marilli said:I am also going to take the less defended side so far and say the extent people say you have to prepare for Magneton (or lose immediately) is unnecessary. Yes, there's very few switches that are near foolproof. But then, there's a ton of Pokemon without foolproof switches. Especially one as slow and frail as Specs Magneton. In fact, Pokemon such as Specs Rotom also have no foolproof switches, and I believe it's even harder to stop Specs Rotom's volt switches because it beats things like Stunfisk and Lanturn switch-ins with its secondary STAB move, so it requires even less prediction. Rotom actually outspeeds most of the metagame, has equally amazing defensive typing, has a legitimate "bulky" set that cripples checks with Will-O-Wisp + Hex set, and trolls offense pretty hard with Scarf set as well. It's impossible to counter specs rotom on paper, just like Specs Magneton. I think in fact it's harder to counter Specs rotom in paper, lol.
252 SpA
Choice Specs Rotom Volt Switch vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Spinda: 210-247 (80.4 - 94.6%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA
Analytic Magneton Volt Switch vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Spinda: 213-252 (81.6 - 96.5%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252+ SpA Choice Specs Analytic Magneton Volt Switch vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Spinda: 349-412 (133.7 - 157.8%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Between Magneton's already impressive Special Attack and Analytic, Magneton already bridges the gap in power between itself and Specs Rotom. So if you equip it with a Scarf, you get to harass offense
while packing the power of Specs Rotom. Or you can put an Eviolite on it to bulk it up if you so wish while giving it the ability to switch moves. Specs Rotom might be harder to counter on paper (though bulky Grounds such as Rhydon, Piloswine, and SpD Torterra would force Specs Rotom to make more predictions than Magneton), but Magneton yields so many comparative advantages in each set, and it's very versatile in function despite its extremely linear movepool. Of course, this by itself is not a banworthy quality.
If magneton is broken, you're going to have to show what makes it broken beyond "it's nearly impossible to switch in because it'll just volt switch out of unfavorable matchups." In similar vein, U-turn Archeops also has no counters and is impossible to counter. So does V-Switch Evire, lol. It doesn't make it broken for all the reasons we know. There must be some reasons beyond the fact that Volt Switch makes hard to have hard counters (and I think there may be, so please provide some.) At the moment the whole thread mostly talks about how it's impossible to switch into without having 3 Pokemon. That's not true. Other than applying offensive pressure, or having no Pokemon that get forced out immediately by Magneton. This is equivalent to essentially fully counterteaming vs. 1 Pokemon but it is a great way to avert the Magneton crisis because you don't get forced to switch and that analytic volt switch doesn't come into play that often. If you choose not to fully counterteam, you have nearly hard counters in Lanturn, Evire, Quagsire, Stunfisk, Vibrava, and Torterra that can feasibly switch into both STABs and force it to make dangerous prediction. Given how frail Specs Magneton is, it usually cannot take 2 hits if it mispredicts and goes for Hidden Power, unless it's pitted against something that cannot threaten Magneton at all. If you carry things that cannot threaten Magnet at all, you need to have at least one of those 5-6 Pokemon, or be forced into dangerous prediction games: this is more accurate representation of the current meta, not "carry these 3 or lose."
The biggest factor for the Magneton outcry is the sheer power of its pivoting move, and how difficult it is to stop it from racking up the damage it does; this was part of the basis for the Heliolisk ban as well. U-turn Archeops and Volt Switch EVire may not have "counters" (obviously more debatable in EVire's case, surprised you didn't just use your Rotom example here), but at least their pivoting move doesn't help them wear down their switch-ins so easily to the point that they can beat them after a few tries. It will take ages for Archeops to begin tackling the bulky Rock-types that switch into it after repeated U-turns, and in EVire's case Volt Switch won't be helping it beat down fatmons like Uxie and Mega Audino in a hurry. In the case of Magneton (in this particular instance Specs), any non-immune Pokemon would be feeling the effects of the Volt Switch
very quickly. To put it into perspective: Pokemon like specially defensive Mega Audino and physically defensive Vileplume take a whopping 1/3 from Specs Analytic Volt Switch, so there's absolutely no half-assing against that kind of damage as most switch-ins get worn down in due time (being like ~1-2 uses because FUK that's strong). This is not even considering any predictions that could be pulled by Magneton to speed up the process. The move itself also has plenty of killing power, unlike U-turn Archeops and VSwitch EVire, so there is much less risk involved for Magneton as well. Again, that is the primary reason people insist on hard counters, and even some of those you listed are only hard checks: EVire can get destroyed on the switch by Hidden Power Ground or even simply 2HKOed by anything non-immune, Quagsire must always be wary about the possibility of HP Grass (which is a perfectly legit option for Magneton), Stunfisk may get the tables turned on it by Magnet Rise Evio Magneton (can replace Thunderbolt, because by the time you want to attack with Volt Switch you shouldn't be facing a Ground mon anyway), and Vibrava can't even switch into Specs Analytic Flash Cannon wut. Basically Lanturn and SpD Torterra are the hardest Magneton counters.
I'm not saying Magneton is bad, I'm just saying we need to clarify the realistic effect of Magneton on the metagame. This is still pretty limiting, so there's still room for argument. By exaggerating you get people like so-and-so who are not convinced - because it isn't quite true. There's plenty of arguments without exaggerating. I mean, the other way I mentioned is kind of obvious so thats why no one mentioned it I guess, but some people need it spelt out, haha.
Also I'm starting to think bunch of these balance builders are incredibly selfish. lo!L Yall keep looking for Pokemon that hard counter all the biggest threats so you can avert crisis without sustaining any damage. This is pokemon, it's impossible to prevent all the big threats from making any progress on your team ffs. If you could do that, the game wouldn't be quite fun lol.
Now I don't play balance too much, but this statement is pretty unfair to those balance players who voiced their concerns about Magneton: they most likely acknowledge that hard counters to Magneton do exist and that you don't need like more than one of them to handle Magneton, plus I would imagine they have bigger things to worry about (Magmortar comes to mind). In fact I think the bigger issue is that Magneton is not just affecting balance, but most playstyles out there, as Scarf can give offense a run for its money with its speed and
power (something Scarf Rotom notably doesn't excel in), Specs you know what it does, and Evio can be tailormade to fuk with people who counter it with the hopes that it is Choiced all the time while still being reasonably effective. Because of this, the sheer influx of Lanturns, Stunfisks, Torterras, etc. in most teams (not just balance, even apparently offensive teams tends to run one of these)
is the realistic effect of Magneton on the meta, and I'm pretty sure most teams (
again, not just balance) would highly appreciate the breathing room for teambuilding again.