I forgot about this until now :(
For the past little while, I've been going arounds collecting rankings of what people think are the best Pokemon in the current LC metagame. It's not for anything official; I just thought you guys would find it interesting to see how your own opinions match up to what other LC players think. So far, we've got 39 viability ranking lists that contain 59 different Pokemon in total, so the lists this time are actually really diverse, which I thought was pretty cool, although there are still mainstays like Mienfoo and Pawniard.
This should be a given, and there's nothing wrong with disagreeing with another list, of course, but please don't criticize other lists in a hurtful manner. I wanted to keep the results applicable to high level play, so the only people I asked lists from were those who are respected, or at least well known in the LC community, as well as Starmaster.
Thanks to everyone who participated!
lists:
Hide
For the record, the lists are just ordered by when I got them.
TCR's list was not included in the results because it is a cuteability list
ANONYMOUS
1. mienfoo
2. foongus
3. porygon
4. timburr
5. pawniard
6. magnemite
7. archen
8. fletchling
9. diglett
10. ponyta
11. spritzee
12. gastly
13. abra
14. gothita
15. staryu
16. omanyte
17. drilbur
18. snubbull
19. shellder
20. croagunk
21. snivy
22. skrelp
23. chinchou
24. vulpix
25. ferroseed
mad0ka
1 Mienfoo
2 Fletchling
3 Pawniard
4 Timburr
5 Diglett
6 Porygon
7 Abra
8 Magnemite
9 Archen
10 spritzee
11 Chinchou
12 Staryu
13 Drilbur
14 Pumpkaboo-Super
15 Snubbull
16 Gastly
17 Omanyte
18 Corphish
19 Zigzagoon
20 gothita
21 Ponyta
22 Foongus
23 Cottonee
Kingler12
1. Mienfoo
2. Pawniard
3. Diglett
4. Abra
5. Fletchling
6. Timburr
7. Porygon
8. Spritzee
9. Gothita
10. Archen
11. Gastly
12. Snivy
13. Chinchou
14. Vullaby
15. Vulpix
16. Snubbull
17. Staryu
18. Omanyte
19. Zigzagoon
20. Cottonnee
Max Carvalho
1. foo
2. pawn
3. cho
4. abra
5. foongus
6. timburr
7. Pony
8. spri
9. Pory
10. Drilbur
11. Skrelp
12. Snubbul
13. Archen
14. Fletchling
15. Staryu
16. Gastly
17. Gothita
18. Doge
19. Larv
20. Cotton
21. Vulpix
Joltage
1 Meinfoo
2 Pawniard
3 Diglett
4 Abra
5 Timburr
6 Archen
7 Fletchling
8 Spritzee
9 Gastly
10 Porygon
11 Snubbull
12 Chinchou
13 Drilbur
14 Croagunk
15 Ferroseed
16 Vullaby
17 Larvesta
18 Snivy
19 Gothita
20 Ponyta
21 Staryu
22 Magnemite
23 Pumpkaboo-Super
24 Corphish
25 Omastar
26 Foongus
27 Scraggy
28 Cottonee
Natu (yes, really)
tazz
1 mienfoo
2 pawniard
3 diglett
4 abra
5 timburr
6 porygon
7 snubbull
8 fletchling
9 vulpix (+ bellsprout)
10 magnemite
11 staryu
12 gothita
13 archen
14 spritzee
15 snivy
16 shellder
17 skrelp
18 corphish
19 cottonee
20 drifloon
Tricking
1. Gothita
2. Mienfoo
3. Spritzee
4. Timburr
5. Abra
6. Omanyte
7. Fletchling
8. porygon
9. Croagunk
10. Gastly
11.Pawniard
12.Diglett
13.Snivy
14.Stunky
15.Cottonee
16.Ponyta
17.Pumpkaboo-Super
18.Corphish
19.Scraggy
20.Chinchou
21.Bunnelby
fran17
1 mienfoo,
2 diglett,
3 pawniard,
4 skrelp,
5 gastly,
6 spritzee,
7 gothita,
8 tomburr,
9 fletchling,
10 porygon,
11 abra,
12 archen,
13 snivy,
14 chou,
15 ferroseed,
16 vulpix,
17 ponyta,
18 staryu,
19 snubbul,
20 drilbur,
21 pumpoaboo
Cheek Pouch
1 Carvanha
2 Pawniard
3 Abra
4 Mienfoo
5 Archen
6 Fletchling
7 Timburr
8 Diglett
9 Porygon
10 Spritzee
11 Gothita
12 Snivy
13 Gastly
14 Staryu
15 Drilbur
16 Larvesta
17 Ferroseed
18 Vulpix
19 Zigzagoon
20 Onix
Melonz
1. Pawniard
2. Mienfoo
3. Porygon
4. Archen
5. Diglett
6. Timburr
7. Magnemite
8. Abra
9. Ponyta
10. Gastly
11. Fletchling
12. Ferroseed
13. Drilbur
14. Skrelp
15. Chinchou
16. Gothita
17. Larvesta
18. Omanyte
19. Zigzagoon
20. Foongus
21. Snubbull
22. Pancham
23. Snivy
24. Houndour
25. Shellder
26. Vullaby
27. Spritzee
28. Vulpix
29. Cottonee
30. Corphish
Mambo
1 Pawniard
2 Abra
3 Mienfoo
4 Gastly
5 Fletchling
6 Timburr
7 Diglett
8 Snivy
9 Porygon
10 Spritzee
11 Drilbur
12 Magnemite
13 Chinchou
14 Dwebble
15 Omanyte
16 Houndour
17 Vullaby
18 Ponyta
19 Ferroseed
20 Staryu
ANONYMOUS
1 magnemite
2 diglett
3 abra
4 mienfoo
5 archen
6 drilbur
7 porygon
8 spritzee
9 pawniard
9 drifloon
11 staryu
12 foongus
13 corphish
14 pumpkaboo-super
15 gastly
16 snubbul
17 skrelp
18 honedge
19 vulpix
19 houndour
21 vullaby
22 ponyta
23 helix
24 tirt
25 shell
26 croagunk
27 venipede
Tahu
1 pawniard
2 timburr
3 diglett
4 porygon
5 mienfoo
6 archen
7 fletchling
8 magnemite
9 chinchou
10 spritzee
11 gastly
12 drilbur
13 gothita
14 ferroseed
15 arvesta
16 skrelp
17 foongus
18 snivy
19 cottonee
Coconut.
