Pocket said:@
Ulevo , I would not consider Manaphy, Thundurus, and Tornadus-T as "several" Pokemon being banned due to Rain, especially when you consider all the numerous non-broken OU Pokemon that benefits from Drizzle. Some even believe that Thundurus would be broken independent of Rain, due to its 111 Speed tier / Prankster / Nasty Plot. What was really problematic was the synergy between the two abilities Drizzle + Swift Swim, and the community made the right decision to clause the interaction of these two separate abilities. Aldaron's Proposal and Excadrill ban were two major bans that solved most of the power imbalance among weather and between weather vs weatherless teams.
Basically, weather (Rain) isn't inherently broken; but the interaction between two abilities created a broken combination, which was quickly removed from BW (and should probably be removed from XY if Rain exists). Outside of some irregular Pokemon like Manaphy and Tornadus-T, Rain did not break any Pokemon and only served as an additional viable playstyle that people can elect to play.
"Several" fits my definition; its more than two. On top of this, we're now discussing whether or not Keldeo, another Pokemon that benefits from Drizzle, should be tested. Not that I am going to make this about semantics, but progress on these dicussions are lost due to miscommunication more than anything, so its important that we're on the same page.
1) I am not sure what Pokemon being banned due to rain and Pokemon benefiting from Drizzle have to do with one another.
2) Even if Pokemon do benefit from Drizzle, there are arguably more Pokemon that are made obsolete due to the necessity of using a weather like Drizzle to remain competitive in BW2 OU. Though, this is entirely irrelevant. We shouldn't be talking about what is "good" for a specific group of Pokemon when talking about what is and isn't appropriate to remain in the tier when it is suspected to be broken.
3) The reality of the matter is that the community, at Aldaron's proposition, bent the rules and traditions to satisfy a
preference under false pretences and limited information. I'm not arguing that Drizzle when combined with Swift Swim wasn't a problem. Blaziken when combined with Speed Boost was also a problem. We didn't make a complex ban of no Blaziken + Speed Boost to preserve Blaziken. We had to make a decision to ban either Speed Boost, or Blaziken, and a decision was made.
The only reason people humored Aldaron's idea was because it was assumed that Drizzle by itself wouldn't become a problem, and that the complex ban would increase variety in OU. I am arguing that there is evidence to support the contrary.
4) Rain is not a playstyle, it's a battlefield condition that benefits a select group of Pokemon out of an otherwise potentially larger group. I don't particularly care for this argument because suspect testing
properly is about making decisive actions against what is broken versus what is not, not what players prefer to play with. I'm just pointing out that I don't buy the supposed net benefits of this pretense.
Essentially I see this as a game of playing favourites. I do agree there was a time when a decision about Drizzle and Swift Swim needed to be made, but I do not believe the decision was correct. We lacked the proper analysis of what the metagame shifts would be based on our decisions, and even on principle it lacked justification. I especially disagree with the notion of implementing it immediately come Gen VI. We don't even know if Drizzle will be legal, whether or not the new OU is cope to handle with Drizzle as a weather, or even if mechanic changes will be implemented that change rain as a weather condition. There could be many other factors to consider as well. We won't gain any relevant information about whether or not Drizzle is manageable in Gen VI by assuming guilty until proven innocent and banning it from the get go.