Sergeant Spooky said:Uh, what are you doing? We know Mega Luke is way more powerful and probably more versatile than Aegislash, that's why it was almost unanimously banned.
But to continue the comparison: Mega Luke ran exactly one item, Lucarionite of course. Aegislash can run Leftovers, Spell Tag/Spooky Plate, Life Orb, Choice Band, Choice Specs, Air Ballon, Shuca Berry, Colbur Berry, and Weakness Policy all pretty well. It also has defensive capabilities way beyond Luke, and can Pursuit trap, unlike Luke.
Dude. Are you seriously going to argue that choice items on aegislash are "pretty well." Please tell me you aren't
Weakness Policy is also garbage in aegislash, and colbur is pretty pointless imo as you can just outspeed your main target for colbur anyway, bisharp. Shuca and everything else is pretty legit, but seriously? Choice items????
Besides, unless these items are radically different (Choice Band vs Choice Specs) they don't really add much to a pokemon's versatility.
Neither Aegislash or Mega Luke had a universal safe switch in by your own account here. Mega Luke had a number of reliable-ish checks, like Aegislash, but nothing could counter every set it could run, just like Aegislash. Mandibuzz and Chesnaught both lose to SubToxic and Flash Cannon sets, while Bisharp can't switch in to Sacred Sword (or check sets with Colbur Berry. Like I know it's a super rare item and most have never seen it used but Aegislash is an amazingly good user of weakness berries.)
Ok, so you switch in mandibuzz into aegislash. If you run some sp. def, the worst that could happen is you gettin toxic'd. Not too bad.
Meanwhile, if you switch your defensive lando-t into mega lucario and get smacked by a flash cannon, you're dead.
See the difference?
Also, bisharp can hold a focus sash, its uncommon but its a thing.
Maybe, if you're comparing to one the most hilariously broken things to ever grace OU.
I'm literally just using mega lucario as an example due to its versatility stop nitpicking the irrelevant details jesus christ. I could've just as easily used fucking infernape as an example.
Sergeant Spooky said:Difference between Talonflame and Aegislash is that, for one, Aegislash doesn't have much of an issue switching in to psychics and some fighting types (okay not most of them, pretty much just Mega Medicham.) Talonflame is really frail, I'm not even going to run calcs but I'm pretty sure it's OHKOed by Lati@s' Draco Meteor, takes a ton from Mega Garde's Psyshock and same with Alakazam. Slowbro counters Talonflame, actually. And Mega Medicham nearly OHKOs Talonflame with resisted HJK and OHKOs with Zen Headbutt, while Mega Heracross OHKOs with Rock Blast so it has trouble switching in to that too. Oh, and Bisharp and Mega Dos eat it with Focus Blast.
Talonflame is a revenge killer only. That's all it basically does. It also has a number of things that reliably counter it. Aegislash is a counter to those mons.
Wow you make it seem like the only talonflame set in existence is CB or something lmao, there's a beautiful fucking set called Bulk up+Taunt talonflame, (the rest is roost+brave bird) and its a beautiful moddafucking set. Talonflame with full sp. def could live a draco and easily roost that off. Seriously, give this set a go, you'll be surprised by how hardy talonflame is. I Was definitely caught off guard when this baby could set up on landorus and char-y.
C. Mega Heracross has both of Earthquake and Knock Off
Mega Heracross never uses knock off, and it never should.
Both are utterly insane when you think about it. Garde has one, singular good counter in Aegislash. Mega Scizor can counter but it hates burns a lot more than Aegislash. Everything else is a check at best; if they try to switch in to Psyshock/Focus Blast/WAIL OF THE BANSHEE they lose. Even Chansey needs to be at really high health to switch in to Psyshock, and it outright loses to any set that has Calm Mind or Taunt.
Even if megazor hates burns, the fact is that it can still just set SD on mega gardevoir and negate that, and then go from there. Besides, jirachi also stands out as a solid check to it, taking pretty much anything it wants to do. Not to mention that the mere presence of a steel type (not named lucario/cobalion) is enough to make mega gardevoir rely on the shaky focus blast, which is pretty significant pressure. After all, it's not as if aegislash can just shake away the burn either, its the most crippling status for it.
Aegislash is the only mon that reliably counters Garde and the best way of handling Cham. Why do you think Bisharp is a top partner for both of them? Cause any defensive team relying on Aegislash to take care of them is screwed if it gets pursuit trapped. I know, I know, "don't check broken shit with broken shit" but I'm not convinced any of Aegis/Cham/Garde are broken. Point is that getting rid of a counter to Cham/Garde, while making them more viable (as it would with any pokemon if you remove a prominent counter,) is not necessarily a good thing, cause both are stronk as living hell and are completely usable in OU.
Also can people stop pointing out obvious shit like "well but it's weak to erfquake."
Aegislash is not the best way of handling cham, it can't even switch into fire punch, and a Sub mega cham can force aegis into 50/50s with KS. Substitute does not change this 50/50 game much either. And dont' try to argue that Sub mega cham is irrelevant or rare; in CTC's sticky webs team, the mega cham set he uses is Sub/Fire Punch/HJK/zen headbutt, and its probably the best set for cham (cuz its priority is balls).
There are other unique pokemon one can use in order to combat mega garde (zor, rachi) and cham (slowbro, mew, cress), and some of these even beat bisharp 1v1.