1 mienfoo
2 pawniard
3 timburr
4 porygon
5 archen
6 fletchling
7 chinchou
8 diglett
9 omanyte
10 abra
11 ponyta
12 drilbur
13 spritzee
14 gastly
15 magnemite
16 shellder
17 snubbull
18 foongus
19 honedge
20 torchic
Celestavian
1. Mienfoo
2. Timburr
3. Abra
4. Pawniard
5. Fletchling
6. Porygon
7. Diglett
8. Drilbur
9. Spritzee
10. Gastly
11. Magnemite
12. Archen
13. Snubbull
14. Chinchou
15. Ponyta
16. Staryu
17. Vulpix
18. Gothita
19. Skrelp
20. Omanyte
Goao
1 mienfoo
2 archen
3 chinchou
4 timburr
5 honedge
6 cottone
7 tirtouga
8 fletchling
9 pawniard
10 bigglet
11 abra
12 gastly
13 foongus
14 carvanha
15 gothita
16 spritzee
17 drilbur
18 ponyta
19 vulpix
20 magnemite
Pikasohn
1 Mienfoo
2 Magnemite
3 Diglett
4 Fletchling
5 Abra
6 Pawniard
7 Zigzagoon
8 Omanyte
9 Snubbull
10 Chinchou
11 Staryu
12 Archen
13 Porygon
14 Foongus
15 Larvesta
16 Snivy
17 Cottonee
18 Surskit
19 Vulpix
20 Wynaut
ANONYMOUS
1.Timburr
2.Pawniard
3.Abra
4.Numel
5.Gastly
6.Baggaïd
7.Dwebble
8.Mienfoo
9.Aron
10.Cottonee
11.Aipom
12.Digglet
13.Croagunk
14.Archen
15.Zigzagoon
16.Vullaby
17.Staryu
18.Surskit
19.Bellsprout
20.Magneti
fitzy72
1 Mienfoo
2 Pawniard
3 Ponyta
4 Archen
5 Abra
6 Fletchling
7 Chinchou
8 Timburr
9 Spritzee
10 Porygon
11 Diglett
12 Magnemite
13 Croagunk
14 Drilbur
15 Gothorita
16 Vulpix
17 Snivy
18 Aipom
19 Pumpkaboo-Super
20 Vullaby
ANONYMOUS
1. Pawniard
2. Mienfoo
3. Timburr
4. Diglett
5. Archen
6. Fletchling
7. Porygon
8. Abra
9. Magnemite
10. Spritzee
11. Drilbur
12. Gastly
13. Omanyte
14. Snivy
15. Gothita
16. Snubbull
17. Vulpix
18. Houndour
19. Carvanha
20. Chinchou
21. Skrelp
22. Staryu
23. Corphish
24. Ferroseed
25. Cottonee
26. Larvesta
27. Vullaby
28. Foongus
29. Shellder
30. Zigzagoon
31. Bellsprout
32. Scraggy
33. Pumpkaboo
34. Drifloon
35. Surskit
36. Dwebble
37. Pancham
38. Tirtouga
39. Aipom
40. Torchic
41. Croagunk
42. Bunnelby
43. Doduo
44. Hippototas
45. Taillow
46. Cranidos
47. Amaura
48. Stunky
49. Riolu
50. Onix
ANONYMOUS
1 Mienfoo
2 Abra
3 Diglett
4 Pawniard
5 Chinchou
6 Fletchiling
7 Gaslty
8 Magnamite
9 Porygon
10 Gothita
11 Timbur
12 Foonguss
13 Spritzee
14 Skrelp
15 Cottone
16 Omanyte
17 Scraggy
18 Pancham
19 Drilbur
20 Archen
Heysup
1. Mienfoo
2. Fletchling
3. Abra
4. Pawniard
5. Timburr
6. Porygon
7. Drilbur
8. Archen
9. Ponyta
10. Snivy
11. Magnemite
12. Cottonee
13. Skrelp
14. Snubbull
15. Carvanha
16. Spritzee
17. Gothita
18. Diglett
19. Gastly
20. Tirtouga / Omanyte / Shellder
ANONYMOUS
1 Mienfoo,
2 Abra,
3 Timburr,
4 Pawniard,
5 Magnemite,
6 Fletchling,
7 Omanyte,
8 Diglett,
9 Snubbull,
10 Snivy,
11 Drilbur,
12 Bunnelby,
13 Carvanha,
14 Larvesta,
15 Foongus,
16 Pumpkaboo,
17 Porygon,
18 Spritzee,
19 Ferroseed,
20 Archen
slurmz
1) Pawniard
2) Fletchling
3) Mienfoo
4) Diglett
5) Abra
6) Timburr
7) Porygon
8) Spritzee
9) Magnetmite
10) Ponyta
11) Chinchou
12) Snubbull
13) Drilbur
14) Archen
15) Gastly
16) Ferroseed
17) Staryu
18) Carvanha
19) LORDGUS
20) Gothita
Fiend
1 Pawniard
2 Mienfoo
3 Magnemite
4 Fletching
5 Timburr
6 Archen
7 Porygon
8 Diglett
9 Gastly
10 Omantye
11 Gothita
12 Snivy
13 Snubull
14 Abra
15 Shellder
16 Corphish
17 Torchic
18 Carvanha
19 Buneary
20 Houndour
21 Cottonee
22 Drilbur
23 Drifloon
24 Foongus
25 Skrelp
26 Ponyta
27 Chinchou
28 Pancham
29 Vullaby
30 Pumpkaboo
31 Doduo
32 Vulpix
33 Aipom
34 Honedge
35 Taillow
36 Bunnelby
37 Larvesta
kingmidas
1. Pawniard
2. Fletchling
3. Porygon
4. Ponyta
5. Diglett
6. Mienfoo
7. Abra
8. Skrelp
9. Timburr
10. Gothita
11. Vullaby.
12. Magnemite
13. Spritzee
14, Larvesta
15. omanyte
16. Corphish
17. Snubbull
18. Scraggy
19. Ferroseed
20. Archen
Vileman
1: pawniard
2: mienfoo
3: porygon
4: fletchling
5: abra
6: digglet
7: timburr
