Royal Flush said:Recent 3D Zeldas are basically better OoTs. You might say Twilight Princess is bad or unnecessary for example, but it's basically Ocarina of Time done right : smoother combat mechanics and better puzzles (OoT you basically press switches and push blocks, plus the annoying infinite stacking small keys). No one can deny that OoT was freaking revolutionary back there, though.
Twilight Princess has poor combat, a drastic step down from Windwaker with a stack full of special moves that add little, poor shield mechanics, and god forbid you're using the wii version where you'll just waggle the stick around till you win in every fight. The dungeons are absolutely uninspired. I was about halfway through someone's house before I realized it was supposed to be the ice dungeon. The first three dungeons feel like the starter temples to OoT, like you expect things to pick up or to encounter the "adult" forest, fire, and water temples but instead you just get a house, a knockoff stone tower temple, and playing catch the ball with wall masters. Desert temple was aight though. Then half the special items in the game don't function often outside of the dungeons they are designed for. Puzzles sounds like personal preference to me but since the level design in OoT was so much more inspired the individual puzzles flowed better.
Twilight Princess was a poor attempt to recapture Ocarina of Time without understanding anything of what made it special;
Ocarina includes the best characters in any Zelda game; the temples themselves. Beyond being associated with different elements, geographies, fantasy races, and characters, the temples also each had their own distinct soundtrack and associated melodies from the Ocarina. In music theory we learn that different types of songs are made to elicit different reactions; minuets, boleros, and nocturnes all have very different cultural connotations. I feel each temple also elicits different feelings; the forest temple feels lonely, the water temple maddening, the shadow temple frightening. I can extrapolate as far as to compare the five temples to the five stages of death. I’m certain the designers did not intend this, however when the game is layered with so much symbolism it invites all sorts of interpretation.
OoT shows its age somewhat. In the open environment there's a lot of wasted space and some truly bizarre dead ends (which might add to its charm, but few can deny Majora's Mask did a better job). But for its dungeon design alone, Ocarina will be one of the absolute best games ever made at least until someone does better. I cross my fingers everytime a new Zelda game comes out, and keep falling into new dungeons that haven't been built up at all (Ancient Cistern!!! Cool dungeon though).