Lair Of Judgment said:Wow, reading all these based explanations makes me wonder why no one realized this a couple of months ago, and suddenly, out of nowhere, the amount of hate being carried towards the shadow tag mons is just incredible, a while ago, more than half of the community never had any issues with shadow tag, it's amusing how the whole community changed it's decisions in such a short amount of time.
I know that dice, donkey, hack, sweep, myself, etc have been critical of tag from the beginning. Hugendugen can testify that I was bothering him about it quite early into XY, I went into SPL with the explicit intention of showing just what Shadow Tag can do, especially those that aren't Gengar. Nobody spoke up about it because the metagame was new and we wanted to see if adaptation was really an option. Our patience has run out and it's clear from the year long history of XY ubers that adaptation isn't possible because Tag can still adapt right back since Shadow Tag ubers is a game played in team builder.
Gonna snip your post up some and reduce it to the essential arguments where possible
shrang said:Anyway, this whole thing is ridiculous. -tl;dr I hate bans and everybody bans too much
Although I appreciate that you used this history lesson to illustrate that background from which your viewpoints were born from but it's irrelevant and mostly distracting. Even if we (collective for the entire smogon community) were just a bunch of shitty as players that banned a bunch of crap cause we couldn't be assed to adapt doesn't mean we don't have valid arguments concerning Shadow Tag. It's also entirely possible that we are right about this and that is completely independent from whatever else we decided to ban.
shrang said:The tier stuck to its mantra for two generations and a bit, and it's primarily the reason why I play this tier, because people understood that to be good at this game, you adapted to the metagame instead banning shit that pissed you off.
You are making the false assumption nobody has put the effort to adapt to the metagame. iirc, Dice has already listed examples on how the metagame has adapted to Mega Gengar. To provide another anecdote, I wasn't even aware that anybody beyond myself felt very strongly about the threat of Gothitelle. When I first started talking about him, it seemed like every other top player considered it a matchup reliant gimmmick that only works on Sticky Webs teams. You can even see that from the current placing on the viability threat list. I pretty much found out this week that, actually, now nearly every top player, including those that initially criticized Gothitelle, agree that it is an incredibly broken threat that removes the power of choice from the player. So yes, we have adapted our strategies to the metagame and they are in favor of abusing the uncompetitiveness of Shadow Tag to win far more games at the team preview than ever before.
If you think there is more adaptation that could take place, why don't you show us instead of making the blind claim that we haven't tried and aren't still trying. Every one of us want to win and every one of us would like to be known as that guy that conquered Shadow Tag.
Also, we certainly aren't here because we are a bunch of sissies that can beat Shadow Tag. On the contrary, I desperately need Shadow Tag if I want to remain a relevant player in tournaments. Anybody who knows anything about my battling and building habits know I'm pretty poor at picking up on player patterns and making smart plays. It's gotten to the point where I
ask the Helix Fossil to make difficult, no right answer plays for me. You can see this in my SPL games among others. My strengths as a player comes from the enormous amount of time and dedication I have put into studying this metagame which has given me a fairly strong familiarity with my potential options, making me a stronger teambuilder than otherwise, and allowing me to deconstruct the teams of others to identify weaknesses and identify patterns in teambuilding to some success. Shadow Tag allows me to emphasize these traits in my favor by constructing sure-fire win conditions basd on the building patterns of my opponents that I spend large amounts of time studying. It also eliminates the need to make difficult plays by removing the power of choice from my opponent and the tool through which they can display their strength of skill over myself.
I'm not advocating for a Shadow Tag clause because I can't handle it myself. I'm pushing for one because, above all else, I care about the ubers metagame that I have fallen in love with and about the ubers community that I want to share a beautifully deep and expressive game with.
shrang said:Banning Gengarite or Shadow Tag means betraying the fundamental reason that we play Ubers, and no, just because we call it "Shadow Tag Clause" does not change the fact that we banned it. If it looks, walks and quacks like a duck, I'm going to call it a duck.
I think you are trying to make a counter point to some semantics argument somebody else has presented. fwiw, I agree with you. I don't really care what we call whatever we are doing to Shadow Tag by clausing it. The main idea here is that it deserves to be removed from competitive play just as much a s all those other things we claused. I don't give two shits if you call it banning or not.
shrang said:However, I'm going to define uncompetitive simply as a game aspect or strategy that makes the game unfair and creates opportunities for one player that gives them an advantage over the other that handicaps them and is something that they cannot inflict on their opponent in return. You might think that this definition is pretty much the same as the one used in Dice's post, but the last bit is the most important.
It is the same. The difference is whether or not you recognize the illusion of choice as an actual choice. Opting to use Shed Shell on every one of your pokemon to avoid Shadow Tag may seem like you have a choice but, in reality, the extremely terrible team that you would be using has an extremely diminished shot at winning in comparision to just yoloing it and hoping you don't get fucked over by the Shadow Tag matchup. The illusion of choice is a very valuable concept in game design to help compensate for the physical limitations of video games and, yet, still give the player the impression that he is in control of their actions and that those actions have meaning. However, it's not very useful in a competitive environment like we have here where the players explicitly search every nook and cranny of the game's design to find the options that have the highest rate of success. The option that has the highest rate of success is trying to bullshit your opponent in the team builder with Shadow Tag. I think that has been pretty clearly demonstrated by the arguments of the XY ubers metagame's best players and in its tournaments so I won't repeat it.
shrang said:An example would be a hypothetical game mechanic that prevented you using Ubers against an opponent that were using Ubers. The other example, is obviously, what our clauses are based off, which is luck. Pretty much all of our clauses with the exception of Sleep and Species (which I'll address later) are based on luck, and for a good reason. Being lucky in a game that rewards luck so heavily gives the lucky player an advantage that the unlucky player cannot inflict back at them. You can run Moody vs opposing Moody players and it won't be the better player that wins, but the players who was most lucky with their boosts. The difference with Shadow Tag/Gengarite is that you have the option of using it against your opponent too. Your opponent might trap and kill some important mon on your team, but so can you. It is still fair. It's kind of like how both sides of the war had machine guns in World War I. Sure the machine guns were overpowered and it was very difficult to get rid of them without resulting in mass casualties, but the war was still relatively fair in the sense that both sides lacked a key advantage that the other could not inflict in return (very unlike how America had nukes and Japan didn't).