8: spritzee
9: Archen
10: Chinchou
11: Magnemite
12: Drilbur
13: Ponyta
14: Gastly
15: Pumpkaboo-super
16: Ferroseed
17: Foongus
18: Snivy
19: Snubull
20: hippopotas
Mr. NudistoBeach
1. Snivy
2. Mienfoo
3. Diglett
4. Pawniard
5. Abra
6. Ponyta
7. Corphish
8. Magnemite
9. Porygon
10. Fletchling
11. Omanyte
12. Foongus
13. Staryu
14. Drifloon
15. Pancham
16. Croagunk
17. Cleffa
18. Pumpkaboo-Super
19. Larvesta
20. Carvanha
Shrug
1. Pawniard
2. Mienfoo
3. Timburr
4. Snubbull
5. Fletchling
6. Ponyta
7. Porygon
8. diglett
9. Mag
10. Gastly
11. Staryu
12. Ferroseed
13. vulpix
14. Skrelp
15. Omanyte
16. Skrelp
17. Houndour
18. chinchou
19. Goth
20. Carv
thecrystalonix
1- pawniard
2- abra
3- fletchling
4- diglett
5- mienfoo
6- timburr
7- ponyta
8- porygon
9- spritzee
10- gastly
11- ferroseed
12- archen
13- gothita
14- larvesta
15- staryu
16- skrelp
17- foongus
18- omanyte
19- bellsprout
20- corphish
Yagura
1 Gothita
2 Mienfoo
3 Diglett
4 Fletchling
5 Abra
6 Pawniard
7 Chinchou
8 Spritzee
9 Omanyte
10 Timburr
11 Ponyta
12 Archen
13 Magnemite
14 Foongus
15 Porygon
16 Drilbur
17 Staryu
18 Carvanha
19 Gastly
20 Stunky
Star.
1. mienfoo
2. pawniard
3. timburr
4. abra
5. porygon
6. diglett
7. fletchling
8. archen
9. magnemite
10. ponyta
11. chinchou
12. spritzee
13. snubbul
14. drilbur
15. ferroseed
16. gastly
17. staryu
18. gothita
19. foongus
20. vullaby
macle
1 pawm
2 foo
3 fletch
4 diglett
5 archen
6 skrelp
7 mag
8 spritzee
9 chinchou
10 foongus
11 timburr
12 goth
13 abra
14 drillbur
15 tirt
16 shellder
17 corphish
18 ponyta
19 omanyte
TheFenderStory
1 Mienfoo
2 Diglett
3 Timburr
4 Pawn
5 Archen
6 Abra
7 Fletch
8 Chou
9 Spritz
10 GOth
11 Foon
12 Vulpix
13 Gastly
14 Drilbur
15 Larv
16 Corphish
17 Helix
18 Snivy
19 Aipom
20 Tirt
Cydrolic
1 diglett
2 mienfoo
3 pawniard
4 foongus
5 magnemite
6 fletchling
7 omanyte
8 drifloon
9 gothita
10 stunky
11 abra
12 timburr
13 spritzee
14 porygon
15 staryu
16 archen
17 carvanah
18 shellder
19 larvesta
20 gastly
21 croagunk
sparktrain
1. Mienfoo
2. Timburr
3. Pawniard
4. Porygon
5. Fletchling
6. Diglett
7. Gothita
8. Spritzee
9. Snubbull
10. Abra
11. Archen
12. Magnemite
13. Ferroseed
14. Gastly
15. Omanyte
16. Ponyta
17. Chinchou
18. Snivy
19. Foongus
20. Drilbur
ThatCrazyRussian
1. Amaura
2. Riolu
3. Teddiursa
4. foongus
5. Buneary
6. Dratini
7. Scraggy
8. Tirtouga
9. Swinub
10. Spheal
11. Phanpy
12. Piplup
13. Growlithe
14. Hippopotas
15. Munchlax
16. Swirlix
17. Mareep
18. Drifloon
19. Aipom
20. Corphish
20. Clamperl
HeaLnDeaL
20. Ferroseed
19. Gastly
18. Tirtouga
17. Archen
16. Drilbur
15. Chinchou
14. Timburr
13. Larvesta
12. Ponyta
11. Omanyte
10. Magnemite
09. Spritzee
08. Foongus
07. Staryu
06. Abra
05. Diglett
04. Pawniard
03. Porygon
02. Fletchling
01. Mienfoo
h%mberkle
1 Snivy
2 Omanyte
3 Pawniard
4 Timburr
5 Gastly
6 Diglett
7 Porygon
8 Mienfoo
9 Staryu
10 Chinchou
11 Houndour
12 Vulpix
13 Croagunk
14 Snubbull
15 Fletchling
16 Hippopotas
17 Archen
18 Carvanha
19 Gothita
20 Abra
The Avalanches
1. Pawniard
2. Timburr
3. Mienfoo
4. Diglett
5. Vullaby
6. Abra
7. Fletchling
8. Magnemite
9. Skrelp
10. Foongus
11. Staryu
12. Porygon
13. Archen
14. Snubbull
15. Spritzee
16. Chinchou
17. Gastly
18. Gothita
19. Snivy
20. Cottonee
Here are the results organized in a few ways:
Pokemon ranked in alphabetical order
name - rankings on individual list (number of times included, higher is better) (sum of rankings on list, lower is better)
abra - 13,7,4,4,4,4,5,11,3,8,2,3,10,3,11,5,3,5,8,2,3,2,5,14,7,5,5,2,5,4,13,6,11,10,6,20,6 (37) (249)
aipom - 11,18,39,33,19 (5) (120)
amaura - 47 (1) (47)
archen - 7,9,10,13,6,13,12,5,4,5,6,5,12,2,12,14,4,5,20,8,20,14,6,20,9,12,12,8,5,5,16,11,17,17,13 (35) (357)
