilous risk of missing your revenging attack and losing your revenge killer, often getting swept from that point out. In the SPL I ran Swarm Scarf Durant which, while effective, was hardly a paragon of power and could not decimate teams to a great extent.
To begin again, Swarm Durant? Why would you ever choose to run a swarm Durant. Hustles accuracy drop yes can be quite the flaw, but hustle will always trump swarm. Hustle is the basis of Durant's massive power. Without it, while still being viable, is B Rank. Swarm should almost never be used on Durant. 80% is admittedly not the greatest odds, but if that's the reason you would be losing, run a separate revenge killer. Plus, Some other revenge killers moves, like focus blast, have only 70% accuracy. 70% is even worse than 80% and Sceptile and Accelgor run it all the time. In order to use Durant effectively, take time to analyze his 4 sets and decide which one is the best for you
Texas Cloverleaf said:This too is true, except that it hold true for every offensive Pokemon. Resists are the base building blocks of Pokemon and being able to deal heavy damage to Pokemon that don't resist your attacks is a very basic quality. The problem lies when your Pokemon has its attacks resisted and cannot effectively break past its counters. Qwilfish, Poliwrath and Steelix are all heralded as counters to Durant for the simple fact that they are bulky and also resist its attacks. I struggle to think of any offensive Pokemon that is considered good, that doesn't threaten Pokemon that don't resist its attacks.
While Durant honestly doesn't have ghost fighting coverage, That doesn't mean its hits hit everything not very effectively. IMO, I've played with Durant a lot and Steelix
does not counter Durant. Every good Durant set runs superpower, which, even only at plus one, sends the massively bulky Steelix to the hills. Plus, with Durant's
112 base defense Steelix isn't going to be taking it out. 252Atk Life Orb +1 Hustle Durant (+Atk) Superpower vs 252HP/252Def Steelix (+Def): 90% - 106% (322 - 378 HP). Guaranteed 2HKO. 42% chance to OHKO. This is full bulky Steelix having a 42% chance to be
OHKO'd by only a plus one Durant. As for Poliwrath and Qwilfish, you make a valid point. However, 252Atk Life Orb +1 Hustle Durant (Neutral) Superpower vs 160HP/0Def Water Absorb Poliwrath (Neutral): 97% - 114% (352 - 414 HP). Guaranteed 2HKO. 85% chance to OHKO, This is Durant at only a plus one against a SubPunch Poliwrath. Qwilfish reliably counters Durant, but every Pokemon has counters, regardless of how good they are.
Texas Cloverleaf said:The issue when running Wide Lends is that you sacrifice an item slot desperately needed to be successful. Every relevant offensive calculation for Durant is provided at +1 and with a Life Orb. Life Orb is a key component to its power, and without that item it is much easier to check. Alternatively, Lum Berry is commonly used to allow Durant a chance at easier set up, letting it potentially reach +2 without difficulty. You also cannot run Choice sets with Wide Lens in tow. By running Wide Lens you sacrifice these otherwise key items in exchange for only gaining 10% accuracy on your attacks; still a 1/10 miss chance.
Every relevant calculation? Life Orb is often a necessity and hustle already makes him powerful, but every relevant calculation. That is simply false. X-Scissor already packs an INCREDIBLE wallop with only hustle and LO, and to be clear, when I said wide lens was a possibility, I didn't mean wide lens was even close to being his best option. Life Orb does give him the extra punch he needs. However, If you have a solid enough RU team and the primary reason you fail is not power, but accuracy. It is a possibility that you might want to run a wide lens. Yes, LO is almost always a better choice, but the Smogon article here
http://www.smogon.com/dp/items/wide_lens says that if accuracy is your greatest downfall, consider a Wide Lens.
Texas Cloverleaf said:This part is simply blatantly false. While the first statement is true, its power and speed are impeccable (accuracy aside), Durant does not and cannot guarantee a kill a match. In order to have a chance at a guaranteed kill Durant must first set up a Hone Claws, no easy feat with its piss poor bulk. Furthermore, if the opponent runs an aforementioned physical wall, especially Qwilfish and Poliwrath, Durant will never get a kill in that match under normal circumstances. Furthermore, Sceptile and Accelgor are not relevant as prominent checks, and neither can ever switch in lest they be KOd, and both must run Hidden Power Fire to reliably revenge kill Durant or else be victim to Focus Blasts 70% accuracy.
Your first statement is spot on, his power and speed are impeccable. But if played right, there is a 95% chance for Durant to hit something hard. Unless the team is Qwilfish, Poliwrath, Steelix maybe, Sceptile who is already unburdened, Accelgor, and maybe a Cryogonal as a revenge killer, Durant is going to hit something, and probably kill it. I didn't say he was unbeatable, I said he was good. Definitely good enough for low S rank. So,
Durant for S Rank. He is a good, fast, strong, well typed Pokemon who is incredible in the RU Pokemon.