I wuv you said:I say no but I can't do a write up on it atm
Lord Cilan said:very compelling arguments.Ive been using this strategy and while I say it works well its certainly easy to shut down and I honestly dont think its that overpowered. Thats just my two cents
Level 51 said:very compelling arguments.
Emerald Master said:BAN IT, BAN IT I SAY!!!
lucariojr said:pretty please
BetaHousing said:Please, yes. I have tried playing triples, and every time Perish song is used, there is always some bullshit added to it. It makes it easy to kill switch ins, and when used with soundproof, Oh my lord, many of my times have fallen to that strategy alone. I would fully support this ban.
I wuv you said:Fine, the problem with Perish Song in triples is that it can be used to KO half of your opponents team with only one successful PerishTrap, and then KO the other half without a trapper. The battle becomes near impossible for your opponent to win if you successfully PerishTrap once, if that isn't uncompetitive I don't know what is.Yes very very compelling
I wuv you said:here we goYes very very compelling
Chenkovsky said:(b) you have more available active slots for soundproof / fake outers / double shadow taggers / wide guarders / quick guarders / other annoying shenanigans to help perishtrap go off successfully and at minimal cost to yourself.Fine, the problem with Perish Song in triples is that it can be used to KO half of your opponents team with only one successful PerishTrap, and then KO the other half without a trapper. The battle becomes near impossible for your opponent to win if you successfully PerishTrap once, if that isn't uncompetitive I don't know what is.
Level 51 said:(c) given that there are only three possible pokémon you can switch in at any given time*, and the only way to survive perish song is to switch: The opponent can run a pokémon that punishes switches to easily seal the deal on perish song getting at least a few kills, directly or indirectly.here we go
(a)
(b) you have more available active slots for soundproof / fake outers / double shadow taggers / wide guarders / quick guarders / other annoying shenanigans to help perishtrap go off successfully and at minimal cost to yourself.
i hope these two reasons are enough to convince you of the vast difference between doubles perishtrap and triples perishtrap (and by extension how broken triples perishtrap is).
Chenkovsky said:Fine, the problem with Perish Song in triples is that it can be used to KO half of your opponents team with only one successful PerishTrap, and then KO the other half without a trapper. The battle becomes near impossible for your opponent to win if you successfully PerishTrap once, if that isn't uncompetitive I don't know what is.
Level 51 said:(b) you have more available active slots for soundproof / fake outers / double shadow taggers / wide guarders / quick guarders / other annoying shenanigans to help perishtrap go off successfully and at minimal cost to yourself.
Emerald Master said:(c) given that there are only three possible pokémon you can switch in at any given time*, and the only way to survive perish song is to switch: The opponent can run a pokémon that punishes switches to easily seal the deal on perish song getting at least a few kills, directly or indirectly.
*this is slightly mitigated by the fact that there are three different slots to switch each pokémon into.
I wuv you said:Three successful spread moves can KO half your opponents team.
You also have three whole slots to answer fake out / wideguard / quick guard / other annoying shenanigans to prevent the perish trap from working.
Or you can simply win in six turns. Given that the average triples match in my experience is about four turns, this doesn't seem very hard.
Anty said:1. THree spread moves can ko half your team if you are a bad player and have a bad team that lack switch ins. Perish trap works on good players as well and needs a lot of team building focus to counter it
2. How are you preventing gengar/whoever from perish song, they are heavily invested in defence and if you are using 1 mon to quick guard, its hards to ko them + a follow me/rage powder threat
3. Good luck with doing that vs 6 bulky mons that protect every other turn most with recovery
By the looks of it you dont seem to notice the uncompetitive aspect of it. Picture losing half your team to score maybe 1 ko or just weakening down some of the opponents team without many ways to stop it. (doesnt sound too competitive, does it?)
I wuv you said:3. If I'm counting right you have 6 turns, and I don't think any pokemon can reliably survive three attacks per turn.
V4Victini said:4 turns
1) Opponent uses Perish Song / End of turn, Perish Count is 3
2) End of turn, Perish Count drops to 2
3) End of turn, Perish Count drops to 1
4) End of turn, Perish Count drops to 0, you faint.
V4Victini said:Just have a Greninja use Mat Block on the turns your trapper can't use perish song.4 turns
1) Opponent uses Perish Song / End of turn, Perish Count is 3
2) End of turn, Perish Count drops to 2
3) End of turn, Perish Count drops to 1
4) End of turn, Perish Count drops to 0, you faint.
The Pizza Man said:Just have a pokemon use feint on the greninja.Just have a Greninja use Mat Block on the turns your trapper can't use perish song.
I wuv you said:2 because of Protect with one perish trapper.So four turns to take out three mons and then another four to take out the last three.
I wuv you said:Mat Block is after Feint.Just have a pokemon use feint on the greninja.
V4Victini said:2 because of Protect with one perish trapper.
V4Victini said:Mat Block is after Feint.
V4Victini said:Actually just do this2 because of Protect with one perish trapper.
Emerald Master said:even if it does have slight "counters", it puts opponents into too strong of a lose-lose situation. You would practically have to dedicate about half of your team to prevent it, in which case any team using legitimate strategies would plow straight through you
Chenkovsky said:If you seriously doubt how broken it is play with it for any length of time, and it should be very obvious after that.