aron - 9 (1) (9)
bellsprout - 19,31,19 (3) (69)
buneary - 19 (1) (19)
bunnelby - 21,42,12,36 (4) (111)
carvanha - 1,14,19,15,13,18,18,20,20,18,17,18 (12) (191)
chinchou - 23,11,13,3,12,20,14,15,13,9,7,14,3,10,7,20,5,11,27,10,18,7,11,9,8,17,15,10,16 (29) (358)
cleffa - 17 (1) (17)
corphish - 18,24,18,18,30,13,23,16,16,7,20,17,16 (13) (236)
cottonee - 23,20,20,28,10,15,29,19,6,17,10,25,15,12,21,20 (16) (290)
cranidos - 46 (1) (46)
croagunk - 20,14,9,26,13,13,41,16,21,13 (10) (186)
diglett - 9,5,3,3,3,12,2,8,5,7,2,3,8,7,10,3,12,11,4,3,18,8,4,8,5,6,3,8,4,3,6,4,2,1,6,5,6,4 (36) (221)
doduo - 43,31 (2) (74)
drifloon - 20,10,34,23,14,8 (6) (109)
drilbur - 17,13,10,13,20,15,13,11,6,12,12,8,17,14,11,19,7,11,13,22,12,16,14,14,14,20,16 (27) (370)
dwebble - 14,7,36 (3) (57)
fletchling - 8,2,5,14,7,8,7,9,6,11,5,7,6,5,8,4,6,6,6,2,6,2,4,2,4,10,5,3,4,7,3,7,6,5,2,15,7 (37) (224)
ferroseed - 25,15,15,17,12,19,14,24,19,16,19,16,12,11,15,13,20 (17) (282)
foongus - 2,22,5,26,20,12,17,18,13,14,28,12,15,19,24,17,12,17,14,19,10,11,4,19,8,10 (26) (388)
gastly - 12,16,11,16,9,10,5,13,10,4,15,11,14,10,12,5,12,7,19,15,9,14,10,10,19,16,13,20,14,19,5,17 (32) (392)
gothita - 14,9,17,19,12,1,7,11,16,13,18,15,15,15,10,17,20,11,10,19,13,1,18,12,10,9,7,19,18 (29) (376)
hippopotas - 44,20,16 (3) (80)
honedge - 18,19,5,34 (4) (76)
houndour - 24,16,20,18,20,17,11 (7) (126)
larvesta - 19,17,16,17,15,15,26,14,37,14,19,14,15,19,13 (15) (270)
magnemite - 6,8,22,10,7,12,1,8,15,11,20,2,20,12,9,8,11,5,9,3,12,11,8,9,13,9,7,5,12,10,8 (31) (303)
mienfoo - 1,1,1,1,1,1,2,1,4,2,3,4,5,1,1,1,1,8,1,2,1,1,1,3,2,6,2,2,2,5,2,1,2,1,2,1,1,8,3 (39) (88)
natu - 0
numel - 4 (1) (4)
omanyte - 16,17,18,18,25,6,18,15,23,9,20,8,13,16,20,7,10,15,11,15,18,9,19,17,7,15,11,2 (28) (398)
onix - 20,50 (2) (70)
pancham - 22,37,18,28,15 (5) (120)
pawniard - 5,3,2,2,2,2,11,3,2,1,1,9,1,2,4,9,6,2,2,1,4,4,4,1,1,1,1,4,1,1,6,2,1,4,3,3,4,3,1 (39) (119)
ponyta - 10,21,7,20,16,17,9,18,22,11,15,18,3,9,10,26,4,13,6,6,7,11,10,18,16,12 (26) (335)
porygon - 3,6,7,9,10,6,8,10,9,3,9,7,4,4,6,13,10,7,9,6,17,7,7,3,3,9,7,8,15,5,14,4,3,7,12 (35) (267)
pumpkaboo super - 14,23,17,21,14,19,33,16,30,15,18 (11) (220)
riolu - 49 (1) (49)
scraggy - 27,19,6,32,17,18 (6) (119)
shellder - 19,16,25,25,16,29,20,15,16,18 (10) (199)
skrelp - 22,11,17,4,14,17,16,19,21,14,13,25,8,14,16,16,6,9 (18) (262)
snivy - 21,12,18,15,13,13,12,23,8,18,16,17,14,10,10,12,18,1,18,18,1,19 (22) (307)
snubbull - 18,15,16,12,11,7,19,21,16,17,13,9,16,14,9,12,13,17,19,4,13,9,14,14 (24) (328)
spritzee - 11,10,8,8,8,14,3,6,10,27,10,8,10,13,9,16,9,10,13,16,18,8,13,8,9,8,12,8,9,13,8,9,15 (33) (357)
staryu - 15,12,17,15,21,11,18,14,20,11,16,11,17,22,17,13,11,15,17,17,15,7,9,11 (24) (352)
stunky - 14,48,20,10 (4) (92)
surskit - 18,18,35 (3) (71)
taillow - 45,35 (2) (80)
timburr - 4,4,6,6,5,5,4,8,7,6,6,2,3,2,4,1,8,3,11,5,3,6,5,9,7,3,6,10,3,11,3,12,2,14,4,2 (36) (200)
tirtouga - 24,7,38,20,15,20,18 (7) (142)
torchic - 20,40,17 (3) (77)
venipede - 27 (1) (27)
vullaby - 14,16,26,17,21,16,20,27,29,11,20,5 (12) (222)
vulpix - 24,15,15,21,9,16,18,28,19,17,19,19,16,17,32,13,12,12 (18) (322)
wynaut - 20 (1) (20)
zigzagoon - 19,19,19,19,7,15,30 (7) (128)
By how many times they were included
name - rankings on individual list (number of times included, higher is better) (sum of rankings on list, lower is better)
1 mienfoo - 1,1,1,1,1,1,2,1,4,2,3,4,5,1,1,1,1,8,1,2,1,1,1,3,2,6,2,2,2,5,2,1,2,1,2,1,1,8,3 (39) (88)
2 pawniard - 5,3,2,2,2,2,11,3,2,1,1,9,1,2,4,9,6,2,2,1,4,4,4,1,1,1,1,4,1,1,6,2,1,4,3,3,4,3,1 (39) (119)
3 fletchling - 8,2,5,14,7,8,7,9,6,11,5,7,6,5,8,4,6,6,6,2,6,2,4,2,4,10,5,3,4,7,3,7,6,5,2,15,7 (37) (224)