Your argument is fallacious because you automatically assume that when both players have Shadow Tag, the best player wins. This becomes a circular argument where you demonstrate it's a skilled based strategy because you have already assumed in your argument demonstrating so that it is skill based. The reality is that when two tag players play eachother, the one with the better team matchup will win consistently because it takes zero skill to apply your shadow tag strategy before the other guy when it already matchup in it's favor starting the game off with that player in the favorable position to do so. You using Shadow Tag abuser of your own doesn't allow you to reverse the ineeitable anymore than you could have without it. You just give yourself a shot at being that guy with the ez team matchup win instead of your opponent.
shrang said:Dice's uncompetitive definition: Okay imma break this down. Sorry to pick on you, Dice, but since your OP is what whole thing is based off, I may as well use that as my discussion point.
- Firstly, this definition was the one used in OU. This is actually important to note, because OU has very different standards from our
No it doesn't. The definition didn't establish what level of uncompetitive is the "cut-off". It just explicitly states what people meant when they used the made up term. It even outright says that it's up to us to determine if something is uncompetitive enough.
I hope you aren't going to try to argue that the OU relevant illustrative examples it provides are a part of the definition.
shrang said:- Autonomy: "Control of (the game's) events" is NOT what autonomy means. Auto = self, and nomy (nomos) = law. It means following a law that you set yourself, ie freedom to choose your own actions. So, I don't think we should even talk about autonomy because you are NOT free to choose your actions, as they are dictated to you by your circumstance and what you perceive to be the wisest move in a given setting.
Yes, you are free to choose your own actions as long as there isn't bullshit like Shadow Tag. Certain choices may imply more risk but sometimes those higher risk choices are the right choices because of there higher risk and the fact the cover options the lower risk choice does not. There is no objectively right choice when you are playing against another human being and his choices impact yours as much as your impact his. That illusion of choice occurs when you remove the power of choice from the other player with bullshit like Shadow Tag.
shrang said:- I can't see how Gengar itself makes poor players beat good players, tbh. I really think the main problem here would be the team matchup (which no amount of banning will EVER fix). The easiest test for this is if you take one of those things out, would it still make a poor player beat a good player? If we take away Mega Gengar, you'd still have a team matchup problem, which I were a shitty player that just counterteamed you, I'm still going win, Gengar or no. If you somehow take away team matchup but leave Gengar (which I know is impossible), would it really give me such advantage? I can honestly not give you a proper answer to this question, but I doubt anyone can, and if you can't answer that question, how can you that Gengar is uncompetitive?
https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/personal-incredulity
No we aren't trying to completely remove team matchup, just remove an element that pushed that factor to the point of eliminating that power of choice from the player. Yes, we have demonstrated that by all sorts of talks about the metagame based on extensive experience and logic. Unless you want us to speculate on what a Tag free metagame would look like? We could run a tournament for that!
shrang said:- Wobb/Skymin are not proper comparisons. Those two were banned in OU, and we're talking about Ubers. Don't compare apples and oranges. Neither Skymin nor Wobb were even considered for bans in Ubers in DPP even though they were banned in OU.
I think these were just the examples included in the citation. (idr the context and too lazy to go to page 1 to check) Ignore them, they don't change the definition nor the points that use it.
shrang said:Trapping: Okay, I get Shadow Tag and trapping is a big deal and you all hate how Gengar and Goth trap shit too easily. It DOES take control away from the game. However, what makes me completely unconvinced is the fact that you can run exactly the same thing. You can trap their weakest link and find a way to win too. Again, it is still fair game because you can retaliate in the same way, and if you couldn't, it's because your team is more susceptible to trapping than your opponent is, which means it's your own fault. Again, I understand team matchup changes how Gengar affects different teams and therefore one Gengar user might have a distinct advantage, but why is banning Gengar the solution? Sure, Gengar adds to the problem, but where's the logic in banning it? It's like blaming violent video games for mass shootings. You're not going to solve the team matchup issue by banning Shadow Tag and Gengarite, you know.
See earlier points. It's not about fair, it's about expressing ourselves and our abillities through the power of choice.
Also your video game example is bullshit because we can show the direct impact Shadow Tag which you can't do with video games and shooting.
shrang said:Stall: This argument is just dumb. Like really, we have the "cutting entire playstyles" bs in lower tiers, which is fine, because they are tiers don't have a big 'WE DON'T BAN SHIT" label on them. Firstly, if stall is wrecked by Gengar/Gothitelle, why should we care? If it's not viable, then you don't use it. It's not like you have to use stall to win games. Secondly, stall is thriving even with Gengar/Gothitelle around, so this entire thing is just retarded.
I agree, it's dumb to be presenting arguments like overcentralization and killing x playstyle as a reason to get rid of Tag. Those have never been valid arguments in ubers.