Halcyon of Light said:I wouldn't say that Porygon2 is easy to fit on teams...I mean, it could be the glue for teams that are weak to Gyara and Salamence, but other than that, I don't see what teams would think "well Porygon2 is the obvious choice for this slot." No one is arguing that Porygon2 does its job well, because it does. The issue is that it isn't really needed, since there are other Pokémon that do the same thing like Rotom-W. Yes the two are different, I'm just saying they both counter those two things. I think Porygon2 is fine where it is now. It has a niche, and it's good at that niche, but I don't think many teams really need that niche filled. At least, not enough for B ran and definitely not enough for A rank.
Porygon2's role isn't countering gyarados and salamence, while I suppose someone looking to do just this would have a great time with porygon2. Nobody thinks 'well Porygon2 is the obvious choice for this slot.' because of its low usage – people haven't tried it and don't understand its capabilities. Porygon's true capabilities lie in its tanking. He's something to switch to, and when switched to isn't helpless like other defensive pokemon. Maybe check out the damage calculations above or the replays I posted to better understand this.
Dark Fallen Angel said:I personally dislike Porygon2 and disagree for it being more than B- Rank, if it even deserves that rank. For starters, yes, Porygon2 has acess to BoltBeam coverage, but Porygon2 struggles to damage anything that is not weak to either Ice Beam or Thunderbolt, and the list of Pokémon that fit this category is surprisingly large, and many of them do not even mind Toxic, Thunder Wave, or both. Ferrothorn, Scizor, Tyranitar, Heatran (however if Porygon2 is able to switch on Heatran, the latter cannot do much to the former due to Flash Fire being traced), Jirachi, Terrakion, and Kyurem-B, and they are not all the examples, just some of the most relevant. In fact, most of those Pokémon can use Porygon2 as setup bait, for example, you can simply switch Ferrothorn and then use Leech Seed, or use the opportunity to setup Stealth Rock or Spikes. Because none of Porygon2' moves can do decent damage or cripple Ferrothorn, it is setup bait for the metal jackfruit.
Porygon2 is very bulky, but it simply cannot wall many Specs/Band users, and will fall to most setup sweepers once they have setup-ed, especially as it has no resistances to begin with. Also, because it has to use Eviotile, it is vulnerable to passive damage, just like Chansey, a Pokémon that you were comparing to Porygon2.
Actually many of the pokemon you listed can be taken out by porygon2.
Scizors are usually banded, and the move of choice is always superpower.
252+ Atk Choice Band Scizor Superpower vs. 252 HP / 184+ Def Eviolite Porygon2: 236-278 (63.1 - 74.33%)
It's really easy to predict and Porygon2 can just recover to lower scizor's attack since it is slower than scizor. It can then just kill it with thunderbolt. I have used this strategy many times. Porygon2 should switch out for a swords dance Scizor, however.
Tyranitar is taken out by toxic. Superpower is again, very predictable.
Porygon2 would usually switch out against a Jirachi, however, it is possible for Porygon2 to stay in against physical Jirachis and try to paralyze Jirachi with a serene grace boosted discharge, with many opportunities thanks to Porygon2's bulk. Calm Mind Jirachi's are only 17% of Jirachis but still, Porygon2 can't do much against them, especially if they are behind subs.
Kyurem-B is toxic stalled
252 Atk Kyurem-B Outrage vs. 252 HP / 184+ Def Eviolite Porygon2: 132-156 (35.29 - 41.71%) -- guaranteed 3HKO
Some choice spec and band users are a threat to porygon2, but not as many as you might think.
252 SpA Choice Specs Latios Dragon Pulse vs. 252 HP / 72 SpD Eviolite Porygon2: 144-169 (38.5 - 45.18%)
252 SpA Choice Specs Latios Draco Meteor vs. 252 HP / 72 SpD Eviolite Porygon2: 220-261 (58.82 - 69.78%)
-2 252 SpA Choice Specs Latios Draco Meteor vs. 252 HP / 72 SpD Eviolite Porygon2: 111-132 (29.67 - 35.29%) (cannot be 2hkod)
Ferrothorn being able to get a free hazard in on porygon2 isn't reason to not raise it to B. Bronzong has the same issue.
I feel like you're only looking at the Pokemon that can check it and not all of the pokemon that it can check. But I would say the checks for Porygon2 would constitute a B rank instead of an A rank. Many of the other B rank pokemon have flaws, pointing these out isn't much of a reason to exclude it from B.
PK Gaming said:Supporting Pokemon in this rank may give opponents free turns or cannot create free turns easily themselves, but can still do their job most of the time.