4 abra - 13,7,4,4,4,4,5,11,3,8,2,3,10,3,11,5,3,5,8,2,3,2,5,14,7,5,5,2,5,4,13,6,11,10,6,20,6 (37) (249)
5 timburr - 4,4,6,6,5,5,4,8,7,6,6,2,3,2,4,1,8,3,11,5,3,6,5,9,7,3,6,10,3,11,3,12,2,14,4,2 (36) (200)
6 diglett - 9,5,3,3,3,12,2,8,5,7,2,3,8,7,10,3,12,11,4,3,18,8,4,8,5,6,3,8,4,3,6,4,2,1,6,5,6,4 (36) (221)
7 porygon - 3,6,7,9,10,6,8,10,9,3,9,7,4,4,6,13,10,7,9,6,17,7,7,3,3,9,7,8,15,5,14,4,3,7,12 (35) (267)
8 archen - 7,9,10,13,6,13,12,5,4,5,6,5,12,2,12,14,4,5,20,8,20,14,6,20,9,12,12,8,5,5,16,11,17,17,13 (35) (357)
9 spritzee - 11,10,8,8,8,14,3,6,10,27,10,8,10,13,9,16,9,10,13,16,18,8,13,8,9,8,12,8,9,13,8,9,15 (33) (357)
10 gastly - 12,16,11,16,9,10,5,13,10,4,15,11,14,10,12,5,12,7,19,15,9,14,10,10,19,16,13,20,14,19,5,17 (32) (392)
11 magnemite - 6,8,22,10,7,12,1,8,15,11,20,2,20,12,9,8,11,5,9,3,12,11,8,9,13,9,7,5,12,10,8 (31) (303)
12 chinchou - 23,11,13,3,12,20,14,15,13,9,7,14,3,10,7,20,5,11,27,10,18,7,11,9,8,17,15,10,16 (29) (358)
13 gothita - 14,9,17,19,12,1,7,11,16,13,18,15,15,15,10,17,20,11,10,19,13,1,18,12,10,9,7,19,18 (29) (376)
14 omanyte - 16,17,18,18,25,6,18,15,23,9,20,8,13,16,20,7,10,15,11,15,18,9,19,17,7,15,11,2 (28) (398)
15 drilbur - 17,13,10,13,20,15,13,11,6,12,12,8,17,14,11,19,7,11,13,22,12,16,14,14,14,20,16 (27) (370)
16 ponyta - 10,21,7,20,16,17,9,18,22,11,15,18,3,9,10,26,4,13,6,6,7,11,10,18,16,12 (26) (335)
17 foongus - 2,22,5,26,20,12,17,18,13,14,28,12,15,19,24,17,12,17,14,19,10,11,4,19,8,10 (26) (388)
18 snubbull - 18,15,16,12,11,7,19,21,16,17,13,9,16,14,9,12,13,17,19,4,13,9,14,14 (24) (328)
19 staryu - 15,12,17,15,21,11,18,14,20,11,16,11,17,22,17,13,11,15,17,17,15,7,9,11 (24) (352)
20 snivy - 21,12,18,15,13,13,12,23,8,18,16,17,14,10,10,12,18,1,18,18,1,19 (22) (307)
21 skrelp - 22,11,17,4,14,17,16,19,21,14,13,25,8,14,16,16,6,9 (18) (262)
22 vulpix - 24,15,15,21,9,16,18,28,19,17,19,19,16,17,32,13,12,12 (18) (322)
23 ferroseed - 25,15,15,17,12,19,14,24,19,16,19,16,12,11,15,13,20 (17) (282)
24 cottonee - 23,20,20,28,10,15,29,19,6,17,10,25,15,12,21,20 (16) (290)
25 larvesta - 19,17,16,17,15,15,26,14,37,14,19,14,15,19,13 (15) (270)
26 corphish - 18,24,18,18,30,13,23,16,16,7,20,17,16 (13) (236)
27 carvanha - 1,14,19,15,13,18,18,20,20,18,17,18 (12) (191)
28 vullaby - 14,16,26,17,21,16,20,27,29,11,20,5 (12) (222)
29 pumpkaboo super - 14,23,17,21,14,19,33,16,30,15,18 (11) (220)
30 croagunk - 20,14,9,26,13,13,41,16,21,13 (10) (186)
31 shellder - 19,16,25,25,16,29,20,15,16,18 (10) (199)
32 houndour - 24,16,20,18,20,17,11 (7) (126)
33 zigzagoon - 19,19,19,19,7,15,30 (7) (128)
34 tirtouga - 24,7,38,20,15,20,18 (7) (142)
35 drifloon - 20,10,34,23,14,8 (6) (109)
36 scraggy - 27,19,6,32,17,18 (6) (119)
37 pancham - 22,37,18,28,15 (5) (120)
38 aipom - 11,18,39,33,19 (5) (120)
39 honedge - 18,19,5,34 (4) (76)
40 stunky - 14,48,20,10 (4) (92)
41 bunnelby - 21,42,12,36 (4) (111)
42 dwebble - 14,7,36 (3) (57)
43 bellsprout - 19,31,19 (3) (69)
44 surskit - 18,18,35 (3) (71)
45 torchic - 20,40,17 (3) (77)
46 hippopotas - 44,20,16 (3) (80)
47 onix - 20,50 (2) (70)
48 doduo - 43,31 (2) (74)
49 taillow - 45,35 (2) (80)
50 numel - 4 (1) (4)
51 aron - 9 (1) (9)
52 cleffa - 17 (1) (17)
53 buneary - 19 (1) (19)
54 wynaut - 20 (1) (20)
55 venipede - 27 (1) (27)
56 cranidos - 46 (1) (46)
57 amaura - 47 (1) (47)
58 riolu - 49 (1) (49)
59 natu - 0
By their average rankings
with all pokemons:
name - rankings on individual list (number of times included, higher is better) (sum of rankings on list, lower is better)
1 mienfoo - 1,1,1,1,1,1,2,1,4,2,3,4,5,1,1,1,1,8,1,2,1,1,1,3,2,6,2,2,2,5,2,1,2,1,2,1,1,8,3 (39) (88)
2 pawniard - 5,3,2,2,2,2,11,3,2,1,1,9,1,2,4,9,6,2,2,1,4,4,4,1,1,1,1,4,1,1,6,2,1,4,3,3,4,3,1 (39) (119)
3 numel - 4 (1) (4)
