xJownage said:You fail to understand banning philosophy, and this isn't the first time I've seen this from a good portion of this community so I really want to point it out because I'm sick of seeing people scramble to unban things for no reason. Just look at Stabmons 1.0.
It takes a certain vote to ban something. That thing has to be uncompetitive or broken, or whatever its factor may be. At the same time, there is no real reason to unban anything when it adds nothing positive to the metagame. This same argument applies to Aegislash being "not as broken" in ORAS OU and people trying to find excuses to let it back in the tier because the metagame is stale. The problem is - it doesn't matter. Adding Greninja to this meta only adds centralization around a very good but impossible to hard counter mon, and this is the primary reason we would not unban it. What does Greninja add to the metagame anyways? We don't know. Should we unban Gira-O or Genesect because we "don't know?" Never. And we never will.
Proof is back to the aegislash retesting. In its original suspect testing, it was BARELY banned, but in the ORAS one, where it was arguably less broken, many more people voted to keep it banned. Why? What would it add to the metagame? An overcentralizing threat would be good to the metagame for what? Aegislash and Greninja parallel here for the exact same reasons. I'm sorry, but there is no good reason to let it in the tier, so why should we bother letting it back into the tier when it doesn't add anything substantially positive?
Ok I'm sick and tired of this crap so let me end this for once and for all.
To your first point: Banning philosophy is and always has been subjective. If something's banworthiness has been predetermined by whoever wrote the smogon banning philosophy guide, then why do we have forums or councils? The one guy who wrote that article should make the decisions for us. Insofar as treating this article as the holy grail is paternaluzing, destroys our autonomy and removes the point of having doeuma, I reject your first argument. Banning philosophy is subjective.
I am not scrambling to unban things for no reason, I am asking for them to be unbanned because THEY ARE NOT BROKEN. Take the deoxyses in stabmons, a meta you yourself quoted. They were B in the viability ranks and nobody thought they were broken. So why should they be banned ? Plus there is a suspect test going on so how is anyone scrambling to unban things? I just gave my opinion on the suspect test and here you are strutting around like you somehow know this way better than anyone else. But hey I like avoiding personal attacks so lets move on. Also what was wrong with Stabmons 1.0? If at all it was the banlist, not th unban list. I heard multiple people asking in the thread "why is each banned Mon banned?" At no time did I hear someone say "why is deo unbanned if it doesn't add anything to the metagame?" So turn your argument as it actually supports my argument.
Another thing I have said that none of you have refuted is: What is the difference between a suspect test of a banned Mon and one of an unbanned one? All of your arguments talk about how there is no reason to unban Ninja, but that is indistinguishable from banning an unbanned Mon. So why can't I apply this to Happiny? Ghoul King's response literally makes no argument- what is the difference between something like that doesn't add value and something that is useless? Is anything you have to prepare for diminishing more value than it is adding? If so ban sheddy and basically everything. I hope you now see how ridiculous your argument is.
But oh boy that isn't it. Your next paragraph talks about similar stuff at first, about the idea that unbanning something has to add value. Once again, this holds true because of your arbitrary distinction that the requirements to be legal or not should be determined by an ancient document by some Smogonite and a ruling in another tier with different game mechanics. But then you finally talk about Greninja and not any banned mon. you justify banning it on adding no "value" to the tier. What does add value to the tier? Only mons with support moves? Only stall mons? This is such an arbitrary definition and should not be used to see if something is banworthy. The only thing that can't be disagreed with by any philosophical crap is cold, hard calcs.
252 SpA Life Orb Greninja Dark Pulse vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Mew: 289-343 (84.7 - 100.5%) -- 6.3% chance to OHKO
It doesnt even KO an uninvested Mew w/o rocks with an SE move. Pinsir on the other hand does this with a neutral move:
252+ Atk Aerilate Mega Pinsir Return vs. 0 HP / 0 Def Mew: 306-360 (89.7 - 105.5%) -- 37.5% chance to OHKO (The equivalent of a jolly return with the 1.6x boost)
Stronger with a non SE move. So Greninja isn't nearly as strong as other threats. What about the broken mon PZ? Is scarf PZ stronger than a SE Greninja hit? If so, Greninja is completely useless.
252+ SpA Choice Specs Adaptability Porygon-Z Tri Attack vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Mew: 294-348 (86.2 - 102%) -- 12.5% chance to OHKO (Equivalent of scarf with changed adaptability)
So If Greninja is broken, you have to ban this stuff too which also have great speed/priority and is stronger even if not super effective. Anything that outspeeds it can probably kill it because it has boosted attacks. And things wall it. AV Regenerator Torn-T takes less than 66% from ice beam so it can just U-Turn out. So don't unban Greninja if you want, but then ban this more insane stuff like Adaptability mons, Mega Pinsir, Gardevoir, etc.
tl;dr Stabmons 1.0 was fun and balanced (besides Sableye on every team imo) and judging by calcs Gren isn't as scary as other stuff. You can't tell anyone that you are definitively right about knowing banning philosophy as it is subjective, so don't be a paternalistic asshole. Don't judge the banlist based on arbitrary decisions in other tiers or some random old document.