Finally I have some time again...
WebBowser said:Synchronation I appreciate the detailed response to my post, and it certainly shows that I am not the most experienced with aegis. I have one question left though. In my post, I made the argument that for a given "50/50" caused by aegislash, if the opponent is a physical mon, the "50/50" will almost certainly be heavily weighted in aegis' favor, in that the reward for aegis predicting correctly is usually much higher then the reward to his opponent for predicting correctly. Do you believe this to be true? If not, why, if yes, do you believe that this is a bad thing?
Depends on your Pokemon. CB-Talonflame would have a problem and the favor in this case is definitely on Aegislash's side (the main reason why not many people uses CB-Talonflame anymore). If your opponent has a Pokemon that can ONLY attack Aegislash then the Kings Shield is not only obvious it is just the best answer.
This is however NOT true if you are a set-up sweeper because the Aegislash-user now risks letting your sweeper become unbeatable. I had alot of these situation as a Charizard-X player and Aegislash-user. I know that Flare Blitz definitely will kill me and Kings Shield is my only way to prevent that, but letting him dragondance instead going for the kill? The burden is on both side and not in Aegislash's favor at all. And like every prediction: If you predicted wrong, you are at a bad spot. If you predicted right, you have the advantage.
I don't think that this is bad. Aegislash is probably the MOST COMPETITIVE Pokemon ever existed. The main problem everybody has is that it has only one difference which makes it unique from other coinflips: It's not a switch you have to predict, it's a move (Kings Shield) and most people think that this is broken or not healthy. While I lost sometimes because I didn't use Kings Shield I also lost because I predicted a switch. That is normal and happens every day.
Haunter said:The real problem is that we never found an agreement on what can be considered 'broken' in Pokémon. While nobody in their right mind would argue that stuff like Mega-Kangaskhan or Mega-Lucario were healthy for the metagame, borderline cases like Aegislash make it extremely difficult for us to make a decision on its tiering and justify it. Aegislash is not blatantly overpowered as someone is claiming, though it's definitely a metagame-defining force.
And no,
MaryLa, I was not referring to you ahah.
I know and that is the problem. Aegislash doesn't sweept teams on its own, it doesn't wall or support so well that you could call it Uber. It is not really overcentralizing because every team has a SE attack to hit it but its still a meta defining Pokemon. But that is exactly the reason I vote for
no ban. We should ban Pokemon that are fullfill the right to be Uber not Pokemon who are really good (but not too good). I see alot of hate for Aegislash probably because they lost some battle predicting wrong against it, but they are forgetting all the battles in which they predicted right. I don't want to ban a Pokemon because some people feel "uncomfortable" to fight against it. I don't like to battle against certain Pokemon too but I don't say they should be banned even if I wouldn't care much.
MegaScizor said:While I agree with you that taunt mandibuzz is a fantastic aegislash counter, you now just admitted that you need two pokes to effectively handle aegislash, and that is the point the pro ban people are trying to make. However I am surprised more people arent mentioning taunt mandibuzz because that is without question the best attempt at a counter. Especially with the head smash variant being one of the less common sets.
However it is important to not be short sighted. If more and more people use taunt mandibuzz, more and more people will run head smash aegislash, and then people will change their counter to counter head smash varient and so on and so forth. THe point I am poorly trying to make is that aegislash defines the meta, and whenever his popular sets change so does the meta. That just doesnt seem to be a very healthy presence and it it why I would like him gone.
Hopefully you got the jist of my point, if not I will gladly attempt to clarify.
You missing out a important point here: Team-support.
Everybody knows that a fast Headsmash-Aegi would destroy Mandibuzz and everybody knows Mandibuzz carrys Taunt and Foul Play very often (in my opinion even the best set). Still only a very small amount uses this Aegislash and there are reasons for this:
1. The obvious one: why should I change my set so dramatically just for this one Pokemon? I have teammembers to deal with Mandibuzz.
2. This set might destroy Mandibuzz but fails to check and counter all the other Pokemon it should check. Most people uses Aegislash to deal with Lati@s or Mega-Medicham and switching in their attacks AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE. Head Smash reduced Aegislash's longevity and with NO RECOVERY it is just a NO GO. It is just way easier to have a Mandibuzz-Check to support Aegislash than letting him deal with one counter but making him useless.
That's why I doubt that Head Smash will ever remain for long. It is really just a gimmick even if it is mentioned as one of its movesets. It just looks good in theory but it just isn't practically.