4 timburr - 4,4,6,6,5,5,4,8,7,6,6,2,3,2,4,1,8,3,11,5,3,6,5,9,7,3,6,10,3,11,3,12,2,14,4,2 (36) (200)
5 fletchling - 8,2,5,14,7,8,7,9,6,11,5,7,6,5,8,4,6,6,6,2,6,2,4,2,4,10,5,3,4,7,3,7,6,5,2,15,7 (37) (224)
6 diglett - 9,5,3,3,3,12,2,8,5,7,2,3,8,7,10,3,12,11,4,3,18,8,4,8,5,6,3,8,4,3,6,4,2,1,6,5,6,4 (36) (221)
7 abra - 13,7,4,4,4,4,5,11,3,8,2,3,10,3,11,5,3,5,8,2,3,2,5,14,7,5,5,2,5,4,13,6,11,10,6,20,6 (37) (249)
8 porygon - 3,6,7,9,10,6,8,10,9,3,9,7,4,4,6,13,10,7,9,6,17,7,7,3,3,9,7,8,15,5,14,4,3,7,12 (35) (267)
9 aron - 9 (1) (9)
10 magnemite - 6,8,22,10,7,12,1,8,15,11,20,2,20,12,9,8,11,5,9,3,12,11,8,9,13,9,7,5,12,10,8 (31) (303)
11 archen - 7,9,10,13,6,13,12,5,4,5,6,5,12,2,12,14,4,5,20,8,20,14,6,20,9,12,12,8,5,5,16,11,17,17,13 (35) (357)
12 spritzee - 11,10,8,8,8,14,3,6,10,27,10,8,10,13,9,16,9,10,13,16,18,8,13,8,9,8,12,8,9,13,8,9,15 (33) (357)
13 gastly - 12,16,11,16,9,10,5,13,10,4,15,11,14,10,12,5,12,7,19,15,9,14,10,10,19,16,13,20,14,19,5,17 (32) (392)
14 chinchou - 23,11,13,3,12,20,14,15,13,9,7,14,3,10,7,20,5,11,27,10,18,7,11,9,8,17,15,10,16 (29) (358)
15 ponyta - 10,21,7,20,16,17,9,18,22,11,15,18,3,9,10,26,4,13,6,6,7,11,10,18,16,12 (26) (335)
16 gothita - 14,9,17,19,12,1,7,11,16,13,18,15,15,15,10,17,20,11,10,19,13,1,18,12,10,9,7,19,18 (29) (376)
17 snubbull - 18,15,16,12,11,7,19,21,16,17,13,9,16,14,9,12,13,17,19,4,13,9,14,14 (24) (328)
18 drilbur - 17,13,10,13,20,15,13,11,6,12,12,8,17,14,11,19,7,11,13,22,12,16,14,14,14,20,16 (27) (370)
19 snivy - 21,12,18,15,13,13,12,23,8,18,16,17,14,10,10,12,18,1,18,18,1,19 (22) (307)
20 omanyte - 16,17,18,18,25,6,18,15,23,9,20,8,13,16,20,7,10,15,11,15,18,9,19,17,7,15,11,2 (28) (398)
21 skrelp - 22,11,17,4,14,17,16,19,21,14,13,25,8,14,16,16,6,9 (18) (262)
22 staryu - 15,12,17,15,21,11,18,14,20,11,16,11,17,22,17,13,11,15,17,17,15,7,9,11 (24) (352)
23 foongus - 2,22,5,26,20,12,17,18,13,14,28,12,15,19,24,17,12,17,14,19,10,11,4,19,8,10 (26) (388)
24 carvanha - 1,14,19,15,13,18,18,20,20,18,17,18 (12) (191)
25 ferroseed - 25,15,15,17,12,19,14,24,19,16,19,16,12,11,15,13,20 (17) (282)
26 cleffa - 17 (1) (17)
27 vulpix - 24,15,15,21,9,16,18,28,19,17,19,19,16,17,32,13,12,12 (18) (322)
28 larvesta - 19,17,16,17,15,15,26,14,37,14,19,14,15,19,13 (15) (270)
29 houndour - 24,16,20,18,20,17,11 (7) (126)
30 cottonee - 23,20,20,28,10,15,29,19,6,17,10,25,15,12,21,20 (16) (290)
31 corphish - 18,24,18,18,30,13,23,16,16,7,20,17,16 (13) (236)
32 drifloon - 20,10,34,23,14,8 (6) (109)
33 zigzagoon - 19,19,19,19,7,15,30 (7) (128)
34 vullaby - 14,16,26,17,21,16,20,27,29,11,20,5 (12) (222)
35 croagunk - 20,14,9,26,13,13,41,16,21,13 (10) (186)
36 honedge - 18,19,5,34 (4) (76)
37 dwebble - 14,7,36 (3) (57)
38 buneary - 19 (1) (19)
39 scraggy - 27,19,6,32,17,18 (6) (119)
40 shellder - 19,16,25,25,16,29,20,15,16,18 (10) (199)
41 pumpkaboo super - 14,23,17,21,14,19,33,16,30,15,18 (11) (220)
42 wynaut - 20 (1) (20)
43 tirtouga - 24,7,38,20,15,20,18 (7) (142)
44 stunky - 14,48,20,10 (4) (92)
45 bellsprout - 19,31,19 (3) (69)
46 surskit - 18,18,35 (3) (71)
47 pancham - 22,37,18,28,15 (5) (120)
48 aipom - 11,18,39,33,19 (5) (120)
49 torchic - 20,40,17 (3) (77)
50 hippopotas - 44,20,16 (3) (80)
51 venipede - 27 (1) (27)
52 bunnelby - 21,42,12,36 (4) (111)
53 onix - 20,50 (2) (70)
54 doduo - 43,31 (2) (74)
55 taillow - 45,35 (2) (80)
56 cranidos - 46 (1) (46)
57 amaura - 47 (1) (47)
58 riolu - 49 (1) (49)
59 natu - 0
with only pokemons that were included more than once:
1 mienfoo - 1,1,1,1,1,1,2,1,4,2,3,4,5,1,1,1,1,8,1,2,1,1,1,3,2,6,2,2,2,5,2,1,2,1,2,1,1,8,3 (39) (88)
2 pawniard - 5,3,2,2,2,2,11,3,2,1,1,9,1,2,4,9,6,2,2,1,4,4,4,1,1,1,1,4,1,1,6,2,1,4,3,3,4,3,1 (39) (119)
3 timburr - 4,4,6,6,5,5,4,8,7,6,6,2,3,2,4,1,8,3,11,5,3,6,5,9,7,3,6,10,3,11,3,12,2,14,4,2 (36) (200)
