Infernis said:The most common spread for Mandibuzz is 252/4/252+ defensive. In this metagame, it's silly easy to get up hazards, and it's a requirement if you want your Jolly Golurk to always beat up Mandibuzz. Jolly Golurk outspeeds it and 2HKO's after rocks. The second most common is also outsped and 2HKO'd after rocks. The third one is much less common, but is outsped and 2HKO'd after rocks. The fourth one is also uncommon, and is outsped and 2HKO'd after rocks. And so forth. So while a Mandibuzz trainer playing smart could just try for a revenge kill with Mandibuzz, it can't really switch in. This is the point I am making.
I find this argument very dubious, as Adamant Golurk can also outspeed 0 Spe Mandibuzz (admittedly, if Adamant Golurk runs over 200 Speed EVs, or just go full 252 Speed), blowing Jolly Golurk's advantage out of the water as it still keeps its wallbreaking potential intact. Jolly Golurk is only more effective against Mandibuzz that run enough speed for Adamant but not for Jolly, and while that range is the standard, it's not the most common as you said.
I just think it's silly that people keep bringing up that Mandibuzz is always a surefire counter to Golurk when my Golurk has dozens and dozens of direct Mandibuzz KOs notched into its belt, probably more than any other Pokemon on the teams I use it on. It's entirely possible that people could just change their Mandibuzz a little and this wouldn't work anymore, but at the moment it's pretty solid on the ladder.
Let's be honest, nothing in the tier is really safe from a 2HKO from Adamant CB Golurk if SR is down. Mandibuzz, like other counters such as Alomo and Tangela, only fears select moves from a CB set and can switch into its other moves, but Mandi's advantage is that it outspeeds
most variants and OHKOes, something few counters can claim to do. This does make Mandi more of an offensive counter, but is still a counter as opposed to a check like Samurott or Jynx.
I do understand where you're getting at: not being made a liability against one of its most common switch-ins is
(usually) a step in the right direction (albeit exposing yourself to a whole lot more defensive pokemon), I'm just not sure I like how you go about doing this. The fact that you're Choice-locked means you still have to predict her switch-in with the correct move or you're screwed regardless, meaning your situation isn't much better off than the standard Adamant Golurk. I calced Life Orb and honestly it didn't make an ounce of difference with Choice Band: Basically if Golurk didn't go for Ice Punch first as Mandi switches into SR, it's still boned, but if it did go for Ice Punch on the switch-in, it can 2HKO Mandi. Since Jolly Golurk's wallbreaking potential has been impaired anyway, I'd say give LO a go so that Mandi won't force you to lock yourself into Ice Punch and can make use of its good coverage. Alternatively there's Expert Belt to bluff a CB set, but your bluff would have to be pretty convincing seeing as Jolly unboosted Golurk has an obvious power difference with Adamant CB Golurk.