Not even a week....
irrelevant rant
This is pretty much aimed at the Council:
I get that you want to make up for lost time with these suspect tests, but seriously, hold your horses. Aegis has been gone less than a week. The meta hasn't had enough time to adapt. Sure, things like Starmie and the stall breaker megas are popping up, but that's only after a few days. That could possibly change in a few more days where other things pop up to take them on. Maybe it will happen, maybe it won't. Give the meta time and hold off a couple of weeks. ORAS May be coming in 3 months, but that's still more than enough time to give the meta breathing room to settle down. I felt this way when the Aegislash suspect was held, but I kept my mouth shut because I was hoping that we'd get more time before the next one. And I was wrong and I know it'll happen right after this one. Hold your ban hammers. The meta is playable. Maybe ideal, but it's not gonna kill anyone to hold off on suspects a couple of weeks in between. Part of the reason why I didn't try as hard as I could've for reqs last round was because I was still dealing with tilt from the previous suspect a week earlier. That, and I had to make a few new teams to fit into the new meta. If Mawile goes, that means even more teams have to be scrapped. I wouldn't Mind this if we had a suspect every few weeks, but we don't even get one. This is why outsiders hate Smogon. Last gen I wasn't around, but from what I've read it looked like they were about a month or so apart on average. I don't see why we can't do that now.
Hold off on suspects for a few weeks after the last one and let the meta settle. It won't kill anyone if you do so
Anyways, another suspect test that I'm torn on. On one hand, we have an absolute powerhouse that kills everything with Play Rough bar resists. On the other hand, we have a poke that is severely underwhelming pre mega and has very few switch in opportunities pre megas giant offensive teams. Intimidate is cool and all, but Mawile will still be taking a lot from special attacks and things like Mega Scizors Bullet Punch is still a 3HKO.
That aside, Mega Mawile is an absolute powerhouse. If you try and argue against that then you're a dumbass. Not very many things can switch into a Play Rough. Of those that do, the proper coverage move takes care of certain threats. Amoonguss is 2HKOed by Fire Fang, Heatran is OHKOed by Focus Punch, Venusaur lacking Sleep Powder
and HP Fire find themselves dead from Iron Head, and Ferrothorn dies from Fire Fang. TL;dr, coverage determines your counters. Of course, Lando-T doesn't care about any coverage moves thanks to Inimidate, but he can't switch in repeatedly.
Every hero has their downfalls. Mawile is no exception. Her Mega has great bulk physically and decent special bulk, but it's offset largely due to her low base HP. Pre mega, however, can't find very many opportunities to hard switch in. Intimidate helps a bit, but that's only physically and she's usually 3HKOed by neutral hits anyways. Don't bother sending her into a special attack. Even resisted hits hurt. Defensive teams are easier to switch into, but wisp bulkyzard doesn't give a shit about her. On top of her limited switch in opportunities, mawiles speed is shit. No ifs, ands, or buts. This does allow her to invest in bulk, but she's also required to take hits repeatedly. She also has no recovery bar rest. She does get a priority move, Sucker Punch, but it can be played around easily and Rotom and Zard can just spam will o wisp to cripple her. It creates 50-50s with certain pokes like Latias and Talonflame, but that's irrelevant (don't like it? Ban Bisharp). She's easily revenge killed by things that resist Sucker Punch or don't care about it that much (like Garchomp, Lando (T), and Keldeo), thanks to her aforementioned low speed.
Facts aside, I don't really know which side I'm on. I usually don't have too much trouble whenever I face her unless I fuck up and let her set up. But then again anything that's set up can sweep a team.