4 fletchling - 8,2,5,14,7,8,7,9,6,11,5,7,6,5,8,4,6,6,6,2,6,2,4,2,4,10,5,3,4,7,3,7,6,5,2,15,7 (37) (224)
5 diglett - 9,5,3,3,3,12,2,8,5,7,2,3,8,7,10,3,12,11,4,3,18,8,4,8,5,6,3,8,4,3,6,4,2,1,6,5,6,4 (36) (221)
6 abra - 13,7,4,4,4,4,5,11,3,8,2,3,10,3,11,5,3,5,8,2,3,2,5,14,7,5,5,2,5,4,13,6,11,10,6,20,6 (37) (249)
7 porygon - 3,6,7,9,10,6,8,10,9,3,9,7,4,4,6,13,10,7,9,6,17,7,7,3,3,9,7,8,15,5,14,4,3,7,12 (35) (267)
8 magnemite - 6,8,22,10,7,12,1,8,15,11,20,2,20,12,9,8,11,5,9,3,12,11,8,9,13,9,7,5,12,10,8 (31) (303)
9 archen - 7,9,10,13,6,13,12,5,4,5,6,5,12,2,12,14,4,5,20,8,20,14,6,20,9,12,12,8,5,5,16,11,17,17,13 (35) (357)
10 spritzee - 11,10,8,8,8,14,3,6,10,27,10,8,10,13,9,16,9,10,13,16,18,8,13,8,9,8,12,8,9,13,8,9,15 (33) (357)
11 gastly - 12,16,11,16,9,10,5,13,10,4,15,11,14,10,12,5,12,7,19,15,9,14,10,10,19,16,13,20,14,19,5,17 (32) (392)
12 chinchou - 23,11,13,3,12,20,14,15,13,9,7,14,3,10,7,20,5,11,27,10,18,7,11,9,8,17,15,10,16 (29) (358)
13 ponyta - 10,21,7,20,16,17,9,18,22,11,15,18,3,9,10,26,4,13,6,6,7,11,10,18,16,12 (26) (335)
14 gothita - 14,9,17,19,12,1,7,11,16,13,18,15,15,15,10,17,20,11,10,19,13,1,18,12,10,9,7,19,18 (29) (376)
15 snubbull - 18,15,16,12,11,7,19,21,16,17,13,9,16,14,9,12,13,17,19,4,13,9,14,14 (24) (328)
16 drilbur - 17,13,10,13,20,15,13,11,6,12,12,8,17,14,11,19,7,11,13,22,12,16,14,14,14,20,16 (27) (370)
17 snivy - 21,12,18,15,13,13,12,23,8,18,16,17,14,10,10,12,18,1,18,18,1,19 (22) (307)
18 omanyte - 16,17,18,18,25,6,18,15,23,9,20,8,13,16,20,7,10,15,11,15,18,9,19,17,7,15,11,2 (28) (398)
19 skrelp - 22,11,17,4,14,17,16,19,21,14,13,25,8,14,16,16,6,9 (18) (262)
20 staryu - 15,12,17,15,21,11,18,14,20,11,16,11,17,22,17,13,11,15,17,17,15,7,9,11 (24) (352)
21 foongus - 2,22,5,26,20,12,17,18,13,14,28,12,15,19,24,17,12,17,14,19,10,11,4,19,8,10 (26) (388)
22 carvanha - 1,14,19,15,13,18,18,20,20,18,17,18 (12) (191)
23 ferroseed - 25,15,15,17,12,19,14,24,19,16,19,16,12,11,15,13,20 (17) (282)
24 vulpix - 24,15,15,21,9,16,18,28,19,17,19,19,16,17,32,13,12,12 (18) (322)
25 larvesta - 19,17,16,17,15,15,26,14,37,14,19,14,15,19,13 (15) (270)
26 houndour - 24,16,20,18,20,17,11 (7) (126)
27 cottonee - 23,20,20,28,10,15,29,19,6,17,10,25,15,12,21,20 (16) (290)
28 corphish - 18,24,18,18,30,13,23,16,16,7,20,17,16 (13) (236)
29 drifloon - 20,10,34,23,14,8 (6) (109)
30 zigzagoon - 19,19,19,19,7,15,30 (7) (128)
31 vullaby - 14,16,26,17,21,16,20,27,29,11,20,5 (12) (222)
32 croagunk - 20,14,9,26,13,13,41,16,21,13 (10) (186)
33 honedge - 18,19,5,34 (4) (76)
34 dwebble - 14,7,36 (3) (57)
35 scraggy - 27,19,6,32,17,18 (6) (119)
36 shellder - 19,16,25,25,16,29,20,15,16,18 (10) (199)
37 pumpkaboo super - 14,23,17,21,14,19,33,16,30,15,18 (11) (220)
38 tirtouga - 24,7,38,20,15,20,18 (7) (142)
39 stunky - 14,48,20,10 (4) (92)
40 bellsprout - 19,31,19 (3) (69)
41 surskit - 18,18,35 (3) (71)
42 pancham - 22,37,18,28,15 (5) (120)
43 aipom - 11,18,39,33,19 (5) (120)
44 torchic - 20,40,17 (3) (77)
45 hippopotas - 44,20,16 (3) (80)
46 bunnelby - 21,42,12,36 (4) (111)
47 onix - 20,50 (2) (70)
48 doduo - 43,31 (2) (74)
49 taillow - 45,35 (2) (80)
Possible viability order
I wasn't sure how to do this because there isn't really a specific number for each Pokemon that I could add to their ranking points to make up for not being included as much, so there are a lot of ties. I put ties whenever a Pokemon had something around a difference of between 21-40 less ranking points for each time they weren't included in a list, the assumption being that between 21-40 would be around where they would be had the list continued. Towards the bottom I increased these numbers because Pokemon would likely have worse imaginary rankings there.
What could be done is to have a predetermined unranked list of Pokemon that are almost universally considered viable and then have people rank them, but I figured that would be a lot more effort and less fun to those being surveyed (hopefully making a list didn't feel like a chore or obligation to any of you except for op! That wasn't my goal at all).
name - rankings on individual list (number of times included, higher is better) (sum of rankings on list, lower is better)
1 mienfoo - 1,1,1,1,1,1,2,1,4,2,3,4,5,1,1,1,1,8,1,2,1,1,1,3,2,6,2,2,2,5,2,1,2,1,2,1,1,8,3 (39) (88)
2 pawniard - 5,3,2,2,2,2,11,3,2,1,1,9,1,2,4,9,6,2,2,1,4,4,4,1,1,1,1,4,1,1,6,2,1,4,3,3,4,3,1 (39) (119)
3/4 fletchling - 8,2,5,14,7,8,7,9,6,11,5,7,6,5,8,4,6,6,6,2,6,2,4,2,4,10,5,3,4,7,3,7,6,5,2,15,7 (37) (224)
3/4 timburr - 4,4,6,6,5,5,4,8,7,6,6,2,3,2,4,1,8,3,11,5,3,6,5,9,7,3,6,10,3,11,3,12,2,14,4,2 (36) (200)
5/6 abra - 13,7,4,4,4,4,5,11,3,8,2,3,10,3,11,5,3,5,8,2,3,2,5,14,7,5,5,2,5,4,13,6,11,10,6,20,6 (37) (249)
5/6 diglett - 9,5,3,3,3,12,2,8,5,7,2,3,8,7,10,3,12,11,4,3,18,8,4,8,5,6,3,8,4,3,6,4,2,1,6,5,6,4 (36) (221)
7 porygon - 3,6,7,9,10,6,8,10,9,3,9,7,4,4,6,13,10,7,9,6,17,7,7,3,3,9,7,8,15,5,14,4,3,7,12 (35) (267)
8 archen - 7,9,10,13,6,13,12,5,4,5,6,5,12,2,12,14,4,5,20,8,20,14,6,20,9,12,12,8,5,5,16,11,17,17,13 (35) (357)
9/10 spritzee - 11,10,8,8,8,14,3,6,10,27,10,8,10,13,9,16,9,10,13,16,18,8,13,8,9,8,12,8,9,13,8,9,15 (33) (357)
9/10 magnemite - 6,8,22,10,7,12,1,8,15,11,20,2,20,12,9,8,11,5,9,3,12,11,8,9,13,9,7,5,12,10,8 (31) (303)
11 gastly - 12,16,11,16,9,10,5,13,10,4,15,11,14,10,12,5,12,7,19,15,9,14,10,10,19,16,13,20,14,19,5,17 (32) (392)
12 chinchou - 23,11,13,3,12,20,14,15,13,9,7,14,3,10,7,20,5,11,27,10,18,7,11,9,8,17,15,10,16 (29) (358)
13 gothita - 14,9,17,19,12,1,7,11,16,13,18,15,15,15,10,17,20,11,10,19,13,1,18,12,10,9,7,19,18 (29) (376)
14/15/16 omanyte - 16,17,18,18,25,6,18,15,23,9,20,8,13,16,20,7,10,15,11,15,18,9,19,17,7,15,11,2 (28) (398)
14/15/16 drilbur - 17,13,10,13,20,15,13,11,6,12,12,8,17,14,11,19,7,11,13,22,12,16,14,14,14,20,16 (27) (370)
14/15/16 ponyta - 10,21,7,20,16,17,9,18,22,11,15,18,3,9,10,26,4,13,6,6,7,11,10,18,16,12 (26) (335)
17/18 foongus - 2,22,5,26,20,12,17,18,13,14,28,12,15,19,24,17,12,17,14,19,10,11,4,19,8,10 (26) (388)
17/18 snubbull - 18,15,16,12,11,7,19,21,16,17,13,9,16,14,9,12,13,17,19,4,13,9,14,14 (24) (328)
19 staryu - 15,12,17,15,21,11,18,14,20,11,16,11,17,22,17,13,11,15,17,17,15,7,9,11 (24) (352)
20 snivy - 21,12,18,15,13,13,12,23,8,18,16,17,14,10,10,12,18,1,18,18,1,19 (22) (307)
21 skrelp - 22,11,17,4,14,17,16,19,21,14,13,25,8,14,16,16,6,9 (18) (262)
22/23 vulpix - 24,15,15,21,9,16,18,28,19,17,19,19,16,17,32,13,12,12 (18) (322)
22/23 ferroseed - 25,15,15,17,12,19,14,24,19,16,19,16,12,11,15,13,20 (17) (282)
24 cottonee - 23,20,20,28,10,15,29,19,6,17,10,25,15,12,21,20 (16) (290)
25/26 larvesta - 19,17,16,17,15,15,26,14,37,14,19,14,15,19,13 (15) (270)
25/26 carvanha - 1,14,19,15,13,18,18,20,20,18,17,18 (12) (191)
27 corphish - 18,24,18,18,30,13,23,16,16,7,20,17,16 (13) (236)
28 vullaby - 14,16,26,17,21,16,20,27,29,11,20,5 (12) (222)
29/30 pumpkaboo super - 14,23,17,21,14,19,33,16,30,15,18 (11) (220)
29/30 croagunk - 20,14,9,26,13,13,41,16,21,13 (10) (186)
31 shellder - 19,16,25,25,16,29,20,15,16,18 (10) (199)
32 houndour - 24,16,20,18,20,17,11 (7) (126)
33 zigzagoon - 19,19,19,19,7,15,30 (7) (128)
34/35 tirtouga - 24,7,38,20,15,20,18 (7) (142)
34/35 drifloon - 20,10,34,23,14,8 (6) (109)
36 scraggy - 27,19,6,32,17,18 (6) (119)
37 honedge - 18,19,5,34 (4) (76)
38/39/40/41 pancham - 22,37,18,28,15 (5) (120)
38/39/40/41 aipom - 11,18,39,33,19 (5) (120)
38/39/40/41 stunky - 14,48,20,10 (4) (92)
38/39/40/41 dwebble - 14,7,36 (3) (57)
42 bellsprout - 19,31,19 (3) (69)
43/44 surskit - 18,18,35 (3) (71)
43/44 bunnelby - 21,42,12,36 (4) (111)
45 torchic - 20,40,17 (3) (77)
46 hippopotas - 44,20,16 (3) (80)
47 onix - 20,50 (2) (70)
48 doduo - 43,31 (2) (74)
49 taillow - 45,35 (2) (80)
50 numel - 4 (1) (4)
51 aron - 9 (1) (9)
52 cleffa - 17 (1) (17)
53 buneary - 19 (1) (19)
54 wynaut - 20 (1) (20)
55 venipede - 27 (1) (27)
56 cranidos - 46 (1) (46)
57 amaura - 47 (1) (47)
58 riolu - 49 (1) (49)
59 natu - 0